User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Blocking assignments against the 3-4 defense do not make sense. Double/Triple teams on NT with LBs running free.
Page:
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Originally posted by GO TEXANS

Hate to inform you of this but that is not a 3-4 defense.Instead those plays were ran out of a 3-2-6.


You can change it to 3-2-6.. the problem is not 3-4 vs 3-2-6 it is when there are only 3 guys on the line the two Gs and the Cs tend to triple team the NT.
I agree with your point about the three lineman and we have tried to use it against opponets in our division only to find out that the lineman in our division seem to have no problem picking it up.The only time it has been successful for us was against lower leveled teams or poor builds.I only wish we could have the results from your posted plays.

I do agree that there seems to be a glitch in the blocking scheme but it also appears as if some linemen have no problems picking it up.

 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
You will notice in all but the first 5 plays the line "picks it up." In fact, overall it was picked up quite more frequently than it was not picked up. This is absolutely not a build issue, it is an issue with the AI logic when choosing a defender to block.

The RG should not pickup a blitzer on the left side if the LG does not have a blocking assignment besides a double-team on the NT. Much like the LG should not pick up a blitz on the right side on the same play where a RG picks up a blitz on the left side.

Edit: In fact, neither G should double the NT unless it is necessary. They should block their gap and help the C or the OT on their side when needed.
Last edited Oct 10, 2008 12:52:23
 
Link
 
I'd have ta agree with the last post in the edit. the G should hold the gap or assist in the direction of the play (ie. left pitch RG help C, LG help LOT) I've seen this and been able to exploit it as a DC. Now when the O-linemen have low chemistry (Offensive chemistry) it happens more frequently and during run plays it happens a bunch, round 75% (guesstimate), and when the OPP forgets to block their builds a combination of agility and vision seems to lead to more of the triple teaming the NT. I've also noticed if the NT is set to agility pass rushing the RG/LG will come to assist the C, I can guess to stop the swimming and spinning of the pass rusher.
 
Link
 
as to the LG picking up a blitz on the other side of the center. happens all the time. its called a pull. I don't see the play your describing but, I would guess its on a pitch/sweep or the guards vision saw the blitzer and moved to stop it.
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UCHI_MATA_MASTER
as to the LG picking up a blitz on the other side of the center. happens all the time. its called a pull. I don't see the play your describing but, I would guess its on a pitch/sweep or the guards vision saw the blitzer and moved to stop it.


Unfortunately it's not. It happens on normal passing plays, the lg and c will double team the NT in a 3 man front and the RG will have to cross to pick up a weak-side blitz.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UCHI_MATA_MASTER
as to the LG picking up a blitz on the other side of the center. happens all the time. its called a pull. I don't see the play your describing but, I would guess its on a pitch/sweep or the guards vision saw the blitzer and moved to stop it.


This is the play I am referring to: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=148978&pbp_id=6209772

Every play that I linked is a passing play.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
OK firstly your pretty much right that this is a mistake, and I agree with most of the comments here...

This style of blocking assignments is called the trap block, where a C and OG will double the NT, with the 'Off Guard' cutting across from the blind side to pick up the Blitz.
Normally this results in a side on block as the LB hits the Line of Scrimmage.

This is normally used only if...
1) You have speedy, agile Guards and your Centre needs help with the NT.
2) You dont have a decent Blocking back, or he is needed on outside protection.
3) The defense relies on 'Read Gap Blitzing' or the delayed blitz, where the LB or even Safety will wait a beat for a gap to appear before blitzing.
4) You want to run the Play action or Delay hand off from the same formation later on.

Basically it is used when you are out matched by the Defenses strength inside or speed outside, or are facing a unique flexible blitz package.
Maybe a undersized OLine built to pull outside will use this style to mix in some pass/play action and disguise the 'look' to keep the SS guessing.

I HIGHLY doubt that it is working as intended, but simply say that Guards dont block to the opposite sides of the field is wrong.

It happens, but it must be part of the overall play design, not happening by accident.
Last edited Oct 11, 2008 16:16:31
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
So, you feel it is by design that a LG picks up a SS on the right side while a RG picks up a LB on the left side? It is pretty clear what the run down for the blocking assignments:

1. Assign normal assignments (LOT->RDE, C->NT, ROT->LDE)
2. Assign RG blocking assignemnt: first blitzer or triple team NT (This also causes problems with DEs running free on the inside of OTs)
3. Assign LG blocking assignment: second blitzer or double team the NT (Same problem with DEs)
4. Assign FB blocking assignment: third blitzer or quadruple team the NT.
5. Assign HB blocking assignment: fourth blitzer or quintuple team the NT. (this is a guess as I have not seen a 3 man rush vs 7 blockers)

Blocking assignments should be:
1. Assign normal blocking assignments (LOT->RDE, C->NT, ROT->LDE)
2. Assess blitzers
3. If one blitzer assign the closest Guard. If two blitzers assign each to their closest G.
4. If a guard is free they hold position and help with the C/OT as necessary.


Also, it is clear they are not doing any sort of trap blocking (mostly because on a trap the G moves around the back of the C, not try to squeeze between the NT and C. And our C definitely does not need double team help on each and every play.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Nope I said quite clearly that this is not happening intentionally, that its not a designed trap block.

However you cant argue that it never happens in real life, it does but it must be part of a designed play call, not happening by accident.

So yes its a Bug, and it is not following football logic.

BUT...

This falls into the same category of bugs as 90% of those posted this season.

The sim is not robust enough to adapt to the current build levels and the complexity of multiple input options.

The sequences of checks are slightly incorrect on several plays. This causes a smalll amount of illogical decisions to be made.
(See the Wide Open WR thread for an example, or the Elusive pathing, or the KR decision making, or the DB match up logic, etc...)

