well thought out solution to gutting: DO NOT LET IT HAPPEN!!! All trades should have to be approved my a Mod if they see that team A is trading everything for little they can take a look into it and if they feel that they are trying to gut because the owner doesn't want to own a team any more they can reject, and retract all the trades and have the owner sell his team in a responsible manner
Forum > Suggestions > Well Thought-Out Solution to Gutting
Aryn
offline
offline
Originally posted by Brohl
It's very much worth the read. It isn't a magic bullet for the problem, but it does address the issue in a way that seems very fair and balanced. My guess would be it won't be well received because it bypasses the queue in most cases for prospective new owners.
I say +1
I think this is a great solution.
I am on the waiting list for a team right now and I would prefer a brand new team from the roll-out, rather than one that is pre-owned.
Maybe there could be an option on the waiting list, another little box to check as to whether you want "new or used" so to speak.
It's very much worth the read. It isn't a magic bullet for the problem, but it does address the issue in a way that seems very fair and balanced. My guess would be it won't be well received because it bypasses the queue in most cases for prospective new owners.
I say +1
I think this is a great solution.
I am on the waiting list for a team right now and I would prefer a brand new team from the roll-out, rather than one that is pre-owned.
Maybe there could be an option on the waiting list, another little box to check as to whether you want "new or used" so to speak.
nottom
offline
offline
Originally posted by seayjoel
well thought out solution to gutting: DO NOT LET IT HAPPEN!!! All trades should have to be approved my a Mod if they see that team A is trading everything for little they can take a look into it and if they feel that they are trying to gut because the owner doesn't want to own a team any more they can reject, and retract all the trades and have the owner sell his team in a responsible manner
This doesn't stop gutting. It just stops the fire sale of players that is a result of gutting. At least when an owner sells all his players, the new owner is left with cash to try and rebuild. If this wasn't allowed, then the owner would sell and all the player contracts would expire (or they would be dropped) at the end of the season and you are now left with a gutted team and no cash in the bank.
well thought out solution to gutting: DO NOT LET IT HAPPEN!!! All trades should have to be approved my a Mod if they see that team A is trading everything for little they can take a look into it and if they feel that they are trying to gut because the owner doesn't want to own a team any more they can reject, and retract all the trades and have the owner sell his team in a responsible manner
This doesn't stop gutting. It just stops the fire sale of players that is a result of gutting. At least when an owner sells all his players, the new owner is left with cash to try and rebuild. If this wasn't allowed, then the owner would sell and all the player contracts would expire (or they would be dropped) at the end of the season and you are now left with a gutted team and no cash in the bank.
nottom
offline
offline
What about the situation when a team is gutted by an owner that just wants to restart? How is that dealt with?
ZachG650
offline
offline
I like it, but it should be less than 66% IMO. But that number is a variable I suppose.
w_alloy
offline
offline
Originally posted by nottom
What about the situation when a team is gutted by an owner that just wants to restart? How is that dealt with?
Well, how would he get the team in the first place? The only teams you can be assigned to through the queue are teams that are at the bottom and in "restart" mode anyways.
Interim owners won't be able to gut teams unless they lie to the team in order to become the legitimate owner next season and then turn on everyone. While this is certainly possible, and will probably happen some if this gets implemented, I don't see it becoming a problem because of the lack of upside for the person doing the gutting. He would be stuck in a higher league without players and recruiting might prove impossible due to his damaged reputation (from lying and gutting). Why not just keep the current players intact?
Owners appointed by the previous owner could do the same thing as described above, but would run into the same problems.
Edit: And I also built in some protection against this by having players with old contracts being able to reject trades and self-release after one year.
What about the situation when a team is gutted by an owner that just wants to restart? How is that dealt with?
Well, how would he get the team in the first place? The only teams you can be assigned to through the queue are teams that are at the bottom and in "restart" mode anyways.
Interim owners won't be able to gut teams unless they lie to the team in order to become the legitimate owner next season and then turn on everyone. While this is certainly possible, and will probably happen some if this gets implemented, I don't see it becoming a problem because of the lack of upside for the person doing the gutting. He would be stuck in a higher league without players and recruiting might prove impossible due to his damaged reputation (from lying and gutting). Why not just keep the current players intact?
Owners appointed by the previous owner could do the same thing as described above, but would run into the same problems.
Edit: And I also built in some protection against this by having players with old contracts being able to reject trades and self-release after one year.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 20:20:55
w_alloy
offline
offline
Originally posted by ZachG650
I like it, but it should be less than 66% IMO. But that number is a variable I suppose.
Ya, my mentality is more geared towards the more competitive leagues. I think a system where the top tier leagues have to get 66-75% and leagues one tier from the bottom have to get around 40%, and scaling the percent for leagues in between those, might be best.
