User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Training doesnt factor in fractional skill points
Page:
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Turkey22
Even numbers look better.


This is the main reason the detractors want this. It's insane.

 
LSUTigerJosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Catullus 16


percentages in training bars should be included in sim calculations:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1074214

what do you mean percentages? Can you explain that better?
fractions of a point isn't what you are talking about, right?


when you train, your training bar increases by a given percentage (e.g. +25%)
when you level, your major/minor skills increase by a certain amount (e.g. +0.25)

the problem is that while fractions (e.g the 0.25) are included in sim calculations, percentages are not (e.g. the 25%). not only does this mean that training is less efficient than it was before, it also means that there is a high likelihood of stray percentages that simply sit uselessly in your training bars for no good reason.

rather than the unnecessary complexity of an integer-based system sitting on top of a decimal-based system, i've been proposing that training percentages be treated like decimals in sim calculations. an additional benefit of having one system is that you only need one graphical representation... if that's decimals, fine... if that's training bars, fine. the aesthetics matter far less than the game mechanics issue.


Agreed and I don't believe players with those percentages are getting full use of them with the training at night. Bort should just have one of the training "bars" fill up to get that eventually converted to the whole number to go with the rest of the formula
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
I'm not happy with how the numbers look.

All decimal points should automatically be changed to training%, I can't see how this could be any easier. When you level up the bonus stats granted should be granted via a traing% bonus to each individual stat that would get the bonus.

It works as it is, it just seems amateurish to me, and why not fix something as easy to fix as this.


 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EagleOtto
I'm not happy with how the numbers look.

All decimal points should automatically be changed to training%, I can't see how this could be any easier. When you level up the bonus stats granted should be granted via a traing% bonus to each individual stat that would get the bonus.

It works as it is, it just seems amateurish to me, and why not fix something as easy to fix as this.




Think first, then post.

Giving training gains means: you don't get ANYTHING from the various +0.25, +0.33 and +0.4 gains your guy gets as he levels.

In order to make them worth something, you are FORCED to train each attribute up to a whole point.

So this ends up in the players chasing the automatic level gains to be completed by training to whole points.

The current system is just fine. Some guys don't like the decimals for a personal reason, but those guys probably care more about how their shoes fit to their shorts instead of football.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Catullus 16


percentages in training bars should be included in sim calculations:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1074214

what do you mean percentages? Can you explain that better?
fractions of a point isn't what you are talking about, right?


when you train, your training bar increases by a given percentage (e.g. +25%)
when you level, your major/minor skills increase by a certain amount (e.g. +0.25)

the problem is that while fractions (e.g the 0.25) are included in sim calculations, percentages are not (e.g. the 25%). not only does this mean that training is less efficient than it was before, it also means that there is a high likelihood of stray percentages that simply sit uselessly in your training bars for no good reason.

rather than the unnecessary complexity of an integer-based system sitting on top of a decimal-based system, i've been proposing that training percentages be treated like decimals in sim calculations. an additional benefit of having one system is that you only need one graphical representation... if that's decimals, fine... if that's training bars, fine. the aesthetics matter far less than the game mechanics issue.


+1

Agree 100%
 
Wolfblade
offline
Link
 
ok .. I see that there is alot of emotion here ... I realize that "Bort said" that the numbers to the right of the decimal point count in the sim, but do you have any way of knowing if it does or not? or when it stops working due to some patch? As for the new system, the partial green bars people seem agreed do not count. So one partial counts and one does not? This is a Beta test guys ... and explaining why such a silly system exists would (I hope) be embarrassing for Bort to explain to anyone new to the game at launch (if that ever happens). I can understand why Bort might want to leave it like it is (more work for him to fix it). What I do not understand are the players who seem to be emotionally vested in leaving it as it is. It seems to me cleaning it up would be in everyones' interest except the guy who has to do the programming. Unless perhaps someone has found some exploit? That might explain all the emotion.

Personally, I dislike having to push green bars, mess with tokens, etc. But I can live with it ... I just don't think it is an improvement. But at least merge the old system with the new ... round everyone up, that should get rid of it ... but it would be much better to just merge the two and have the green bar stuff work like the old system and "count" and then you could see the numbers to the right of the decimal point move up and you wouldnt have to look at some green bar and try to figure how to train based on partial bars (a total waste of time).
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.