User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > can we lessen the point after misses, please.
Page:
 
Razup
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze

Other positions seem to function perfectly well with similar %'s of their attributes.


That's because they're facing opponents of similar percentage attributes. Kickers don't face off against anyone but themselves.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Considering he's COMPLETELY neglected speed/agility/jumping, 26/29 isn't half bad.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Razup
If kickers were perfect by level 30, what would be the point in leveling up beyond that?

Now, if you're level 50+, with 100's in kicking, strength, confidence, vision, etc, and still missing EPs, then it's a problem. But level ~30, with a vision of ~60% of max, ~75% of max kicking, ~60% max strength, ~15% max agility... you're gonna miss some things.


I played on 2 different HS teams. On one we had a soccer player who was the kicker. In 2 years he was 26 of 27 and 34 of 34 on extra points. One team I played for was a small town and a DE kicked the extra points. He had a better % than some of the level 30 kickers have in this game.

Nobody thinks kickers should be perfect at these levels. But we are talking about 19 yard kicks. Miss a higher percentage of the over 50, a higher percentage of the over 40, etc. But kickers shouldn't have stats that rival a 7th grader's extra point statistics and a NFL player's field goal statistics.
 
Razup
offline
Link
 
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/recap?gameId=242480099

It happens.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
but why miss point-afters?

FG's, maybe. but point-afters? maybe we need a seperate code for these and not lump them with FG's


you honestly tell me you would rather your kicker to miss more FG's then XP's hell i would much rather have a kicker that missed a XP now and again as long as he made all his FG's.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

but why miss point-afters?

FG's, maybe. but point-afters? maybe we need a seperate code for these and not lump them with FG's


you honestly tell me you would rather your kicker to miss more FG's then XP's hell i would much rather have a kicker that missed a XP now and again as long as he made all his FG's.


The problem with missing a lot of XPs is that anyone that's ever watched, hell heard of football knows that they're all but automatic.

A team counts on those XPs a lot more than the FGs. If one team is 4-4 and the other team is 3-4, it throws the whole game out of whack.

People should definitely miss XPs, but kickers need to be able to make their saving throw easier, especially lvl 30+ kickers.


Edit:

Oh, for the record, my kicker(s) are doing fine. I've seen similar builds that are not doing so well. I believe that it's too random.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=625085
Lvl 18, 32/33 XP and 10/14 FG (3 were beyond his range, 1 was simply a miss)
I'm happy with those results from him.



http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=625085
My kicker, lvl 14 - 7/8 XP and 4/9 FG (4 out of 5 misses are well beyond his range)
I'm also happy with these results, though 8 XPs is not much to go on.


The "out of range" misses I'm referring to here are where we're near the 30 or so, and 4th down comes up with a bit too much "to go". Punting is a 10 yard gain 9 times out of 10, so there's no reason not to kick. Hence, the "out of range" misses.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 21:00:54
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigDaddyTim
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

but why miss point-afters?

FG's, maybe. but point-afters? maybe we need a seperate code for these and not lump them with FG's


you honestly tell me you would rather your kicker to miss more FG's then XP's hell i would much rather have a kicker that missed a XP now and again as long as he made all his FG's.


you miss the point all together, man.

pay attention please.

missed FG's and XP's are ok. the problem is the percentages. our kicker has missed 3 XP's in 7 games. he is on pace to miss 3 more for a 16 game season.

even YOU can't miss that many IN THE NFL. what with your low agility and big gut.

someone said it here. too many XP's being missed. FG's missed i think is ok (percentages). so i think XP's percentages should be different than FG's. XP's should have a lower percentage of misses.

even a LEVEL 40 kicker has 3 XP's missed.

now if it is being blocked then we need to see that too. code issue.

i said it before and i'll say it again: this game's ad says it is a sim BASED ON AMERICAN FOOTBALL. what is first and foremost thing that comes to mind when you say AMERICAN FOOTBALL? the NFL, right?
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Maybe they mean American soccer and the goalie's making the save on all your one-point attempts
 
bdnannac
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Be glad you're making the 3s and missing the 1s, geez.


