User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
The Strong I needs addressing. The only way to stop it consistently is to play Goal Line against it, or something close to it.

If people don't see something wrong with that, then I suppose we have even bigger issues.


The Strong I is the best running play against many teams, but that is more due to the metagme on DEs than anything else.

Your statement that there is only one way to stop it is factually incorrect.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
The Strong I is the best running play against many teams, but that is more due to the metagme on DEs than anything else.

Your statement that there is only one way to stop it is factually incorrect.


You're free to think that, but, even if that were true (and I don't think it is) I'd rather the sim didn't come down to whether a team has a run-stopping LDE or not. One position shouldn't be the difference in stopping a play or not.

And, for the record, I'm one of the biggest proponents of contain ends you'll find. It still isn't enough in the upper leagues.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
My team has managed to contain the strong I without calling a goal line defense, and we've faced some very good running teams. Of course, we also use it for about 75% of our running plays this year so I completely understand what people are saying - there needs to be more than one running play that people can run. Sweeps are broke ass, I refuse to call them unless I am playing a gutted team. Inside Runs are ok, but when you can get much more consistent output from the off tackle, why call it?

But back to the original point... you can stop the off tackle, it just takes some figuring.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by tautology

The Strong I is the best running play against many teams, but that is more due to the metagme on DEs than anything else.

Your statement that there is only one way to stop it is factually incorrect.


You're free to think that, but, even if that were true (and I don't think it is) I'd rather the sim didn't come down to whether a team has a run-stopping LDE or not. One position shouldn't be the difference in stopping a play or not.

And, for the record, I'm one of the biggest proponents of contain ends you'll find. It still isn't enough in the upper leagues.


I know. Your typical 'run stopping' DE is just a pass rusher with all his gear in strength. Kinda self defeating.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
We just had the opponent run over 50% Strong I off-tackle runs, its almost impossible to stop to less than a 6 yard gain. If you can not run over the blockers, there is no possible set-up that stops it that I can see.

I believe this play is over powered, and now too many people know how to force it to run repeatedly, and use it because they KNOW its broken. I have no problem losing, its just ashame to see sim plays exploited like this.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
We just had the opponent run over 50% Strong I off-tackle runs, its almost impossible to stop to less than a 6 yard gain. If you can not run over the blockers, there is no possible set-up that stops it that I can see.

I believe this play is over powered, and now too many people know how to force it to run repeatedly, and use it because they KNOW its broken. I have no problem losing, its just ashame to see sim plays exploited like this.


So in summary (of the thread), most teams can't figure out how to stop said play - so therefore it must be overpowered.

Interesting.
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 22:44:12
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
We just had the opponent run over 50% Strong I off-tackle runs, its almost impossible to stop to less than a 6 yard gain. If you can not run over the blockers, there is no possible set-up that stops it that I can see.

I believe this play is over powered, and now too many people know how to force it to run repeatedly, and use it because they KNOW its broken. I have no problem losing, its just ashame to see sim plays exploited like this.


Hey Eagle

Here's the whole problem - there are only two running options: inside and OT.

Everyone knows pitches/sweeps are broken and are a gamble, at best. No one calls them often and lives to tell about it.

That leaves inside runs or OT runs. If the defense has a dominant DT/NT (such as Robert Mackey on the Carnage), what options are there? Seriously? Run directly at the defense's strength?

Plus, from what I've seen, there are two defensive play calls that can keep it in check. Yes, it's powerful, but it's not broken. And everyone has the option of running it, so it's a level playing field.

An expanded playbook next season should help.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by EagleOtto

We just had the opponent run over 50% Strong I off-tackle runs, its almost impossible to stop to less than a 6 yard gain. If you can not run over the blockers, there is no possible set-up that stops it that I can see.

I believe this play is over powered, and now too many people know how to force it to run repeatedly, and use it because they KNOW its broken. I have no problem losing, its just ashame to see sim plays exploited like this.


Hey Eagle

Here's the whole problem - there are only two running options: inside and OT.

Everyone knows pitches/sweeps are broken and are a gamble, at best. No one calls them often and lives to tell about it.

