User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
After taking more looks into these incompletions, every single play the WR is open because the DB froze while the ball is in the air. If the DB does not freeze up, the WR wouldn't not be open in most of these plays. Since most of us think that the DB freezing up is caused by pump fake, it can be derived that the pump fake is still freezing up DBs pretty regularly. If pump fake is tuned down (especially in man to man coverage, in which the DB wouldn't be looking at the QB anyway), the WRs would not have been open on these plays.

I think this is really a result of nerfing the pump fake.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by datongw

RJ, I took a look at all 3 of the games. Here are my thoughts:

1. Yes, there is definitely a lot of the occurrence in which the WR seems to be open and the pass is on target, but it's incomplete.
2. The 3 games you showed as an example, the opponents were all pretty decent, so the data is pretty valid. Against these 3 quality opponents, your QB is 83-132, 63%, 281 yards a game, 7 TDs and 3 Ints. Rating of 89.3, which is pretty decent. I don't know what your QB's exact build is, but been a level 31 QB and only having 49 in the passing bar, I'm guessing his throwing+vision is about 140 with a lot invested in the SA (4-5 in most passing SA). Honestly, not a bad QB, but it's probably average for a level 31 QB. In which, against quality opponents, getting a rating of 89.3 is not bad.
3. There are 19 cases where the WR was open and the pass was not completed, if these were completions, your QB would have completed 102 out of 132 passes, which would be 77%. That is a bit high for any QB that plays quality defenses, and average 10 yards a completion. If most passes were short passes, 77% is achievable, but the average completion won't be 10 yards.

So, it's in my opinion that the passing results from these 3 games (based on your QB, and level of competition), are pretty realistic. We know Bort tuned down pump fake a bit, there are two ways to do this: 1) change the graphics so the DB stays with the WR when the pump fake is not working; 2) keep the graphics the way it is, but reduce the completion % for WRs getting open because of the pump fake. Logically, I would think the first method is the way to go. But I think what has happened is that the second method is implemented, maybe for technical reasons such as easier fix without having to change too much code.

I'm still seeing too many DBs getting faked out on passes. As a matter of fact, if you take a look at these incomplete passes, most of the time the WR is open because the CB froze. Of course, I'm just guessing here.


It is not the numbers that I'm necessarily arguing with - granted they would be far better if those passes were all complete - but the nature in which these particular passes are incomplete. I'd rather every one of the passes he drops into coverage be incomplete and all the wide open ones be complete - which would give him a far worse percentage but be more accurate.

I think the misconception of everybody who is refuting posts about this issue is that the people posting on it are complaining about the qb's numbers - Hugh's numbers are perfectly acceptable - but the nature of the sim and the way these plays are working is just plain wrong. Also, Bort's nerf of pump fake is intended to shorten the length of the fake - it should have absolutely no effect on whether the pass is caught if it reaches the reciever - so if it IS affecting that, then that is a problem.


I agree that there are some misrepresentations in the sim that should be worked out. But I try to remind myself that the dots are not real, only representations. There are many times it looks like the dot wasn't even close to the goalline and a TD was rewarded, or it looked like no gain, but 3-4 yards were gained.

After looking over at all these imcompletions, I'm more convinced than ever that if the DB froze on the play (presumably the effect of pump fake), the odds are pretty good the pass will not be completed. This is certainly a way to nerf the pump fake, is it the most efficient way with the most realism in viewing? Probably not.

It should be fixed, but I don't think the results will be much different, as we both pretty much agree that the numbers are acceptable. It would be really nice if the graphics of this game is better, but that will probably be difficult to do, and I don't think it's the highest priority right now. Personally I'd rather see Bort spend more of his time to add more plays into the playbook.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
I see. So your saying that basically, Bort nerfed pump fake, but didn't update the graphic representation accordingly - that's your implication here?
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 22:53:17
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
I see. So your saying that basically, Bort nerfed pump fake, but didn't update the graphic representation accordingly - that's your implication here?


That would be my guess, I'm not Bort so I don't know. But it does seem that if the WR is open because the DB froze up, the pass is going to be incomplete most of the time.
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
completely realistic IMO
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by rj414

I see. So your saying that basically, Bort nerfed pump fake, but didn't update the graphic representation accordingly - that's your implication here?


That would be my guess, I'm not Bort so I don't know. But it does seem that if the WR is open because the DB froze up, the pass is going to be incomplete most of the time.


