User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #4 > Dude Bigsly For League MVP thread
Page:
 
merk
offline
Link
 
But what would a Dawg need mittens for?
 
Sooner Steve
offline
Link
 
Dude is the man, er..the Dude!
Awesome MVP Season double the 2nd best in number of sacks!

 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
For some reason, I'd expect the defensive MVP to come from the team with the best defense in the league. So that kinda excludes the Dude.
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 10:48:58
 
merk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
For some reason, I'd expect the defensive MVP to come from the team with the best defense in the league. So that kinda excludes the Dude.


I guess everyone has a different set of qualifications for MVP. I thought it might be most valuable...

Originally posted by PackMan97
Toss in the fact most QB's he faces are quickly demoralized by the Dude, it's really no shock at all those INTs.


You can't really have it both ways. If Dude isn't the most valuable that's fine. But then you have to give our DB Chris Hill some props!
 
Sooner Steve
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
For some reason, I'd expect the defensive MVP to come from the team with the best defense in the league. So that kinda excludes the Dude.


I am sorry I disagree, what do you base this statement on! LOL

We have the number one rush def and lead the league in sacks, hurries, FF, Fumbles returned for TD, Int's, INT's returned for TD, I think that might qualify our Defense for some props/awards-LOL...Not that they mean anything if we lose.

All of these stats mean nothing if we get monkey poop thrown on us, or we get throttled by a white and red tipped cane bearers, Or sacrificed by ancient indians, or sniped, or lion woofed, or berserked on, or snake bitten,......

Just thought a couple of the players on the Dawgz deserved some Props! That is all.

There are other teams with players that need props-nighttrain vision, Romain Chevigny, Jack Edup, Hank Datank, Ralph Lewis..
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 11:46:11
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
I just don't see Sooner State suffering if Dude or Hill were no longer on the team. While they make a great combo I don't think they are that "valuable".

They certainly deserve any individual award they will receive, but to me the MVP is the "lynch pin" for a team. If you take that one player out, the house of cards comes falling down. I just don't see anyone from a team as dominant as Sooner State earning that award.

Now, if you want to call it the "Most Impressive Player" award, there are any number of guys on Sooner State that deserve it.
 
Onyxgem
offline
Link
 
With the damge Dude does to the opposing QB game in and game out there is no questions that he is definatly the defensive MVP of the league this year.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
FWIW - I'd easily give the "BEST PLAYER" award to the Dude, I just don't equate that to MVP. Without Dude, Sooner State is still 16-0.
 
Sooner Steve
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
FWIW - I'd easily give the "BEST PLAYER" award to the Dude, I just don't equate that to MVP. Without Dude, Sooner State is still 16-0.


I don't know about being 16-0 (those darn monkeys, mayans, and blind could sneak up on us any time), but I have to agree with your thought process on how you arrive at your opinion.
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 12:36:18
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Sooner, call it a penalty of your success. FWIW - I don't really think anyone from Santiago is MVP material either. Cohen would come close as would our HB's, but we have two great ones...

I'd go for someone like zig Nzag maybe who is really battling every game. I think you take him off the Tigers, they don't make the playoffs. Then of course, the problem comes in what does he do against the elite teams?

It's just too hard to really figure out a true MVP with as much talent gap across the teams.

Honestly, if you pressed me for the award right now...it would be a somewhat unconventional pick...

...I'd split it between Canton Bound and Jack Block.
 
merk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
FWIW - I'd easily give the "BEST PLAYER" award to the Dude, I just don't equate that to MVP. Without Dude, Sooner State is still 16-0.


Fair enough. I've always seen the MVP as a mixture of the 2 (at least when comes to NFL, MLB, etc...things I can have a fair perspective on). Thanks for explaining your totally legitimate viewpoint. I'm also doubly impressed that you came up with a list of other strong candidates. zig Nzag has been extremely valuable...also hard to argue with giving it to a player at one of the most under appreciated positions.
 
Hokiemon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97

Honestly, if you pressed me for the award right now...it would be a somewhat unconventional pick...

...I'd split it between Canton Bound and Jack Block.



OK, now I know you are on crack, Packman. Btw, which one of us is the stalker here, you or me . More direct competition, love it.

While I do appreciate your acknowledgement (our team owner is worthless tbh, no recognition for the big uglies on offense), I'd have to say Dude is the MVP hands down. I understand your reasoning, but you are wrong about our D being dominant without him. We have a couple of good DEs other than Dude, but in no way can they do the things he does. He CONTROLS games, plain and simple.

His sacks and tackles not only demoralize the QBs, they more importantly stall drives and get our high powered offense the ball back. His hurries many times result in incomplete passes or INTs, getting our O the ball back yet again. Add in his ability to force fumbles, allowing our O to get the ball back as well, you get the idea. With Dude "doing his thing", it becomes our O against the other teams D. We aren't going to be outscored, all we have to do is put some points on the board to win. Hell, our CBs get enough points for us to win. Our O just adds on and is good for running the clock out . Without Dude, it becomes a game of the other team's O against our D, and our O against their D, etc. Dude completely abolishes that equation.

THAT is the definition of an MVP. The player that changes outcomes of games, and no one does it better than Dude.

 
nitetrain
offline
Link
 
to make anything official dont we need nominations and voting from one representative for each team.

Either way I have 2 players to be nominated.

Romain WR - I am sure everyone kept their best corner at the # 1 spot opposite of him. Really wasnt a CB in the league that contained him..

nitetrain vision QB - I bet every team defended against the passing game because of these two guys

They both played important roles in our wins, close wins and losses and overall success..
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 20:48:58
 
KioCad
offline
Link
 
For the stats :


Romain de Chevigny WR: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=67562&playoffs=0
Nitetrain Vision QB: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=404308&playoffs=0
 
merk
offline
Link
 
Both have insane stats! The question is did the WR make the QB or did the QB make the WR?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.