User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
fee420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blevstone
Originally posted by startbrady

SO where do you want Montreal.

They arent getting ahead of KCDD.
KCDD isnt getting ahead of any of the 3 teams in front of them.

The only thing I could really do is swap KCDD and Montreal, but why do that whe KCDD beat them and BLEW OUT CLPO which montreal barely squeaked by?


Like I said...too much bias for your own team here. Montreal has lost 2 times all season compared to your 5 times...you don't automatically get to be higher than them because you beat them if the difference is that huge. Look at the NFL as an example...the Browns beat the Giants, does that mean that they get to be higher in the power rankings or even that they're a better team? Not really, so just because you guys beat them head to head doesn't make up for the huge difference right now in your records.

I think they should be at MINIMUM #3 in your rankings ahead of Chilliwack and Pittsburgh since they beat both of those teams and have a better record than them. I don't see how you can argue they should be below them especially with a huge win over Chilliwack a couple games ago. They've lost their games this year by a combined 6 points...not exactly decisive losses and no reason whatsoever to have them that low.

You gotta take a step back here and look at it without giving bias to your own team on where you belong here. You guys have a good team, not discounting that in the least and you're playing well now...but those 5 losses keep you from being higher in the rankings if you're looking at it from an unbiased standpoint. A blowout is all well and good but it's not the be all, end all of a discussion...we blew out the Sabres but do I think we would do it again if we played them? Not a chance....sometimes things are just clicking and you get a big win.


+1
 
startbrady
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blevstone
Originally posted by startbrady

SO where do you want Montreal.

They arent getting ahead of KCDD.
KCDD isnt getting ahead of any of the 3 teams in front of them.

The only thing I could really do is swap KCDD and Montreal, but why do that whe KCDD beat them and BLEW OUT CLPO which montreal barely squeaked by?


Like I said...too much bias for your own team here. Montreal has lost 2 times all season compared to your 5 times...you don't automatically get to be higher than them because you beat them if the difference is that huge. Look at the NFL as an example...the Browns beat the Giants, does that mean that they get to be higher in the power rankings or even that they're a better team? Not really, so just because you guys beat them head to head doesn't make up for the huge difference right now in your records.

I think they should be at MINIMUM #3 in your rankings ahead of Chilliwack and Pittsburgh since they beat both of those teams and have a better record than them. I don't see how you can argue they should be below them especially with a huge win over Chilliwack a couple games ago. They've lost their games this year by a combined 6 points...not exactly decisive losses and no reason whatsoever to have them that low.

You gotta take a step back here and look at it without giving bias to your own team on where you belong here. You guys have a good team, not discounting that in the least and you're playing well now...but those 5 losses keep you from being higher in the rankings if you're looking at it from an unbiased standpoint. A blowout is all well and good but it's not the be all, end all of a discussion...we blew out the Sabres but do I think we would do it again if we played them? Not a chance....sometimes things are just clicking and you get a big win.



SO since KCDD lost 4 of their 5 games by 4 points are less we should be a minimum at number 3 as well?Blev your logic is flawed except for the biased part, and youd get that with any rankings EVERY loss in AAA has been close in the top 8. You can put MOntreal ahead of KCDD if you want, but I dont see the point. KCDD lost to the teams ahead of them by a very small marginThe top 1-7or 8 is a tossup each week. Honestly Manitoba could beat Kensington on a good day. Maybe GSP didnt showup on the day they played KCDD. BUt KCDD's blowout of CLPO could make a case for them that they didnt show up when they played some of those teams..

It changes weekly.
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
You're using an awful lot of what ifs in that argument. I'm looking at the plain fact that you guys have lost 5 TIMES compared to their 2 times and they've beaten 2 of the teams you have placed in the top 4 and those 2 teams have 1 MORE loss than them! There's a BIG difference between losing 4 close games and 1 blowout and losing 2 close games and that being all the losses you have on the season.

Did you seriously try to use the argument that your team just maybe happened not to show up when you lost all those games? Seriously? Could Manitoba beat us on a good day? Maybe...but you can't deal in what ifs when you're making a power rankings...all that matters are the results. And those results are that you've lost 5 games, albeit close ones for the most part, and they've lost 2 games.

It shows extreme bias for your team that you are basically giving your team the complete benefit of the doubt and not doing the same for any other team. Because if you were doing it equally it's A LOT easier to write off the one close loss Montreal had with you guys than it is the 4 close losses you guys had to other teams...so the benefit of the doubt should fall with them and not with you.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by startbrady
BUt KCDD's blowout of CLPO could make a case for them that they didnt show up when they played some of those teams.



Or it could make a case that CLPO didn't show up that day, or you just got lucky that game.

The bias Blev is referring to is that you sound like you assume that CLPO played the game of their lives that day and you blew them out because you are just so much better than them. It also sounds like you are assuming all your loses were due to the other team getting lucky.

Yet, when it comes to Montreal, who has lost a lot less games than you have, you make it sound like they were lucky to win any games at all.

Look, I think it's great that you are confident in your own team, but if you want to put together decent power rankings, you need to be fair and apply the same criteria and assumptions to every team.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Lol, I swear I wrote that before I saw Blev's almost identical post...

Second time that's happened today - lol!
 
douglasiv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cuivienen

Look, I think it's great that you are confident in your own team, but if you want to put together decent power rankings, you need to be fair and apply the same criteria and assumptions to every team.


Another requirement is that you have to rank Chilliwack low.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by douglasiv
Another requirement is that you have to rank Chilliwack low.



Because they deserve it?
 
douglasiv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Originally posted by douglasiv

Another requirement is that you have to rank Chilliwack low.



Because they deserve it?


All those loses were all part of our plan... yeah that's it... we lost on purpose to avoid the curse in the playoffs and continue the tradition the western conference 4 vs 5 game winner taking the league championship.
 
Hammertime15
offline
Link
 
Hammertime15 thinks Cuivienen and blevstone may be connected at the ass.
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hammertime15
Hammertime15 thinks Cuivienen and blevstone may be connected at the ass.


Wow...that was creative, how long did it take you to think that one up?
 
Hammertime15
offline
Link
 
Hammertime15 thinks it took him about the same time to think of that as it does for Cuivienen to zip up after giving blevstone the business.
 
Sharrow
offline
Link
 
So the backbone of your argument is that you guys blew out Crotch Lake, and Montreal only beat them by a touchdown? What about you guys getting blown out by Chilliwack and Montreal beating them by three scores?
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 13:19:26
 
startbrady
offline
Link
 
No. Im using rhetoricals to counter what blevstone said.


My point is: ANyone can beat anyone in the top 8 right now. So youll always have blevstones and Cuiviennes whining after one. Just because the OPs got close to beating them because of all the "flukes"
 
Rezit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by startbrady
No. Im using rhetoricals to counter what blevstone said.


My point is: ANyone can beat anyone in the top 8 right now. So youll always have blevstones and Cuiviennes whining after one. Just because the OPs got close to beating them because of all the "flukes"


Except for maybe Manitoba. What happened to those guys??
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
KCDD should be in CPL. They are a perfect fit for the CPL forum.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.