"There would be max of 3 owners who actually do the work to do all of this"
Why? Everyone would vote for the final 3 at each position and then all teams vote again.
There isn't any more work other than voting twice. You still have to compile the list. This would actually be easier than the way of having a couple people trying to compile a list of candidates... unless they were going to randomly pick names. But if they wanted to do it right, those guys should look at every stat of every player on every team.
At least my way would have each owner doing the work for the few people organizing this.
I don't think there is an easy way if you want to do a quality selection process.
My suggestion is basically as easy as...
1. Each team selects their nominations.
2. The owners vote on which nominations move to the next round. Basically voting for the "most deserving" nominations.
3. The owners place the remaining players in order 1,2,3
-We could have the initial nominations in private forum PM'd to the "organizers" so all the owners wouldnt feel obligated to pick every one of their agents players for fear of hurting someones feelings.
-Then we would post the top 3 (with votes) at each position.
-We could have it where the owners can not vote for their players during the first round of voting to eliminate some bias. But they can vote for any of their players that made the final 3 voting... basically because at that point there wouldn't be much bias remaining as the whole league voted for the final 3, so the player should be worthy of a vote even from his own owner.
-We could make a comitte of lets say about 5 owners that handles and organizes the whole thing. I wouldn't mind helping, and bruiser sounds like he may want to if it's put together right.
-I could even start a private forum for the "All-Pro" committee. This would really makes things a little easier.
Thoughts???
I think this
Why? Everyone would vote for the final 3 at each position and then all teams vote again.
There isn't any more work other than voting twice. You still have to compile the list. This would actually be easier than the way of having a couple people trying to compile a list of candidates... unless they were going to randomly pick names. But if they wanted to do it right, those guys should look at every stat of every player on every team.
At least my way would have each owner doing the work for the few people organizing this.
I don't think there is an easy way if you want to do a quality selection process.
My suggestion is basically as easy as...
1. Each team selects their nominations.
2. The owners vote on which nominations move to the next round. Basically voting for the "most deserving" nominations.
3. The owners place the remaining players in order 1,2,3
-We could have the initial nominations in private forum PM'd to the "organizers" so all the owners wouldnt feel obligated to pick every one of their agents players for fear of hurting someones feelings.
-Then we would post the top 3 (with votes) at each position.
-We could have it where the owners can not vote for their players during the first round of voting to eliminate some bias. But they can vote for any of their players that made the final 3 voting... basically because at that point there wouldn't be much bias remaining as the whole league voted for the final 3, so the player should be worthy of a vote even from his own owner.
-We could make a comitte of lets say about 5 owners that handles and organizes the whole thing. I wouldn't mind helping, and bruiser sounds like he may want to if it's put together right.
-I could even start a private forum for the "All-Pro" committee. This would really makes things a little easier.
Thoughts???
I think this






























