that is OK just pick who you want.
MorsDraconis
offline
offline
Originally posted by czman
3 gutted teams in zeta and 1 in alpha. I am sure that skews some of the numbers.
We get it. You guys still have this idea that Alpha is better than Zeta. That's fine.
Just for the sake of Dedric, we played one of Alpha's THREE gutted teams as well, Sioux City Rampage. Hell, you can't even count the game against To Ken Love Bort since our punt returner scored all the points that game (offense only got 33 plays the whole game and Dedric still threw for 5 TDs).
It's not any Zeta conference QB's fault that Alpha decided to inflate their RB's stats instead of their QB's stats.
And it's certainly not Zeta's fault that Kamakura only put up 90 points on each of their other gutted teams compared to the three on our side getting destroyed by pretty much everyone. Running the ball all the time does that.
3 gutted teams in zeta and 1 in alpha. I am sure that skews some of the numbers.
We get it. You guys still have this idea that Alpha is better than Zeta. That's fine.
Just for the sake of Dedric, we played one of Alpha's THREE gutted teams as well, Sioux City Rampage. Hell, you can't even count the game against To Ken Love Bort since our punt returner scored all the points that game (offense only got 33 plays the whole game and Dedric still threw for 5 TDs).
It's not any Zeta conference QB's fault that Alpha decided to inflate their RB's stats instead of their QB's stats.
And it's certainly not Zeta's fault that Kamakura only put up 90 points on each of their other gutted teams compared to the three on our side getting destroyed by pretty much everyone. Running the ball all the time does that.
datongw
offline
offline
I think a good QB must be able to lead his team into the playoffs, and he must be consistent throughout the season and comes up big in big games. With that said, let's take a look at the playoff QBs:
Alpha:
Joey Kickatello, (Kamakura Katanas 15-1) 3489, 70% 34-5 rating of 115. Only two games with ratings under 80, team won both and one of them he threw for 335. Threw for 294 with a rating of 86 in the team's only loss.
Texan Raider (Portland Dirty Penguins 14-2) 3472, 65% 27-11 rating of 104. Also only two games with ratings under 80 (1 W 1 L). Threw for 368 in win against Kamakura.
Atomic Dog (P-Funk Allstars 13-3) 3098, 59% 29-9 rating of 89. 5 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 3 L). Performed miserably in all 3 of the team's losses.
Chord Naim (Samed Accomplishers 12-4) 2340 64% 23-8 rating of 96. 4 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 3 L). Did not perform well in all team's 4 losses.
Art Schlichter (Padong Dragons 11-5) 3653 70% 16-12 rating of 89. 8 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 5 L), enough said.
Larry Ballstar (Sumatra Swarm 11-5) 3945 63% 27-12 rating of 89. 6 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 4 L).
Jack E Adamski (Perrinton Panthers 11-5) 2938 62% 13-10 rating of 81. Only 13 TDs, and 10 INTs.
Danny White (Tongduchon Cowboys 11-5) 3399 62% 26-9 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (3 W 3 L). Best game came against Perrinton not counting games against weak opponents. But that's the only game with rating over 100 against playoff teams.
Zeta:
Tony Fatass (Hong Kong Hustlers 14-2) 3685 67% 41-5 rating of 116. 4 games with rating under 80 (4 W 0 L). In team's two losses threw for 576 yards, 5 TD and 1 INT.
Song Yuanyuan (TKW 14-2) 2732 64% 27-2 rating of 123. 5 games with ratings under 80 (4 W 0 L). Only 2 INTs on the season, 9.4 yards per attempt highest among league starters.
Dedric "The Arm" Frederickson (SAB 14-2) 3938 67% 58-6 rating of 121. 3 games with rating under 80 (3 W 0 L). League leader in TDs, in 2 losses threw for 393 yards, 3 TDs and 0 INTs.
Silver Surfer (Bali Waves 12-4) 3997 69% 38-9 rating of 110. 3 games with rating under 80 (2 W 1 L). Nearly perfect in upset win over HKH, also played well against AWE, MON, SAB, BAN. The only bad game of the season was against TKW.
Jim McMahon (Awendaw ToadFish 12-4) 3530 68% 33-6 rating of 110. 4 games with rating under 80 (2 W 2 L). Played well in losses against TKW and Bali.
Dave Choate (Montana Mercenaries 11-5) 4067 62.1% 31-7 rating of 91. 7 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 4 L). Best game of the season came against Taiwan. But only 2 TDs in 5 losses (4 INTs).
Wayne Walters (Taiwan Demons 9-7) 3302 59% 31-8 rating of 91. 6 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 5 L). Performed poorly against top 5 teams in conference.
William Parker-Laursen (Bangkok Authority Figures 9-7) 3989 64% 36-14 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (1 W 5 L). 6 TDs and 7 INTs against top 5 teams in conference (0-5).
Alpha:
Joey Kickatello, (Kamakura Katanas 15-1) 3489, 70% 34-5 rating of 115. Only two games with ratings under 80, team won both and one of them he threw for 335. Threw for 294 with a rating of 86 in the team's only loss.
Texan Raider (Portland Dirty Penguins 14-2) 3472, 65% 27-11 rating of 104. Also only two games with ratings under 80 (1 W 1 L). Threw for 368 in win against Kamakura.
