User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > BUG - Offensive AI not being followed
Page:
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
The Tester can't see every flaw. Sometimes an input doesn't get called for other reasons, such as it's location or downs being mis-set. I have checked over quite a few AI's after stuff like this and it's always been user error. By myself on several occasions

(I just got to use the same reply in 2 threads!)
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
let's not focus on the FG triggers. That obviously isn't causing this. It is not hitting ANY of your triggers for anything and triggering the CPU to decide on it's own. It will then kick on 4th down if it is within range. That is what is happening.


Incorrect. It IS hitting my triggers. For example, the "medium air/bomb it out" pair are from the "end of half, outside RZ" setting. The FG attempt that occured at the end of the 2nd half, the first one listed in the first post, matched all requirements for this input, and the AI tester correctly identifies it as the appropriate set of outputs.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
The only way anyone can actually help you is if they can see your AI dude. Which means you either wait for Bort to never answer or let someone here have a look.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
I really wish people would stop treating me like I was a moron.

I was the only active GM for my team last year, meaning I had to fill every set of shoes there were to be filled. I had to personally update the AI settings for every game. With all that, we went 15-1, 2-1. These are the same settings as last year, except that I changed the %ages. There have been no structural changes in my settings for over a year in game and this is the first time anything like this has ever happened to me.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
The only way anyone can actually help you is if they can see your AI dude. Which means you either wait for Bort to never answer or let someone here have a look.


Steelersinsider isn't interested in helping, he just wants to beat his chest and act superior. I'll never let a person like that look at my settings.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Fair enough, but there are a lot of possibilities here besides bug. Including sabotage. It would be pretty easy to switch FG range until the game has started simming and then switch it back for example. A very small change that would be hard to spot but, as you've seen, pretty effective.

Perhaps it might be worth a while pming support to check the logs for the day in question and see who made edits?
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
The AI is so highly susceptible to user error that it is an endless amount of bugs waiting to happen.

 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
Fair enough, but there are a lot of possibilities here besides bug. Including sabotage. It would be pretty easy to switch FG range until the game has started simming and then switch it back for example. A very small change that would be hard to spot but, as you've seen, pretty effective.

Perhaps it might be worth a while pming support to check the logs for the day in question and see who made edits?


I'm the only person with OC rights. If someone else edited the tactics, it was by hacking.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

let's not focus on the FG triggers. That obviously isn't causing this. It is not hitting ANY of your triggers for anything and triggering the CPU to decide on it's own. It will then kick on 4th down if it is within range. That is what is happening.


Incorrect. It IS hitting my triggers. For example, the "medium air/bomb it out" pair are from the "end of half, outside RZ" setting. The FG attempt that occured at the end of the 2nd half, the first one listed in the first post, matched all requirements for this input, and the AI tester correctly identifies it as the appropriate set of outputs.



You aren't understanding what I'm saying.

It isn't hitting your KICK FG trigger if you have distance limits on it.

It is hitting the bomb it out play.

But what is your bomb it out play?? That is your answer. That is where you made a mistake.

If you don't want to list what dropdowns are selected, then how are we supposed to help??
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai

0:14 left in 2nd qtr, losing by 14, ball on Opp 46.5, 1st and 10:
Possible Outputs
95% Bomb it out (pass)
5% Medium Air (pass)



what play is your bomb it out play?

receiver: ??
long/med/short: ??

run/pass/kick: (we know this one is set to pass)

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by hemprobot

The only way anyone can actually help you is if they can see your AI dude. Which means you either wait for Bort to never answer or let someone here have a look.


Steelersinsider isn't interested in helping, he just wants to beat his chest and act superior. I'll never let a person like that look at my settings.


lol.

You just want to waste Bort's time is what you want to do.

If everyone acted like you, then we wouldn't have more plays added until season 12.
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Zurai, it is very possible what happened to you. We had the opposite happen to us. We were WELL within FG range and the AI either ran it or punted, despite repeated inputs in the AI tester.

Situation 1
4th and 20.5 from opponent 25.5
Result: Rush up the middle
AI Test: FG

Situation 2
4th and 1.5 from opponent 20.5
Result: Punt
AI Test: FG

Situation 3
4th and 3 from opponent 28
Result: Punt
AI Test: FG

Level 22 kicker with 54 on his bar, so I'm pretty sure it was well within his range...the AI DOESN'T FOLLOW CORRECTLY in many circumstances, yet everyone attributes this to user error.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 00:05:44
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Okay, here's the link for my error thread:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1169676

Something is wrong, because we haven't changed Offensive AI on this team at all with the exception of ONE input, which is only on downs 1-3. And we only saw problems in this one game. It's like the AI chooses games to completely wig out on.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
This sounds similar to the going for it from 4th and Goal bug last season that to my knowledge was never fixed. And I let several people look through my AI and all said they were good. We seemed to eliminate the problem by changing our input in yards to go from 0 to 0.001. We haven't gone for it on 4th and anything other than the range we wanted since.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
@ dpell, That's not possible because you can't enter a non whole number into the ai...

@ Saintedix, I've seen your exact problem before at least 15-20 times and it was user error every single time.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.