User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric


or mr. bo Jackson there... Take away your two shut out games, he loses 16 TDs and near 1000 yds making him middle of the road.


Yeah, 2200 yards and 28 TDs in 14 games is middle of the road.

Crazy person alert.

BTW, every team in every league plays the same bad and gutted teams. Take away from one and you take away from everyone else. We all had a chance to play them and stat pump from it. Every single one of us.
 
OSUmike03
offline
Link
 
I wish we had played as many cupcake games as you guys did. We would have some players on the watch list.

It's like Alpha is the Big 10 or Pac-10, and Zeta is the Big 12.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 10:04:26
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikeyw77
The same arguement can be made for G Alen Faneca 82 of his pancakes came against two of the bottom teams one that is all CPU team and the other that is mostly CPU. Caledric has a good point in that all the teams play the same cupcake games in each conference so the stats can even out after everyone plays those teams.


Some teams play less intense against the worst teams, some play more intense. There are all sorts of variables.

But if you're naming MVPs, you need to look at how those teams play when they're up against the best competition. The MVP isn't the guy who puts up the best numbers - it's the guy who helps his team win. A guy putting up great numbers against the top teams in the league to help his team win big games is an MVP. A guy who piles to increase a win from 80-0 to 108-0 isn't an MVP. There's a reason they don't give Heisman Trophies to Hawaii QBs (not just Colt Brennan).

Similarly, a lvl 28 DE beating a lvl 15 OT for 15 sacks isn't an MVP. A monkey could assign SP to a DE and make that happen. That's a 73 SP difference.

Want me to bring my lvl 34 WR over? It doesn't matter how I assigned his SP - he could be a horrible build. But I guarantee that he'll put up 2000 receiving yards.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 10:09:49
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSUmike03
I wish we had played as many cupcake games as you guys did. We would have some players on the watch list.

It's like Alpha is the Big 10 or Pac-10, and Zeta is the Big 12.


Not sure who the "you guys" is referring to, but "we" are in your conference.

Regardless, both conferences have bad teams. If Zeta is better, then it makes our accomplishments that much better.
 
Narrator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by mikeyw77

The same arguement can be made for G Alen Faneca 82 of his pancakes came against two of the bottom teams one that is all CPU team and the other that is mostly CPU. Caledric has a good point in that all the teams play the same cupcake games in each conference so the stats can even out after everyone plays those teams.


The MVP isn't the guy who puts up the best numbers - it's the guy who helps his team win. A guy putting up great numbers against the top teams in the league to help his team win big games is an MVP. A guy who piles to increase a win from 80-0 to 108-0 isn't an MVP. There's a reason they don't give Heisman Trophies to Hawaii QBs (not just Colt Brennan).


The MVP is always a guy who puts up some of the best numbers. Take Brady last year obviously had great stats as he set the TD record, but at the same time it he played in the worse division in football. He was still playing in the forth quarter and padding on some of his stats against teams that they were blowing out.

Same can be said with Tebow last year if you compare the games with LSU between him and McFadden:
Tebow 158 yds pass 67 yds rush 3 total TD in a loss
Mcfadden 34 yds Pass 206 yds rush 4 total TD in a win
So with your arguement why didn't McFadden win the Heisman.

MVP arguements can last forever that is why it is just someone's opinion on who they think is a MVP.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 10:45:38
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
And I can't wait for the "yeah, well our conference is better than your conference" argument, which is not only untrue, but unprovable, making it the perfect excuse for being completely wrong.


Lol, just because one of your teams ran out and bought the best talent they could possibly find last year to win a championship doesn't mean you are anywhere near the level of the competition of Alpha.

Where are your precious champions now? Oh that's right everyone bailed because salaries couldn't be paid and the team is coming right back here next year where it won't even compete.

As with last year, you guys have one team who MIGHT be able to compete in the alpha conference... other then that. No one would be a play off team if they moved up to alpha from Zeta.

I really do wish I had it as easy as Skaro. To have playoff teams that are cup cakes and you can pad stats against must be an awesome feeling. Sadly, over here in Alpha all 10 teams fighting for a playoff spot can compete with each other on any given day.

