User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Fix Missed XPs, this is STUPID AND RUINING THE GAME
Page:
 
morid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NWWarrior
XPs should be more of an automatic thing with only the very occasional miss.
Having a Playoff game you spent 2 days scouting and planning for come down to a missed XP should not happen as often as it does here in the GLB. IMHO


+1
 
Caiderman98
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Kono22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nurosa
Originally posted by saintedix

Originally posted by luxembourgh


Originally posted by SCACE



Originally posted by luxembourgh




Why are there SO MANY MISSED XPs? A kicker DOES NOT miss multiple xps in a game while they consistently hit 30-40 something yard FGs. Its damn ridiculous and better be addressed. Bort wants to make this simulation realistic, well this is extremely unrealistic.


If a level 13 kicker never misses them, what does a kicker have to work towards?

EDIT: I agree there are too many missed, esp. among higher level kickers, and there should be an explanation. But in the low levels, there should be some more frequently than higher levels.


Agree SCACE, lower levels should definitely miss more than higher levels. But this is a 20 yard chip shot extra point and even a 13 level kicker should be hitting these consistently. hell, we have a fun game on one of my teams where everyone plays out of position and our Guard plays kicker and he has never missed an xp with a kicking of 9. Theres just no rhyme or reason. If the kicker has ample kicking, vision, and strength to hit a 30-40 yarder consistently, then they should rarely, if ever, miss an XP.


Our level 29 kicker missed a 24 yard FG with less than two minutes in our playoff game that would've tied it. Kickers don't make EVERYTHING, especially when you score TD's close together.

Personally, I think the solution is giving your kicker more stamina. I mean, say you score 2 TD's in 1:30 seconds, that's 4 plays for the kicker, who has probably 8 stamina. I think MANY kickers would see a whole lot less missed XP's if they had higher stamina, even if they just trained it to 15 or so.




Stamina is now 23ish.. Still having issues. Hasn't really helped any.


Why would you waste training or SPs on stamina? It's pointless. My Kicker has 10 stamina and doesn't miss that much, even when kicking 30+ times a game.
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by luxembourgh

Why are there SO MANY MISSED XPs? A kicker DOES NOT miss multiple xps in a game while they consistently hit 30-40 something yard FGs. Its damn ridiculous and better be addressed. Bort wants to make this simulation realistic, well this is extremely unrealistic.


If a level 13 kicker never misses them, what does a kicker have to work towards?

EDIT: I agree there are too many missed, esp. among higher level kickers, and there should be an explanation. But in the low levels, there should be some more frequently than higher levels.


How about a level 30 that missed 8 this season?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=64549&playoffs=0

Level 29 missed 4?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=105793&playoffs=0

Level 33 missed 10?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=251176&playoffs=0

Level 33 missed 9?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=51376&playoffs=0

Level 32 missed 7?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=113564&playoffs=0

Level 32 missed 9?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=91781&playoffs=0

Yes, XP's are missed, and should continue to be missed occasionally, yes bad snaps happen, the holder screws up, the kicker screws up.

It happens far too often in GLB.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
As for stamina you see the end of game stamina, kickers sit on the bench alot therefore there energy regained most of it by the end of the game, but during the game that little 10 stamina made your energy run very low, and you were at a high penalty for all your other stats.

Raising my stamina from 10 -> 25 made a world of difference.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Preaching to the choir NRY...guys at those levels shouldn't miss so often....once in a blue moon.
 
Skvan
offline
Link
 
As a % of the number of XP's they attempt the failure rate its somewhere around the 10% mark from the kickers I looked at.
Yeah its a little high but honestly its not totally out of wack. A reduction to something like 5% of them being missed would be welcome though
 
Roughneck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by luxembourgh
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by luxembourgh


Why are there SO MANY MISSED XPs? A kicker DOES NOT miss multiple xps in a game while they consistently hit 30-40 something yard FGs. Its damn ridiculous and better be addressed. Bort wants to make this simulation realistic, well this is extremely unrealistic.


If a level 13 kicker never misses them, what does a kicker have to work towards?

EDIT: I agree there are too many missed, esp. among higher level kickers, and there should be an explanation. But in the low levels, there should be some more frequently than higher levels.



Agree SCACE, lower levels should definitely miss more than higher levels. But this is a 20 yard chip shot extra point and even a 13 level kicker should be hitting these consistently. hell, we have a fun game on one of my teams where everyone plays out of position and our Guard plays kicker and he has never missed an xp with a kicking of 9. Theres just no rhyme or reason. If the kicker has ample kicking, vision, and strength to hit a 30-40 yarder consistently, then they should rarely, if ever, miss an XP.



check the season stats and career progression of a L30 kicker and please tell me what is wrong...
S3 12 of 17 from 30 to 50+
S5 9 of 21 from 30 to 50+

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=168189&playoffs=0
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 18:06:17
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nurosa
Originally posted by saintedix

Originally posted by luxembourgh


Originally posted by SCACE



Originally posted by luxembourgh




Why are there SO MANY MISSED XPs? A kicker DOES NOT miss multiple xps in a game while they consistently hit 30-40 something yard FGs. Its damn ridiculous and better be addressed. Bort wants to make this simulation realistic, well this is extremely unrealistic.


If a level 13 kicker never misses them, what does a kicker have to work towards?

EDIT: I agree there are too many missed, esp. among higher level kickers, and there should be an explanation. But in the low levels, there should be some more frequently than higher levels.