Atomic Dog (P-Funk Allstars 13-3) 3098, 59% 29-9 rating of 89. 5 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 3 L). Performed miserably in all 3 of the team's losses.
Chord Naim (Samed Accomplishers 12-4) 2340 64% 23-8 rating of 96. 4 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 3 L). Did not perform well in all team's 4 losses.
Art Schlichter (Padong Dragons 11-5) 3653 70% 16-12 rating of 89. 8 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 5 L), enough said.
Larry Ballstar (Sumatra Swarm 11-5) 3945 63% 27-12 rating of 89. 6 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 4 L).
Jack E Adamski (Perrinton Panthers 11-5) 2938 62% 13-10 rating of 81. Only 13 TDs, and 10 INTs.
Danny White (Tongduchon Cowboys 11-5) 3399 62% 26-9 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (3 W 3 L). Best game came against Perrinton not counting games against weak opponents. But that's the only game with rating over 100 against playoff teams.
Zeta:
Tony Fatass (Hong Kong Hustlers 14-2) 3685 67% 41-5 rating of 116. 4 games with rating under 80 (4 W 0 L). In team's two losses threw for 576 yards, 5 TD and 1 INT.
Song Yuanyuan (TKW 14-2) 2732 64% 27-2 rating of 123. 5 games with ratings under 80 (4 W 0 L). Only 2 INTs on the season, 9.4 yards per attempt highest among league starters.
Dedric "The Arm" Frederickson (SAB 14-2) 3938 67% 58-6 rating of 121. 3 games with rating under 80 (3 W 0 L). League leader in TDs, in 2 losses threw for 393 yards, 3 TDs and 0 INTs.
Silver Surfer (Bali Waves 12-4) 3997 69% 38-9 rating of 110. 3 games with rating under 80 (2 W 1 L). Nearly perfect in upset win over HKH, also played well against AWE, MON, SAB, BAN. The only bad game of the season was against TKW.
Jim McMahon (Awendaw ToadFish 12-4) 3530 68% 33-6 rating of 110. 4 games with rating under 80 (2 W 2 L). Played well in losses against TKW and Bali.
Dave Choate (Montana Mercenaries 11-5) 4067 62.1% 31-7 rating of 91. 7 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 4 L). Best game of the season came against Taiwan. But only 2 TDs in 5 losses (4 INTs).
Wayne Walters (Taiwan Demons 9-7) 3302 59% 31-8 rating of 91. 6 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 5 L). Performed poorly against top 5 teams in conference.
William Parker-Laursen (Bangkok Authority Figures 9-7) 3989 64% 36-14 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (1 W 5 L). 6 TDs and 7 INTs against top 5 teams in conference (0-5).
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by datongw
I think a good QB must be able to lead his team into the playoffs, and he must be consistent throughout the season and comes up big in big games. With that said, let's take a look at the playoff QBs:
Alpha:
Joey Kickatello, (Kamakura Katanas 15-1) 3489, 70% 34-5 rating of 115. Only two games with ratings under 80, team won both and one of them he threw for 335. Threw for 294 with a rating of 86 in the team's only loss.
Texan Raider (Portland Dirty Penguins 14-2) 3472, 65% 27-11 rating of 104. Also only two games with ratings under 80 (1 W 1 L). Threw for 368 in win against Kamakura.
Atomic Dog (P-Funk Allstars 13-3) 3098, 59% 29-9 rating of 89. 5 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 3 L). Performed miserably in all 3 of the team's losses.
Chord Naim (Samed Accomplishers 12-4) 2340 64% 23-8 rating of 96. 4 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 3 L). Did not perform well in all team's 4 losses.
Art Schlichter (Padong Dragons 11-5) 3653 70% 16-12 rating of 89. 8 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 5 L), enough said.
Larry Ballstar (Sumatra Swarm 11-5) 3945 63% 27-12 rating of 89. 6 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 4 L).
Jack E Adamski (Perrinton Panthers 11-5) 2938 62% 13-10 rating of 81. Only 13 TDs, and 10 INTs.
Danny White (Tongduchon Cowboys 11-5) 3399 62% 26-9 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (3 W 3 L). Best game came against Perrinton not counting games against weak opponents. But that's the only game with rating over 100 against playoff teams.
Zeta:
Tony Fatass (Hong Kong Hustlers 14-2) 3685 67% 41-5 rating of 116. 4 games with rating under 80 (4 W 0 L). In team's two losses threw for 576 yards, 5 TD and 1 INT.
Song Yuanyuan (TKW 14-2) 2732 64% 27-2 rating of 123. 5 games with ratings under 80 (4 W 0 L). Only 2 INTs on the season, 9.4 yards per attempt highest among league starters.
Dedric "The Arm" Frederickson (SAB 14-2) 3938 67% 58-6 rating of 121. 3 games with rating under 80 (3 W 0 L). League leader in TDs, in 2 losses threw for 393 yards, 3 TDs and 0 INTs.
Silver Surfer (Bali Waves 12-4) 3997 69% 38-9 rating of 110. 3 games with rating under 80 (2 W 1 L). Nearly perfect in upset win over HKH, also played well against AWE, MON, SAB, BAN. The only bad game of the season was against TKW.
Jim McMahon (Awendaw ToadFish 12-4) 3530 68% 33-6 rating of 110. 4 games with rating under 80 (2 W 2 L). Played well in losses against TKW and Bali.
