User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
You are missing the point Vilita.

My point was PRO level teams have nothing to gain from this. So your opinion is skewed from the start. Of course you don't care why your team is where it is. That's because caring serves you no purpose on a personal investment level.

We're not stupid.

PRO level teams, by doing nothing more then starting sooner then everyone else (and there's no skill involved in that, just luck) have had numerous advantages over non-PRO teams. One good example --> waiting to boost in early seasons of the game.

Truth is, if you've done your job Vilita, and your team is in line, talent wise, with the rest of your region, then you've got nothing to worry about.

I don't propose the absolute highest level teams go into the highest division. However, if the Pro average level today is 32.5, and someone's team in pro is relatively uncompetitive (meaning a 6 win season or less) and a few levels below this average - then they should be replaced.



 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
No, you are missing the point. This thread has nothing to do with me being in Pro League, you are just using that as a springboard to argue against the thread that you don't even disagree with, because you have a beef with me.


The point is that restructuring does absolutely nothing to solve the problem, as the second restructuring is complete, teams will be sold back again and the effect of the restructuring will be lost.

I'm not worried at all. If I end up in a league other than the one I'm in (the one I chose to be in from the start of the game because I like Oceania) then I will be the first one to re-do all my players contracts to end on day 40 and sell back my team, proving that the restructuring did jack shit to solve the problem and proving my point.

So its a win-win for me, I'd just rather see an actual solution instead of a band-aid fix that does nothing just because a bunch of uninformed people have voted for it in a poll.

Originally posted by

I don't propose the absolute highest level teams go into the highest division. However, if the Pro average level today is 32.5, and someone's team in pro is relatively uncompetitive (meaning a 6 win season or less) and a few levels below this average - then they should be replaced.


No disagreement, but there are ways to do that without restructuring the entire gameworld.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Out of curiosity which choice on Poll 1 did you choose?
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
I cast one vote for all 3 of these options by hitting back, selecting the next option, and hitting submit:

Yes, but only if I can stay in my current region

No, but I would like to see an increased promotion/relegation count

No, I really like the leagues the way they are
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I myself picked "No, but I would like to see an increased Promotion/Regulation count"
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
If I end up in a league other than the one I'm in (the one I chose to be in from the start of the game because I like Oceania) then I will be the first one to re-do all my players contracts to end on day 40 and sell back my team, proving that the restructuring did jack shit to solve the problem and proving my point.



Actually, the only thing that your actions will prove is that you're a whiney child!

You said elsewhere about the poll being made up of 95% of people in other leagues - well, reality check - there are more leagues than just yours, you know. And more opinions than yours too.

As with all the other whiney 'got here early so it's my right to never have to compete or get promoted or worry about finances, etc, etc, yawn, yawn' you are now shitting yourselves at the prospect of being exposed as 'ordinary'.

And, in the 1337 g33k land where you live, that is something that's not permissable, which is the REAL reason why you'd sell all you players and then the team.


 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Yea its not a bad option, but again, I don't think it completely solves the problem. I'd rather see a system like the one I suggested or has been possibly suggested by others where its not that the number of hard promotion/relegation that is increased, but the number of levels a team can be relegated that has chosen to do so or that does not meet the leagues requirements for competition.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
OPL is just filled with dissatisfied owners... I know of 3 myself.

Ideally your system would work, but there are WAAAY too many jackass' who would rather play in a capped league and talk about how great they are than actually try.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 04:56:36
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Vilita

If I end up in a league other than the one I'm in (the one I chose to be in from the start of the game because I like Oceania) then I will be the first one to re-do all my players contracts to end on day 40 and sell back my team, proving that the restructuring did jack shit to solve the problem and proving my point.

reality check - there are more leagues than just yours, you know. And more opinions than yours too.



Reality check, so why not just poll each league individually? If a league wants to restructure include them in the restructure, if they don't, don't include them.

Its not rocket science I'm asking for here, in fact, its the complete opposite (common sense)

People are voting for the hot topic because its the hot topic.

Additionally, ever since they've been forcing people (in a way) to sign up in whatever the first available league was, people have been getting teams in leagues they didn't want to be in.

But for those of us that want to remain in the same region, because we chose this region for a reason when we signed up, we shouldn't be forced to be restructured somewhere else just because the majority of people voting are members of a team in the bottom league of a region they didn't want to be in to begin with or didn't care about.


So don't be so quick to write someone off as a "Whiney Child" just because they have a different point of view on a situation than you do. And don't even begin to attempt to tell me what the real reason I would sell my team back is, because surely you are no mind reader.

You have to get past the fact that I happen to control a Pro League team and look at the actual issue. The restructuring doesn't actually solve anything, it just hides it for one season before its just as rampant as it was before. And its my opinion, that there are more than just one person who would be upset at the entire league system potentially being broken up for, in the end, no reason whatsoever.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
OPL is just filled with dissatisfied owners... I know of 3 myself.

Ideally your system would work, but there are WAAAY too many jackass' who would rather play in a capped league and talk about how great they are than actually try.



http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1100851

It works fine in other games. At the end of each season they just drop sold teams down the league system, and promote (in order) the highest teams in their place that have the tick box selected. Bare bones, simple solution that does essentially everything the restructuring does, but is a continuous, not one time only solution. And it has the added benefit of preserving the league structures and rivalries we already have.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita

Reality check, so why not just poll each league individually? If a league wants to restructure include them in the restructure, if they don't, don't include them.


LOL - reality check - because the people like yourself, sat in leagues that are unattainable for the majority due to the massive imbalance in the leagues and the game itself, would never want to have to compete.

As I keep saying GLB is minority-centric. This is perhaps the first time that measures might be taken to address that issue and the owners who've historically had it easy 'coz they got here first' are now realising that they are going to have to compete.

I'd say the real 'game players' would be saying 'bring it on'. So what does that make you??

Whiney?? I reckon............
 
Allarius
offline
Link
 
Nevermind,I was wrong..just fixing that.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 06:28:13
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

I'd say the real 'game players' would be saying 'bring it on'. So what does that make you??


I'd say the real 'game players' would immediately be able to process the fact that restructuring does absolutely nothing to fix the issue in the game that people are concerned about. All it does is sweep it under the rug for one season, maybe two at best.

 
TexanInMA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by Knick

in one of my teams BBB league we have 6 gutted teams in the CONFERENCE. 6/16 /= 3/32


BBB Is the bottom league in the pyramid - All that proves is the system is working itself out nicely...


Canada AAA#2 was rated the #13 league in season 2 by Bort. It's not a low level league. I was the highest rated non-US AAA and higher than many Pro leagues. Half our our teams are gutted.

This is not a problem of low levels.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.