User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > 4 out of 29 Completion ratio to open WR…incomplete. Plays showing all of them.
Page:
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Nothing about passing this year is the same. I watch every play of every game I have a player on and there is so many incompletes or in my opinion too many drops when the players is wide open.

Here is my favorite one:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=162562&pbp_id=1409259

Level 31 WR

52 Catch 48 Jump 38 Vision 5 Sticky Hands 5 Jump Catch.. there is no reason he should drop this ball. Also it was the third play of the game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=162562&pbp_id=1409819

Same exact play and player. 2 Drives Later


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=162562&pbp_id=1410355

Still first quarter

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=162562&pbp_id=1410370

There is no reason these should be drops or incompletes
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 10:39:16
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
It was unacceptable that corner builds that worked season 3 were totally jacked up season 4 and couldnt cover worth a damn.

The answer they got use skill points to improve. IF peeps were foolish enough to boost right at the beginning of the season knowing that every season that Bort has made changes thats there own fault.

I dont see whats so different from past seasons. There have always been changes. Last season the Passing teams got a big boost an became overpowered. I cant tell you the number of times I shook my head in digust at the 3rd an 19.5 yard pass that was completed to get a first down with nary a incomplete.

The west coast offense is an offense that uses short passing with some intermediate routes. What I see here in glb is that peeps dont seem to understand that fact and they want the results of an Nfl west coast offense but they want it with a medium to long passing game. Recent short passing game result was 84% completion rate actually higher than an nfl west coast offense success rate.

Why dont some of you folks that are complaining switch to a short passing game with a few medium pass's thrown in. I'll bet that your passing % rates will be up an incompletes will be down.

Adjust just like all the defenses had to adjust to less effective corners last season.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 10:39:21
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge
It was unacceptable that corner builds that worked season 3 were totally jacked up season 4 and couldnt cover worth a damn.

The answer they got use skill points to improve. IF peeps were foolish enough to boost right at the beginning of the season knowing that every season that Bort has made changes thats there own fault.

I dont see whats so different from past seasons. There have always been changes. Last season the Passing teams got a big boost an became overpowered. I cant tell you the number of times I shook my head in digust at the 3rd an 19.5 yard pass that was completed to get a first down with nary a incomplete.

The west coast offense is an offense that uses short passing with some intermediate routes. What I see here in glb is that peeps dont seem to understand that fact and they want the results of an Nfl west coast offense but they want it with a medium to long passing game. Recent short passing game result was 84% completion rate actually higher than an nfl west coast offense success rate.

Why dont some of you folks that are complaining switch to a short passing game with a few medium pass's thrown in. I'll bet that your passing % rates will be up an incompletes will be down.


I agree.. but uncalled for drops and non catches when they are apparently wide open?
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge
It was unacceptable that corner builds that worked season 3 were totally jacked up season 4 and couldnt cover worth a damn.

The answer they got use skill points to improve. IF peeps were foolish enough to boost right at the beginning of the season knowing that every season that Bort has made changes thats there own fault.

I dont see whats so different from past seasons. There have always been changes. Last season the Passing teams got a big boost an became overpowered. I cant tell you the number of times I shook my head in digust at the 3rd an 19.5 yard pass that was completed to get a first down with nary a incomplete.

The west coast offense is an offense that uses short passing with some intermediate routes. What I see here in glb is that peeps dont seem to understand that fact and they want the results of an Nfl west coast offense but they want it with a medium to long passing game. Recent short passing game result was 84% completion rate actually higher than an nfl west coast offense success rate.

Why dont some of you folks that are complaining switch to a short passing game with a few medium pass's thrown in. I'll bet that your passing % rates will be up an incompletes will be down.

Adjust just like all the defenses had to adjust to less effective corners last season.


