User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
bullblue
offline
Link
 
LOL You are crazy spear.
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
Originally posted by AnimalmotherWell



I agree spear...for the most part everyones top 10 looks a bit like this I would assume...

Clearly the best on paper:
London Angels
Thunder Bay Blue Jays

Could win it all:
Mile High Gladiators
Saskatchewan Stampeders
Halifax Hellions


Not the guys in Halifax... here's a sample of their list:

1. Halifax Hellions
2. 2007 New England Patriots
3. North Delta Grizzlies
4. Nanaimo 9ers
5. Rob Dog's Tigers of Clemson
6. Pecker's Point Master Baiting Seaman
7. Langley Lightning
8. Yukon Badgers
9. Edmonton En........
......
..........ouver Generals
15. North Chicago Maulers
16. Montreal Mean Machine
17. Dirt
.........
55. Bacteria
........
98. Fecal matter......
99. Thunder Bay Blues Jays
100. London Angels
101. Saska......


Spear you forgot the undefeated Dolphins. 72 right??
 
Link
 
He said they were 102.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Unspoken
Spear you forgot the undefeated Dolphins. 72 right??


I was going to include the 72 Dolphins, but I hate them, and don't consider them a great All-Time team anyways. They were an average Super-Bowl caliber team that was very fortunate. So I went with the Patriots instead, who I consider an all-time great team.
 
dobyns98
offline
Link
 
Something is definitely up with North Delta. They have played too many close games this season where they comfortably blew people out previously. And I disagree that it is because other teams have gotten that much better. Something else is in the works.

On a side note, Halifax is on steroids and should be tested.
 
Sihtric
offline
Link
 
This isn't a shot at anyone, but, I'd love for Halifax to be 15-0 come week 16, that would make the game that much better for us. I think we match up well. Looking forward to the game!
 
BOTF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dobyns98
Something is definitely up with North Delta. They have played too many close games this season where they comfortably blew people out previously.


I have to agree with you there. This has had all us with the Rangers just scratching our heads. In no way did we expect the outcome of the last game.
 
SE49erFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
Originally posted by Unspoken

Spear you forgot the undefeated Dolphins. 72 right??


I was going to include the 72 Dolphins, but I hate them, and don't consider them a great All-Time team anyways. They were an average Super-Bowl caliber team that was very fortunate. So I went with the Patriots instead, who I consider an all-time great team.


The Patriots are a close second to the 49ers, to being one of the all-time great teams.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dirtysouthbomb
Originally posted by SpearSrai

Originally posted by Unspoken


Spear you forgot the undefeated Dolphins. 72 right??


I was going to include the 72 Dolphins, but I hate them, and don't consider them a great All-Time team anyways. They were an average Super-Bowl caliber team that was very fortunate. So I went with the Patriots instead, who I consider an all-time great team.


The Patriots are a close second to the 49ers, to being one of the all-time great teams.


Im missing the part on how a team that DIDNT win the superbowl (07 pats)was one of the best of all time but a team that did(72 phins) isnt? I mean the pats had a good run of drafting and cheating for a few years there but the 2007 pats are just another losing team imho and all in all they only have a few sb's as a franchise. Before recent years i dont see a long rich history of winning either... when we start talking best of all time that may be a bit much?
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 17:27:16
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother

Im missing the part on how a team that DIDNT win the superbowl (07 pats)was one of the best of all time but a team that did(72 phins) isnt? I mean the pats had a good run of drafting and cheating for a few years there but the 2007 pats are just another losing team imho and all in all they only have a few sb's as a franchise. Before recent years i dont see a long rich history of winning either... when we start talking best of all time that may be a bit much?


You're addressing several different things here...

1) A team does not have to win a Super Bowl to be an all-time great team. Perhaps the casual fan and TV analyst would suggest this to be the case, but the realist would know that in the sudden-death world of professional football, even a great team can suffer defeat on a given day. Another example of this would be the 2003 Rams.