The blocking assignments on almost EVERY play are incorrect, but most of the time its close enough to get the job done.

This Bug (And I agree it is a Bug), has been in the system since Day 1.
The well built OGs have sufficient Vision, Agility and Speed to reduce the issue.

Fixing this Bug seems logical, but in doing so those people who min maxed their builds get a hand up, and those that spent time and effort working out what was happening lose their advantage.

Like every other change that people want to see happen, I like to take a second to see what it will change in the game. Because although these relatively small bugs are annoying to some people, Constant changes are causing a lot of unrest in every player.

Bugs need fixing agreed, but the fix needs to have no unexpected consequences across GLB as a whole.

What do you think will happen to the Blitz if this is changed universally?
Especially from the 3-4 (And variant) systems.

The reason you use the 34 is to confuse the O-Line, and that just isnt written into the SIM (O-Line should fail more vision checks against a 34 than a 43.)

Right now the % that I personally have seen are not excessively in favour of the 3-4 defense.

The teams where it does work have been building specifically to use the 34 since early Season 2.
The teams that defend it well have built specifically to address that issue.

What happens to the ILB builds, that overnight have gone from successful to useless?

What about the teams that have been carrying extra LBs and less DTs because they want to use the 34, if it is 'Nerfed' by accident, then thats a lot more people annoyed by unexpected changes.

I agree 100% that the pass blocking assignments are very poor.

But I havent seen them be so completely exploited that it justifies such a wide scale change.

Now the second problem you have is that if the OG fails a Vision Check, you have him just staying in his gap.
That effectively is what he should do anyway.
If he makes the read he picks up the blitz in his gap, if he fails it he stays in his gap and the blitz runs into him.

Once a LB is engaged by a OG he will not get free as the Sim stands.

Can we force the Blitz to get past the OG if he fails a Vision check is that possible, or even better than what we have now?

Its a careful balancing act, and I would hate to see the inside Blitz completely over powered by a pass block which cannot fail.

How can we fix the assignments and maintain a inside pass rush with Some success, while not overdoing it and making the inside blitz too effective?



Last edited Oct 12, 2008 10:44:29
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Nope I said quite clearly that this is not happening intentionally, that its not a designed trap block.

However you cant argue that it never happens in real life, it does but it must be part of a designed play call, not happening by accident.

So yes its a Bug, and it is not following football logic.

BUT...

This falls into the same category of bugs as 90% of those posted this season.

The sim is not robust enough to adapt to the current build levels and the complexity of multiple input options.

The sequences of checks are slightly incorrect on several plays. This causes a smalll amount of illogical decisions to be made.
(See the Wide Open WR thread for an example, or the Elusive pathing, or the KR decision making, or the DB match up logic, etc...)

The blocking assignments on almost EVERY play are incorrect, but most of the time its close enough to get the job done.

This Bug (And I agree it is a Bug), has been in the system since Day 1.
The well built OGs have sufficient Vision, Agility and Speed to reduce the issue.

Fixing this Bug seems logical, but in doing so those people who min maxed their builds get a hand up, and those that spent time and effort working out what was happening lose their advantage.

Like every other change that people want to see happen, I like to take a second to see what it will change in the game. Because although these relatively small bugs are annoying to some people, Constant changes are causing a lot of unrest in every player.

Bugs need fixing agreed, but the fix needs to have no unexpected consequences across GLB as a whole.

What do you think will happen to the Blitz if this is changed universally?
Especially from the 3-4 (And variant) systems.

The reason you use the 34 is to confuse the O-Line, and that just isnt written into the SIM (O-Line should fail more vision checks against a 34 than a 43.)

Right now the % that I personally have seen are not excessively in favour of the 3-4 defense.

The teams where it does work have been building specifically to use the 34 since early Season 2.
The teams that defend it well have built specifically to address that issue.

What happens to the ILB builds, that overnight have gone from successful to useless?

What about the teams that have been carrying extra LBs and less DTs because they want to use the 34, if it is 'Nerfed' by accident, then thats a lot more people annoyed by unexpected changes.

I agree 100% that the pass blocking assignments are very poor.

But I havent seen them be so completely exploited that it justifies such a wide scale change.

Now the second problem you have is that if the OG fails a Vision Check, you have him just staying in his gap.
That effectively is what he should do anyway.
If he makes the read he picks up the blitz in his gap, if he fails it he stays in his gap and the blitz runs into him.

Once a LB is engaged by a OG he will not get free as the Sim stands.

Can we force the Blitz to get past the OG if he fails a Vision check is that possible, or even better than what we have now?

Its a careful balancing act, and I would hate to see the inside Blitz completely over powered by a pass block which cannot fail.

How can we fix the assignments and maintain a inside pass rush with Some success, while not overdoing it and making the inside blitz too effective?



I think I agree with every single point made here...the 3-4 is working as intended in the overall scheme of things, though the path by which is gets there is a little less than elegant.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
nm, mike already chimed in better than I could
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 20:39:40
 
MentalMisfit
offline
Link
 
Notice alot of teams lately going with a 3 D-linemen and when you don't blitz anyone both guards just team up on the NT with the center leaving a huge gap for the DE to run threw. Really kind of needs to be looked at I don't think my Guard should always be triple teaming on a NT. I've never seen him once try to help out the tackle. He has over 40 vision so I don't think he isnt seeing the DE he just isn't coded to go after him

 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
I do not think people should build builds around bugs. If it turns out this makes inside blitzes less effective than Bort needs to look at ways to make those plays more effective -- but that should not be a reason to not fix what is clearly a bug.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.