Dave Choate (Montana Mercenaries 11-5) 4067 62.1% 31-7 rating of 91. 7 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 4 L). Best game of the season came against Taiwan. But only 2 TDs in 5 losses (4 INTs).
Wayne Walters (Taiwan Demons 9-7) 3302 59% 31-8 rating of 91. 6 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 5 L). Performed poorly against top 5 teams in conference.
William Parker-Laursen (Bangkok Authority Figures 9-7) 3989 64% 36-14 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (1 W 5 L). 6 TDs and 7 INTs against top 5 teams in conference (0-5).
Great analysis, Datong! I don't think you made it much easier to decide, though.
I think a good QB must be able to lead his team into the playoffs, and he must be consistent throughout the season and comes up big in big games. With that said, let's take a look at the playoff QBs:
Alpha:
Joey Kickatello, (Kamakura Katanas 15-1) 3489, 70% 34-5 rating of 115. Only two games with ratings under 80, team won both and one of them he threw for 335. Threw for 294 with a rating of 86 in the team's only loss.
Texan Raider (Portland Dirty Penguins 14-2) 3472, 65% 27-11 rating of 104. Also only two games with ratings under 80 (1 W 1 L). Threw for 368 in win against Kamakura.
Atomic Dog (P-Funk Allstars 13-3) 3098, 59% 29-9 rating of 89. 5 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 3 L). Performed miserably in all 3 of the team's losses.
Chord Naim (Samed Accomplishers 12-4) 2340 64% 23-8 rating of 96. 4 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 3 L). Did not perform well in all team's 4 losses.
Art Schlichter (Padong Dragons 11-5) 3653 70% 16-12 rating of 89. 8 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 5 L), enough said.
Larry Ballstar (Sumatra Swarm 11-5) 3945 63% 27-12 rating of 89. 6 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 4 L).
Jack E Adamski (Perrinton Panthers 11-5) 2938 62% 13-10 rating of 81. Only 13 TDs, and 10 INTs.
Danny White (Tongduchon Cowboys 11-5) 3399 62% 26-9 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (3 W 3 L). Best game came against Perrinton not counting games against weak opponents. But that's the only game with rating over 100 against playoff teams.
Zeta:
Tony Fatass (Hong Kong Hustlers 14-2) 3685 67% 41-5 rating of 116. 4 games with rating under 80 (4 W 0 L). In team's two losses threw for 576 yards, 5 TD and 1 INT.
Song Yuanyuan (TKW 14-2) 2732 64% 27-2 rating of 123. 5 games with ratings under 80 (4 W 0 L). Only 2 INTs on the season, 9.4 yards per attempt highest among league starters.
Dedric "The Arm" Frederickson (SAB 14-2) 3938 67% 58-6 rating of 121. 3 games with rating under 80 (3 W 0 L). League leader in TDs, in 2 losses threw for 393 yards, 3 TDs and 0 INTs.
Silver Surfer (Bali Waves 12-4) 3997 69% 38-9 rating of 110. 3 games with rating under 80 (2 W 1 L). Nearly perfect in upset win over HKH, also played well against AWE, MON, SAB, BAN. The only bad game of the season was against TKW.
Jim McMahon (Awendaw ToadFish 12-4) 3530 68% 33-6 rating of 110. 4 games with rating under 80 (2 W 2 L). Played well in losses against TKW and Bali.
Dave Choate (Montana Mercenaries 11-5) 4067 62.1% 31-7 rating of 91. 7 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 4 L). Best game of the season came against Taiwan. But only 2 TDs in 5 losses (4 INTs).
Wayne Walters (Taiwan Demons 9-7) 3302 59% 31-8 rating of 91. 6 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 5 L). Performed poorly against top 5 teams in conference.
William Parker-Laursen (Bangkok Authority Figures 9-7) 3989 64% 36-14 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (1 W 5 L). 6 TDs and 7 INTs against top 5 teams in conference (0-5).
Great analysis, Datong! I don't think you made it much easier to decide, though.

czman
offline
offline
Originally posted by MorsDraconis
Originally posted by czman
3 gutted teams in zeta and 1 in alpha. I am sure that skews some of the numbers.
We get it. You guys still have this idea that Alpha is better than Zeta. That's fine.
Just for the sake of Dedric, we played one of Alpha's THREE gutted teams as well, Sioux City Rampage. Hell, you can't even count the game against To Ken Love Bort since our punt returner scored all the points that game (offense only got 33 plays the whole game and Dedric still threw for 5 TDs).
It's not any Zeta conference QB's fault that Alpha decided to inflate their RB's stats instead of their QB's stats.
And it's certainly not Zeta's fault that Kamakura only put up 90 points on each of their other gutted teams compared to the three on our side getting destroyed by pretty much everyone. Running the ball all the time does that.
Can you read?
I never said alpha was better.
I never said anything about any positional player vs another.
You scored 10 more points than us against out bad team and we scored 20 more than you on your bad team....Who cares nothing to do with what I typed at all.
I just think this is mental masturbation. People are so interested in pumping up players on their team or league when in reality they know little to nothing about the other league.
I know you know nothing about Alpha and my team from your comments.
The katanas had the most TD passes in Alpha.
You should really do some fact checking before you start to type nonsense.
Originally posted by czman
3 gutted teams in zeta and 1 in alpha. I am sure that skews some of the numbers.
