User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Dammit, the 3-4 outside linebacker pathing is still hosed
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
@islander1

- OLBs are typically faster - so they cover more distance while performing the drop back
- all LBs can't read (or fail to read) the play before the ball is handed off or pitched to the HB (unless it's one of those rare pre-snap reads); so in the I formation that has the HB quite a bit back, there's a longer "drop down phase"
- so by the time the HB gets the ball, the MLB/ILBs are (still) closer and more likely to check the play right: even if they read "pass", they start moving towards their coverage assignments - which happens to be the HB and FB.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
RAPB,

Nope no hard feelings, just getting frustrated. The idea that the linebackers take their first step backwards works OK for a 4-3 defense, because the linemen on the line are there and by the design of the formation will get in the way to slow up off tackle, and other runs.

The 3-4 is based on active linebackers. If the linebackers are not moving towards the line in that formation, or at the very least staying in position, it simply can NEVER stop an off tackle play with any sort of regularity. It stuns me that the designer of a football SIM would consider this a valid solution. Hell, at this point in time, I'd almost be slightly happy if he toned down how far they ran off the line of scrimmage, 6 and 7 yards is simply amazing. I might as well be playing defense with 9 guys, because two are useless on running plays, unless the HB gets 8 or 9 yards down the field.

PinTBC
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
... I might as well be playing defense with 9 guys, because two are useless on running plays, unless the HB gets 8 or 9 yards down the field.


Well... right now some safety blitz combined with MLB/LILB blitzing has shown some decent results. The problem is, the SS arrives too early at the LB/RG couple and almost all the time goes inside towards the center. In that position, he's not able to make the play on the off tackle run.

Best solution still is a hell of a LDE that either makes the tackle himself or eats up the FB or TE for a double team block.

 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
But that's not a solution, it's a kludge made necessary by a stupid design decision. Intentionally breaking the outside linebackers in a 3-4 to artificially boost the running game is just absurd.
 
smittdog101
offline
Link
 
We must be discussing the 2WR formation only, right?

If you think about it. The 3-4 leaves more defenders to cover offensive players. The FS is the only one in zone coverage on cover 1 m2m. DE's don't cover, hence the extra defender to "man up". You just need to know who is guarding who. Eventually, some one is going to be selected to double up a guy. If you don't want some one doubled up, blitz him. He has to pick some one to guard. Or they could double team someone and leave the WR single covered. IMO, I want the WR double covered. If I don't, then I will blitz him.

It's not that hard to fix. I seem to do pretty well with the 3-4. You just have to set your AI to force the people in the right place. Shifting helps too.

Don't get me wrong, I don't have the 3-4 mastered, but I think it can be effective against the pitch play especially.
Last edited Oct 4, 2008 22:01:10
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smittdog101
We must be discussing the 2WR formation only, right?


The standard 3-4 defense, which I run against the 2 WR set mostly yes.


Originally posted by smittdog101
If you think about it. The 3-4 leaves more defenders to cover offensive players. The FS is the only one in zone coverage on cover 1 m2m. DE's don't cover, hence the extra defender to "man up". You just need to know who is guarding who. Eventually, some one is going to be selected to double up a guy. If you don't want some one doubled up, blitz him. He has to pick some one to guard. Or they could double team someone and leave the WR single covered. IMO, I want the WR double covered. If I don't, then I will blitz him.


cough. That is all well and good, but in pass defense the 3-4 works excellently. That particular team is not one of the stronger teams in their league, but is near the top in pass defense. The problem isn't pass defense, as the 3-4 does very well covering all receivers. The problem is the rush defense and the idea that the linebackers leave their zone of control to go have lunch while letting the running plays directly at them gain 6 to 7 yards pretty much every single play. Now, I agree that you could blitz your RoLB, and LoLB, but that then leaves a gaping hole in the pass coverage.

Originally posted by smittdog101
It's not that hard to fix. I seem to do pretty well with the 3-4. You just have to set your AI to force the people in the right place. Shifting helps too.

Don't get me wrong, I don't have the 3-4 mastered, but I think it can be effective against the pitch play especially.


chuckle. Do you regularly run the 3-4 as your base defense? The people I've seen that like the 3-4 use it in a 3 WR set or in obvious passing situations. It performs decently against the pass, because of all the linebackers dropping off, but unless you blitz your linebackers, they leave gaping holes against any type of a decent running game.

You shouldn't have to blitz them to keep them home. This idea that they should run for the hills at the snap of the ball is a piss poor implementation. At the very worst, they should stand still, and at least being their zone of coverage.

