I am not taking sides here. Just putting my 2 cents in. Palmer is not that good of a QB. He has always been surrounded by superstar WR's and has never won a Super Bowl. Favre made average WR's look like studs. Favre has also won a Super Bowl as well as a crap load of playoff games. Rodgers is an average QB on a good team.
kadafitcd
offline
offline
Just my input here. IHas said atm which I believe means at the moment. Well Palmer is playing like sh*t atm and Favre just threw 6 TD's... Need we say more? Palmer was promising until his knee injury. He hasn't been the same since. Otherwise I would agree Palmer is better. I don't think Rodgers is better than him. But Favre at 38 is still better. Palmer may get back to his old self we'll just have to wait and see.
xTrav
offline
offline
Take the Bengals glasses off your face just because you live in, around, or near Cincinatti and look at the FACTS ! Carson is a shit QB. The Bengals are to the point where its time to draft the QB of the future as soon as possible.
xTrav
offline
offline
Originally posted by IHasUsername
You too. Offense is struggling, not a good thing.
Wrong. Our Defense is clicking.
You too. Offense is struggling, not a good thing.
Wrong. Our Defense is clicking.
Excalibur
offline
offline
Every team in the NFL sucks except the Browns... we are just giving everyone else a head start then we are going to win out... yeah, and Carson Palmer is the best QB in the league.
Beaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by Excalibur
Every team in the NFL sucks except the Browns... we are just giving everyone else a head start then we are going to win out... yeah, and Carson Palmer is the best QB in the league.
Fuck that. Gus Farrot is the best QB in the league fools!
Every team in the NFL sucks except the Browns... we are just giving everyone else a head start then we are going to win out... yeah, and Carson Palmer is the best QB in the league.
Fuck that. Gus Farrot is the best QB in the league fools!
PhireHawk
offline
offline
You are both crazy.
Everybody knows the Lions are just layin' in the weeds waiting to strike. Jon Kitna is going to get hot...
Just wait, it will happen... this is the year...
Everybody knows the Lions are just layin' in the weeds waiting to strike. Jon Kitna is going to get hot...
Just wait, it will happen... this is the year...
Doomsday
offline
offline
Trent Edwards is the best QB in the league that has a RB on his team named Marshawn Lynch. No other team QB can say that atm.
Beaker
offline
offline
Really, I take it back. Ronnie Brown is the best QB in the league! 158.3 QB rating baby!
IHasUsername
offline
offline
Originally posted by davitrav30
Originally posted by IHasUsername
You too. Offense is struggling, not a good thing.
Wrong. Our Defense is clicking.
Meh. Our O should score more than 14 even on a clicking D tbh. We're struggling with dropped passes and a lackluster run game :/
Originally posted by IHasUsername
You too. Offense is struggling, not a good thing.
Wrong. Our Defense is clicking.
Meh. Our O should score more than 14 even on a clicking D tbh. We're struggling with dropped passes and a lackluster run game :/
Fat Banana
offline
offline
Originally posted by Beaker
Originally posted by IHasUsername
The guy you traded threw for 6 TDs while injured. The guy that replaced him got injured. Carson Palmer is better than either of them atm btw. OC just refuses to throw the ball because Cincys coaching is shit.
. . .riiiight.
Aaron Rodgers: 61.9 comp percent, 961 yards, 6 TDs, 3 INTs, 91.4 QB rating
Brett Favre: 70.2 comp percent, 935 yards, 12 TDs, 4 INTs, 110.8 QB rating
Carson Palmer: 57.8 comp percent, 514 yards, 1 TD, 3 INTs, 63.8 QB rating
No, Carson Palmer is not better then either of them and the OC probably does not want to throw the ball because he is not a big fan of incompletions and picks. I will agree that the Bungles do not have the best coaching staff in the world, but when it comes down to it, the players have to make the plays on the field too, and Palmer is just not getting it done.
Aaron Rodgers kind of reminds me of Rex Grossman. Except maybe even less durable.
Originally posted by IHasUsername
The guy you traded threw for 6 TDs while injured. The guy that replaced him got injured. Carson Palmer is better than either of them atm btw. OC just refuses to throw the ball because Cincys coaching is shit.
. . .riiiight.
Aaron Rodgers: 61.9 comp percent, 961 yards, 6 TDs, 3 INTs, 91.4 QB rating
Brett Favre: 70.2 comp percent, 935 yards, 12 TDs, 4 INTs, 110.8 QB rating
Carson Palmer: 57.8 comp percent, 514 yards, 1 TD, 3 INTs, 63.8 QB rating
No, Carson Palmer is not better then either of them and the OC probably does not want to throw the ball because he is not a big fan of incompletions and picks. I will agree that the Bungles do not have the best coaching staff in the world, but when it comes down to it, the players have to make the plays on the field too, and Palmer is just not getting it done.
Aaron Rodgers kind of reminds me of Rex Grossman. Except maybe even less durable.
BerkeyTerps
offline
offline
Originally posted by Fat Banana
Originally posted by Beaker
Originally posted by IHasUsername
The guy you traded threw for 6 TDs while injured. The guy that replaced him got injured. Carson Palmer is better than either of them atm btw. OC just refuses to throw the ball because Cincys coaching is shit.
. . .riiiight.
Aaron Rodgers: 61.9 comp percent, 961 yards, 6 TDs, 3 INTs, 91.4 QB rating
Brett Favre: 70.2 comp percent, 935 yards, 12 TDs, 4 INTs, 110.8 QB rating
Carson Palmer: 57.8 comp percent, 514 yards, 1 TD, 3 INTs, 63.8 QB rating
No, Carson Palmer is not better then either of them and the OC probably does not want to throw the ball because he is not a big fan of incompletions and picks. I will agree that the Bungles do not have the best coaching staff in the world, but when it comes down to it, the players have to make the plays on the field too, and Palmer is just not getting it done.
Aaron Rodgers kind of reminds me of Rex Grossman. Except maybe even less durable.
1 injury doesn't tell the tale yet on rodgers, we'll see how he's doing after 1-2 seasons
Originally posted by Beaker
Originally posted by IHasUsername
The guy you traded threw for 6 TDs while injured. The guy that replaced him got injured. Carson Palmer is better than either of them atm btw. OC just refuses to throw the ball because Cincys coaching is shit.
. . .riiiight.
Aaron Rodgers: 61.9 comp percent, 961 yards, 6 TDs, 3 INTs, 91.4 QB rating
Brett Favre: 70.2 comp percent, 935 yards, 12 TDs, 4 INTs, 110.8 QB rating
Carson Palmer: 57.8 comp percent, 514 yards, 1 TD, 3 INTs, 63.8 QB rating
No, Carson Palmer is not better then either of them and the OC probably does not want to throw the ball because he is not a big fan of incompletions and picks. I will agree that the Bungles do not have the best coaching staff in the world, but when it comes down to it, the players have to make the plays on the field too, and Palmer is just not getting it done.
Aaron Rodgers kind of reminds me of Rex Grossman. Except maybe even less durable.
1 injury doesn't tell the tale yet on rodgers, we'll see how he's doing after 1-2 seasons
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
