User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > 4th Down Fumble
Page:
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Timbo Slice
Hes Right. http://www.ncaa.org/library/rules/2004/2004_football_rules.pdf Pg. 94


Do you have the http://www.glb.org/library/rules/2008/2008_football_rules.pdf Pg. 94?

If not, what's the point? If you claim that GLB doesn't resemble American football because of this rule, you're insane. It's just a different rule set.
 
Timbo Slice
offline
Link
 
This guy lost a game due to a rule that is in NCAA and NFL rules. If its going to start costing people games it needs to change.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Timbo Slice
This guy lost a game due to a rule that is in NCAA and NFL rules. If its going to start costing people games it needs to change.


Uh, no.


He lost a game because the other team scored more points than his team.


It's not as if this is a new rule that was put in place just for his game. The fumble on 4th down happened, and the ball was advanced. In GLB, that is legal. It's not such a drastic difference from the NFL/NCAA rules that it turns football into cricket.

It's still football. It's got a few different rules. Big deal.
 
Timbo Slice
offline
Link
 
I never said there was a big difference. I just explained that this is a rule that is in college football and not just NFL. I think that this is a rule that needs to looked over thats all. Im pretty sure thats all the OP wants as well.
 
mortalq2
offline
Link
 
in High School football there is no restriction for advancing fumbles on 4th down...
 
dboys194
offline
Link
 
just think of the fumble as a lateral, basically same thing since the ball went backwards.
 
Dvolution
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by Timbo Slice

This guy lost a game due to a rule that is in NCAA and NFL rules. If its going to start costing people games it needs to change.


Uh, no.


He lost a game because the other team scored more points than his team.


It's not as if this is a new rule that was put in place just for his game. The fumble on 4th down happened, and the ball was advanced. In GLB, that is legal. It's not such a drastic difference from the NFL/NCAA rules that it turns football into cricket.

It's still football. It's got a few different rules. Big deal.


Pushing Forbin's logic further, this is GLB rules, not NCAA or NFL, otherwise why not having 3 downs instead of 4 like the CFL? This ain't CFL either. On a given sports, the rule can change from one league to another, you have to learn the variants and deal with them.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
you can't intentionally fumble in this game



...so unnecessary rule in GLB.

Adding it for reality's sake would require a lot of coding on Bort's part, as he'd have to code other OFF players not to attempt to pick up the fumble on 4th down. He'd then have to code a vision check or something similar where OFF players do pick it up, to simulate a potential penalty happening on this play.

A lot of work for no real return. Would be nice, sure, but low priority IMO.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Originally posted by Schaffer05

you can't intentionally fumble in this game



...so unnecessary rule in GLB.

Adding it for reality's sake would require a lot of coding on Bort's part, as he'd have to code other OFF players not to attempt to pick up the fumble on 4th down. He'd then have to code a vision check or something similar where OFF players do pick it up, to simulate a potential penalty happening on this play.

A lot of work for no real return. Would be nice, sure, but low priority IMO.


uhh what? It's not a penalty the play is dead... no longer a play, just like the guy was tackled. It's not illegal for another offensive player to pick up the ball, he just can't advance it because once he picks it up he's "down". It is an uncessary rule though because you can't purposely fumble the ball, which is why it's a rule in NCAA and NFL
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mortalq2
in High School football there is no restriction for advancing fumbles on 4th down...


Players are paid in this game ergo it's not high school.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Depends on the high school...

My old high school "paid" players to play for them. Won quite a few state championships in a row too because of it.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
uhh what? It's not a penalty the play is dead



Pedantic much?
 
BarrySwitzer
offline
Link
 
Holy roller
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.