User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
"There would be max of 3 owners who actually do the work to do all of this"

Why? Everyone would vote for the final 3 at each position and then all teams vote again.

There isn't any more work other than voting twice. You still have to compile the list. This would actually be easier than the way of having a couple people trying to compile a list of candidates... unless they were going to randomly pick names. But if they wanted to do it right, those guys should look at every stat of every player on every team.

At least my way would have each owner doing the work for the few people organizing this.

I don't think there is an easy way if you want to do a quality selection process.

My suggestion is basically as easy as...

1. Each team selects their nominations.
2. The owners vote on which nominations move to the next round. Basically voting for the "most deserving" nominations.
3. The owners place the remaining players in order 1,2,3

-We could have the initial nominations in private forum PM'd to the "organizers" so all the owners wouldnt feel obligated to pick every one of their agents players for fear of hurting someones feelings.
-Then we would post the top 3 (with votes) at each position.
-We could have it where the owners can not vote for their players during the first round of voting to eliminate some bias. But they can vote for any of their players that made the final 3 voting... basically because at that point there wouldn't be much bias remaining as the whole league voted for the final 3, so the player should be worthy of a vote even from his own owner.
-We could make a comitte of lets say about 5 owners that handles and organizes the whole thing. I wouldn't mind helping, and bruiser sounds like he may want to if it's put together right.
-I could even start a private forum for the "All-Pro" committee. This would really makes things a little easier.

Thoughts???


I think this
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
"There would be max of 3 owners who actually do the work to do all of this"

Why? Everyone would vote for the final 3 at each position and then all teams vote again.

There isn't any more work other than voting twice. You still have to compile the list. This would actually be easier than the way of having a couple people trying to compile a list of candidates... unless they were going to randomly pick names. But if they wanted to do it right, those guys should look at every stat of every player on every team.

At least my way would have each owner doing the work for the few people organizing this.

I don't think there is an easy way if you want to do a quality selection process.

My suggestion is basically as easy as...

1. Each team selects their nominations.
2. The owners vote on which nominations move to the next round. Basically voting for the "most deserving" nominations.
3. The owners place the remaining players in order 1,2,3

-We could have the initial nominations in private forum PM'd to the "organizers" so all the owners wouldnt feel obligated to pick every one of their agents players for fear of hurting someones feelings.
-Then we would post the top 3 (with votes) at each position.
-We could have it where the owners can not vote for their players during the first round of voting to eliminate some bias. But they can vote for any of their players that made the final 3 voting... basically because at that point there wouldn't be much bias remaining as the whole league voted for the final 3, so the player should be worthy of a vote even from his own owner.
-We could make a comitte of lets say about 5 owners that handles and organizes the whole thing. I wouldn't mind helping, and bruiser sounds like he may want to if it's put together right.
-I could even start a private forum for the "All-Pro" committee. This would really makes things a little easier.

Thoughts???


I think this


You were not here last year. NO ONE did any work. We had 7 total teams or something like that do nominations. And then even fewer who actually voted.

I can guarantee that you get less than 25% of the owners to actually do this
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by Godzirra

"There would be max of 3 owners who actually do the work to do all of this"

Why? Everyone would vote for the final 3 at each position and then all teams vote again.

There isn't any more work other than voting twice. You still have to compile the list. This would actually be easier than the way of having a couple people trying to compile a list of candidates... unless they were going to randomly pick names. But if they wanted to do it right, those guys should look at every stat of every player on every team.

At least my way would have each owner doing the work for the few people organizing this.

I don't think there is an easy way if you want to do a quality selection process.

My suggestion is basically as easy as...

1. Each team selects their nominations.
2. The owners vote on which nominations move to the next round. Basically voting for the "most deserving" nominations.
3. The owners place the remaining players in order 1,2,3

-We could have the initial nominations in private forum PM'd to the "organizers" so all the owners wouldnt feel obligated to pick every one of their agents players for fear of hurting someones feelings.
-Then we would post the top 3 (with votes) at each position.
-We could have it where the owners can not vote for their players during the first round of voting to eliminate some bias. But they can vote for any of their players that made the final 3 voting... basically because at that point there wouldn't be much bias remaining as the whole league voted for the final 3, so the player should be worthy of a vote even from his own owner.
-We could make a comitte of lets say about 5 owners that handles and organizes the whole thing. I wouldn't mind helping, and bruiser sounds like he may want to if it's put together right.
-I could even start a private forum for the "All-Pro" committee. This would really makes things a little easier.