I think that anything below 66% for the top tiers and you might as well be gutting since recruiting is so hard and you will lose every game to competitive teams with 2/3rds of a roster.
I like it, but it should be less than 66% IMO. But that number is a variable I suppose.
Ya, my mentality is more geared towards the more competitive leagues. I think a system where the top tier leagues have to get 66-75% and leagues one tier from the bottom have to get around 40%, and scaling the percent for leagues in between those, might be best.
I think that anything below 66% for the top tiers and you might as well be gutting since recruiting is so hard and you will lose every game to competitive teams with 2/3rds of a roster.
greengoose
offline
offline
So in essence we will be resetting sold back teams to create more competitive balance - but allowing functionally equivalent teams (slow builders) to propagate the landscape and continue upset competitive balance with 150-0 scores every season INTENTIONALLY?.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3185
This is what I'm talking about. A team in the LOWEST level league in Western Europe. They are worse than a gutted team because even after this season they will still be 15-20 levels below the competition.
What are we gonna do - promote 9-7 teams to higher leagues (and much higher competition levels) to accommodate new owners? We will be creating a vicious circle because that 9-7 team that is forcibly promoted from A to AA will likely say #$%^ it once he realizes he's now in a league where he's 10 levels+ below the competition level with little hope to compete.
I think the real problem is there are more teams in GLB than there is capable owners to run them in the first place.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3185
This is what I'm talking about. A team in the LOWEST level league in Western Europe. They are worse than a gutted team because even after this season they will still be 15-20 levels below the competition.
What are we gonna do - promote 9-7 teams to higher leagues (and much higher competition levels) to accommodate new owners? We will be creating a vicious circle because that 9-7 team that is forcibly promoted from A to AA will likely say #$%^ it once he realizes he's now in a league where he's 10 levels+ below the competition level with little hope to compete.
I think the real problem is there are more teams in GLB than there is capable owners to run them in the first place.
Xiong Yoshi
offline
offline
Originally posted by gravenimages
Essentially, if a GM doesn't want to assume the team, keep them together with an interim owner with powers to set gameplans/depth charts but no hiring/firing capability.
The problem with this is that it doesn't take into consideration the reality of how a gutting happens, or why it happens.
The entire idea of gutting happens because there is no clear distinction between the Agent that "Owns" the team - and the team itself.. Because of this lack of distinction, when Players sign contracts to play for the team - many Players sign on to play for the Owner, or a GM. It is a networking thing.. and as soon as the Owner leaves announces that they are planning on leaving - the Players will naturally ask to be released because they don't want to get stuck with an unknown owner.. and because some Players ask, and the Owner's own Players will be leaving, that makes the team uncompetitive and therefore the rest of the Players want off too.
What would an interim owner mean to the Players? nothing.. just another random person who may or may not have their interests at heart.
Essentially, if a GM doesn't want to assume the team, keep them together with an interim owner with powers to set gameplans/depth charts but no hiring/firing capability.
The problem with this is that it doesn't take into consideration the reality of how a gutting happens, or why it happens.
The entire idea of gutting happens because there is no clear distinction between the Agent that "Owns" the team - and the team itself.. Because of this lack of distinction, when Players sign contracts to play for the team - many Players sign on to play for the Owner, or a GM. It is a networking thing.. and as soon as the Owner leaves announces that they are planning on leaving - the Players will naturally ask to be released because they don't want to get stuck with an unknown owner.. and because some Players ask, and the Owner's own Players will be leaving, that makes the team uncompetitive and therefore the rest of the Players want off too.
What would an interim owner mean to the Players? nothing.. just another random person who may or may not have their interests at heart.
maybe make all players wait 6 days to be cut. Lets a new owner come in and make friends with everyone? Then after the new owner comes in a gets to actually TALK to everyone they can decide to scram or not...
w_alloy
offline
offline
Greengoose:
This plan will help with slow building teams by moving them all to the lowest division when they are created. No more teams making slow building teams in upper and medium tier leagues which is much more of a problem. People should expect some really bad and weird teams at the lowest level, and bad teams will be moved there more quickly under my system. But it won't change anything besides that regarding slow building and I don't think that's necessarily a negative thing. But this is getting off-topic and a discussion for another thread.
I agree that promotion and relegation can be painful in leagues where there is a high level difference between tiers. Unfortunately this is a result of how Bort created the teams and the order of league creation, and a problem in the current system, not a problem specific to my proposal (not saying how he did it was bad).
Originally posted by greengoose
I think the real problem is there are more teams in GLB than there is capable owners to run them in the first place.
Well no argument there but at least this system does a better job of concentrating all the incapable owners at the bottom. A lot of bad owners are new owners, just because experience is important and bad owners are more likely to quit after a few seasons.
