bump? are we gonna do this?
trazer
offline
offline
Wouldnt that cause alot of positions to get very very few votes? everyone notices the HB or QB/WR stats..but hardly anyone gives a crap about the DT stats or the LOT stats. They just wont get many votes so 1-2 votes for them will get them into the pro-bowl.
Or am i missing something?
Or am i missing something?
ryan_grant-25
offline
offline
Originally posted by trazer
Wouldnt that cause alot of positions to get very very few votes? everyone notices the HB or QB/WR stats..but hardly anyone gives a crap about the DT stats or the LOT stats. They just wont get many votes so 1-2 votes for them will get them into the pro-bowl.
Or am i missing something?
well if you want your players on the team you would vote for positions that have not been voted for a lot, common sense IMO
Wouldnt that cause alot of positions to get very very few votes? everyone notices the HB or QB/WR stats..but hardly anyone gives a crap about the DT stats or the LOT stats. They just wont get many votes so 1-2 votes for them will get them into the pro-bowl.
Or am i missing something?
well if you want your players on the team you would vote for positions that have not been voted for a lot, common sense IMO
trazer
offline
offline
I agree there, but that doesnt exactly get the right probowl players in there..that just gets the sub par linemen from the sub par teams in the probowl because the better teams prob have more than 5 player that may deserve a shot at the probowl.
IE #1 team has 1 HB 1 QB 1 WR 1 CB and 2 LBs that SHOULD get to the probowl but the owner can only vote for 5..that leaves 1 guy out of the running
the #7 ranked team has 1 HB 1 CB and 1 LOT that deserves a probowl bid but the owner gets 5 votes so puts in 2 LBs...
Maybe his crappy LB gets in because team #1 couldnt put his in.
Now i know more teams get to vote but limiting each team like that could certainly leave out players that deserve a chance.
I guess im just saying you are asking for a system that just begs people to try and exploit it to get sub par people in there.
IE #1 team has 1 HB 1 QB 1 WR 1 CB and 2 LBs that SHOULD get to the probowl but the owner can only vote for 5..that leaves 1 guy out of the running
the #7 ranked team has 1 HB 1 CB and 1 LOT that deserves a probowl bid but the owner gets 5 votes so puts in 2 LBs...
Maybe his crappy LB gets in because team #1 couldnt put his in.
Now i know more teams get to vote but limiting each team like that could certainly leave out players that deserve a chance.
I guess im just saying you are asking for a system that just begs people to try and exploit it to get sub par people in there.
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 13:25:33
trazer
offline
offline
Ya man whatever...im just saying a better way would be good, but if you want to cry because someone suggests something then oh well..its not my division anyways...i dont really care.
BMB2008
offline
offline
Originally posted by Santah
QB: Johnny Chase
HB: Running Rabbit
HB: John Sutton
FB: Ryan Smithers
WR: Jon Bostic
WR: Deeben Cidar
TE: thomas lemoine
T: Mike Garner
T: Carls NIcks
G: Doctor Cox
G: Blue Amigo
C: Fred 'The Whaffle' Maker
DE: Toss Salad
DE: Robert Quinn
DT: Hidden Goatsee
DT: Tommie Crane
LB: Cummin Hard
LB: Villian McMillan
LB: David Parsons
CB: Jared Fortna
CB: Randall Doctor
FS: Steve Jerz
SS: Drake Estructor
KR: Donovan Warren
PR: Tripp Still
K: Phat Boot
P: Slur P
Take too long to give reason for each person. Picked based off stats, lvl, custom equip etc. I also penalised players for errors like throwing intercepts, fumbling, missing tackles etc. Anyone with their build open was automatically disqualified.
How in the fuck can you not put your own teams CB in the running? 11 ints 5 TD, you must be retarded.
QB: Johnny Chase
HB: Running Rabbit
HB: John Sutton
FB: Ryan Smithers
WR: Jon Bostic
WR: Deeben Cidar
TE: thomas lemoine
T: Mike Garner
T: Carls NIcks
G: Doctor Cox
G: Blue Amigo
C: Fred 'The Whaffle' Maker
DE: Toss Salad
DE: Robert Quinn
DT: Hidden Goatsee
DT: Tommie Crane
LB: Cummin Hard
LB: Villian McMillan
LB: David Parsons
CB: Jared Fortna
CB: Randall Doctor
FS: Steve Jerz
SS: Drake Estructor
KR: Donovan Warren
PR: Tripp Still
K: Phat Boot
P: Slur P
Take too long to give reason for each person. Picked based off stats, lvl, custom equip etc. I also penalised players for errors like throwing intercepts, fumbling, missing tackles etc. Anyone with their build open was automatically disqualified.
