User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bountytaker


I do wonder, though, if we're just moving closer and closer to that suggestion from a while back, where each year we just realign the leagues.

I don't like it, because I like having rivalries. But, if it gets to the point where I have two rivals and 9+ cupcakes, I just may have to change my mind.


This was brought up back in season 2, and indeed, was declined globally for this exact reason. However, the game was much different then. The economic dichotomy that cripples this game now was just in an infancy back in season 2.

Oh and guess what. You almost DO have 9 cupcakes this season.

Last edited Sep 22, 2008 13:44:56
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
I think the solution is two-fold.

#1: League level MINIMUMS. Teams can't sign or trade for players below a certain level. This (combined with a minimum human roster of 40) keeps teams from getting gutted through trades. Teams could work around this (by having all of the contracts expire on the same day, for example). So, to keep teams from gutting money with last second bonuses, there would have to be a rule to keep teams from signing or re-signing players to same-season day 40 contracts after day 22, or so.

#2: When a team is gutted and sold back to GLB, roster spots that are not filled by players with the minimum level will be filled by CPU players at the minimum level UNTIL THE END OF THE SEASON. After that, they are dropped from the roster, and all gutted teams are moved to the bottom tier and sold to people waiting for teams, allowing some extra promotions for Conference runners-up, etc.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 15:32:10
 
phershey
offline
Link
 
When it comes down to it, there are thousands of guys that think it would be cool to be an owner. If you have 10 bucks, that is all you need to make that happen.

Chances are they will inherit a gutted team. instead of taking on the challenge and spend 2 to 3 or maybe even more seasons working hard to rebuild, they get frustrated an quit.

This game is pretty much recruiting. Bring in more "better". If my better is better than your better I should beat you. It takes perseverance to get a lot of rejected contracts and keep at it. It has nothing to do with the system in place. In the end it will always come down to how much heart it takes to turn a team around. Having 1000 Flex Points does not make someone qualified to do it. I'm fine with it. We're probably the 10th best team in the East. I'm hoping some of you guys ahead of us pack it up and quit. Just 2 of you gutting puts us in the playoffs.
 
jdusaf777
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
I think the solution is two-fold.

#1: League level MINIMUMS. Teams can't sign or trade for players below a certain level. This (combined with a minimum human roster of 40) keeps teams from getting gutted through trades. Teams could work around this (by having all of the contracts expire on the same day, for example). So, to keep teams from gutting money with last second bonuses, there would have to be a rule to keep teams from signing or re-signing players to same-season day 40 contracts after day 22, or so.

#2: When a team is gutted and sold, roster spots that are not filled by players with the minimum level will be filled by CPU players at the minimum level UNTIL THE END OF THE SEASON. After that, they are dropped from the roster, and all gutted teams are moved to the bottom tier, allowing some extra promotions for Conference runners-up, etc.


Coming at it from the perspective as the newly minted owner of a gutted team I cant get on board with point number 2. While it certainly sucks, I am sure, to have a team that you work hard to make competitive with good management have to play a bunch of gutted teams in your conference, it's not an ideal situation for us gutted team owners either. I'm sure most owners who inherit gutted teams didnt ask for them, I know I didn't, but we have to play the hand we are dealt.

It is almost impossible to recruit period, much less recruit FAs or make trades for guys at the level and abilities it takes to compete seriously in this conference when you have a gutted team. So its vitally important that we at least have the option to sign the lower level guys to longer term deals so we can develop them and hopefully field a competitive team in a few seasons. If we are not allowed to do that and have to fill rosters with CPU players it becomes basically a wasted season. I know we are going to be in for many more 184-0 games like we had in game 1 and my players know that but I still feel we are making progress and are setting ourselves up to be competitive in this league down the road.

I truly do wish their were a way that gutted teams could automatically get relegated down to lower conferences and other conference winners in lower leagues could come up I'm all for coming up with a system to encourage that. However please don't place any limits on the kind of human recruiting that us gutted team owners can do because the development of my players and the hopeful future returns are the only bright side of what will surely be a dismal season.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdusaf777

It is almost impossible to recruit period, much less recruit FAs or make trades for guys at the level and abilities it takes to compete seriously in this conference when you have a gutted team. So its vitally important that we at least have the option to sign the lower level guys to longer term deals so we can develop them and hopefully field a competitive team in a few seasons. If we are not allowed to do that and have to fill rosters with CPU players it becomes basically a wasted season.


