I agree, going by levels is bullshit there are some really good teams that don't match the level of the league. They need to go by wins and losses or something that is not dependent on levels.
palmer_garnett_95
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mofo
I agree, going by levels is bullshit there are some really good teams that don't match the level of the league. They need to go by wins and losses or something that is not dependent on levels.
I think try to keep the leagues together, just move the gutted teams down. I guess you could try realigning so that all the Pro Leagues have the best teams, but I think I would rather just keep the regions the same and just move everyone up.
I agree, going by levels is bullshit there are some really good teams that don't match the level of the league. They need to go by wins and losses or something that is not dependent on levels.
I think try to keep the leagues together, just move the gutted teams down. I guess you could try realigning so that all the Pro Leagues have the best teams, but I think I would rather just keep the regions the same and just move everyone up.
chasecrawford
offline
offline
I think the fix for the future is to redistribute teams based on level and then implement where sold teams are automatically relegated to the bottom leagues. I agree that distribution based on levels is far from perfect, but its a quick fix that will help a lot (I'm impatient I tend to go for quick fixes).
palmer_garnett_95
offline
offline
Originally posted by chasecrawford
I think the fix for the future is to redistribute teams based on level and then implement where sold teams are automatically relegated to the bottom leagues. I agree that distribution based on levels is far from perfect, but its a quick fix that will help a lot (I'm impatient I tend to go for quick fixes).
You have to be careful with levels. A team with a higher level average doesn't necessarily mean a better team. If we went by levels, Bel Air could get moved backwards, and that shouldn't happen.
I think the fix for the future is to redistribute teams based on level and then implement where sold teams are automatically relegated to the bottom leagues. I agree that distribution based on levels is far from perfect, but its a quick fix that will help a lot (I'm impatient I tend to go for quick fixes).
You have to be careful with levels. A team with a higher level average doesn't necessarily mean a better team. If we went by levels, Bel Air could get moved backwards, and that shouldn't happen.
chasecrawford
offline
offline
i agree that it would be a bad deal for some teams, but i think its what would be best for the game as a whole. the game is losing a lot of dedicated players because of the loss of competition. a quick fix is whats needed.
in my opinion, the best solution would be a free for all season that would act as a qualifying period. but as a web developer i dont see that as being worth the time and work needed to implement it.
in my opinion, the best solution would be a free for all season that would act as a qualifying period. but as a web developer i dont see that as being worth the time and work needed to implement it.
Painmaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by chasecrawford
a quick fix is whats needed.
Not if it's a dirty fix.
Doubling promotion/relegation (heck, taking it to 4x) for a season or two would be a cleaner fix. It also would provide the opportunity to assess how the solution is working during fix "implementation," so they can respond dynamically by accelerating or decelerating promotion/relegation season by season to account for distribution of underpowered teams.
Players aren't going to abandon the game wholesale if they see a solution has been decided on and is on the immediate horizon (and yes, "in about a month" is fairly immediate). On the contrary, I'd anticipate more players getting fed up and leaving if they are arbitrarily reassigned leagues based on average roster level.
a quick fix is whats needed.
Not if it's a dirty fix.
Doubling promotion/relegation (heck, taking it to 4x) for a season or two would be a cleaner fix. It also would provide the opportunity to assess how the solution is working during fix "implementation," so they can respond dynamically by accelerating or decelerating promotion/relegation season by season to account for distribution of underpowered teams.
Players aren't going to abandon the game wholesale if they see a solution has been decided on and is on the immediate horizon (and yes, "in about a month" is fairly immediate). On the contrary, I'd anticipate more players getting fed up and leaving if they are arbitrarily reassigned leagues based on average roster level.
Dyslexia
offline
offline
Originally posted by chasecrawford
I think the fix for the future is to redistribute teams based on level and then implement where sold teams are automatically relegated to the bottom leagues.
I don't see why a team deserves to be in a higher bracket because they have more players that boosted and were created in season 1 than another team.
What Painmaker suggested seems much more logical and in spirit with the first 5 seasons of GLB. If we put all the teams in a bag shake them up and rebuild the conferences by level then we were, essentially, playing for nothing.