He's right. My kicker is missing the FG's this year and not the XP's. My build is similar to the OP but I got around 32 agility. This season he is 17/18 on XP's and 9/15 on FG's this season.
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bdnannac
Originally posted by oldskool

Be glad you're making the 3s and missing the 1s, geez.


He's right. My kicker is missing the FG's this year and not the XP's. My build is similar to the OP but I got around 32 agility. This season he is 17/18 on XP's and 9/15 on FG's this season.


Yah the kicker on my team is 21/22 on Xp's and 4/6 on field goals. He missed a 29 yard chip shot with 12 seconds to go yesterday to tie the game.
Last edited Oct 6, 2008 09:01:30
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Guys before you post concerns about PATs please take some time to look at the games in which your guys missed. So often is the case that misses are linked to low in-game energy. Even two quick scores might significantly reduce a kicker's percentage if he's got low stamina. Don't look at your ending energy, it doesn't really help you (unless the PAT miss came in like the final minute of the game), look at the play-by-play to see if your kicker was in on a number of plays in a short time period. Doing this can probably explain half of those missed PATs, meaning that you're left with a more reasonable amount of legit misses.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Guys before you post concerns about PATs please take some time to look at the games in which your guys missed. So often is the case that misses are linked to low in-game energy. Even two quick scores might significantly reduce a kicker's percentage if he's got low stamina. Don't look at your ending energy, it doesn't really help you (unless the PAT miss came in like the final minute of the game), look at the play-by-play to see if your kicker was in on a number of plays in a short time period. Doing this can probably explain half of those missed PATs, meaning that you're left with a more reasonable amount of legit misses.


our kicker missed the first TD of the game. stamina is not a factor (and it really shouldn't unless it PAT comes after a kickoff, recieving team fumbles, tackling team recovers and scores a TD. realistically it can tire out a kicker)

what i think is wrong is that FG's and PAT's are lumped together in percentage of misses in the whole GLB.

i think it should be seperate. if the game has it programmed that 30% of the kicker in a day will miss 1 FG, the percentage of PAT should be 5%. that way kickers won't miss too much of PAT's.

one guy said here that it is too random and i agree. for a level 40 kicker to miss 3 PAT's in 7 games sucks.

and a level 20 is perfect 20 out of 20.

what i'm ultimately saying is this: it's a lot easier to make PAT's than FG's. so their code should be different.

unless a coder would tell us how they code both FG's and PAT's i think we'll never know.

 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Considering he's COMPLETELY neglected speed/agility/jumping, 26/29 isn't half bad.


is this some sort of joke?

speed agility jumping for your place kicker?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Razup
If kickers were perfect by level 30, what would be the point in leveling up beyond that?

Now, if you're level 50+, with 100's in kicking, strength, confidence, vision, etc, and still missing EPs, then it's a problem. But level ~30, with a vision of ~60% of max, ~75% of max kicking, ~60% max strength, ~15% max agility... you're gonna miss some things.



This is the real answer. Bort needs people to continue to boost at all positions - even kickers. If kickers made 100% of XP's, then many kickers would stop boosting.

And if EVERYONE'S kickers are missing, then WHO CARES? It's even.
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Razup

If kickers were perfect by level 30, what would be the point in leveling up beyond that?

Now, if you're level 50+, with 100's in kicking, strength, confidence, vision, etc, and still missing EPs, then it's a problem. But level ~30, with a vision of ~60% of max, ~75% of max kicking, ~60% max strength, ~15% max agility... you're gonna miss some things.



This is the real answer. Bort needs people to continue to boost at all positions - even kickers. If kickers made 100% of XP's, then many kickers would stop boosting.

And if EVERYONE'S kickers are missing, then WHO CARES? It's even.


Tell that to my friends team that missed two extra points and lost by 1 to get to the championship game last season. The other team was perfect.

My kicker is perfect on FGs for the season and has only missed one extra point (oddly right after I boosted). My friend had an almost identical build in the game he missed two. It is fluky.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.