User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > IS STRONGBASE BROKEN? (by WiSeIVIaN, the guy who posts threads that never really go anywhere)
Page:
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
what do you think Tunnel Vision would do for a DT? It affects agility and speed. Its available as advanced equipment.


I think it'd help with high speed/agility, though bort re-nerfed advanced equipment a bit. Was only really worthwile with +1 SA/level imo...
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Vision: 24.64 = your guy doesn't know what to do
Confidence: 15.2 = your guy doesn't believe he can do it

Low in-game morale probably lets your 92 strength and 52 agility immediately drop. And since your playing backup NT too, there's no SA slowing that fall down. A typical guard or center you're going to battle got 80+ strength. So sure it takes some time to push him out of the way too.

I could be wrong, but can you provide some examples of your guy actually pass rushing lately (+ the number of plays he played before in that game)?

_________________________________________________________________

EDIT: Way to go to the 11 in Big Sack. That one carreer sack sure brought that morale of the QB down.


In blowout wins I doubt confidence is an issue. Perhaps I underestimate vision, but I'd still like to think that my DT with bad awareness would do something, sometimes to OG's he outlevels... Low confidence does not mean that your moral auto-drops every play, but rather it drops more when bad things happen. In blowout games, not alot of bad things happen...
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Not to knock anything and I did read the OP with your concerns but imo even if strong base did work properly your player wouldn't have the necessary speed/agility to shoot at the QB to even register a sack/hurry.

Perhaps Strong Base is just a modifier, not so much an activated skill. Thus it is just slightly boosting your strength. If an opposing LG has 80+ strength you're still not going to knock him down 5 times in the game.

I'd try putting him only at DT, take him off the NT depth chart. If you're double teamed even if you knock down 1 you won't get by the other. Perhaps the NT has less stamina than the DT and you are playing a majority of NT.



Starting DT/NT play same amount of plays fwiw. Tried him at only starting DT a few games last year with 8 strong base and no results fwiw.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madd_Maxx
Originally posted by RAPB

Vision: 24.64 = your guy doesn't know what to do
Confidence: 15.2 = your guy doesn't believe he can do it

Low in-game morale probably lets your 92 strength and 52 agility immediately drop. And since your playing backup NT too, there's no SA slowing that fall down. A typical guard or center you're going to battle got 80+ strength. So sure it takes some time to push him out of the way too.

I could be wrong, but can you provide some examples of your guy actually pass rushing lately (+ the number of plays he played before in that game)?

_________________________________________________________________

EDIT: Way to go to the 11 in Big Sack. That one carreer sack sure brought that morale of the QB down.


My DT has 25 in vision and 19 in confidence and dominates equal leveled Guards. His problem is low agility and speed.



Gonna be 2nd softcapping speed/agility asap as I planned anyhow. Though it doesn't change the fact that strongbase doesn't seem to have any effect on getting past an OG...
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by babiiverson
How does the team do in sacks overall? If anything, he could benefit the outside rushers in getting to the QB. Also, does he get any hurries?


4 hurries. 3 of them were vs a gutted team playing against CPU players though, so they literally mean nothing...
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
This thread was meant moreso on whether strong base is worthless as an SA, not why I make DTs that don't do anything fwiw, lol. I made a position talk thread for build advice, so thats not really what I'm looking for here.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
I did a similar experiment with Shed Block and Agility, but not so extreme in Agility as you have in Strength.

The results have been up and down, but, now that I've focused in other areas, the results and consistency have been much better.

And you're severely underestimating the effects of Confidence. And Vision, for that matter.

What I'm saying is this: if the equation to get past the Guard consists of Strength, Agility, Speed, and Vision, you only have a fourth of the equation in your favor, even if Strong Base modifies Strength a good deal. Also, with the low Confidence, that Strength can be quickly reduced to less effective levels, rendering Strong Base less effective also.
 
JBrown5390
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Vision: 24.64 = your guy doesn't know what to do
Confidence: 15.2 = your guy doesn't believe he can do it

Low in-game morale probably lets your 92 strength and 52 agility immediately drop. And since your playing backup NT too, there's no SA slowing that fall down. A typical guard or center you're going to battle got 80+ strength. So sure it takes some time to push him out of the way too.

I could be wrong, but can you provide some examples of your guy actually pass rushing lately (+ the number of plays he played before in that game)?

_________________________________________________________________

EDIT: Way to go to the 11 in Big Sack. That one carreer sack sure brought that morale of the QB down.


Your an idiot, he has 1 in big sack, not 11.
How bout my DT? HAd 90+ strength, 5 in strong base, 60+ agility, 30+ confidence and 20+ vision. How come he cant pass rush? I know its not vision, vision doesnt do shit for pass rushers.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Strong base works just fine, in my experience.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by JBrown5390
Originally posted by RAPB

Vision: 24.64 = your guy doesn't know what to do
Confidence: 15.2 = your guy doesn't believe he can do it

Low in-game morale probably lets your 92 strength and 52 agility immediately drop. And since your playing backup NT too, there's no SA slowing that fall down. A typical guard or center you're going to battle got 80+ strength. So sure it takes some time to push him out of the way too.

