User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Shouldn't be kicking PATs in Overtime
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by WlI
Originally posted by SKADOODLE

GLB isnt like NFL. If GLB wants to kick XPs then GLB will.




but whats the point

first team to score whens

the team got 6

dont need 7
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LostPeon
Kickers need all the chances they can get to get XP. Why deprive them of this?


I'm gonna stick by this explanation.
 
SKADOODLE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by SKADOODLE

GLB isnt like NFL. If GLB wants to kick XPs then GLB will.


By the NFL you mean "all football"?

GLB doesn't aim to be a simulation of football???

Your logic is horrible.


Ummmm no. By NFL I mean NFL. In college at certain times in OT you have to kick the XP for the win. But this is neither. This is GLB and they do what they want. So sir, your logic is horrible.

 
SKADOODLE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by True Blue Titan
Originally posted by WlI

Originally posted by SKADOODLE


GLB isnt like NFL. If GLB wants to kick XPs then GLB will.




but whats the point

first team to score whens

the team got 6

dont need 7


More points. Tbh
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SKADOODLE
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by SKADOODLE


GLB isnt like NFL. If GLB wants to kick XPs then GLB will.


By the NFL you mean "all football"?

GLB doesn't aim to be a simulation of football???

Your logic is horrible.


Ummmm no. By NFL I mean NFL. In college at certain times in OT you have to kick the XP for the win. But this is neither. This is GLB and they do what they want. So sir, your logic is horrible.



Actually, you never have to kick and extra point. In college, since it isn't sudden death, you can kick or go for two, and eventually have to go for 2. So you don't need to kick it.
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kweideman
Originally posted by XSlugX

just seems wrong to me that you would post this in the BUG forum....


A: You're a dick

B: Game is over when TD is scored, so shouldn't be kicking PATs - BUG

C: You're still a dick


 
SKADOODLE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman

Actually, you never have to kick and extra point. In college, since it isn't sudden death, you can kick or go for two, and eventually have to go for 2. So you don't need to kick it.


I was talking more like they missed the XP so you just tied the game and now you can go for two or kick the XP. Logical choice would be XP but yeah you're right you dont HAVE to

 
Swiftus
offline
Link
 
In high school, college, or the pros... if you don't have to kick a PAT after an OT TD, you don't.

So when it is NOT sudden death, and the other team didn't score in the current OT, any score ends the game.

Don't make me find the rule.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 07:00:42
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Just because there's a difference in the rules in GLB versus the rules in real-life football doesn't make it a bug.

If Bort had tried to program the sim so that it wouldn't kick XPs in OT and it kept doing it anyway, THAT would be a bug, because the intent and the outcome were different.

But I'd be willing to bet dollars to donuts that Bort left XPs in intentionally because it was easier to code it that way for now, it's a minor issue that doesn't have any real impact on the outcome of games, and he can always fix it later for improved accuracy once he's taken care of more pressing matters.

If Bort did it intentionally, it's NOT A BUG. It is inaccurate, and it is incorrect according to the rules of real-life football, but it's not a bug.

This thread should be moved to the Suggestions Forum.
Last edited Oct 27, 2008 07:34:35
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
It doesn't hurt anything to kick it- so if its a pain to change this, it's obviously going to be low on the priorities. If it's easy to fix, it should be fixed.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Just because there's a difference in the rules in GLB versus the rules in real-life football doesn't make it a bug.

If Bort had tried to program the sim so that it wouldn't kick XPs in OT and it kept doing it anyway, THAT would be a bug, because the intent and the outcome were different.

But I'd be willing to bet dollars to donuts that Bort left XPs in intentionally because it was easier to code it that way for now, it's a minor issue that doesn't have any real impact on the outcome of games, and he can always fix it later for improved accuracy once he's taken care of more pressing matters.

If Bort did it intentionally, it's NOT A BUG. It is inaccurate, and it is incorrect according to the rules of real-life football, but it's not a bug.

This thread should be moved to the Suggestions Forum.


You are missing a 3rd case where Bort didn't even consider it. That's the most likely IMO.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by Novus

Just because there's a difference in the rules in GLB versus the rules in real-life football doesn't make it a bug.

If Bort had tried to program the sim so that it wouldn't kick XPs in OT and it kept doing it anyway, THAT would be a bug, because the intent and the outcome were different.

But I'd be willing to bet dollars to donuts that Bort left XPs in intentionally because it was easier to code it that way for now, it's a minor issue that doesn't have any real impact on the outcome of games, and he can always fix it later for improved accuracy once he's taken care of more pressing matters.

If Bort did it intentionally, it's NOT A BUG. It is inaccurate, and it is incorrect according to the rules of real-life football, but it's not a bug.

This thread should be moved to the Suggestions Forum.


You are missing a 3rd case where Bort didn't even consider it. That's the most likely IMO.


True... but even in that 3rd category, it's still not a bug.
 
Iversen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
It doesn't hurt anything to kick it- so if its a pain to change this, it's obviously going to be low on the priorities. If it's easy to fix, it should be fixed.


It CAN hurt to kick it .

I know this is far out , but if two teams are tied for 4th place and the one team gets the 4th seed and homefield + money for having 1 more point scored than the other , which came in an overtime win then it does matter ?

But that's just far out and really , no need to fix this if it is too difficult or time consuming imho .
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.