 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Wow, all 10 teams! Including the one run by the CPU, that people are trying to get eliminated from the playoffs?

The competition must be pretty fierce if the the basic cpu strategy can be ranked #5.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jonw9
Wow, all 10 teams! Including the one run by the CPU, that people are trying to get eliminated from the playoffs?

The competition must be pretty fierce if the the basic cpu strategy can be ranked #5.


When they were player owned they were a good team, but removing them from the equation and even Phuket would be a top 3 team in Zeta.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
I also find it funny that you pick out the CPU team. A team that was touted as one of the best in the League during the first half before they were sold. A team which during the pre-season games DESTROYED Skaro.

What's that say about your team if you lost to a CPU team?

You might want to leave the fighting to matta. At least he doesn't make you guys look like complete fools when he does it.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 11:30:24
 
Bruche
offline
Link
 
hey guys, it don't matter which conference is tougher than which. You are in that conference and everyone has to play against those same teams. Saying that one player has insane stats because he played lower class teams is true but everyone had that same chance.

Everyone is taking this way too personal. There are lots of very good players that won't be named MVP. So what, that agent should already know that they have a great player. That team should also know that player makes a huge impact to the team.

My RB for example http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=683041 1526 yards rushing, 5.8 avg, 36 TDs. He won't be named MVP but he has performed very well against competition that out levels him greatly. Sure he didn't really step it up in the big games but still made an impact. Only one stat that really matters in this game and that's W/L!
 
wallyopd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric
I also find it funny that you pick out the CPU team. A team that was touted as one of the best in the League during the first half before they were sold. A team which during the pre-season games DESTROYED Skaro.

What's that say about your team if you lost to a CPU team?

You might want to leave the fighting to matta. At least he doesn't make you guys look like complete fools when he does it.


Crap, I didn't realize that scrimmage games counted. I was always under the impression that they were for practice and experimentation.

Although now that they do count I guess that since our 3rd place team DESTROYED (see how the caps make it look more impressive?) your undefeated first place team, it must mean that Zeta is the best?
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 11:37:23
 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric
I also find it funny that you pick out the CPU team. A team that was touted as one of the best in the League during the first half before they were sold. A team which during the pre-season games DESTROYED Skaro.


C'mon. Even the Detroit Lions won in the pre-season. What does that say about your theory?

Last edited Oct 20, 2008 11:37:29
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric
Originally posted by matta

And I can't wait for the "yeah, well our conference is better than your conference" argument, which is not only untrue, but unprovable, making it the perfect excuse for being completely wrong.


Lol, just because one of your teams ran out and bought the best talent they could possibly find last year to win a championship doesn't mean you are anywhere near the level of the competition of Alpha.

Where are your precious champions now? Oh that's right everyone bailed because salaries couldn't be paid and the team is coming right back here next year where it won't even compete.

As with last year, you guys have one team who MIGHT be able to compete in the alpha conference... other then that. No one would be a play off team if they moved up to alpha from Zeta.

I really do wish I had it as easy as Skaro. To have playoff teams that are cup cakes and you can pad stats against must be an awesome feeling. Sadly, over here in Alpha all 10 teams fighting for a playoff spot can compete with each other on any given day.



Mr. Delusional - you have just as many cupcake teams as we do. Accept it.
 
Bruche
offline
Link
 
I never got any cupcakes when I played any team!!! I want some cupcakes!
 
mat5592
it's here
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
And I can't wait for the "yeah, well our conference is better than your conference" argument, which is not only untrue, but unprovable, making it the perfect excuse for being completely wrong.

And again, remember that I didn't pick the best two players in Zeta to compare to your "insane" player - I just picked the two guys you mentioned from my team - two guys not even up for MVP. And the #2 sack leader (not to mention #1 sack leader) on just my team (not to mention the other 30 teams in the league) beats out your guy in every category against playoff teams, despite being substantially out leveled.





Saying that it is "unprovable" is pretty stupid. In the cross conference matchup last season we went something like 12-4...and We have a chance to do that again in a few days. Also you can take the results of scrimmages and friendlies.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.