I could be wrong, but can you provide some examples of your guy actually pass rushing lately (+ the number of plays he played before in that game)?

_________________________________________________________________

EDIT: Way to go to the 11 in Big Sack. That one carreer sack sure brought that morale of the QB down.


Your an idiot, he has 1 in big sack, not 11.
How bout my DT? HAd 90+ strength, 5 in strong base, 60+ agility, 30+ confidence and 20+ vision. How come he cant pass rush? I know its not vision, vision doesnt do shit for pass rushers.



A lot of ya'll are under estimating vision and confidence. Vision is a must have for all positions. If you can't see or know where to go/put your hands yadda yadda yadda then your guy won't do much.
If your guy is getting pushed around a little by a G then your in game morale will drop as well, especially if you get pancaked, even if you are winning.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JBrown5390
Originally posted by RAPB

Vision: 24.64 = your guy doesn't know what to do
Confidence: 15.2 = your guy doesn't believe he can do it

Low in-game morale probably lets your 92 strength and 52 agility immediately drop. And since your playing backup NT too, there's no SA slowing that fall down. A typical guard or center you're going to battle got 80+ strength. So sure it takes some time to push him out of the way too.

I could be wrong, but can you provide some examples of your guy actually pass rushing lately (+ the number of plays he played before in that game)?

_________________________________________________________________

EDIT: Way to go to the 11 in Big Sack. That one carreer sack sure brought that morale of the QB down.


Your an idiot, he has 1 in big sack, not 11.
How bout my DT? HAd 90+ strength, 5 in strong base, 60+ agility, 30+ confidence and 20+ vision. How come he cant pass rush? I know its not vision, vision doesnt do shit for pass rushers.


You got hit with the 'bust' code. Some players are like that.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Strong base works just fine, in my experience.


Holy crapola do you have alot of DTs.

Not to question your opinion, but you don't have a DT (unless I missed one) with more than 1 sack in seasons 4 and 5 combined. So unless your considering it a run stuffing SA (inproperly listed and hard to judge), you sure it works just fine budster?

Not calling you out by any means, just curious if you can elaborate on your sentence.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 22:34:47
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by JBrown5390

Originally posted by RAPB


Vision: 24.64 = your guy doesn't know what to do
Confidence: 15.2 = your guy doesn't believe he can do it

Low in-game morale probably lets your 92 strength and 52 agility immediately drop. And since your playing backup NT too, there's no SA slowing that fall down. A typical guard or center you're going to battle got 80+ strength. So sure it takes some time to push him out of the way too.

I could be wrong, but can you provide some examples of your guy actually pass rushing lately (+ the number of plays he played before in that game)?

_________________________________________________________________

EDIT: Way to go to the 11 in Big Sack. That one carreer sack sure brought that morale of the QB down.


Your an idiot, he has 1 in big sack, not 11.
How bout my DT? HAd 90+ strength, 5 in strong base, 60+ agility, 30+ confidence and 20+ vision. How come he cant pass rush? I know its not vision, vision doesnt do shit for pass rushers.



A lot of ya'll are under estimating vision and confidence. Vision is a must have for all positions. If you can't see or know where to go/put your hands yadda yadda yadda then your guy won't do much.
If your guy is getting pushed around a little by a G then your in game morale will drop as well, especially if you get pancaked, even if you are winning.


I would absolutely love to see a DT with high vision/confidence who has had production rushing the passer. You don't have to open the build, but I'd love to see one buddy and would fully concede to your point.

The fact is there are a ton of people who go around preaching vision/confidence, with no evidence to back it up. I'm not saying your one of them (and I hope your not), but if you go on the WR forum for instance you have a crapload of people telling others to softcap vision, even though results tend to show no great change in production for higher vision WRs...

And low confidence will lead to inconsistant play (1 good game followed by an awful game, like streaky QBs). Low confidence does not lead to consistant crappyness. If a player is consistantly crappy, high confidence is very unlikely to change that... My WR has no vision or confidence and is still freaking awsome. My CB lacks confidence and is still consistantly the best CB on my team... 1 bad play doesn't ruin the day of a player with 15 confidence, and I'd like to think with 92 strength my DT isn't getting pancaked and manhandled every play/game...
 
Havoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
My DT has 11 strong base and 92 strength, yet has done basically nothing rushing the passer (or peroid for that matter) this season.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=273398



I think the issue is you dont have the agility and speed to properly exploit the Strong Base even if the SA activates and gets you past the OL.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
I love how, any time someone posts that something may not be working, people always find one low stat and instantly blame said low stat.

It could be possible that strong base actually isn't working. If it was confidence, you'd think that the player would have seen results at some point early in games, even with low vision.

If every stat is so important to softcap at every position, though, players will never touch SAs. I highly doubt you need 50+ in each stat for SAs to fire off or anything.

My DE has 36 vision and 26 confidence. Yet he's playing well this year. His build is working just fine despite 26 confidence:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=184345

Honestly, I think the big issue is simply that O Line loads up on strength, therefore strength based stuff is not nearly as effective. As people focus more and more on non-strength based stuff, it'll become more effective.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 22:44:14
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.