How in the fuck can you not put your own teams CB in the running? 11 ints 5 TD, you must be retarded.
ryan_grant-25
offline
offline
is devo puffer really not here? hes the best fuckin back in the league, also you picked the O linemen by pancakes? really is that a joke? my center only averages about 30 pancakes a year, but has never given up a sack
Santah
offline
offline
How the fuck do you want me to pick an O line when I cant see anyones builds? Kill yourself.
...and fuck devo. He only leads Running Rabbit and John Sutton because he got more carries. We both have higher averages.
...and fuck devo. He only leads Running Rabbit and John Sutton because he got more carries. We both have higher averages.
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 20:28:40
SunDevil03
offline
offline
Santah, Devo also has almost TWICE as many TDs as both Rabbit and Sutton.
Devo - 60 TDs
Rabbit - 36 TDs
Sutton - 38 TDs
I don't care what your average is, Devo actually produces results. Also, since you want to point out how many less carries you guys got, Devo only has 1 more fumble than either Rabbit or Sutton, and they had less carries.
So basically... Rabbit and Sutton don't find the end zone as much, and are more prone to fumble. Seems to me like Ryan has a really good argument for Devo being #1.
Devo - 60 TDs
Rabbit - 36 TDs
Sutton - 38 TDs
I don't care what your average is, Devo actually produces results. Also, since you want to point out how many less carries you guys got, Devo only has 1 more fumble than either Rabbit or Sutton, and they had less carries.
So basically... Rabbit and Sutton don't find the end zone as much, and are more prone to fumble. Seems to me like Ryan has a really good argument for Devo being #1.
Last edited Oct 24, 2008 21:18:26
trazer
offline
offline
Originally posted by SunDevil03
Santah, Devo also has almost TWICE as many TDs as both Rabbit and Sutton.
Devo - 60 TDs
Rabbit - 36 TDs
Sutton - 38 TDs
I don't care what your average is, Devo actually produces results. Also, since you want to point out how many less carries you guys got, Devo only has 1 more fumble than either Rabbit or Sutton, and they had less carries.
So basically... Rabbit and Sutton don't find the end zone as much, and are more prone to fumble. Seems to me like Ryan has a really good argument for Devo being #1.
The man makes a good arguement.
Santah, Devo also has almost TWICE as many TDs as both Rabbit and Sutton.
Devo - 60 TDs
Rabbit - 36 TDs
Sutton - 38 TDs
I don't care what your average is, Devo actually produces results. Also, since you want to point out how many less carries you guys got, Devo only has 1 more fumble than either Rabbit or Sutton, and they had less carries.
So basically... Rabbit and Sutton don't find the end zone as much, and are more prone to fumble. Seems to me like Ryan has a really good argument for Devo being #1.
The man makes a good arguement.
toxic9876
offline
offline
Originally posted by SunDevil03
Santah, Devo also has almost TWICE as many TDs as both Rabbit and Sutton.
Devo - 60 TDs
Rabbit - 36 TDs
Sutton - 38 TDs
I don't care what your average is, Devo actually produces results. Also, since you want to point out how many less carries you guys got, Devo only has 1 more fumble than either Rabbit or Sutton, and they had less carries.
So basically... Rabbit and Sutton don't find the end zone as much, and are more prone to fumble. Seems to me like Ryan has a really good argument for Devo being #1.
Rabbit would of had more yards and been close in TD's if I did't give Mr. Freight Train half the carries to keep the energy levels up for both.
Rabbit-2586 yards 36 TD
Train -2060 yards 26 TD
Devo had about 7.5 more carries per game then the rabbit. With the 7.5 carries the rabbit would have a 1000 more yards for the season
Santah, Devo also has almost TWICE as many TDs as both Rabbit and Sutton.
Devo - 60 TDs
Rabbit - 36 TDs
Sutton - 38 TDs
I don't care what your average is, Devo actually produces results. Also, since you want to point out how many less carries you guys got, Devo only has 1 more fumble than either Rabbit or Sutton, and they had less carries.
So basically... Rabbit and Sutton don't find the end zone as much, and are more prone to fumble. Seems to me like Ryan has a really good argument for Devo being #1.
Rabbit would of had more yards and been close in TD's if I did't give Mr. Freight Train half the carries to keep the energy levels up for both.
Rabbit-2586 yards 36 TD
Train -2060 yards 26 TD
Devo had about 7.5 more carries per game then the rabbit. With the 7.5 carries the rabbit would have a 1000 more yards for the season
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