We get it. You guys still have this idea that Alpha is better than Zeta. That's fine.
Just for the sake of Dedric, we played one of Alpha's THREE gutted teams as well, Sioux City Rampage. Hell, you can't even count the game against To Ken Love Bort since our punt returner scored all the points that game (offense only got 33 plays the whole game and Dedric still threw for 5 TDs).
It's not any Zeta conference QB's fault that Alpha decided to inflate their RB's stats instead of their QB's stats.
And it's certainly not Zeta's fault that Kamakura only put up 90 points on each of their other gutted teams compared to the three on our side getting destroyed by pretty much everyone. Running the ball all the time does that.
Can you read?
I never said alpha was better.
I never said anything about any positional player vs another.
You scored 10 more points than us against out bad team and we scored 20 more than you on your bad team....Who cares nothing to do with what I typed at all.
I just think this is mental masturbation. People are so interested in pumping up players on their team or league when in reality they know little to nothing about the other league.
I know you know nothing about Alpha and my team from your comments.
The katanas had the most TD passes in Alpha.
You should really do some fact checking before you start to type nonsense.
datongw
offline
offline
It's pretty clear in Alpha the best QBs are Joey Kickatello and Texan Raider. Joey was a bit more efficient with higher completion % and less INTs. But Texan Raider gets the edge in yards per attempt and big head to head win.
It's a little more crowded in Zeta, one could make a case for all 5 of the top five teams in the conference. A closer look at their numbers against the other 4 teams:
Tony Fatass 60-92 578 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (3-1 record)
Song YuanYuan 45-72 401 yards 0 TD 1 INT (3-1 record)
Dedric Frederickson 74-130 730 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Silver Surfer 102-160 998 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Jim McMahon 88-142 936 yards 5 TD 5 INTs (2-2 record)
Song Yuanyuan didn't pass enough to put up significant numbers; Jim McMahon threw the most picks; Silver Surfer had the highest passing yards, but took the most attempts. It comes down between Tony Fatass and Dedric Frederickson, both put up similar numbers, very tough call between these 2 QBs as their numbers are almost identical on so many levels. In the end, the edge goes to Tony Fatass by the slightest of margins for winning the game head to head even though Frederickson out threw him in that game.
So there you have it: Texas Raider for Alpha and Tony Fatass for Zeta. Since there are not enough inter conference games played, it's hard to compare the stats between the two conferences.
Edit: Against common opponents: Taiwan and Samed, Texas Raider and Tony Fatass put up these numbers:
Texas Raider: 36-56 64% 534 yards 4 TD 2 INT (1-1 record)
Tony Fatass: 57-83 68% 480 yards 3 TD 1 INT (1-1 record)
Very similar numbers....
It's a little more crowded in Zeta, one could make a case for all 5 of the top five teams in the conference. A closer look at their numbers against the other 4 teams:
Tony Fatass 60-92 578 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (3-1 record)
Song YuanYuan 45-72 401 yards 0 TD 1 INT (3-1 record)
Dedric Frederickson 74-130 730 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Silver Surfer 102-160 998 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Jim McMahon 88-142 936 yards 5 TD 5 INTs (2-2 record)
Song Yuanyuan didn't pass enough to put up significant numbers; Jim McMahon threw the most picks; Silver Surfer had the highest passing yards, but took the most attempts. It comes down between Tony Fatass and Dedric Frederickson, both put up similar numbers, very tough call between these 2 QBs as their numbers are almost identical on so many levels. In the end, the edge goes to Tony Fatass by the slightest of margins for winning the game head to head even though Frederickson out threw him in that game.
So there you have it: Texas Raider for Alpha and Tony Fatass for Zeta. Since there are not enough inter conference games played, it's hard to compare the stats between the two conferences.
Edit: Against common opponents: Taiwan and Samed, Texas Raider and Tony Fatass put up these numbers:
Texas Raider: 36-56 64% 534 yards 4 TD 2 INT (1-1 record)
Tony Fatass: 57-83 68% 480 yards 3 TD 1 INT (1-1 record)
Very similar numbers....
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 18:27:09
czman
offline
offline
Originally posted by datongw
It's pretty clear in Alpha the best QBs are Joey Kickatello and Texan Raider. Joey was a bit more efficient with higher completion % and less INTs. But Texan Raider gets the edge in yards per attempt and big head to head win.
It's a little more crowded in Zeta, one could make a case for all 5 of the top five teams in the conference. A closer look at their numbers against the other 4 teams:
Tony Fatass 60-92 578 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (3-1 record)
Song YuanYuan 45-72 401 yards 0 TD 1 INT (3-1 record)
Dedric Frederickson 74-130 730 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Silver Surfer 102-160 998 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Jim McMahon 88-142 936 yards 5 TD 5 INTs (2-2 record)
Song Yuanyuan didn't pass enough to put up significant numbers; Jim McMahon throw the most picks; Silver Surfer had the highest passing yards, but took the most attempts. Tony Fatass and Dedric Frederickson put up similar numbers, very tough call between these 2 QBs as their numbers are almost identical on so many levels. In the end, the edge goes to Tony Fatass by the slightest of margins for winning the game head to head even though Frederickson out threw him in that game.
So there you have it: Texas Raider for Alpha and Tony Fatass for Zeta. Since there are not enough inter conference games played, it's hard to compare the stats between the two conferences.
