Even if kickers had an expected miss rate of, say, 5%, that doesn't mean they will always be 95% or higher on kicks. Say that 95% means, when picking a random number from 1-1000, you will miss on 951-1000, and make it should any other number be picked.
Sometimes, the random number generator will pick high a few times in a row. Sometimes, it'll always pick under 500. But if 5% was targeted as a miss rate, you wouldn't see an exact 95% rate, but some would be around 90%, others around 100%, and maybe a few even lower than 90. It isn't like the game is going to say "oh crap, you're at 15% missed for the season, you won't miss another until you get to 95%".
And for what its worth, the miss rate does get to the 5% or less range at higher levels:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=92225&playoffs=0Heck, check out the league I play in, where we had 5 kickers who attempted 125+ XPs this season finish at 95% or higher:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=18&conference_id=0&stat=kicking&sort=(extra_points_made/extra_points_attempted)*100&playoffs=0As others have said in the thread...lower levels need something to work towards. That's why kickers booting 65 and 70 yard field goals at level 20 needed to be toned down (well, that and the realism aspect of it).