User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
How does stating that fact the OP, and people supporting it, are moronic make me a "tough guy"? The poster actually says it is impossible for the WR to outjump his CB on a play because his CB has 30 odd jumping. I'm sorry if the morons took offence but that's pretty fucking stupid and shows complete ignorance of, you know, math in general.


Oh then carry on then...I thought you were talking about the play I posted.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by numone
I want to take you over to physics class though. The receiver is standing right behind me and I jump for a ball. The ball stops in front of me and the receiver makes the catch. This means the receiver would have to jump over me, then reach in front of me to make the catch. it isn't like the circles were at the same spot or anything, the replay clearly showed turf between us.

An engineer with no sense of scale. I sure hope I never stand near anything you've built. Since you believe so much in the accuracy of the graphics could you perhaps explain why your player's waist is 3 foot in diameter and why the football is a yard long?

Also, I would be very interested to know how you ascertained the direction your player, WHO IS A FUCKING CIRCLE, was facing. Is that a special skill you learn at Engineer School?

Aside from all of that, you seemingly have no comprehension of how the sim even works. First the result of a play is generated using only mathematical algorithms which encompass all the variables. This information is then used to draw a rough graphic of what happened based on co-ordinate geometry. The circles represent the approximate location of the players and ball for any given moment but are not exact.
Last edited Oct 23, 2008 13:57:42
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
To be fair:

1) The dots are not 100% accurate.
2) This is probably a case where if the sim waited an additional tick the WR would make no play on the ball. I believe added a tick tick that happens in half of the time of normal ticks but is not animated in this situations, hence you are seeing a lot of "phantom catches"
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
I'm just wondering if there might be knock-ons from fixing the wide open missed catch bug. I have seen plays like the one in the OP in the past, but not really any where there are two DBs in between the WR & the ball, the ball stops at the DBs, but the WR gets the catch.

One was already posted, and here's another one:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=200424&pbp_id=10159402

jprietman's post makes sense, however there might be a problem if the WR "check for catch" discounts multiple defenders in close coverage between him and the ball.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whoshotjr
I'm just wondering if there might be knock-ons from fixing the wide open missed catch bug. I have seen plays like the one in the OP in the past, but not really any where there are two DBs in between the WR & the ball, the ball stops at the DBs, but the WR gets the catch.

One was already posted, and here's another one:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=200424&pbp_id=10159402

jprietman's post makes sense, however there might be a problem if the WR "check for catch" discounts multiple defenders in close coverage between him and the ball.



Hold on...is it just the Wang's exploiting this?
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by whoshotjr

I'm just wondering if there might be knock-ons from fixing the wide open missed catch bug. I have seen plays like the one in the OP in the past, but not really any where there are two DBs in between the WR & the ball, the ball stops at the DBs, but the WR gets the catch.

One was already posted, and here's another one:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=200424&pbp_id=10159402

jprietman's post makes sense, however there might be a problem if the WR "check for catch" discounts multiple defenders in close coverage between him and the ball.



Hold on...is it just the Wang's exploiting this?


No in looking at the Bugs forum this is covered in the Wide Open Incompletion Case Study: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1114096&page=31

So basically this is a knock-on from the fix made to that issue. There are plays happening like the ones posted. In addition, it appears that WRs are now given extra time to attempt to catch deflections as there are examples of of DBs deflecting the ball...and then the WR being credited with a drop even though the ball is nowhere near him.
 
numone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
Originally posted by numone

I want to take you over to physics class though. The receiver is standing right behind me and I jump for a ball. The ball stops in front of me and the receiver makes the catch. This means the receiver would have to jump over me, then reach in front of me to make the catch. it isn't like the circles were at the same spot or anything, the replay clearly showed turf between us.

An engineer with no sense of scale. I sure hope I never stand near anything you've built. Since you believe so much in the accuracy of the graphics could you perhaps explain why your player's waist is 3 foot in diameter and why the football is a yard long?

Also, I would be very interested to know how you ascertained the direction your player, WHO IS A FUCKING CIRCLE, was facing. Is that a special skill you learn at Engineer School?

Aside from all of that, you seemingly have no comprehension of how the sim even works. First the result of a play is generated using only mathematical algorithms which encompass all the variables. This information is then used to draw a rough graphic of what happened based on co-ordinate geometry. The circles represent the approximate location of the players and ball for any given moment but are not exact.


Well i'm a computer science engineer so i haven't "built" anything you stand on or in. And to an engineer accuracy is everything, you wouldn't be too happy with your building if it were the accurate numbers.

aside from that, i know how the game is ran, i'm not an idiot. but the graphics rendering is pretty bad if you look at that replay. I understand it isn't 100% accurate but the fact the ball stops at the cb and not the WR is pretty bad. Also, i know you have never coded anything before, but try to understand, when you create a bunch of logic algorithms there is bugs in it. Flaws that only sometimes happen based upon several previous conditions happening.

