User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Africa A League > Africa A #3 > Schmidt Brand Power Rankings and Thompson Rankings
Page:
 
jlusch21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NSchmidt10

Please don't criticize unless you are have an alternative to suggest or post your own no biased computer formulated rankings.


+1
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 13:53:09
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NSchmidt10

Please don't criticize unless you are have an alternative to suggest or post your own no biased computer formulated rankings.


Haha okay. What do you consider this:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1117428&page=1#8672417
Hmm, it looks like my own no biased computer formulated rankings....
 
NSchmidt10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36
Originally posted by NSchmidt10


Please don't criticize unless you are have an alternative to suggest or post your own no biased computer formulated rankings.


Haha okay. What do you consider this:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1117428&page=1#8672417
Hmm, it looks like my own no biased computer formulated rankings....


Seems like its just a made up ranking system or something that someone who has spent 20 minutes using excel has created. Also, even though I play in the better conference (Lion Conference) I still post Elephant rankings.
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Actually I only spent about 5 minutes in excel making it, and yet its still more accurate than yours...so maybe you should reconsider your approach
 
NSchmidt10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36
Actually I only spent about 5 minutes in excel making it, and yet its still more accurate than yours...so maybe you should reconsider your approach


LOL... I am pretty sure that everyone will disagree with you come week 6 or 7. Good statistical analysis takes more than just a few inputs to be accurate.
 
jsully75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NSchmidt10
Originally posted by csull36

Actually I only spent about 5 minutes in excel making it, and yet its still more accurate than yours...so maybe you should reconsider your approach


LOL... I am pretty sure that everyone will disagree with you come week 6 or 7. Good statistical analysis takes more than just a few inputs to be accurate.


But it takes a lot of them to be very inaccurate!
 
Lombard
offline
Link
 
you can't dismiss the whole "any given sunday" thing either.
 
mat5592
it's here
offline
Link
 
sigh....I thought I told everyone that the excel spreadsheets would be VERY inaccurate for the first few games...but that might have been on my team's league forum...
 
NSchmidt10
offline
Link
 
BUMP for new power rankings!
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
I don't know that anyone is going undefeated in this conference. I think the Africa A tournament is showing A#3 Lion may be the best conference in all of Africa A.
 
gretho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NSchmidt10
Originally posted by csull36

hmmm I'm going to go out on a limb and say your power ranking formula is pretty inaccurate. Your #2 ranked team lost to your #4 ranked team and your #5 ranked team lost to your #9 team in Elephant. Do you factor in strength of schedule? How about wins? That might be a good place to start...


Please don't criticize unless you are have an alternative to suggest or post your own no biased computer formulated rankings.

Also, I made a slight error in the game score that showed Boston Dogs with a 2-1 record, I fixed this and reposted the rankings, sorry, slight human error.


WTF. He hardly critized you and pointed out obvious flaws in your formula . If you can't debate these then whats the use in putting them up.
 
NSchmidt10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gretho
Originally posted by NSchmidt10

Originally posted by csull36


hmmm I'm going to go out on a limb and say your power ranking formula is pretty inaccurate. Your #2 ranked team lost to your #4 ranked team and your #5 ranked team lost to your #9 team in Elephant. Do you factor in strength of schedule? How about wins? That might be a good place to start...


Please don't criticize unless you are have an alternative to suggest or post your own no biased computer formulated rankings.

Also, I made a slight error in the game score that showed Boston Dogs with a 2-1 record, I fixed this and reposted the rankings, sorry, slight human error.


WTF. He hardly critized you and pointed out obvious flaws in your formula . If you can't debate these then whats the use in putting them up.


Do you understand how the power rankings work? I input scores from all of the games, sooooo that means that the fewer games input the greater the error will be. Given more time, these rankings will become increasingly more accurate.
 
Thompson08
offline
Link
 
kinda updated
 
punkaweedus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arles
I don't know that anyone is going undefeated in this conference. I think the Africa A tournament is showing A#3 Lion may be the best conference in all of Africa A.

Yeah, A#3 is really representing well. Too bad the Warlords missed out on the tournament.
 
threadkiller
offline
Link
 
damn you congo. you beat nile and we all lose our computer rankings. thanks a lot selfish.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.