you are built like an elusive back.so play like one until you get your strength higher,make sure your tactics are set right.you have a nice build.really need strength though.lot of big guys hit rb's pretty hard.
cam69,
Ignore the idiots in this thread who havent bothered to read your posts.
Based on what you have said I can see why you feel this is a bug, or possible something predestined about your player.
Have you looked specifically at the plays on which you have fumbled?
I have many teams which use 2 HBs equally, both have the same builds, and very different fumble rates.
I eventually discovered after spending a lot of time tracking it down, that the sub rates on my HBs coincided with certain plays in my playbook.
I found that a team that subs in/out every play, and has a sustained drive, can get into a sequence or cycle.
For the sake of example one of my teams had this sequence...
1st Down = HB1 = Outside Run
2nd Down = HB2 = Inside Run
3rd Down = HB1 = Pass
1st Down = HB1 = Outside run
2nd Down = HB2 = Inside Run
1st Down = HB1 = Outside Run
2nd Down = HB2 = Inside Run
I realised that HB1 was fumbling often on Outside Runs.
I figured it was because he was getting to the outside, and being tackled by a fast moving SS.
As he was a high speed/agility build, that meant he was travelling at higher speeds as well as the SS.
So I realised that HB1 was more likely to be involved in high speed Tackles, and that was the reason he was fumbling more than his back up who had EXACTLY the same build, and a 50-50 split of playing time.
Try looking at it like that and see if it helps narrow it down, as I found different HBs are effected more on different plays, and Vs different defenses etc.
Also a few teams have a slightly lower build as back up, and he has less fumbles because he subs in against other back ups on defense, so if there is one player on defense causing the fumbles he doesnt face the back up HB.
Ignore the idiots in this thread who havent bothered to read your posts.
Based on what you have said I can see why you feel this is a bug, or possible something predestined about your player.
Have you looked specifically at the plays on which you have fumbled?
I have many teams which use 2 HBs equally, both have the same builds, and very different fumble rates.
I eventually discovered after spending a lot of time tracking it down, that the sub rates on my HBs coincided with certain plays in my playbook.
I found that a team that subs in/out every play, and has a sustained drive, can get into a sequence or cycle.
For the sake of example one of my teams had this sequence...
1st Down = HB1 = Outside Run
2nd Down = HB2 = Inside Run
3rd Down = HB1 = Pass
1st Down = HB1 = Outside run
2nd Down = HB2 = Inside Run
1st Down = HB1 = Outside Run
2nd Down = HB2 = Inside Run
I realised that HB1 was fumbling often on Outside Runs.
I figured it was because he was getting to the outside, and being tackled by a fast moving SS.
As he was a high speed/agility build, that meant he was travelling at higher speeds as well as the SS.
So I realised that HB1 was more likely to be involved in high speed Tackles, and that was the reason he was fumbling more than his back up who had EXACTLY the same build, and a 50-50 split of playing time.
Try looking at it like that and see if it helps narrow it down, as I found different HBs are effected more on different plays, and Vs different defenses etc.
Also a few teams have a slightly lower build as back up, and he has less fumbles because he subs in against other back ups on defense, so if there is one player on defense causing the fumbles he doesnt face the back up HB.
Last edited Sep 28, 2008 17:18:23
cam69
offline
offline
Thank you very much. That was very insightful and I will look into it tomorrow after work. This might also explain why game after game the other back is getting better ypc averages even though we have similar builds(I arguably have better stats, but that is obviously in the eye of the user).
Weather
offline
offline
I'd say, if it keeps being a problem in several more games, you might have a problem.
But 4 games is still a pretty small sample size.
When have the fumbles been happening, later in games?
But 4 games is still a pretty small sample size.
When have the fumbles been happening, later in games?
RyguyRB
offline
offline
Ive noticed my power back is fumbling an awful lot, as well.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=325416
6 fumbles, 3 in regular season games. I have 80+ strength, 40+ carrying, 4 in cover up, and im actually playing in probably a worse league than iwas last season, when i had nearly 10 less carrying/strength and only fumbled 3 times the entire season.
Even the mostly gutted team forced a fumble on my RB. Was a little curious with this as well... our other back has well, SIGNIFICANTLY (20+ in all areas) fewer ball protection stats than me as well as 7 levels lower than me and has actually fumbled fewer times than me.
Not a stamina issue either, all of these fumbles have come relatively early when my energy should be nice and high. Confidence is at 26.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=325416
6 fumbles, 3 in regular season games. I have 80+ strength, 40+ carrying, 4 in cover up, and im actually playing in probably a worse league than iwas last season, when i had nearly 10 less carrying/strength and only fumbled 3 times the entire season.
