User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > Please Address Why Kickers Keep Missing PATs
Page:
 
emdude
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Speed: 18.82
Agility: 19.11
Jumping: 19.59


I'm not convinced speed or jumping has more than a very minimal affect on it, but 19 agility probably plays a big part on XP misses. I know that as soon I upped my kicker's agility past 30, the XPs started becoming more automatic.
 
conmack49
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by conmack49

... What the fuck is up with that? ...


Now how could anyone possibly expect that this guy wanted an answer?

...so this happens if you can't divide the whiners from the guys worth giving an answer:

Originally posted by conmack49

So I'm supposed to believe that speed, agility, jumping, and stamina are causing a kicker to miss PATs? You assbags are completely off your meds. At least give a legitimate reason.




I'm sincerely sorry if I damaged your fragile sensibilities, but this was an awful headache for my team last year; it cost us one game outright and made several very uncomfortable. I don't expect any kicker to be 100% in all areas no matter how good their build is, but missing a PAT almost every regular season game last year and seeing the trend start again this year is ridiculous. BETA game or not, some folks pay REAL money to make their players and teams competitive and this kind of issue is detrimental to everyone's enjoyment of the game and to the success of GLB in the long run.

I would never advocate the outright publication of formulas or programming, but some official word on what the 'physics' (for lack of a better term) of the game are would be helpful. One guy made the comment that even he could make PATs and I think most adult males can consistently make PATs with a deccent hold, so having players that are dedicated to the kicking skill inexplicably miss PATs is beyond ridiculous.
Last edited Sep 23, 2008 08:48:39
 
conan8425
offline
Link
 
This was a problem for our kicker last year, too, so some the feedback here was nice. But something substantial would be nice as well.
 
bdnannac
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by conmack49

So I'm supposed to believe that speed, agility, jumping, and stamina are causing a kicker to miss PATs? You assbags are completely off your meds. At least give a legitimate reason.


Yes, they are. Stamina is vital this season, especially for special teams as teams appear to be scoring a lot more. Stamina is how fast you recover energy and how effective you are at lower energy. 13 stamina us unacceptable for a kicker at LVL 27. That needs to be doubled at least. Stamina is probably why you are missing Xps.

Minor atts for a position cannot be ignored, even if "minor" or "secondary".


LOL...so all of the sudden kickers need tons of stamina?
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bdnannac
Originally posted by caponesgun

Originally posted by conmack49


So I'm supposed to believe that speed, agility, jumping, and stamina are causing a kicker to miss PATs? You assbags are completely off your meds. At least give a legitimate reason.


Yes, they are. Stamina is vital this season, especially for special teams as teams appear to be scoring a lot more. Stamina is how fast you recover energy and how effective you are at lower energy. 13 stamina us unacceptable for a kicker at LVL 27. That needs to be doubled at least. Stamina is probably why you are missing Xps.

Minor atts for a position cannot be ignored, even if "minor" or "secondary".


LOL...so all of the sudden kickers need tons of stamina?


The fact that he doesn't even have a Kicker tells me all I need to know.
 
rbetesta
offline
Link
 
He only owns his own team and GM's for 8 others so he must not have any experience being around kickers.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbetesta
He only owns his own team and GM's for 8 others so he must not have any experience being around kickers.


Exactly...
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bdnannac
LOL...so all of the sudden kickers need tons of stamina?


No, but if they're kicking 8XP (so therefore 8 Kickoffs) and 3FG's, plus additional kickoff at halftime or beginning of the game - there's 20 snaps already. Factor in how tired special teamers get, it's no surprise to see kickers missing PAT's or having worsening FG %.

20 would be a good starting base for stamina probably, but really the more you have the better your kicker will be able to maintain his best form.

Same for Punters.
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by bdnannac

LOL...so all of the sudden kickers need tons of stamina?


No, but if they're kicking 8XP (so therefore 8 Kickoffs) and 3FG's, plus additional kickoff at halftime or beginning of the game - there's 20 snaps already. Factor in how tired special teamers get, it's no surprise to see kickers missing PAT's or having worsening FG %.

20 would be a good starting base for stamina probably, but really the more you have the better your kicker will be able to maintain his best form.

Same for Punters.


My Kicker had 8 XP's in his last game and only went down to 82 energy. Another 3 FG's wouldn't have made a huge difference to that.
 
JPop
offline
Link
 
* 19 agility = your guy is a dufus who can't even swing his leg without throwing himself off-balance
* 19 jumping = poor leg strength (or if you prefer, poor "spring" in your legs)
* 14 stamina = all of your abilities degrade rapidly as the game goes on

Last edited Sep 24, 2008 08:49:01
 
Lancelot
offline
Link
 
this is how you make a kicker!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=777498
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by Koncorde

Originally posted by bdnannac


LOL...so all of the sudden kickers need tons of stamina?


No, but if they're kicking 8XP (so therefore 8 Kickoffs) and 3FG's, plus additional kickoff at halftime or beginning of the game - there's 20 snaps already. Factor in how tired special teamers get, it's no surprise to see kickers missing PAT's or having worsening FG %.

20 would be a good starting base for stamina probably, but really the more you have the better your kicker will be able to maintain his best form.

Same for Punters.


My Kicker had 8 XP's in his last game and only went down to 82 energy. Another 3 FG's wouldn't have made a huge difference to that.


In game energy vs end game energy. And I'm not sure if it's the PAT's that drain energy, I think it's special teams. But the more PAT's you have, the more kick offs you do.

Did you miss a 20 yard FG? Yes. At the end of the first half, yes? Had your kickoff distances been dropping on consecutive kicks 81, 76, 55. Possible symptom? Maaaaybe.

Last season meanwhile your kicker missed PAT's in 20TD, 11TD and 10TD games - which are also (obviously) doubled by kickoffs.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lancelot
this is how you make a kicker!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=777498


I assume you meant to link to this kicker?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=28748
 
moxon4
offline
Link
 
Whose to say the missed extra points arent getting blocked at times?
 
Zupe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Speed: 18.82
Agility: 19.11
Jumping: 19.59


I'd find this more plausible if the kicker on one of my team's hadn't gone 70/70 on XPs last season never having raised any of the three at all (all 3 are still below 14) while my kicker with all 3 over 22 (not ridiculously high, but significantly better than 14) missed 12 XPs (96/108).

As an additional check, I looked at a couple of the other kickers on the team's I'm on that are within 3-4 levels of me. The three that faired best on XPs had put no points whatsoever in Speed/Agil/Jumping, while the one other that struggled similarly to mine had done at least some training on all 3 of those stats.

I'm not saying those stats hurt your ability making XPs, or even that they don't help a bit, but it seems hard to believe that they're the main factor with the (admittedly limited) results I've seen.

I'll also add that my stamina is the highest of any of the kickers I looked at to answer that question in advance.

From what I've seen so far, it sure appears to be pretty much random, and that some kicker's just end up with a lot of bad luck.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.