When I tell some random chick at the bar that my team won the conference championships lets get naked, she will be like, but you're in the Brazilian League 64B Chapter 3, yeah right, rofls!
And that will be that ...
edit: I can speak for pretty much all of the Beardogs that we would quit if we got relegated down.
I think the fix for the future is to redistribute teams based on level and then implement where sold teams are automatically relegated to the bottom leagues.
I don't see why a team deserves to be in a higher bracket because they have more players that boosted and were created in season 1 than another team.
What Painmaker suggested seems much more logical and in spirit with the first 5 seasons of GLB. If we put all the teams in a bag shake them up and rebuild the conferences by level then we were, essentially, playing for nothing.
When I tell some random chick at the bar that my team won the conference championships lets get naked, she will be like, but you're in the Brazilian League 64B Chapter 3, yeah right, rofls!
And that will be that ...
edit: I can speak for pretty much all of the Beardogs that we would quit if we got relegated down.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:47:31
PP
offline
offline
This is all being made out to be so much tougher than it has to be. After the normal promotions are done in this coming off season, all you do is take out all the teams that have either been sold within the last season (to anyone other than a GM) or that finishes with 4 or less Ws. Set them aside and look at each conference to see how many teams they need. Let's say USA Pro East needs 3. You move up the top 2 teams form AAA #1 East and 1 from AAA #2 East (based on PO finsish, with regular season finish being the tie breaker when needed). USA Pro West needs 4 teams. Move up the top 2 both AAA #1 & #2 West.
So, between the move ups and dropping downs, USA AAA#2 East needs 8 teams. Take the top 4 from AA#3 East and 4 from AA #4 East. Keep repeating your way across and then down. It's really damn simple, unless you want to make it harder than it has to be.
When everything is done, fill in the gaps of missing teams in the lowest leagues with the ones moved down and you're set.
So, between the move ups and dropping downs, USA AAA#2 East needs 8 teams. Take the top 4 from AA#3 East and 4 from AA #4 East. Keep repeating your way across and then down. It's really damn simple, unless you want to make it harder than it has to be.
When everything is done, fill in the gaps of missing teams in the lowest leagues with the ones moved down and you're set.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 15:27:24
Reggie Smash
offline
offline
Exactly. Just sweep starting from the top & moving on down. I don't see what's so difficult about it.
PP
offline
offline
I miss the hell out of this league. There's actually intelligent conversation here. I'm quite certain that's never happened up there before and have my doubts that it ever will
palmer_garnett_95
offline
offline
Feel free to just hang out here instead of up there. I agree that would be the best way to do it. I just don't see Bort doing something that simple.
chrome
offline
offline
Originally posted by Reggie Smash
Exactly. Just sweep starting from the top & moving on down. I don't see what's so difficult about it.
Sure its a nice fix for next season, but you'll just be right back to the same thing within 4 seasons. Its actually funny listening to you guys, in a depressing sort of way. Have any of you even actually had a losing season in GLB? Do you have any idea what it does to a team?
And don't think it won't happen to you, b/c statistically its going to.
When they relegate this off-season, I'll most likely have to ask to get moved down to the next league. I simply won't be able to compete against the winning AA teams who'll be moving up. They've all had 3 seasons of winning to build up their stadiums and talent, while the near .500 teams like my own are slowly bled dry by free agency and the broken economical system.
Exactly. Just sweep starting from the top & moving on down. I don't see what's so difficult about it.
Sure its a nice fix for next season, but you'll just be right back to the same thing within 4 seasons. Its actually funny listening to you guys, in a depressing sort of way. Have any of you even actually had a losing season in GLB? Do you have any idea what it does to a team?
And don't think it won't happen to you, b/c statistically its going to.
When they relegate this off-season, I'll most likely have to ask to get moved down to the next league. I simply won't be able to compete against the winning AA teams who'll be moving up. They've all had 3 seasons of winning to build up their stadiums and talent, while the near .500 teams like my own are slowly bled dry by free agency and the broken economical system.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























