User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bruins33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by Bomber085

How not? Everyone plays the same teams except for game 16.. How is that not taking it into account enough?



Some people run up the score on lower teams and try to stat pad, while others try and get back ups much more playing time and mess with the depth chart. PD against the whole league is favored too much IMO.


Ya well like when we beat Cabo Wabo 51-14 and say someone else edged them out its different.
 
Bomber085
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bruins33
Originally posted by bruiser 1234

Originally posted by Bomber085


How not? Everyone plays the same teams except for game 16.. How is that not taking it into account enough?



Some people run up the score on lower teams and try to stat pad, while others try and get back ups much more playing time and mess with the depth chart. PD against the whole league is favored too much IMO.


Ya well like when we beat Cabo Wabo 51-14 and say someone else edged them out its different.


The problem with that is that you're asking me to put in my judgement. Right now, the highest weighted item in the formula is who you beat related to the levels of players on the team..

For example, if you beat Gangnam (currently the lowest leveled), you get 5 points plus the point differential. If you beat Shanhai Swamp Legends (currently the highest leveled) you get 160 points plus the point differential.

I don't want to go too much further into the formula, but I'm sure if you go back through my arguments for all the weeks, you can put it together. I think the formula works as it distributes the points relatively evenly across all teams in the league. I don't want to put too much judgement into this because that allows me to play favorites and I don't want to have a league bias..
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bomber085
Originally posted by Bruins33

Originally posted by bruiser 1234


Originally posted by Bomber085



How not? Everyone plays the same teams except for game 16.. How is that not taking it into account enough?



Some people run up the score on lower teams and try to stat pad, while others try and get back ups much more playing time and mess with the depth chart. PD against the whole league is favored too much IMO.


Ya well like when we beat Cabo Wabo 51-14 and say someone else edged them out its different.


The problem with that is that you're asking me to put in my judgement. Right now, the highest weighted item in the formula is who you beat related to the levels of players on the team..

For example, if you beat Gangnam (currently the lowest leveled), you get 5 points plus the point differential. If you beat Shanhai Swamp Legends (currently the highest leveled) you get 160 points plus the point differential.

I don't want to go too much further into the formula, but I'm sure if you go back through my arguments for all the weeks, you can put it together. I think the formula works as it distributes the points relatively evenly across all teams in the league. I don't want to put too much judgement into this because that allows me to play favorites and I don't want to have a league bias..


Ok. How is Shanghai the highest leveled though? Highest in Zeta, or highest overall? And did you update the levels from transactions, or just the levels from when you started it?

Sorry all the questions, just trying to figure out the formula a bit for myself
 
Bomber085
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234

Ok. How is Shanghai the highest leveled though? Highest in Zeta, or highest overall? And did you update the levels from transactions, or just the levels from when you started it?

Sorry all the questions, just trying to figure out the formula a bit for myself


haha, no worries.. like I said before.. I'll quickly lay out the whole process, it's not really a secret..

I add up all the levels of starters for each team and rank from 1st to 32nd.

I update these rankings every 2-3 games, depending on when I have time.. It takes like an hour to put together..

For each ranking, I assign a point system, starting at the bottom, 5pts, and working all the way up to #1, 160 pts., increasing by 5 for each team up the rankings.

The winning team each week gets the corresponding points for the team they defeated. So right now, if you beat Shanghai, you would get 160.. if you beat Gagnum, 5. To the losers, they get nothing. I track these totals by week, but don't go backwards to update based on the change in rankings. What's done is done.

I also track the score differential for each game for all teams.. At the end, I add up the totals of Lvls + Pt Differential + Points for Wins.. This gives me my total for points for each team. And I rank them according to that total.

The wins give points for the reason alone that their wins. the point differential helps adjust the fact that if you beat Gagnum, you don't get dropped on the rankings just because they are the worst team, so it helps balance out because of whom you play throughout the season, but also gives a one point in time standings. Also, who generally considered better? A team that beats Jakarta by 20, or a team that beats Jakarta by 50? Lastly, again ideally, the levels is used to rank teams because you would expect a team with the higher leveled players to be better than a team who doesn't have as high a level of players..

This is my system.. It seems simple enough, but I promise you, it takes forever to set up, so I have a Spreadsheet setup that I could share if you'd like to use it for other leagues. It takes about 35 mins to update after each game and spit out rankings. It takes a little over an hour to run through all the levels each time you update them.

Overall, there really is no judgement used in the end rankings, but moreso judgement used in the development of the formula. I think the judgement used to develop the formula is appropriate and pretty well thought out, but then again, I'm bias!

Suggestions?

 
Saerin
offline
Link
 
I have a suggestion. It goes to everyone that complains about these things.

If you have nothing better to do than complain about somebody's effort then you have a clear choice. You can either:

1) Find a better solution to the issue and do it yourself

OR

2)shut your piehole and be thankful that someone is taking the time to do these things.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saerin
I have a suggestion. It goes to everyone that complains about these things.

If you have nothing better to do than complain about somebody's effort then you have a clear choice. You can either:

1) Find a better solution to the issue and do it yourself

OR

2)shut your piehole and be thankful that someone is taking the time to do these things.


I was asking about the formula not complaining. And I said before that I understand why, I just do not like these things 100% because it does not take into account certain circumstances. I like that Bomber takes the time to do this, it is cool
 
Bomber085
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by Saerin

I have a suggestion. It goes to everyone that complains about these things.

If you have nothing better to do than complain about somebody's effort then you have a clear choice. You can either:

1) Find a better solution to the issue and do it yourself

OR

2)shut your piehole and be thankful that someone is taking the time to do these things.


I was asking about the formula not complaining. And I said before that I understand why, I just do not like these things 100% because it does not take into account certain circumstances. I like that Bomber takes the time to do this, it is cool


Thanks Saerin and Bruiser 1234 for the kind words.. I wasn't upset, just thought I'd post my method so that people can use it in other leagues if they'd like. I will keep doing this league going forward so no worries.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.