2) What does a team's history of winning have to do with their all-time greatness in a given year?

3) What makes the 2007 Patriots great is the combination of Tom Brady, Randy Moss, Billy Belichick, and Co. The only team to ever finish the season 16-0, setting records for all-time scoring, passing TD's, and receiving TD's.

As for the Super Bowl itself...consider that, with 2 minutes left, Asante Samuel had a sure-interception fall through his hands, which would have ended the game, and given the Patriots their 4th Super Bowl in 7 years. So now an entire 53-man roster, that went 18-0 to that point, cannot be great because of, ultimately, the result of one-play? That's just a very narrow way of looking at sports.

I'm not a Patriots fan. I'm a Ravens fan. When we won our Super Bowl, there was no doubt which team was better that year. But the Patriots/Giants game was so close... it was decided by a handful of plays, in the end. When other sports need 7-game series to decide their champions, I have a hard time writing a team off for dropping a ball or two, or giving up one catch here or there.

It sounds to me like you're just a Patriots hater.
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 18:54:03
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
I dont hate the pats at all... infact id give my left nut to get Pioli over to Detroit to fix this mess. Maybe the 1st,3rd and 6th we got from dallas tonight for Roy would help bring a decent GM like Pioli(i know hes not the gm). I listened to an interview on sirius where Bill broke down how him and scott work on the draft and how there draft board works and I was in awe at the work they put into scouting. They had there draft board set for next season (to a degree ofcoarse) by opening day lol.

My only point was if a team chokes when it counts like the greatest show on turf or the 2007 pats they dont deserve to be at the top of any alltime list. They won the second worst draft pic and thats about it
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Just a question about redundancy here Spear. If a team breaks a record for passing TD's in a season, doesn't it stand to reason they would automatically break the receiving TD's mark?
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 21:41:40
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Wolf
Just a question about redundancy here Spear. If a team breaks a record for passing TD's in a season, doesn't it stand to reason they would automatically break the receiving TD's mark?


I'm talking individual records. Brady passing, Moss receiving. When Manning set the passing TD record a few years ago, it was with multiple receivers... and none set the receiving TD mark. That's what I meant.... Figured people would know what I was talking about.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
I dont hate the pats at all... infact id give my left nut to get Pioli over to Detroit to fix this mess. Maybe the 1st,3rd and 6th we got from dallas tonight for Roy would help bring a decent GM like Pioli(i know hes not the gm). I listened to an interview on sirius where Bill broke down how him and scott work on the draft and how there draft board works and I was in awe at the work they put into scouting. They had there draft board set for next season (to a degree ofcoarse) by opening day lol.

My only point was if a team chokes when it counts like the greatest show on turf or the 2007 pats they dont deserve to be at the top of any alltime list. They won the second worst draft pic and thats about it


neither team "choked". Even great teams can lose a game here and there... The pats won their first 3 super bowls, 23 consecutive games, and had the only 16 win season. It's okay to lose a game once in a while. Just because it was the super bowl, I don't take anything away from them. They split the season 1-1 against NY. It just so happens that the second one was the super bowl. But if both teams were already giving 100% in both games, then a super bowl loss isn't much different than any other loss. It just counts for a trophy.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
I guess then the 90's Bills should be right up there at the top...
Buffalo Bills
Lost the1990 Superbowl 25 to the New York Giants 20-19
Lost the1991 Superbowl 26 to the Washington Redskins 37-24
Lost the 1992 Superbowl 27 to the Dallas Cowboys 52-17
Lost the 1993 Superbowl 28 to the Dallas Cowboys 30-13

Imho the 90's Bills were about as dominate as it gets and still you dont see anyone not from Buffalo claiming they belong in the best of all time.

To each his own.. I totaly get your point about the Pats and its valid..infact if they did win that game the conversation about the best team ever would prob be a short one
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.