Now since you have not seen the code, and you cannot debug this play I would like you to shut the fuck up before you continue to try to attack me.
 
stamango
offline
Link
 
The GUI (Graphical User Interface) is not portraying the physics of the game correctly any longer. This is a big concern. I had hoped it would get better. Apparently, it is getting worse. Instead of making the game more user friendly, we have a game that is even more complicated, due to---you just can't watch the dots and see what is really happening any longer, you have to guess more now. The more experienced ones amongst us will know what is happening, but the layman will simply get frustrated and not play any longer. I think too much too soon, and Bort probably needs help. I would think that the game should be simplified a bit to gain wider appeal.

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stamango
The GUI (Graphical User Interface) is not portraying the physics of the game correctly any longer. This is a big concern. I had hoped it would get better. Apparently, it is getting worse. Instead of making the game more user friendly, we have a game that is even more complicated, due to---you just can't watch the dots and see what is really happening any longer, you have to guess more now. The more experienced ones amongst us will know what is happening, but the layman will simply get frustrated and not play any longer. I think too much too soon, and Bort probably needs help. I would think that the game should be simplified a bit to gain wider appeal.



All that's happened here is that phantom drops are occurring less often, but still happen, and phantom catches are the new thing. I just think we need more ticks, but Bort said something earlier about why he doesn't do that already...not sure what the answer is
 
stamango
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by stamango

The GUI (Graphical User Interface) is not portraying the physics of the game correctly any longer. This is a big concern. I had hoped it would get better. Apparently, it is getting worse. Instead of making the game more user friendly, we have a game that is even more complicated, due to---you just can't watch the dots and see what is really happening any longer, you have to guess more now. The more experienced ones amongst us will know what is happening, but the layman will simply get frustrated and not play any longer. I think too much too soon, and Bort probably needs help. I would think that the game should be simplified a bit to gain wider appeal.



All that's happened here is that phantom drops are occurring less often, but still happen, and phantom catches are the new thing. I just think we need more ticks, but Bort said something earlier about why he doesn't do that already...not sure what the answer is


Overkill concerning the correction of the phantom drops?
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 10:12:45
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stamango
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by stamango


The GUI (Graphical User Interface) is not portraying the physics of the game correctly any longer. This is a big concern. I had hoped it would get better. Apparently, it is getting worse. Instead of making the game more user friendly, we have a game that is even more complicated, due to---you just can't watch the dots and see what is really happening any longer, you have to guess more now. The more experienced ones amongst us will know what is happening, but the layman will simply get frustrated and not play any longer. I think too much too soon, and Bort probably needs help. I would think that the game should be simplified a bit to gain wider appeal.



All that's happened here is that phantom drops are occurring less often, but still happen, and phantom catches are the new thing. I just think we need more ticks, but Bort said something earlier about why he doesn't do that already...not sure what the answer is


Overkill concerning the correction of the phantom drops?


One would assume...the last I read Bort only tested the changes on the D-leagues before implementing the change...mind you, I never feel that a change made right before the playoffs is ever a good thing after playing the whole season under one set of rules, but what do I know
 
PyscoJester13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShamsTron
The dots are not the exact representation of the play. If the text and replay don't match up the text is ALWAYS right.


You will have to pardon me for saying this, but that sounds liek some grade a BS. What is the point of having a visual component to the game when it doesnt follow the script we are being told happened?

Funny how these "messed up dots" start to happen after fixes..... but even that doesnt explain soem of the wierd crap I have witnessed this season alone. There are soem major flaws somewhere for sure.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PyscoJester13
Originally posted by ShamsTron

The dots are not the exact representation of the play. If the text and replay don't match up the text is ALWAYS right.


You will have to pardon me for saying this, but that sounds liek some grade a BS. What is the point of having a visual component to the game when it doesnt follow the script we are being told happened?

Funny how these "messed up dots" start to happen after fixes..... but even that doesnt explain soem of the wierd crap I have witnessed this season alone. There are soem major flaws somewhere for sure.


The dots were messed up before the fixes...it was just "phantom incompletions" which are now "phantom completions". If you read back through the big thread on the incompletion study, it is well explained -- I learned a lot from that thread.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PyscoJester13
Funny how these "messed up dots" start to happen after fixes..... but even that doesnt explain soem of the wierd crap I have witnessed this season alone. There are soem major flaws somewhere for sure.


I would guess when Bort makes a tweak, he looks extensively at the stat output...but not much at the PbP replays.

I say this because he mentioned that there would probably be more drops as a result of this change, and he seems to be correct. However, it looks like a chunk of these drops are actually pass deflections a few yards away and the extra tick results in a drop for whatever reason.

 
Link
 
Ya know how many times this happens in every game that gets simmed, even to players with 70 vision and 60 jumping?! Lol get over it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.