User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
rekcuf
offline
Link
 
Here's an interesting play today:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142672&pbp_id=5883125

It's the short pass play call 'Flats.' It didn't end up being a back dump pass, even though the QB seemed in a hurry to get rid of the ball for some reason. Why it's interesting is because the only short passes scripted for that situation were to the TE. There aren't even any TE's in that formation.

Wiggedy wiggedy whack.

Bugged.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
This does happen, and it isn't new.

It is relatively rare, but mostly occurs when your receivers are covered and the clock is ticking, or pressure mounts.

It may be affected by vision/confidence and SAs for your QB as well.

Personally, I accept it as part of the game.

Similarly, a QB may sometimes scramble, even when set against it.

Last edited Oct 8, 2008 17:20:51
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rekcuf
I understand that Mat, but if those flare patterns are all for the back to be hanging out around the line of scrimmage, wouldn't those be considered dump passes? If the QB is set to never throw dump passes, shouldn't he either force a throw further downfield or eat the ball rather than checkdown? Even worse, as Islander notes, those plays all look like the back is the primary receiver if that's what the orange arrow means.

It's a good theory Islander, and it may be true. But some of those passes were situationally called as short to the TE or WR and didn't use the basic settings. They used the advanced AI.


Just because your AI calls for a TE to get the pass doesnt mandate he does. He's just the first 'look'.

I really think the game generates the formation/play call before it factors in the QB's individual setting for dump passes.

 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1

Just because your AI calls for a TE to get the pass doesnt mandate he does. He's just the first 'look'.

I really think the game generates the formation/play call before it factors in the QB's individual setting for dump passes.



If I were a betting man, I would have to bet that you are correct. The one interesting thing with the plays that Bort released to look at are the various options available on each play. So, if you have 2 WRs, and a TE in the pattern, but all are covered, and your HB happens to be next on the progression list, he gets the ball.

I'm stretching here, but I am hoping that Bort would renumber the progression list on each play based on the QB's settings. Someone with checkdown often might have the HB as third on his progression list, someone with checkdown rarely maybe fourth, and checkdown never might just tag him on the list as the dead last option.

Remember, the play is at least partially scripted, so that HB is going to go out in the pattern even if the QB doesn't want to throw him the ball. Maybe if Bort could add some extra inputs to the plays, a QB who never checks down might be able to keep the HB in the backfield as a blocker?

PinTBC
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by islander1


Just because your AI calls for a TE to get the pass doesnt mandate he does. He's just the first 'look'.

I really think the game generates the formation/play call before it factors in the QB's individual setting for dump passes.



If I were a betting man, I would have to bet that you are correct. The one interesting thing with the plays that Bort released to look at are the various options available on each play. So, if you have 2 WRs, and a TE in the pattern, but all are covered, and your HB happens to be next on the progression list, he gets the ball.

PinTBC



Something else to factor in as well - if you don't use short passing at all, even when the halfback does go out on a pattern, it won't be a negative loss one. So you could allow dump passes 'sometimes', and it typically won't be for a major loss at the point of completion/catch.

For medium, he'll go run a valve route often times, if he catches the 'dump' it'll be for a 4-5 yard gain.

It just really sucks, because I dislike feeling forced into not use the short passing game.

Last edited Oct 8, 2008 21:39:18
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
You know, earlier I posted that ever since my QB switched to 'no dump passes' that we haven't had any...well today we had some.

I had added more chance of short passes into the AI, I guess that's the reason. Pretty annoying passing it to a HB that drops it, or if they catch it get tackled for a loss. Guess I'll be taking out those short passes.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
You know, earlier I posted that ever since my QB switched to 'no dump passes' that we haven't had any...well today we had some.

I had added more chance of short passes into the AI, I guess that's the reason. Pretty annoying passing it to a HB that drops it, or if they catch it get tackled for a loss. Guess I'll be taking out those short passes.


at least until Bort fixes this. In my view, it's a bona fide bug, because the plays aren't executing as individual tactics are designed/intended.
 
sicarius
offline
Link
 
I've had several HB dump-offs occur before the receivers were even halfway into their routes. The QB was under no pressure, and no threat of the blitz on the way. Because the ball was released SO soon, the defense hadn't even dropped that far yet. The result is the HB getting obliterated for no gain or a loss. Really screwed up otherwise decent series.
 
Bearphin
offline
Link
 
yeah, please get this to stop! I hate dump passes that are obviously going no where. If the guy is wide open on the other side of the field thats one thing, but if a LB is 3 yards away, c'mon...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Nixx

You know, earlier I posted that ever since my QB switched to 'no dump passes' that we haven't had any...well today we had some.