Even the mostly gutted team forced a fumble on my RB. Was a little curious with this as well... our other back has well, SIGNIFICANTLY (20+ in all areas) fewer ball protection stats than me as well as 7 levels lower than me and has actually fumbled fewer times than me.
Not a stamina issue either, all of these fumbles have come relatively early when my energy should be nice and high. Confidence is at 26.
Originally posted by cam69
Thank you very much. That was very insightful and I will look into it tomorrow after work. This might also explain why game after game the other back is getting better ypc averages even though we have similar builds(I arguably have better stats, but that is obviously in the eye of the user).
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=166668&pbp_id=1329623
If you look at this play its a very good example of a high speed impact causing a fumble.
Only had a quick look at your guy, see if you can find a pattern at all.
Thank you very much. That was very insightful and I will look into it tomorrow after work. This might also explain why game after game the other back is getting better ypc averages even though we have similar builds(I arguably have better stats, but that is obviously in the eye of the user).
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=166668&pbp_id=1329623
If you look at this play its a very good example of a high speed impact causing a fumble.
Only had a quick look at your guy, see if you can find a pattern at all.
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Anyone have some valuable information for this whiny little kid? Because I sure don't.
You are a tool.
Is your life that insignificant, for you to troll the BUGS forum, just to harass people that are having genuine problems with this game?
Go get a fucking life.
Anyone have some valuable information for this whiny little kid? Because I sure don't.
You are a tool.
Is your life that insignificant, for you to troll the BUGS forum, just to harass people that are having genuine problems with this game?
Go get a fucking life.
manx
offline
offline
i'm having similar issues on my HB with a similar build, but in reality I think it does just have to do with build make-up in the current system. My personal issue is that the 2 main stats and main SA for carrying are all powerback skills, so it just makes creating an easy to build overpowerback that much easier.
surgej805
offline
offline
My HB's have more than 40 carrying, very high +50 strength as well as +4 SA cover up and they are still fumbling. So it's not just because of the build excuse of low carrying, strength, and cover up.
Something isn't right and I hope it gets fixed....
Something isn't right and I hope it gets fixed....
Jonny Patches
offline
offline
I've seen a huge increase in fumbles all across the board, far greater then last season.
So either it's a bug or Power Tackling/Big Hit/Monster Hits are actually working
So either it's a bug or Power Tackling/Big Hit/Monster Hits are actually working
Jack Del Rio
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Anyone have some valuable information for this whiny little kid? Because I sure don't.
You are a tool.
Is your life that insignificant, for you to troll the BUGS forum, just to harass people that are having genuine problems with this game?
Go get a fucking life.
Hey, sand dweller, the kid's whining about a tiny sample size of fumbles. One HB with shitty fumble protection is fumbling, another isn't, and the kid didn't think twice about actually looking at replays to see if his HB was getting hit harder. He instantly called out "BUG!" when it is not a bug. But tell me this, sand dweller, how on earth did you make enough free time to post your little jab at me?
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Anyone have some valuable information for this whiny little kid? Because I sure don't.
You are a tool.
Is your life that insignificant, for you to troll the BUGS forum, just to harass people that are having genuine problems with this game?
Go get a fucking life.
Hey, sand dweller, the kid's whining about a tiny sample size of fumbles. One HB with shitty fumble protection is fumbling, another isn't, and the kid didn't think twice about actually looking at replays to see if his HB was getting hit harder. He instantly called out "BUG!" when it is not a bug. But tell me this, sand dweller, how on earth did you make enough free time to post your little jab at me?
TtD
offline
offline
Will throw our HB in to the mix, powerback running only inside and off-tackle runs, 8 fumbles through 7 games. 80+ strength, softcapped speed/agility/carrying, 3 in cover up.
Will note that all have been when he's got through to the secondary. Same with our backup whose a converted powerrunning FB, lots of fumbles, all having broken through the line and hit by safeties/LBs.
Will note that all have been when he's got through to the secondary. Same with our backup whose a converted powerrunning FB, lots of fumbles, all having broken through the line and hit by safeties/LBs.
Last edited Sep 29, 2008 13:35:43
Tito716
offline
offline
0 fumbles in 81 touches on my HB with 35 str and 48 carry with NO cover up.
2 fumbles in 83 touches on the other HB with 56 str and 35 carry with 3 in cover up.
Moral of the story:
Luck is important.
2 fumbles in 83 touches on the other HB with 56 str and 35 carry with 3 in cover up.
Moral of the story:
Luck is important.
Kirk Gibson
offline
offline
My power back has hit his fumble total from last year already with 3 fumbles the last game. 67 Str / 50 carrying / cover up 3. Something is definitely wrong and it seem to be focused on Power backs that take hits head on because my elusive backs don't have the same issue.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