Thoughts???


I think this


You were not here last year. NO ONE did any work. We had 7 total teams or something like that do nominations. And then even fewer who actually voted.

I can guarantee that you get less than 25% of the owners to actually do this


Thats fine... then they have no vote, and no right to bitch. And if they do bitch... it will fall on deaf ears. For that matter I don't care if just you and I vote. Nobody else wants to participate, thats up to them. And if they want to cry about the selections after... fuck em.

I thought it might be something enjoyable and entertaining that everyone would want to participate in, and be a nice gesture for the players.
 
jbiller
offline
Link
 
I think it would be pretty awesome if it is done correctly, and not just the owners bitching that their players didn't make it.
 
Paladin58
offline
Link
 
I concur, Jbiller.
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra

Thats fine... then they have no vote, and no right to bitch. And if they do bitch... it will fall on deaf ears. For that matter I don't care if just you and I vote. Nobody else wants to participate, thats up to them. And if they want to cry about the selections after... fuck em.

I thought it might be something enjoyable and entertaining that everyone would want to participate in, and be a nice gesture for the players.


Yeah, you'd think that would be the way it works. But last year we had people bitch, and not participate, and bitch about why they didn't participate. And most of the bitching was because they were too ignorant or lazy to read the rules. You suggest that teams can't vote for their own players... but they couldn't last year, and people still bitched that it was just a tool for a few owners to put their own lineups in. We had about 30% participation... that was it. Now you can expect some teams, the cupcakes who aren't really trying, to ignore it... I don't know why those guys even have teams if they're not going to be a little more competitive and participate in league stuff. Whatever. But a lot of the good teams thought it was somehow rigged.

I'd be happy to participate by voting a ballot and even nominating players but honestly, it was too much work to try to run it myself. The missing piece is an owner willing to go through every position in every conference and come up with a truly deserving list of nominees at every position that would serve as a starting point. But it's a ton of effort to do that.

I'll make a suggestion that might help out. I'd recommend that the owners/GMs who want this to happen divide up the "ballot creation" work among themselves. You probably need four people: one offense and one defense in each conference. Those volunteers go through the roster of every team and the league record sheets and collect the most worthy players at each position (I'd suggest no fewer than five choices and as many as ten, maybe even more at deep positions like WR/CB/LB). Do that way ahead of time, maybe around game 14 or so as the deadline. Then after game 16, fill in the regular season stats for each player and PM the ballots to the right people. Allow a lot of time for voting, maybe even until day 40 so that playoff teams who are busy setting lineups and gameplanning have a chance to participate. Tally the results and post them just after the championship game.

Depending on when you were to set the ballot creation deadline, I'd be willing to volunteer as one of those four (and of course you could break it down even further if you get more volunteers). But I'll be on vacation and only able to get to GLB a little during that time so if it's a game 12 or so deadline I can't help out.
Last edited Oct 4, 2008 18:13:03
 
Bruins33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by Godzirra


Thats fine... then they have no vote, and no right to bitch. And if they do bitch... it will fall on deaf ears. For that matter I don't care if just you and I vote. Nobody else wants to participate, thats up to them. And if they want to cry about the selections after... fuck em.

I thought it might be something enjoyable and entertaining that everyone would want to participate in, and be a nice gesture for the players.


Yeah, you'd think that would be the way it works. But last year we had people bitch, and not participate, and bitch about why they didn't participate. And most of the bitching was because they were too ignorant or lazy to read the rules. You suggest that teams can't vote for their own players... but they couldn't last year, and people still bitched that it was just a tool for a few owners to put their own lineups in. We had about 30% participation... that was it. Now you can expect some teams, the cupcakes who aren't really trying, to ignore it... I don't know why those guys even have teams if they're not going to be a little more competitive and participate in league stuff. Whatever. But a lot of the good teams thought it was somehow rigged.

I'd be happy to participate by voting a ballot and even nominating players but honestly, it was too much work to try to run it myself. The missing piece is an owner willing to go through every position in every conference and come up with a truly deserving list of nominees at every position that would serve as a starting point. But it's a ton of effort to do that.

I'll make a suggestion that might help out. I'd recommend that the owners/GMs who want this to happen divide up the "ballot creation" work among themselves. You probably need four people: one offense and one defense in each conference. Those volunteers go through the roster of every team and the league record sheets and collect the most worthy players at each position (I'd suggest no fewer than five choices and as many as ten, maybe even more at deep positions like WR/CB/LB). Do that way ahead of time, maybe around game 14 or so as the deadline. Then after game 16, fill in the regular season stats for each player and PM the ballots to the right people. Allow a lot of time for voting, maybe even until day 40 so that playoff teams who are busy setting lineups and gameplanning have a chance to participate. Tally the results and post them just after the championship game.