You sir, and all the other people that just come on here spouting this garbage, are a donkey. Obviously the completion percentages will go up if we scale our passing games back. The completion percentage, at least for me, isn't the issue. If my QB is missing his target, great, show that graphically so I can figure out what to do to change the build. I am not bitching that my QB is missing his target. I am bitching that my qb, who's equipment I've changed 3 times to try and compensate for this, is NAILING his target (I've another thread where I have countered every excuse i've heard so far with evidence) and it's being ruled incomplete every damn time. I'm complaining because my QB is missing wide open recievers 7 yards away when the ball is landing right on top of them. It happens on routes on every depth, and it is atrocious. This same qb who missed a reciever 7 yards away in the endzone, in the same game a few plays prior completed one 40 yards away to a wr in double coverage. Personally, I'd rather that pass have gone incomplete if on all these plays that my WRs diss the coverage they got rewarded with either a TD, or the knowledge that if the QB hadnt over or underthrown them they woulda had one.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Funny thing is that I was randomly perusing links on google about the game, like I do from time to time, last night and I came across another message board complaining of the same thing (WR's missing open catches)...in July.

If something is wrong (and I'm not convinced that there necessarily is) then it's been going on since at least mid last season, which is when I last made adjustments to QB throwing, adding the ability to throw away from the defenders.

Anyone notice anything in common on these reports? i.e. the types of pass, the QB throwing setting, the position of the defenders, etc?
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 10:57:20
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Funny thing is that I was randomly perusing links on google about the game, like I do from time to time, last night and I came across another message board complaining of the same thing (WR's missing open catches)...in July.

If something is wrong (and I'm not convinced that there necessarily is) then it's been going on since at least mid last season, which is when I last made adjustments to QB throwing, adding the ability to throw away from the defenders.

Anyone notice anything in common on these reports? i.e. the types of pass, the QB throwing setting, the position of the defenders, etc?


I think the longer passes are the problem, sort of like what you said in another post. QBs could be throwing to high or to low and Wrs are not able to get to the ball. TE passing seems to work fine but those are shorter routes.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
It's possible that part of the problem is WR's who load up on speed causing them to speed past where they should be to catch the ball.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
It's possible that part of the problem is WR's who load up on speed causing them to speed past where they should be to catch the ball.


Could be, I guess. Just getting a little out of range because they are too damn fast to slow down soon enough.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Serenity

It's possible that part of the problem is WR's who load up on speed causing them to speed past where they should be to catch the ball.


Could be, I guess. Just getting a little out of range because they are too damn fast to slow down soon enough.


which is why like I said TE catching is not a problem.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
is there code that determines which way the WR is facing at any moment?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I wonder if any slower receivers are having problems
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
is there code that determines which way the WR is facing at any moment?


Sorta, it's really just based around his agility and vision.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Serenity

It's possible that part of the problem is WR's who load up on speed causing them to speed past where they should be to catch the ball.


Could be, I guess. Just getting a little out of range because they are too damn fast to slow down soon enough.


Wouldn't a real QB learn the speed of his WR? Too fast really would bother me. There are no receivers in any football game that are too fast. QB's just throw it further in front of there guys. It is actually something most teams would prefer. Less chance of a pick when only one guy has a chance at it.

And why doesn't it say dropped. I know the animation isn't perfect but most of these look to hit the guy pretty square.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 12:24:01
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Funny thing is that I was randomly perusing links on google about the game, like I do from time to time, last night and I came across another message board complaining of the same thing (WR's missing open catches)...in July.

If something is wrong (and I'm not convinced that there necessarily is) then it's been going on since at least mid last season, which is when I last made adjustments to QB throwing, adding the ability to throw away from the defenders.

Anyone notice anything in common on these reports? i.e. the types of pass, the QB throwing setting, the position of the defenders, etc?


We use medium throws. I didn't see anything like this last season, although my fastest WR did have the most drops, but last season they were usually drops and they weren't hitting him square on like they are now. We added 2 new very speedy guys. Perhaps the boosting of this season and adding even more speed made it worse. Either way, a good QB which some of us should have, should be able to figure out the guys speed to get it out in front of him.

What if we add more strenth will we throw it out in front of the receiver?

And some of these throw are only 15-25 yards.
 
wesmiley
offline
Link
 
I think its a problem with scrimmages.. anyone ever notice that most problems happen in scrimmages?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.