This plan will help with slow building teams by moving them all to the lowest division when they are created. No more teams making slow building teams in upper and medium tier leagues which is much more of a problem. People should expect some really bad and weird teams at the lowest level, and bad teams will be moved there more quickly under my system. But it won't change anything besides that regarding slow building and I don't think that's necessarily a negative thing. But this is getting off-topic and a discussion for another thread.
I agree that promotion and relegation can be painful in leagues where there is a high level difference between tiers. Unfortunately this is a result of how Bort created the teams and the order of league creation, and a problem in the current system, not a problem specific to my proposal (not saying how he did it was bad).
Originally posted by greengoose
I think the real problem is there are more teams in GLB than there is capable owners to run them in the first place.
Well no argument there but at least this system does a better job of concentrating all the incapable owners at the bottom. A lot of bad owners are new owners, just because experience is important and bad owners are more likely to quit after a few seasons.
w_alloy
offline
offline
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by gravenimages
Essentially, if a GM doesn't want to assume the team, keep them together with an interim owner with powers to set gameplans/depth charts but no hiring/firing capability.
The problem with this is that it doesn't take into consideration the reality of how a gutting happens, or why it happens.
The entire idea of gutting happens because there is no clear distinction between the Agent that "Owns" the team - and the team itself.. Because of this lack of distinction, when Players sign contracts to play for the team - many Players sign on to play for the Owner, or a GM. It is a networking thing.. and as soon as the Owner leaves announces that they are planning on leaving - the Players will naturally ask to be released because they don't want to get stuck with an unknown owner.. and because some Players ask, and the Owner's own Players will be leaving, that makes the team uncompetitive and therefore the rest of the Players want off too.
What would an interim owner mean to the Players? nothing.. just another random person who may or may not have their interests at heart.
But my system DOES address this much more than is currently done.
The relationship you described about teams being bound by their owners is correct and is not going to change. What better way to address a team's desire for a new good owner then by having them first vote on who is the best possible owner to take over the team and then voting (basically with their contracts) if they want the team to move forward with this new owner, after a short trial period to test them out.
If this doesn't save the team, nothing will, and it would have been gutted and left in the league anyways (at least my system removes it fast). There is no good way to stop teams being bound by their owners without changing the importance of the owner to the team, and I don't want those type of changes.
Originally posted by gravenimages
Essentially, if a GM doesn't want to assume the team, keep them together with an interim owner with powers to set gameplans/depth charts but no hiring/firing capability.
The problem with this is that it doesn't take into consideration the reality of how a gutting happens, or why it happens.
The entire idea of gutting happens because there is no clear distinction between the Agent that "Owns" the team - and the team itself.. Because of this lack of distinction, when Players sign contracts to play for the team - many Players sign on to play for the Owner, or a GM. It is a networking thing.. and as soon as the Owner leaves announces that they are planning on leaving - the Players will naturally ask to be released because they don't want to get stuck with an unknown owner.. and because some Players ask, and the Owner's own Players will be leaving, that makes the team uncompetitive and therefore the rest of the Players want off too.
What would an interim owner mean to the Players? nothing.. just another random person who may or may not have their interests at heart.
But my system DOES address this much more than is currently done.
The relationship you described about teams being bound by their owners is correct and is not going to change. What better way to address a team's desire for a new good owner then by having them first vote on who is the best possible owner to take over the team and then voting (basically with their contracts) if they want the team to move forward with this new owner, after a short trial period to test them out.
If this doesn't save the team, nothing will, and it would have been gutted and left in the league anyways (at least my system removes it fast). There is no good way to stop teams being bound by their owners without changing the importance of the owner to the team, and I don't want those type of changes.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 04:32:52
w_alloy
offline
offline
Originally posted by Knick
maybe make all players wait 6 days to be cut. Lets a new owner come in and make friends with everyone? Then after the new owner comes in a gets to actually TALK to everyone they can decide to scram or not...
This might be better then the current system, but why force a new unknown owner on to a team when they can vote themselves? Especially if a new owner looking for team forum was created, and active players could add a dedicated prospective owner to the ballot (a possible modification to my main proposal). And then he could make his pitch to the team and they would vote. Wouldn't that be better then having the owner of a team, the most important part of it, decided by just the random order of joining a queue?
maybe make all players wait 6 days to be cut. Lets a new owner come in and make friends with everyone? Then after the new owner comes in a gets to actually TALK to everyone they can decide to scram or not...
This might be better then the current system, but why force a new unknown owner on to a team when they can vote themselves? Especially if a new owner looking for team forum was created, and active players could add a dedicated prospective owner to the ballot (a possible modification to my main proposal). And then he could make his pitch to the team and they would vote. Wouldn't that be better then having the owner of a team, the most important part of it, decided by just the random order of joining a queue?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