I stand corrected.....
This man, even though I disagree with him about the one owner teams, is actually trying to put personal feelings aside and attempting to find the best player with the information available.
Not sure I think you should be dropping Larry Ballstar off of the list. He was huge for a team that is in the second round of the playoffs. I think he mat have been the most important QB to a playoff team. Or he may not be. But he was still really good.
It's pretty clear in Alpha the best QBs are Joey Kickatello and Texan Raider. Joey was a bit more efficient with higher completion % and less INTs. But Texan Raider gets the edge in yards per attempt and big head to head win.
It's a little more crowded in Zeta, one could make a case for all 5 of the top five teams in the conference. A closer look at their numbers against the other 4 teams:
Tony Fatass 60-92 578 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (3-1 record)
Song YuanYuan 45-72 401 yards 0 TD 1 INT (3-1 record)
Dedric Frederickson 74-130 730 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Silver Surfer 102-160 998 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Jim McMahon 88-142 936 yards 5 TD 5 INTs (2-2 record)
Song Yuanyuan didn't pass enough to put up significant numbers; Jim McMahon throw the most picks; Silver Surfer had the highest passing yards, but took the most attempts. Tony Fatass and Dedric Frederickson put up similar numbers, very tough call between these 2 QBs as their numbers are almost identical on so many levels. In the end, the edge goes to Tony Fatass by the slightest of margins for winning the game head to head even though Frederickson out threw him in that game.
So there you have it: Texas Raider for Alpha and Tony Fatass for Zeta. Since there are not enough inter conference games played, it's hard to compare the stats between the two conferences.
I stand corrected.....
This man, even though I disagree with him about the one owner teams, is actually trying to put personal feelings aside and attempting to find the best player with the information available.
Not sure I think you should be dropping Larry Ballstar off of the list. He was huge for a team that is in the second round of the playoffs. I think he mat have been the most important QB to a playoff team. Or he may not be. But he was still really good.
datongw
offline
offline
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by datongw
It's pretty clear in Alpha the best QBs are Joey Kickatello and Texan Raider. Joey was a bit more efficient with higher completion % and less INTs. But Texan Raider gets the edge in yards per attempt and big head to head win.
It's a little more crowded in Zeta, one could make a case for all 5 of the top five teams in the conference. A closer look at their numbers against the other 4 teams:
Tony Fatass 60-92 578 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (3-1 record)
Song YuanYuan 45-72 401 yards 0 TD 1 INT (3-1 record)
Dedric Frederickson 74-130 730 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Silver Surfer 102-160 998 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Jim McMahon 88-142 936 yards 5 TD 5 INTs (2-2 record)
Song Yuanyuan didn't pass enough to put up significant numbers; Jim McMahon throw the most picks; Silver Surfer had the highest passing yards, but took the most attempts. Tony Fatass and Dedric Frederickson put up similar numbers, very tough call between these 2 QBs as their numbers are almost identical on so many levels. In the end, the edge goes to Tony Fatass by the slightest of margins for winning the game head to head even though Frederickson out threw him in that game.
So there you have it: Texas Raider for Alpha and Tony Fatass for Zeta. Since there are not enough inter conference games played, it's hard to compare the stats between the two conferences.
I stand corrected.....
This man, even though I disagree with him about the one owner teams, is actually trying to put personal feelings aside and attempting to find the best player with the information available.
Not sure I think you should be dropping Larry Ballstar off of the list. He was huge for a team that is in the second round of the playoffs. I think he mat have been the most important QB to a playoff team. Or he may not be. But he was still really good.
Larry had a good season, but in team's 5 losses, he threw 8 INTs and only 2 TDs. He will need to play better against higher competition to be in the same class of QB as Joey and Texan.
Originally posted by datongw
It's pretty clear in Alpha the best QBs are Joey Kickatello and Texan Raider. Joey was a bit more efficient with higher completion % and less INTs. But Texan Raider gets the edge in yards per attempt and big head to head win.
It's a little more crowded in Zeta, one could make a case for all 5 of the top five teams in the conference. A closer look at their numbers against the other 4 teams:
Tony Fatass 60-92 578 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (3-1 record)
Song YuanYuan 45-72 401 yards 0 TD 1 INT (3-1 record)
Dedric Frederickson 74-130 730 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Silver Surfer 102-160 998 yards 6 TD 3 INTs (2-2 record)
Jim McMahon 88-142 936 yards 5 TD 5 INTs (2-2 record)
Song Yuanyuan didn't pass enough to put up significant numbers; Jim McMahon throw the most picks; Silver Surfer had the highest passing yards, but took the most attempts. Tony Fatass and Dedric Frederickson put up similar numbers, very tough call between these 2 QBs as their numbers are almost identical on so many levels. In the end, the edge goes to Tony Fatass by the slightest of margins for winning the game head to head even though Frederickson out threw him in that game.
So there you have it: Texas Raider for Alpha and Tony Fatass for Zeta. Since there are not enough inter conference games played, it's hard to compare the stats between the two conferences.
I stand corrected.....
This man, even though I disagree with him about the one owner teams, is actually trying to put personal feelings aside and attempting to find the best player with the information available.
Not sure I think you should be dropping Larry Ballstar off of the list. He was huge for a team that is in the second round of the playoffs. I think he mat have been the most important QB to a playoff team. Or he may not be. But he was still really good.