If that's the case, wouldn't the sim record a deflection from the corner? Bort has stated that if the ball is ruled incomplete, it means it wasn't within the recievers catch radius. He's also stated that if the reciever attempts to catch it and it isn't caught, it registers as a drop. It goes to follow that if the CB were actually in position and attempted to break up the pass and succeeded it would go down as a deflection, would it not?

If your theory that the PF nerf is responsible and the graphics just arent displaying it properly were true (I'm taking that to mean you believe the CB is actually staying with the WR, even if the image isn't showing that) then that implies that the CB broke up the pass, but just didn't appear to be in position to do so. If so, that would read as a deflection. Until these errors I've NEVER seen a ball touch a WR and just go incomplete, in 4.5 seasons playing this game, even if the CB was draped all over him. Usually balls that just read incomplete go past the WR, behind him, or land short. Never hit him and stop.

I still just don't buy it.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Additionally, there are examples of this from as far back as halfway through last season, and before the announcement of the pump fake nerf from this year (Our first preseason game was filled with them)
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by rj414


I see. So your saying that basically, Bort nerfed pump fake, but didn't update the graphic representation accordingly - that's your implication here?


That would be my guess, I'm not Bort so I don't know. But it does seem that if the WR is open because the DB froze up, the pass is going to be incomplete most of the time.


If that's the case, wouldn't the sim record a deflection from the corner? Bort has stated that if the ball is ruled incomplete, it means it wasn't within the recievers catch radius. He's also stated that if the reciever attempts to catch it and it isn't caught, it registers as a drop. It goes to follow that if the CB were actually in position and attempted to break up the pass and succeeded it would go down as a deflection, would it not?

If your theory that the PF nerf is responsible and the graphics just arent displaying it properly were true (I'm taking that to mean you believe the CB is actually staying with the WR, even if the image isn't showing that) then that implies that the CB broke up the pass, but just didn't appear to be in position to do so. If so, that would read as a deflection. Until these errors I've NEVER seen a ball touch a WR and just go incomplete, in 4.5 seasons playing this game, even if the CB was draped all over him. Usually balls that just read incomplete go past the WR, behind him, or land short. Never hit him and stop.

I still just don't buy it.


Not all incompletions are result of deflections. As a matter of fact, we have way too many deflections in GLB. In the NFL a good CB will get maybe 20 deflections a season. Most imcompletions are result of poor throws, too short, too high, too low, a bit behind (on crossing patterns), etc.

Put it this way, if we don't get to see the dots running, rather we just see the play by play results, would you be this upset right now?

I'm just saying that it's the result that matters, not how it looks.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 23:01:57
 
aspenwolf
offline
Link
 
i just found this thread, and i'm glad to see that there's more than just me with this problem

i'm been going nuts thinking that i've neglected some part of my wr as i built him. currently this season this is happening to him 2-3 times a game, each and every game. very frustrating
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aspenwolf
i just found this thread, and i'm glad to see that there's more than just me with this problem

i'm been going nuts thinking that i've neglected some part of my wr as i built him. currently this season this is happening to him 2-3 times a game, each and every game. very frustrating


Yeah, it's happening to every body, happens to my team too. I'm just learning to live with it.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
I think the main point of this discussion is people want to know why the pass is incomplete so they can make the necessary changes in their builds to complete them in the future. The way things are now, you have no idea how to alter your build to correct the problem.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
I think the main point of this discussion is people want to know why the pass is incomplete so they can make the necessary changes in their builds to complete them in the future. The way things are now, you have no idea how to alter your build to correct the problem.


Hit the nail squarely on the head.
 
aspenwolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
I think the main point of this discussion is people want to know why the pass is incomplete so they can make the necessary changes in their builds to complete them in the future. The way things are now, you have no idea how to alter your build to correct the problem.


agree 100%
 
Den
offline
Link
 
^^
Quick Economic rhetorical question....

Does it take more FP to figure it out when you have an idea of how to tell what is wrong (the graphics actually make sense) or does it take more FP to figure it out by pure trial and error (the graphics are consistently explained as a 'vague' display of the simmed results) until you find the magic formula ?

Last edited Sep 25, 2008 23:38:08
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
I think the main point of this discussion is people want to know why the pass is incomplete so they can make the necessary changes in their builds to complete them in the future. The way things are now, you have no idea how to alter your build to correct the problem.


Seems to me accuracy is the problem- so add more throwing and maybe vision?

Could be vision on the WRs, not seeing/knowing where the ball is ahead of time.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 23:42:43
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.