My suggestion involved a second system for players in their 2nd and 3rd seasons (D-league being the place for 1st season players). It would work like a minor league system, but after a player is over 3 seasons old (or maybe make it 4), he would have to leave. There has to be some limitation like this to keep parity in the farm leagues.
...thunder, if you limit it as you suggest then teams like the current farm teams will continue to exist in the regular leagues where there isn't such regulation. If the point of the dedicated farm leagues is to push farm team activity to a separate realm then you have to make the move motivating. Otherwise there will always be guys who will use the regular teams to develop and prepare players for their primary (parent) club.
I see ya'lls point but as written you still take away, or maybe I'm misunderstanding, the need for new players as most people will just take care of their small group of slow build friends or whatever.
So people are left on the waiting list while owners get a second team?
The farm system works well in pro baseball (colleges being a farm for pro football).
I don't think this would create a desirable environment at GLB from the player point of view.
Kretch I really like the vast majority of your posts, you too rbedgood. I think you are both suffering from 'owner tunnel vision'. Seeing whats better for established team owners while ignoring the fact that most GLB'ers are NOT owners.
Originally posted by didymus So people are left on the waiting list while owners get a second team?
The farm system works well in pro baseball (colleges being a farm for pro football).
I don't think this would create a desirable environment at GLB from the player point of view.
Kretch I really like the vast majority of your posts, you too rbedgood. I think you are both suffering from 'owner tunnel vision'. Seeing whats better for established team owners while ignoring the fact that most GLB'ers are NOT owners.
Didymus,
In this thread I've played more the devil's advocate than anything. I don't know what the right solution is. However I can tell you as an owner I only have one team. I'm not griping from the perspective of stopping others, but rather admitting that the competitive advantages of the farm system are big, and that if you want to move those farm teams out of regular leagues you'll have to realize what their goals are. If you set level caps and such on the 'farm leagues' that are being proposed then players will continue to buy and use regular teams as farm clubs, and there will be little to no change in the current problems.
I recognize that most GLBers are not owners and that there is a long-waiting list. However the problem that is being addressed in this thread is the issue of farm teams currently residing in regular leagues and messing with the parity of those leagues. There are many other issues that need to be discussed, but lets save those for other threads.
Farm team idea is inherently bad. Teams will hire / play players according to the needs of the parent team and not in their own self intereset.
Why make a league for teams that don't care one whit about winning in the first place? What would be the point? To isolate them like a disease (accurate term).
So Farm teams screw with competition, but also with player choices. If farm teams proliferate, a GLB player would be ostracized for not being 'in the family'. If a player was unwilling to make a career long commitment to an organization, why would they hire and play him? Even if he's a well built player - who cares? The farm teams aren't trying to win games.
We should actively combat collusion, not enable it!
-with respect to my esteemed colleagues with whom I don't entirely agree
Originally posted by didymus Farm team idea is inherently bad. Teams will hire / play players according to the needs of the parent team and not in their own self intereset.
Why make a league for teams that don't care one whit about winning in the first place? What would be the point? To isolate them like a disease (accurate term).
So Farm teams screw with competition, but also with player choices. If farm teams proliferate, a GLB player would be ostracized for not being 'in the family'. If a player was unwilling to make a career long commitment to an organization, why would they hire and play him? Even if he's a well built player - who cares? The farm teams aren't trying to win games.
We should actively combat collusion, not enable it!
-with respect to my esteemed colleagues with whom I don't entirely agree
Good points...but not every owner would use this farm league. Sure, it would certainly benefit the owner that does pay the extra 500 flex each season, but it wouldn't be entirely overpowering. There would still be plenty of teams that would operate as they do now in the free agent market. This would just make it cheaper for owners that currently use farm teams to do so in its own league...pushing these teams out of the regular league and improving parity (no level caps for these teams, imo).
At the same time that these regular league farm teams are disappearing, more spots will open up for owners on the waiting list.
Originally posted by kretchfoop Originally posted by didymus
Farm team idea is inherently bad. Teams will hire / play players according to the needs of the parent team and not in their own self intereset.
Why make a league for teams that don't care one whit about winning in the first place? What would be the point? To isolate them like a disease (accurate term).
So Farm teams screw with competition, but also with player choices. If farm teams proliferate, a GLB player would be ostracized for not being 'in the family'. If a player was unwilling to make a career long commitment to an organization, why would they hire and play him? Even if he's a well built player - who cares? The farm teams aren't trying to win games.