Larry had a good season, but in team's 5 losses, he threw 8 INTs and only 2 TDs. He will need to play better against higher competition to be in the same class of QB as Joey and Texan.
czman
offline
offline
I know but The swarm were 5th in total rushing yards and 7 in TDs. He did very well without the benefit of the running game that the Katanas and the PDP had. You are right though he did not do it against the best teams though.
Originally posted by datongw
I think a good QB must be able to lead his team into the playoffs, and he must be consistent throughout the season and comes up big in big games. With that said, let's take a look at the playoff QBs:
Alpha:
Joey Kickatello, (Kamakura Katanas 15-1) 3489, 70% 34-5 rating of 115. Only two games with ratings under 80, team won both and one of them he threw for 335. Threw for 294 with a rating of 86 in the team's only loss.
Texan Raider (Portland Dirty Penguins 14-2) 3472, 65% 27-11 rating of 104. Also only two games with ratings under 80 (1 W 1 L). Threw for 368 in win against Kamakura.
Atomic Dog (P-Funk Allstars 13-3) 3098, 59% 29-9 rating of 89. 5 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 3 L). Performed miserably in all 3 of the team's losses.
Chord Naim (Samed Accomplishers 12-4) 2340 64% 23-8 rating of 96. 4 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 3 L). Did not perform well in all team's 4 losses.
Art Schlichter (Padong Dragons 11-5) 3653 70% 16-12 rating of 89. 8 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 5 L), enough said.
Larry Ballstar (Sumatra Swarm 11-5) 3945 63% 27-12 rating of 89. 6 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 4 L).
Jack E Adamski (Perrinton Panthers 11-5) 2938 62% 13-10 rating of 81. Only 13 TDs, and 10 INTs.
Danny White (Tongduchon Cowboys 11-5) 3399 62% 26-9 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (3 W 3 L). Best game came against Perrinton not counting games against weak opponents. But that's the only game with rating over 100 against playoff teams.
Zeta:
Tony Fatass (Hong Kong Hustlers 14-2) 3685 67% 41-5 rating of 116. 4 games with rating under 80 (4 W 0 L). In team's two losses threw for 576 yards, 5 TD and 1 INT.
Song Yuanyuan (TKW 14-2) 2732 64% 27-2 rating of 123. 5 games with ratings under 80 (4 W 0 L). Only 2 INTs on the season, 9.4 yards per attempt highest among league starters.
Dedric "The Arm" Frederickson (SAB 14-2) 3938 67% 58-6 rating of 121. 3 games with rating under 80 (3 W 0 L). League leader in TDs, in 2 losses threw for 393 yards, 3 TDs and 0 INTs.
Silver Surfer (Bali Waves 12-4) 3997 69% 38-9 rating of 110. 3 games with rating under 80 (2 W 1 L). Nearly perfect in upset win over HKH, also played well against AWE, MON, SAB, BAN. The only bad game of the season was against TKW.
Jim McMahon (Awendaw ToadFish 12-4) 3530 68% 33-6 rating of 110. 4 games with rating under 80 (2 W 2 L). Played well in losses against TKW and Bali.
Dave Choate (Montana Mercenaries 11-5) 4067 62.1% 31-7 rating of 91. 7 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 4 L). Best game of the season came against Taiwan. But only 2 TDs in 5 losses (4 INTs).
Wayne Walters (Taiwan Demons 9-7) 3302 59% 31-8 rating of 91. 6 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 5 L). Performed poorly against top 5 teams in conference.
William Parker-Laursen (Bangkok Authority Figures 9-7) 3989 64% 36-14 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (1 W 5 L). 6 TDs and 7 INTs against top 5 teams in conference (0-5).
Very nice. datongw
I think a good QB must be able to lead his team into the playoffs, and he must be consistent throughout the season and comes up big in big games. With that said, let's take a look at the playoff QBs:
Alpha:
Joey Kickatello, (Kamakura Katanas 15-1) 3489, 70% 34-5 rating of 115. Only two games with ratings under 80, team won both and one of them he threw for 335. Threw for 294 with a rating of 86 in the team's only loss.
Texan Raider (Portland Dirty Penguins 14-2) 3472, 65% 27-11 rating of 104. Also only two games with ratings under 80 (1 W 1 L). Threw for 368 in win against Kamakura.
Atomic Dog (P-Funk Allstars 13-3) 3098, 59% 29-9 rating of 89. 5 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 3 L). Performed miserably in all 3 of the team's losses.
Chord Naim (Samed Accomplishers 12-4) 2340 64% 23-8 rating of 96. 4 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 3 L). Did not perform well in all team's 4 losses.
Art Schlichter (Padong Dragons 11-5) 3653 70% 16-12 rating of 89. 8 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 5 L), enough said.
Larry Ballstar (Sumatra Swarm 11-5) 3945 63% 27-12 rating of 89. 6 games with ratings under 80 (2 W 4 L).
Jack E Adamski (Perrinton Panthers 11-5) 2938 62% 13-10 rating of 81. Only 13 TDs, and 10 INTs.
Danny White (Tongduchon Cowboys 11-5) 3399 62% 26-9 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (3 W 3 L). Best game came against Perrinton not counting games against weak opponents. But that's the only game with rating over 100 against playoff teams.