Sometimes I wonder what Bort is going to do when he actually finishes the offense and allows them to actually choose their plays. The defenses are going to be so screwed it isn't even funny. Right now he has so many bandaids trying to allow the offense to move the ball, it is starting to look like he doesn't know where he wants to eventually end.

I am in charge of an EMD team of engineers working hardware and software design on some very new stuff. The one thing I found very early on is that if you do not set your end goals early on, and drive to meet those goals, you end up with a heaping pile of spaghetti code and designs that only patch existing holes versus move your design to the desired end state.

This game is beginning to resemble spaghetti code.

PinTBC
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
I checked: They run a 4-3 on rushing downs much of the time. So his money ain't where his mouth is.
 
smittdog101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AgentTBC
I checked: They run a 4-3 on rushing downs much of the time. So his money ain't where his mouth is.



Don't know what you are looking at. I run 3-4 a good amount of times vs. 2 WR. I never said all of the time. Watch some plays and see. Just looking at my general AI is checking. I had 3rd quarter settings for 3-4 most of this season. Why? Because it works vs. the pitch pretty well.
 
AgentTBC
offline
Link
 
I checked the first drive against Appalachia and you ran a 3-4 on 1st&10 and 2nd&10 and switched to a 4-3 for 3rd&2.5. Of course then you ran a 4-3 on 1st&10 and switched to a 3-4 for like 2nd&1 so you are correct, it isn't as clear cut as going to a 4-3 for running downs.

Why run a 4-3 on 1st&10 and then switch to a 3-4 on 2nd&1? Um, you don't really need to answer that.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
This is a case where it would only take someone to pop in and say, "Yes, the path the outside linebackers is taking is indeed intended and is part of the design of the game." I've now sent two messages to Support asking about it, with no success, and two threads where players have posted their suppositions, but no replies by anyone that might be in the know.

I've never had a problem with the game design changing, as I do believe this is a beta game and Bort has some serious balance issues he is going to have to deal with if he ever manages to implement any sort of offensive play selection. I am starting to move toward the camp of people that complain about a serious lack of information.

I am also wondering exactly what my purpose here is. Am I a Beta tester? I which case I should be feeding back issues and discussing problems. Or am I a customer, in which case, I can be seriously irritated as per the lack of information in the game mechanics.

PinTBC
 
OUTLAW77
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
This is a case where it would only take someone to pop in and say, "Yes, the path the outside linebackers is taking is indeed intended and is part of the design of the game." I've now sent two messages to Support asking about it, with no success, and two threads where players have posted their suppositions, but no replies by anyone that might be in the know.

I've never had a problem with the game design changing, as I do believe this is a beta game and Bort has some serious balance issues he is going to have to deal with if he ever manages to implement any sort of offensive play selection. I am starting to move toward the camp of people that complain about a serious lack of information.

I am also wondering exactly what my purpose here is. Am I a Beta tester? I which case I should be feeding back issues and discussing problems. Or am I a customer, in which case, I can be seriously irritated as per the lack of information in the game mechanics.

PinTBC


+ 1
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
The information given out in this game is wonderfully in depth...... Honest it is......

I just wish that I could get a little in this thread.

PinTBC
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
defense ai sucks in this game. ive had ss problems, fs problems, lb problems u name it! good thing i don't dc anymore.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Up until this season, the defenses I've had a hand in were very decent. The reason I keep asking about this particular issue is that this pathing is different than the end of last season. I understand that Bort's answer is most likely going to be "But I didn't change anything", and I'm hoping to get him to at the very least look at it, and what it is doing to the 3-4 defense.

My only other option is to say screw it and remove the 3-4 defense from my base set, which gets into my other point. Am I supposed to be beta testing this game? If this is the case, I should do what I've been doing by trying to identify distinct problems with the 3-4 base defense.

But if concerns and what I would hope are obvious problems are simply ignored, why the hell am I beating my head against the wall, when it seems that I am the only one who particularly cares? The people responding to this thread have offered some work arounds, some of which might work if I can suddenly train my left outside linebackers 12 times in vision.

This doesn't excuse the basic fact that the outside linebackers should not be doing what they are doing if anyone ever hopes that a 3-4 defense can be used as anything but a special set.

I would be hoping that since the 3-4 is offered as a basic defense, it should actually work as a basic set.

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
I thought I'd bump this again as I would hate for it to fall off the page without someone seeing it.

I know Voltron posted in my suggestion thread so he is aware of the problem that many Bugs are being discussed with little or no comment from the "powers that be", and I hope he manages to find the time to stop in and chat about it.

I know of course how busy he is though, so he might not make it. It takes a lot of time to think up some of the "wittier" posts he puts up in the FFA forum.

PinTBC
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.