User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
MentalMisfit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bountytaker
Just to clarify some things:

-The second one shouldn't be based on the carry skill, otherwise it would have been a catch and fumble, I believe. Besides, he never should have gotten the ball knocked loose anyway, as he FAR outskills the guy hitting him.

-

-I have no problem with drops, and agree they add excitement to the game. But nearly 40%, which is WAY up from our scrimmage the previous day, seems like a lot.


Actually it does If you catch a ball and a CB hits you or strips it before you have full possession its called a drop not a fumble. Once a WR gets his hands on a ball in the sim carry skill takes over alot of WR completely ignore carry and str.


If you look threw the rest of the game a lot of your other drops might of been because of the same reason. But its cool just ask for reasons why this happened and then tell everyone they don't know wtf they are talking about and they are wrong and just blame the sim because it couldn't of been because of your supreme player builds....
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I think there have definately been changes. In game for one team I have players on our team had 6 catches and 0 drobs by the HBs. The WRs and TEs had 3 catches and 9 drops in a 3-7 loss. The other teams WR/TEs had 14 catches and 5 drops. Definately looks like a SIM change.
 
dwebb12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kettle
I'm getting so fed up with drops. My possession receiver has 50 in catching and it means absolutely nothing! 4 receptions and 3 drops!

In fact I'm getting fed up with all the changes to my players reactions in this "Beta" game and not getting a respec for the players.


Is his jumping up because once you get that up around 25 the drops seem less often.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
I think people fail to realize the impact that 15 skill points distributed across your league every offseason has on what happens in the sims the following season. People learn, adjust, and with 15 skill points in the right spots they can make huge strides. Conversely, if they go the right way and you go the wrong, the change can be even more pronounced.

Maybe this is an actual problem. But keep the boosts in mind when you're suddenly thinking "The sim was changed."

If you are a player who boosted, and re-did your equipment from one season to the next, you can have COMPLETELY different results from the season before, that have absolutely nothing to do with a sim change.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
I think people fail to realize the impact that 15 skill points distributed across your league every offseason has on what happens in the sims the following season. People learn, adjust, and with 15 skill points in the right spots they can make huge strides. Conversely, if they go the right way and you go the wrong, the change can be even more pronounced.

Maybe this is an actual problem. But keep the boosts in mind when you're suddenly thinking "The sim was changed."

If you are a player who boosted, and re-did your equipment from one season to the next, you can have COMPLETELY different results from the season before, that have absolutely nothing to do with a sim change.


+1

...and consider raising catching-abilities to work somewhat towards more drops: your WR might get a hand - but just a hand - on (badly) thrown passes he'd miss out completely before
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk

If you are a player who boosted, and re-did your equipment from one season to the next, you can have COMPLETELY different results from the season before, that have absolutely nothing to do with a sim change.



The problem is players who have not changed since pre-season and are getting completely different results from the preseason games.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by superpunk


If you are a player who boosted, and re-did your equipment from one season to the next, you can have COMPLETELY different results from the season before, that have absolutely nothing to do with a sim change.



The problem is players who have not changed since pre-season and are getting completely different results from the preseason games.


They're also playing different teams.

The amount of variables is so incredible, that just blaming it on a possible "sim change" is intellectually lazy, IMO.

Teams can shift their entire focus from one season to the next. Each play factors in what those corners/WRs/DL/QBs did to their players this offseason. The possibilities are endless.

You can trace the problem back to the lack of knowledge about how the sim works in even the slightest manner. And that is definitely a problem, since we're all just throwing darts at a dartboard right now. The possibility that some other team threw better darts at the imaginary dartboard that we know nothing about is higher than the chances that it's a different dart-board, IMO - based on the number of variables involved in both options.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by superpunk



If you are a player who boosted, and re-did your equipment from one season to the next, you can have COMPLETELY different results from the season before, that have absolutely nothing to do with a sim change.



The problem is players who have not changed since pre-season and are getting completely different results from the preseason games.


They're also playing different teams.

The amount of variables is so incredible, that just blaming it on a possible "sim change" is intellectually lazy, IMO.

Teams can shift their entire focus from one season to the next. Each play factors in what those corners/WRs/DL/QBs did to their players this offseason. The possibilities are endless.

You can trace the problem back to the lack of knowledge about how the sim works in even the slightest manner. And that is definitely a problem, since we're all just throwing darts at a dartboard right now. The possibility that some other team threw better darts at the imaginary dartboard that we know nothing about is higher than the chances that it's a different dart-board, IMO - based on the number of variables involved in both options.



This is true, but you can also watch the SIM and look at what happened. WRs dropping open passes is not dependant upon opponent. I agree there are several variables to take into account. However, you can also watch SIM and look for patterns to determine when there was a SIM change. If it was just one team experiencing the problem, then I say it was a fluke or would look for other reasons. When drops are up all over the place, and watching SIMs eliminates defensive coverages and quality of opponent as the causes then process of elimination makes you start to wonder if there was a sim change.


 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk


The amount of variables is so incredible, that just blaming it on a possible "sim change" is intellectually lazy, IMO.



These are reception/drop totals by WRs in games from Africa A #1 that I checked.

In one game WRs for the 2 teams combined for 17 catches and 14 drops.
In another it was 24 catches 14 drops by WRs.
In another it was 26 catches 9 drops by WRs.
In another it was 28 catches 9 drops by WRs.
In another it was 25 catches 11 drops by WRs.
In another it was 20 catches 13 drops by WRs.

WRs, especially lower level ones seem to be dropping a lot more passes today across the board. This is not a one team issue. I also have a theory that the drop % has gone up more on longer passes than shorter ones, but haven't researched enough or watched enough sims to make that determination yet.

 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.