Depending on when you were to set the ballot creation deadline, I'd be willing to volunteer as one of those four (and of course you could break it down even further if you get more volunteers). But I'll be on vacation and only able to get to GLB a little during that time so if it's a game 12 or so deadline I can't help out.


I know I am talking everyone, I will volenteer to do all the gathering for offense and defense if someone will do all the collecting votes stuff. I will gather 4 players for most positions except CB, LB, OT, G, DT, DE, and WR, they will have a total of 6 or 7. I will only do this though if no one bitches about my picks. I will be fair.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
I am down for either way.

My post earlier stands true if we choose to do it that way. I will be in charge of things, with help from a couple others in that way.

I think we will get more participation with my way, but either way I am fine
 
Mud Turkey 13
offline
Link
 
I think the way it was done last year was perfect except for the way the nominations were handled. I think if we did it the same way except had a nomination "committee" this year it would work better. Now, I know people don't think the nomination committee would be a fair representation because those committee people could just nominate their own players. To eliminate that we could have a committee from each conference who would make the nominations for the other conference. So, if I was on the committee I would nominate Zeta players since I own an Alpha team.

What do you think?



 
jbiller
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mud Turkey 13
I think the way it was done last year was perfect except for the way the nominations were handled. I think if we did it the same way except had a nomination "committee" this year it would work better. Now, I know people don't think the nomination committee would be a fair representation because those committee people could just nominate their own players. To eliminate that we could have a committee from each conference who would make the nominations for the other conference. So, if I was on the committee I would nominate Zeta players since I own an Alpha team.

What do you think?



That sounds pretty good. One thing I think the committee needs to do is identify cupcake teams and ignore stat gains against them, otherwise you'll have a huge bitchfest regarding people stat padding against weaker teams.

 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbiller

That sounds pretty good. One thing I think the committee needs to do is identify cupcake teams and ignore stat gains against them, otherwise you'll have a huge bitchfest regarding people stat padding against weaker teams.


The problem being that doing that is way way way too much work. On the other hand, every team will have an equal schedule through at least the first fifteen games, so stat padding games should be a wash.

I would definitely recommend that the voting be open to EVERY player, regardless of who makes the official ballot. That way if some team feels their player was snubbed in the nomination process, they can advocate for that player here on the league message board.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
Originally posted by jbiller


That sounds pretty good. One thing I think the committee needs to do is identify cupcake teams and ignore stat gains against them, otherwise you'll have a huge bitchfest regarding people stat padding against weaker teams.


The problem being that doing that is way way way too much work. On the other hand, every team will have an equal schedule through at least the first fifteen games, so stat padding games should be a wash.

I would definitely recommend that the voting be open to EVERY player, regardless of who makes the official ballot. That way if some team feels their player was snubbed in the nomination process, they can advocate for that player here on the league message board.


That leaves too much for teams to only vote for their players.
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bruiser 1234
Originally posted by Gabrosin

Originally posted by jbiller



That sounds pretty good. One thing I think the committee needs to do is identify cupcake teams and ignore stat gains against them, otherwise you'll have a huge bitchfest regarding people stat padding against weaker teams.


The problem being that doing that is way way way too much work. On the other hand, every team will have an equal schedule through at least the first fifteen games, so stat padding games should be a wash.

I would definitely recommend that the voting be open to EVERY player, regardless of who makes the official ballot. That way if some team feels their player was snubbed in the nomination process, they can advocate for that player here on the league message board.


That leaves too much for teams to only vote for their players.


No, I'm in favor of keeping the same rule as last time, you can't cast any votes for players on your own team. But I definitely think owners should vote in their own confidence. All I have to go on for Zeta is stats; if I'm voting in Alpha I can remember tough players I scouted and players who came up big in games against the Heroes. For example, Nagamasa Azai would get my first vote at linebacker because he was a nightmare to play against, constantly in our backfield making tackles. If you ask me the top MLB in Zeta I'll just shrug.
Last edited Oct 5, 2008 21:13:02
 
Mud Turkey 13
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I just meant people from the opposite conference make the nominations. Owners then vote for the best players in their own conference based on the list compiled from the other conference's committee.

 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Last edited Oct 5, 2008 23:03:30
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.