User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
Originally posted by Robbnva

bort eliminated the exploit so deal with it, yeah not everyone was using it so all of us punters have to get used to it.

BTW I have like 5 or 6 punters so if anyone feels your pain it is me.


he should take the exploit part away, not the actual XP for punts.


that was how the xploit worked. A punter playing QB, CB, or whatever got no special gain but a Punter punting every single down OR say a kicker kicking a FG on 1st down all the time got high XP.

It was taken advantage of people complained, I tried my hardest to prevent it, bort chimed in after like 20 people complained and that was it. Bort doesn't let the masses decide, or the REAL punters decide what effects them, he listens to people who don't even have a punter make up his mind.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

Originally posted by Robbnva


bort eliminated the exploit so deal with it, yeah not everyone was using it so all of us punters have to get used to it.

BTW I have like 5 or 6 punters so if anyone feels your pain it is me.


he should take the exploit part away, not the actual XP for punts.


that was how the xploit worked. A punter playing QB, CB, or whatever got no special gain but a Punter punting every single down OR say a kicker kicking a FG on 1st down all the time got high XP.

It was taken advantage of people complained, I tried my hardest to prevent it, bort chimed in after like 20 people complained and that was it. Bort doesn't let the masses decide, or the REAL punters decide what effects them, he listens to people who don't even have a punter make up his mind.


I thought he added that you couldnt punt except on 4th down? I understand giving very limited XP for plays not at punter, but punts done on 4th down should be at full XP.
 
Toric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
this just in - punter experience has ALWAYS sucked.

Another small thing Bort said he'd fix, back when we found Malachorn's exploited punter. Yet, nothing changed. like the punting yardage bug thats been around since freakin season 1


yes it did !!! you can get a magic +5 punting of doom shoelace at the magic store now !!!
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

Originally posted by islander1


this just in - punter experience has ALWAYS sucked.

Another small thing Bort said he'd fix, back when we found Malachorn's exploited punter. Yet, nothing changed. like the punting yardage bug thats been around since freakin season 1


I dont know what game you have been playing but punter XP used to be twice as much as a normal player if you got enough punts. that was to compensate for the games when you didnt punt much.


Wow, you really are as stupid as your original post.


really? So how many other positions got 700+ XP from a single game or almost 600 XP as a level 7 by only punting? Perhaps you you should stick to tic tac toe.
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
More interested in the fact my punter got no xp from last game, and likely will from half the games this season as we're stuck playing gutted teams. Needs to be some reworking of punters but it's tricky as plays varies so much.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Its entirely reasonable that Bort should be thinking of a way to make the punter position only hold certain classes (like P, K and maybe HB/QB) and just bar anyone else from taking a spot in the punter depth chart.

In fact, I think the same of the PR/KR players too. I hate seeing DE's and DT's and O-Linemen in that position.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TtD
More interested in the fact my punter got no xp from last game, and likely will from half the games this season as we're stuck playing gutted teams. Needs to be some reworking of punters but it's tricky as plays varies so much.


this is the whole reason that punters/kickers originally could earn extra XP in some games to compensate these games. Now these players are being greatly handicapped because a few people decided to be asses.

I seriously dont understand why so many corrections in the game penalize the legit players. In this case, the simple solution would have been to limit punter/kicker XP to those plays only instead they get all their XP nerfed.
 
Oso
offline
Link
 
wow....just....wow
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GmanV2
Originally posted by islander1



Wow, you really are as stupid as your original post.


How is he stupid for either post? Flame elsewhere dude, seriously. He's making a valid point which should Bort see it, may take into consideration.


You're both stupid if you think punters should level every game because they punt a certain amount of times in a game. If you got XP based on performance, or performing at all, then the game would be totally imbalanced, just like Malachorn's punter showed last season.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Right. I had thought, in last season's thread discussing punter's XP, that Bort was going to reduce the max XP and guarantee a minimum XP for punters. This would have, I think, solved the problem of punters on good teams never leveling up while getting rid of the punting exploit that Malachorn (and others) were using. It seems, though, that Bort only fixed the exploit problem without fixing the low XP problem.
 
Link
 
Of course, the XP needed fixing one way or another, since, under normal circumstances with no screwery, my punter managed over 1000 XP in a game his first season... and the other team's punter had even -more- punts. Even without intentional exploitation, it could and did get ridiculous.

As for playing gutted teams that you will never need to punt against, that'd be the time to ask to be slipped onto Special Teams somewhere on the depth chart. Not only will you get your XP, you may get the satisfaction of your punter pancaking someone! It worked for me.

Anyway, it seems like it should be possible to get punters up to a proper place on XP. Could give some base XP for a proper player on the punter depth chart, make punts count extra as far as actual plays go, and set a cap for XP that directly caps XP, not number of plays that give XP. Could work.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by GmanV2

Originally posted by islander1




Wow, you really are as stupid as your original post.


How is he stupid for either post? Flame elsewhere dude, seriously. He's making a valid point which should Bort see it, may take into consideration.


You're both stupid if you think punters should level every game because they punt a certain amount of times in a game. If you got XP based on performance, or performing at all, then the game would be totally imbalanced, just like Malachorn's punter showed last season.


when did anyone every say punters should level every game? I simply pointed out that punters now cant even get max XP with 32 punts. You seem to be the idiot that failed reading comprehension so please go find some other thread to show your stupidity. Dont let the facts hit you in your ass/brain on your way out.

Originally posted by Gyuri1
Right. I had thought, in last season's thread discussing punter's XP, that Bort was going to reduce the max XP and guarantee a minimum XP for punters. This would have, I think, solved the problem of punters on good teams never leveling up while getting rid of the punting exploit that Malachorn (and others) were using. It seems, though, that Bort only fixed the exploit problem without fixing the low XP problem.


I thought this would have covered it too. I liked the idea that punters would be creadited as the holder for XP/FG, only allowing punters to get XP punting, and capping XP at 150% max XP would have been a fairly simple solution.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 05:03:40
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.