I had added more chance of short passes into the AI, I guess that's the reason. Pretty annoying passing it to a HB that drops it, or if they catch it get tackled for a loss. Guess I'll be taking out those short passes.


at least until Bort fixes this. In my view, it's a bona fide bug, because the plays aren't executing as individual tactics are designed/intended.



This is not a "bug" at all.

I have a perfectly good explanation for it, and everyone in my alliance knows how to avoid this from happening.

Sorry, I can't give all the secrets of the game out.

If any high level teams that think they have other "secrets of the game" to contribute, we are always looking for other great offensive and defensive minds to join us.

send me a PM if interested. Of course it would take some time to be fully approved by the other teams, but it is something you could have fixed before the playoffs and have as an advantage over the teams that don't know how to prevent this kind of "bug" from happening on offense or defense.


Last edited Oct 9, 2008 18:05:54
 
Link
 
Actually, I'm not going to be happy if Bort gives this one a way.

Because this is NOT a bug. It is a result of a mistake on the user's part in making the calls on offense and defense.

I hope you know that there are many teams who choose to share this info.

That is what public forums are about. Notice that you don't see any top 10 teams in GLB in here giving away all of the details of why their offense and defense works better than their opponents.

 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Because this is NOT a bug. It is a result of a mistake on the user's part in making the calls on offense and defense.


My guess...If you choose short pass and don't choose a primary receiver it goes by your basic AI settings.

Well I guess that's wrong because my short pass settings (which I think resulted in dump passes this last game) are set to TE as the primary receiver, and my basic settings say 0% passes to HB and FB.

When does 0% and 'never' mean 'sometimes, if you don't know the super secret trick'? When playing GLB, of course!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Because this is NOT a bug. It is a result of a mistake on the user's part in making the calls on offense and defense.


My guess...If you choose short pass and don't choose a primary receiver it goes by your basic AI settings.

Well I guess that's wrong because my short pass settings (which I think resulted in dump passes this last game) are set to TE as the primary receiver, and my basic settings say 0% passes to HB and FB.

When does 0% and 'never' mean 'sometimes, if you don't know the super secret trick'? When playing GLB, of course!



Nixx,

You are a very good poster and know alot about the game. You give away way too much info in these forums though. I know you want to be a mod or something, but you didn't see Harper or Asheme in here giving away their team secrets when they were mods. Or Hud or VT or any other mods for that matter besides tpat.....and I love the guy, but you see how they have done record wise.

If you want to be part of my alliance, let me know and we can start the process.

I guarantee we can fix that HB problem at least if you don't want to throw there.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by rekcuf
I have purposely set the offensive gameplan so that it never throws a short pass to the HB or FB. They are set as zero as pass receivers in the generic tactics page, they never have short pass plays scripted for them, the QB was set to "never" on dump pass, and the auto adjust was off. Yet these four plays were all called last game:

FB Flare - Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5326639


HB Flat – Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5327127

HB Flat – Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5327768

HB Flat - Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5328250

On a couple of those there were scripted short plays to the TE and WR, but never for the HB. It seems like every time a short pass is called, even if it's specified to the TE or WR, the HB may be called as the primary receiver anyway. I assume the little orange arrow on the play schemes recently posted signify the primary receiver.


Rek, did you run these scenarios through the AI test page? Maybe there's a scenario you forgot to cover and it's going to a default setting. I suggest you take the data from each play and plug it into the test page and see what it says. If the play that it comes up w/ says 0% short pass to HB and FB, then it's either a bug, or your QB is lying.
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Nixx

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Because this is NOT a bug. It is a result of a mistake on the user's part in making the calls on offense and defense.


My guess...If you choose short pass and don't choose a primary receiver it goes by your basic AI settings.

Well I guess that's wrong because my short pass settings (which I think resulted in dump passes this last game) are set to TE as the primary receiver, and my basic settings say 0% passes to HB and FB.

When does 0% and 'never' mean 'sometimes, if you don't know the super secret trick'? When playing GLB, of course!



Nixx,

You are a very good poster and know alot about the game. You give away way too much info in these forums though. I know you want to be a mod or something, but you didn't see Harper or Asheme in here giving away their team secrets when they were mods. Or Hud or VT or any other mods for that matter besides tpat.....and I love the guy, but you see how they have done record wise.

If you want to be part of my alliance, let me know and we can start the process.

I guarantee we can fix that HB problem at least if you don't want to throw there.




Jebus.

'Secret Alliance' my fat ass.



 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.