Agree SCACE, lower levels should definitely miss more than higher levels. But this is a 20 yard chip shot extra point and even a 13 level kicker should be hitting these consistently. hell, we have a fun game on one of my teams where everyone plays out of position and our Guard plays kicker and he has never missed an xp with a kicking of 9. Theres just no rhyme or reason. If the kicker has ample kicking, vision, and strength to hit a 30-40 yarder consistently, then they should rarely, if ever, miss an XP.


Our level 29 kicker missed a 24 yard FG with less than two minutes in our playoff game that would've tied it. Kickers don't make EVERYTHING, especially when you score TD's close together.

Personally, I think the solution is giving your kicker more stamina. I mean, say you score 2 TD's in 1:30 seconds, that's 4 plays for the kicker, who has probably 8 stamina. I think MANY kickers would see a whole lot less missed XP's if they had higher stamina, even if they just trained it to 15 or so.




Stamina is now 23ish.. Still having issues. Hasn't really helped any.


Speed and agility??
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Raising my kicker's stamina to 20 helped with missed XPs in blowouts. Speed and agility trained to 27 and I'm 84/86 on the year. Now I've jinxed myself probably.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by luxembourgh
Originally posted by phthalatemagic

Originally posted by luxembourgh


Originally posted by phthalatemagic



Originally posted by luxembourgh




Why are there SO MANY MISSED XPs? A kicker DOES NOT miss multiple xps in a game while they consistently hit 30-40 something yard FGs. Its damn ridiculous and better be addressed. Bort wants to make this simulation realistic, well this is extremely unrealistic.


You know what else is unrealistic? All of the players look exactly like dots.


always a smart ass somewhere who thinks hes funny


Well, what I'm saying is that you need to calm down.


nope thats not what you were saying, you were attempting to be funny, im not getting worked up tho. (I realize I did use some caps there however) I just think its silly thats all. Ive just seen it way too much. I think adding a comment in the text (blocked, bad snap, etc) would help.

Thanks to all the people making the suggestions tho, it does make sense.


The calming down thing - just give it a shot.
 
wheatrich
offline
Link
 
most of the "problems" guys are posting still have about a 92-95% percent XP conversion. The NFL rate is probably 98% so I don't really see this as being a monster problem. (do college kickers even make 95%? I doubt it and surely low levels won't make 90) A bunch of these missed XP's are only noticeable because a lot of teams are blowing out others and then the kicker gets tired and blows a few. Because there's as many games in GLB as there is unless it's 100% somebody will blow an XP to lose it probably every day. This isn't really a big deal compared to some bugs that actually should be fixed first.
 
luxembourgh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
Originally posted by luxembourgh

Originally posted by phthalatemagic


Originally posted by luxembourgh



Originally posted by phthalatemagic




Originally posted by luxembourgh





Why are there SO MANY MISSED XPs? A kicker DOES NOT miss multiple xps in a game while they consistently hit 30-40 something yard FGs. Its damn ridiculous and better be addressed. Bort wants to make this simulation realistic, well this is extremely unrealistic.


You know what else is unrealistic? All of the players look exactly like dots.


always a smart ass somewhere who thinks hes funny


Well, what I'm saying is that you need to calm down.


nope thats not what you were saying, you were attempting to be funny, im not getting worked up tho. (I realize I did use some caps there however) I just think its silly thats all. Ive just seen it way too much. I think adding a comment in the text (blocked, bad snap, etc) would help.

Thanks to all the people making the suggestions tho, it does make sense.


The calming down thing - just give it a shot.


lol, anyone who knows me in this game or real life, knows Im a very chill individual.
I love how you make such bold, generic assumptions about my attitude from one post. And I wont make one about you.
Tho I can appreciate your avatar, Raising Arizona is a very underrated movie and one of my alltime favorites .

to wheatrich, yes this probably isnt the most pressing problem in the game. But its a shame that team loses a playoff game 19-20 cause of a missed xp. Ive been on both sides and I just dont think its fair for all the money and time the players and owners put into this game for this to happen as often as it does, and I think 7-10% missed xps is silly high. It should be in the range of 2-3%. Once again, yes this is NOT the most pressing need in this game, but I do believe it is a simple fix.
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
I still think it's just a build problem due to the secondary attributes being more important.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Even if kickers had an expected miss rate of, say, 5%, that doesn't mean they will always be 95% or higher on kicks. Say that 95% means, when picking a random number from 1-1000, you will miss on 951-1000, and make it should any other number be picked.

Sometimes, the random number generator will pick high a few times in a row. Sometimes, it'll always pick under 500. But if 5% was targeted as a miss rate, you wouldn't see an exact 95% rate, but some would be around 90%, others around 100%, and maybe a few even lower than 90. It isn't like the game is going to say "oh crap, you're at 15% missed for the season, you won't miss another until you get to 95%".

And for what its worth, the miss rate does get to the 5% or less range at higher levels:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=92225&playoffs=0

Heck, check out the league I play in, where we had 5 kickers who attempted 125+ XPs this season finish at 95% or higher:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=18&conference_id=0&stat=kicking&sort=(extra_points_made/extra_points_attempted)*100&playoffs=0

As others have said in the thread...lower levels need something to work towards. That's why kickers booting 65 and 70 yard field goals at level 20 needed to be toned down (well, that and the realism aspect of it).
Last edited Oct 25, 2008 11:23:19
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.