We should actively combat collusion, not enable it!
-with respect to my esteemed colleagues with whom I don't entirely agree
Good points...but not every owner would use this farm league. Sure, it would certainly benefit the owner that does pay the extra 500 flex each season, but it wouldn't be entirely overpowering. There would still be plenty of teams that would operate as they do now in the free agent market. This would just make it cheaper for owners that currently use farm teams to do so in its own league...pushing these teams out of the regular league and improving parity (no level caps for these teams, imo).
At the same time that these regular league farm teams are disappearing, more spots will open up for owners on the waiting list.
The Galaxy Aces have farm teams but they arent really farm teams
Yeah this is similar to thunderdoozer's suggestion a while ago. I like the idea quite a bit, especially if the levels are capped on them, since it gives human teams a very good reason to sign low level players to develop them (which is currently sorely lacking).
It would require doubling the number of sim servers we have, which I'm not sure if we can support or not at the moment. There's only so much room in the rack, and we didn't plan for something like this, so I would have to see if our current contract could support the power needs, etc.
Maybe if we started out with it limited to Pro, AAA, and AA teams or something, it would easier to get put in with our current setup. Of course, then what do you do with relegated AA teams?
Originally posted by popo1010 Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by didymus
Farm team idea is inherently bad. Teams will hire / play players according to the needs of the parent team and not in their own self intereset.
Why make a league for teams that don't care one whit about winning in the first place? What would be the point? To isolate them like a disease (accurate term).
So Farm teams screw with competition, but also with player choices. If farm teams proliferate, a GLB player would be ostracized for not being 'in the family'. If a player was unwilling to make a career long commitment to an organization, why would they hire and play him? Even if he's a well built player - who cares? The farm teams aren't trying to win games.
We should actively combat collusion, not enable it!
-with respect to my esteemed colleagues with whom I don't entirely agree
Good points...but not every owner would use this farm league. Sure, it would certainly benefit the owner that does pay the extra 500 flex each season, but it wouldn't be entirely overpowering. There would still be plenty of teams that would operate as they do now in the free agent market. This would just make it cheaper for owners that currently use farm teams to do so in its own league...pushing these teams out of the regular league and improving parity (no level caps for these teams, imo).
At the same time that these regular league farm teams are disappearing, more spots will open up for owners on the waiting list.
The Galaxy Aces have farm teams but they arent really farm teams
I hope this is a joke.
Related to the topic, I like the idea, but at the same time, it gives existing agents an even more significant advnatage over newer guys.
And having it only for Pro - AA would create a significant advantage that would make it difficult for A and lower teams in the long run.
that would be a joke to move down because u dont want to boost. I'm not going to be spending a ton of cash on a cpu game. to be honest. ive spent $20, but i cant afford to spend money to boost every year. Im in high-school am 15 and arent old enough to have a job, so that would be unfair to spend money i cant gain back on a game. U can say that cuz u have a job and probly spend ur pay check on this game
Originally posted by FairForever Originally posted by popo1010
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by didymus
Farm team idea is inherently bad. Teams will hire / play players according to the needs of the parent team and not in their own self intereset.
Why make a league for teams that don't care one whit about winning in the first place? What would be the point? To isolate them like a disease (accurate term).
So Farm teams screw with competition, but also with player choices. If farm teams proliferate, a GLB player would be ostracized for not being 'in the family'. If a player was unwilling to make a career long commitment to an organization, why would they hire and play him? Even if he's a well built player - who cares? The farm teams aren't trying to win games.
We should actively combat collusion, not enable it!
-with respect to my esteemed colleagues with whom I don't entirely agree
Good points...but not every owner would use this farm league. Sure, it would certainly benefit the owner that does pay the extra 500 flex each season, but it wouldn't be entirely overpowering. There would still be plenty of teams that would operate as they do now in the free agent market. This would just make it cheaper for owners that currently use farm teams to do so in its own league...pushing these teams out of the regular league and improving parity (no level caps for these teams, imo).
At the same time that these regular league farm teams are disappearing, more spots will open up for owners on the waiting list.
The Galaxy Aces have farm teams but they arent really farm teams
I hope this is a joke.
Related to the topic, I like the idea, but at the same time, it gives existing agents an even more significant advnatage over newer guys.
And having it only for Pro - AA would create a significant advantage that would make it difficult for A and lower teams in the long run.