That leaves inside runs or OT runs. If the defense has a dominant DT/NT (such as Robert Mackey on the Carnage), what options are there? Seriously? Run directly at the defense's strength?

Plus, from what I've seen, there are two defensive play calls that can keep it in check. Yes, it's powerful, but it's not broken. And everyone has the option of running it, so it's a level playing field.

An expanded playbook next season should help.


The right build for a halfabck CAN effectively run sweeps/pitches. Again, they aren't broken. Just in the past week my owned team has faced two opponents that surprised me with their ability to run pitches.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
The right build for a halfabck CAN effectively run sweeps/pitches. Again, they aren't broken. Just in the past week my owned team has faced two opponents that surprised me with their ability to run pitches.


While I believe it, I have yet to see it. And the fact that you were surprised indicates that it's a pretty rare occurrence.

So maybe broken wasn't the best description - severely hampered?

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by islander1

The right build for a halfabck CAN effectively run sweeps/pitches. Again, they aren't broken. Just in the past week my owned team has faced two opponents that surprised me with their ability to run pitches.


While I believe it, I have yet to see it. And the fact that you were surprised indicates that it's a pretty rare occurrence.

So maybe broken wasn't the best description - severely hampered?



Only hampered by the percentage of running backs capable of running it.

The biggest problem - imo - with pitches is that linebackers seem to magically run right through open, unengaged blockers like the FB and RG leading out in front of it.

The run itself isn't broken, it's the pathing of the linebackers and their magical ability to ignore the offensive line. We've all seen it happen - it's largely why it is removed from most playbooks to begin with.

 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by EagleOtto

We just had the opponent run over 50% Strong I off-tackle runs, its almost impossible to stop to less than a 6 yard gain. If you can not run over the blockers, there is no possible set-up that stops it that I can see.

I believe this play is over powered, and now too many people know how to force it to run repeatedly, and use it because they KNOW its broken. I have no problem losing, its just ashame to see sim plays exploited like this.


Hey Eagle

Here's the whole problem - there are only two running options: inside and OT.

Everyone knows pitches/sweeps are broken and are a gamble, at best. No one calls them often and lives to tell about it.

That leaves inside runs or OT runs. If the defense has a dominant DT/NT (such as Robert Mackey on the Carnage), what options are there? Seriously? Run directly at the defense's strength?

Plus, from what I've seen, there are two defensive play calls that can keep it in check. Yes, it's powerful, but it's not broken. And everyone has the option of running it, so it's a level playing field.

An expanded playbook next season should help.


True the expanded playbook will help the problem, I don't mind the play as long as it can not be continuously called over and over. In real life a defense can adjust in-game, unfortunately in sim world you can't.

As for the game, I did not think we would be able to stop the Barracudas from scoring on us all day, its just disappointing to see after I set up a 100% run defense strong side shift get destroyed that badly
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 23:12:20
 
Havoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54


My team can stop every other running play cold, or at least very well but not this play in particular, nobody can.



I have to disagree with you on that one.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
nm
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 23:18:59
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by flames54



My team can stop every other running play cold, or at least very well but not this play in particular, nobody can.



I have to disagree with you on that one.



You got to resort to trickery to stop it though, either a goalline defense or add in a nickle/dime CB and blitz.
A regular 4-3 3-4 defense don't have a chance though.
Learned this lesson too late
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54

My team can stop every other running play cold


The main problem is the lack of variety in the running game. A good team SHOULD have an strong I run that is hard to stop, and has the potential to go to the endzone. If it needs anything, it is nothing more than a tweak.

However, I see a huge problem with his statement here. Pro league teams seem to be able to easily stop every other running play cold- forcing people to run THE ONLY HALFWAY DECENT running play left. This game is not supposed to be forced into the air at high levels, it's supposed to be balanced.

-Clearly inside runs are no good at the high level, despite being the most basic run play with the most variety programmed into it.

-Pitch plays suck monkey nuts against LBs with halfway decent speed. I have no idea how Bort could start to balance them out better, but as it is they are no more than an instant TFL wasting space in the playbook.
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 23:24:59
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.