Zeta:
Tony Fatass (Hong Kong Hustlers 14-2) 3685 67% 41-5 rating of 116. 4 games with rating under 80 (4 W 0 L). In team's two losses threw for 576 yards, 5 TD and 1 INT.
Song Yuanyuan (TKW 14-2) 2732 64% 27-2 rating of 123. 5 games with ratings under 80 (4 W 0 L). Only 2 INTs on the season, 9.4 yards per attempt highest among league starters.
Dedric "The Arm" Frederickson (SAB 14-2) 3938 67% 58-6 rating of 121. 3 games with rating under 80 (3 W 0 L). League leader in TDs, in 2 losses threw for 393 yards, 3 TDs and 0 INTs.
Silver Surfer (Bali Waves 12-4) 3997 69% 38-9 rating of 110. 3 games with rating under 80 (2 W 1 L). Nearly perfect in upset win over HKH, also played well against AWE, MON, SAB, BAN. The only bad game of the season was against TKW.
Jim McMahon (Awendaw ToadFish 12-4) 3530 68% 33-6 rating of 110. 4 games with rating under 80 (2 W 2 L). Played well in losses against TKW and Bali.
Dave Choate (Montana Mercenaries 11-5) 4067 62.1% 31-7 rating of 91. 7 games with ratings under 80 (3 W 4 L). Best game of the season came against Taiwan. But only 2 TDs in 5 losses (4 INTs).
Wayne Walters (Taiwan Demons 9-7) 3302 59% 31-8 rating of 91. 6 games with ratings under 80 (1 W 5 L). Performed poorly against top 5 teams in conference.
William Parker-Laursen (Bangkok Authority Figures 9-7) 3989 64% 36-14 rating of 97. 6 games with rating under 80 (1 W 5 L). 6 TDs and 7 INTs against top 5 teams in conference (0-5).
Very nice. datongw
MorsDraconis
offline
offline
Personally, I don't think head-to-head records should come into play at all. The NFL doesn't do that, even in statistical breakdowns of the players.
Sure, their Pro Bowl is basically a popularity contest, but sometimes they get it right (Derek Anderson being there was definitely deserved even though most people disagreed because without him last season, the Browns wouldn't have done nearly as well as they did even with all the INTs he threw).
I think we should take the NFL's idea and run with it. Why do we have to have only one from each conference? Why not 3 or 4?
Also, going by the playoff teams is great, but you're leaving out a QB that I think is probably right up there in performance in Kyoto's QB Donovan "Go Get It" Freeman. The dude threw for 5,000 yards and 47 TDs for christ's sake and only 9 INTs. That's insane considering he threw the ball 730 times. That's 81 attempts per interception. That's pretty damn good in my opinion considering that's probably 2 games in a row without an INT before throwing one.
Want information about his play against the top 4 in Zeta?
Against South Austin: 74.4 QB Rating 31 of 59 (52.5%) for 343.5 yards 2 TDs and 1 INT
Against TKW: 70.5 QB Rating 27 of 47 (57.4) for 232.0 yards 0 TDs and 0 INTs
Against HKH: 44.9 QB Rating 28 of 51 (54.9) for 183.5 yards 1 TDs and 3 INTs (definitely his worst game)
Against Bali: 111.9 QB Rating 31 of 44 (70.5) for 300.0 yards 3 TDs and 0 INTs (definitely his best game)
I'd say that's pretty good considering he's basically their entire offense and going into games, teams knew that they were going to pass the ball. So even though they knew that they were going to pass the ball, he put up those kind of numbers. I'd say that's pretty damn impressive compared to some of the other QBs playing for run first teams or teams that can do both well.
Sure, their Pro Bowl is basically a popularity contest, but sometimes they get it right (Derek Anderson being there was definitely deserved even though most people disagreed because without him last season, the Browns wouldn't have done nearly as well as they did even with all the INTs he threw).
I think we should take the NFL's idea and run with it. Why do we have to have only one from each conference? Why not 3 or 4?
Also, going by the playoff teams is great, but you're leaving out a QB that I think is probably right up there in performance in Kyoto's QB Donovan "Go Get It" Freeman. The dude threw for 5,000 yards and 47 TDs for christ's sake and only 9 INTs. That's insane considering he threw the ball 730 times. That's 81 attempts per interception. That's pretty damn good in my opinion considering that's probably 2 games in a row without an INT before throwing one.
Want information about his play against the top 4 in Zeta?
Against South Austin: 74.4 QB Rating 31 of 59 (52.5%) for 343.5 yards 2 TDs and 1 INT
Against TKW: 70.5 QB Rating 27 of 47 (57.4) for 232.0 yards 0 TDs and 0 INTs
Against HKH: 44.9 QB Rating 28 of 51 (54.9) for 183.5 yards 1 TDs and 3 INTs (definitely his worst game)
Against Bali: 111.9 QB Rating 31 of 44 (70.5) for 300.0 yards 3 TDs and 0 INTs (definitely his best game)
I'd say that's pretty good considering he's basically their entire offense and going into games, teams knew that they were going to pass the ball. So even though they knew that they were going to pass the ball, he put up those kind of numbers. I'd say that's pretty damn impressive compared to some of the other QBs playing for run first teams or teams that can do both well.
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by MorsDraconis
Personally, I don't think head-to-head records should come into play at all. The NFL doesn't do that, even in statistical breakdowns of the players.
Sure, their Pro Bowl is basically a popularity contest, but sometimes they get it right (Derek Anderson being there was definitely deserved even though most people disagreed because without him last season, the Browns wouldn't have done nearly as well as they did even with all the INTs he threw).
I think we should take the NFL's idea and run with it. Why do we have to have only one from each conference? Why not 3 or 4?
Also, going by the playoff teams is great, but you're leaving out a QB that I think is probably right up there in performance in Kyoto's QB Donovan "Go Get It" Freeman. The dude threw for 5,000 yards and 47 TDs for christ's sake and only 9 INTs. That's insane considering he threw the ball 730 times. That's 81 attempts per interception. That's pretty damn good in my opinion considering that's probably 2 games in a row without an INT before throwing one.
Want information about his play against the top 4 in Zeta?
Against South Austin: 74.4 QB Rating 31 of 59 (52.5%) for 343.5 yards 2 TDs and 1 INT
Against TKW: 70.5 QB Rating 27 of 47 (57.4) for 232.0 yards 0 TDs and 0 INTs
Against HKH: 44.9 QB Rating 28 of 51 (54.9) for 183.5 yards 1 TDs and 3 INTs (definitely his worst game)
Against Bali: 111.9 QB Rating 31 of 44 (70.5) for 300.0 yards 3 TDs and 0 INTs (definitely his best game)
I'd say that's pretty good considering he's basically their entire offense and going into games, teams knew that they were going to pass the ball. So even though they knew that they were going to pass the ball, he put up those kind of numbers. I'd say that's pretty damn impressive compared to some of the other QBs playing for run first teams or teams that can do both well.
I've got to agree about Donovan. I can't believe he's been overlooked. Up until the last couple of weeks of the season, he was leading the league in TDs and yards. Pretty impressive.
Personally, I don't think head-to-head records should come into play at all. The NFL doesn't do that, even in statistical breakdowns of the players.
Sure, their Pro Bowl is basically a popularity contest, but sometimes they get it right (Derek Anderson being there was definitely deserved even though most people disagreed because without him last season, the Browns wouldn't have done nearly as well as they did even with all the INTs he threw).
I think we should take the NFL's idea and run with it. Why do we have to have only one from each conference? Why not 3 or 4?
Also, going by the playoff teams is great, but you're leaving out a QB that I think is probably right up there in performance in Kyoto's QB Donovan "Go Get It" Freeman. The dude threw for 5,000 yards and 47 TDs for christ's sake and only 9 INTs. That's insane considering he threw the ball 730 times. That's 81 attempts per interception. That's pretty damn good in my opinion considering that's probably 2 games in a row without an INT before throwing one.
Want information about his play against the top 4 in Zeta?
Against South Austin: 74.4 QB Rating 31 of 59 (52.5%) for 343.5 yards 2 TDs and 1 INT
Against TKW: 70.5 QB Rating 27 of 47 (57.4) for 232.0 yards 0 TDs and 0 INTs
Against HKH: 44.9 QB Rating 28 of 51 (54.9) for 183.5 yards 1 TDs and 3 INTs (definitely his worst game)
Against Bali: 111.9 QB Rating 31 of 44 (70.5) for 300.0 yards 3 TDs and 0 INTs (definitely his best game)
I'd say that's pretty good considering he's basically their entire offense and going into games, teams knew that they were going to pass the ball. So even though they knew that they were going to pass the ball, he put up those kind of numbers. I'd say that's pretty damn impressive compared to some of the other QBs playing for run first teams or teams that can do both well.
I've got to agree about Donovan. I can't believe he's been overlooked. Up until the last couple of weeks of the season, he was leading the league in TDs and yards. Pretty impressive.
officerpdny
offline
offline
Originally posted by datongw
Larry had a good season, but in team's 5 losses, he threw 8 INTs and only 2 TDs. He will need to play better against higher competition to be in the same class of QB as Joey and Texan.
I think Larry had a solid statistical year. As for your stipulation, he threw for 420yds and 3tds with 0ints today against the Portland Dirty Penguins.
Like any player he has his ups and downs. For me it's important to remember that Sumatra was still adjusting to the new league for the first few games, which is also where we suffered our most (and worst) losses.
Whether or not that adds anything to the ProBowl balloting? I'm a believer that the regular season is all that matters for that stuff.
Larry had a good season, but in team's 5 losses, he threw 8 INTs and only 2 TDs. He will need to play better against higher competition to be in the same class of QB as Joey and Texan.
I think Larry had a solid statistical year. As for your stipulation, he threw for 420yds and 3tds with 0ints today against the Portland Dirty Penguins.
Like any player he has his ups and downs. For me it's important to remember that Sumatra was still adjusting to the new league for the first few games, which is also where we suffered our most (and worst) losses.
Whether or not that adds anything to the ProBowl balloting? I'm a believer that the regular season is all that matters for that stuff.
zebo13
offline
offline
Either way, when HKH takes the Gold Cup two years in a row it will be obvious who the MVP QB is...
czman
offline
offline
Originally posted by zebo13
Either way, when HKH takes the Gold Cup two years in a row it will be obvious who the MVP QB is...
Still one game to play.
Either way, when HKH takes the Gold Cup two years in a row it will be obvious who the MVP QB is...
Still one game to play.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