I guess I should have been clearer.

The team would remain a CPU team for the rest of the season. It would be demoted and sold in the offseason.
 
jdusaf777
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by jdusaf777


It is almost impossible to recruit period, much less recruit FAs or make trades for guys at the level and abilities it takes to compete seriously in this conference when you have a gutted team. So its vitally important that we at least have the option to sign the lower level guys to longer term deals so we can develop them and hopefully field a competitive team in a few seasons. If we are not allowed to do that and have to fill rosters with CPU players it becomes basically a wasted season.


I guess I should have been clearer.

The team would remain a CPU team for the rest of the season. It would be demoted and sold in the offseason.


Ah yes, that would make sense I think.
 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdusaf777 However please don't place any limits on the kind of human recruiting that us gutted team owners can do because the development of my players and the hopeful future returns are the only bright side of what will surely be a dismal season. [/QUOTE


Yeah, I call it "the Marshall effect"

gutting is like a plane crash. I didn't ask for the gutted team,and Marshall sure as shit didn't ask for a plane crash, but you gotta play freshmen, and we gotta be able to sign lvl 1's
Even in the NFL, when teams are rebuilding, you have to go with less than stellar players just to make a team. see KC.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
You guys see the poll questions?

What say you?

Me, I am not a fan of global combined reshuffling. I would be good with the following:

1) Reshuffle by country only. I signed up as a new team back when you were given the choice, in season 2. I chose the more difficult path of starting in USA A, versus AA or AAA in another country/region. I don't want to be moved out of region just to be in a higher tier. If my club isn't one of the 96 best in the USA, then I'll stay where I am until I prove it is.

2) Simply increase the promotions/relegations to 2 up, 4 down. This is by far the simplest to implement - although it won't completely deal with the gutting issue in a given season, it WILL handle it within two seasons of a team gutting.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
You guys see the poll questions?

What say you?

Me, I am not a fan of global combined reshuffling. I would be good with the following:

1) Reshuffle by country only. I signed up as a new team back when you were given the choice, in season 2. I chose the more difficult path of starting in USA A, versus AA or AAA in another country/region. I don't want to be moved out of region just to be in a higher tier. If my club isn't one of the 96 best in the USA, then I'll stay where I am until I prove it is.

2) Simply increase the promotions/relegations to 2 up, 4 down. This is by far the simplest to implement - although it won't completely deal with the gutting issue in a given season, it WILL handle it within two seasons of a team gutting.


I agree about the reshuffle by country only. I signed up as an US team back when I could pick (and I went as high a league as was available.) I will not accept being moved to another country because my team "isn't good enough."

The problem with the 2 up, 4 down seems to me that we are just dumping the crappy teams slowly down the system and it could take several seasons for them be down to where they can compete. I say send all the non-competitive teams down to a group of new leagues set up for the purpose next season and promote as many teams from below as are required.

I'd also like the leagues to be setup like the NFL - 16 team conferences really aren't as much fun.

T
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Good point on #2. True gutted teams should be dropped right to the bottom. I guess that is where my first page idea of doing it comes into play.

I also think it'd be fun to have an NFL type setup. Maybe 15 teams (3 divisions of 5), and a schedule set up like the NFL.

2 against division (8 games)
4 against teams in the other two divisions - 2 against your equivalent place team from the previous season, and 2 others to be determined (random?).
4 games against teams in the other conference - 3 against your equivalent place teams from the previous season, and 1 random.

It may not sound nice to those of us with good teams, but it sure would promote parity, wouldn't it? It's worked for the NFL.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 07:52:45
 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
I agree, reshuffle by country only. The only reason we didnt bitch as much as we probably had the right to do is because we got a USA team. USA is where USA football is played, and beign the champion of any other region, IMO, is a dubious honor. You have the option to choose the region you want when you buy a team, if you want to play in USA, I suppose you just have to wait longer.

I think they need to promote and relegate more. If our team had been relegated with the others, there would have been what? six teams brought up from A#5? and they could have been competitive, maybe not chamion-eque, but definitly more competitive than 189-0 blowouts.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
not to mention, again, I would be really disinterested in GLB if I was running a team getting abused like this - unless I was intentionally running a slow-build farm team which by its actual goal is to get killed but produce amazing young talent.

My defensive tackle is on a farm team.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
I voted like islander1. Reshuffle by region, increase promotion/relegation rate.

 
kenmoody
offline
Link
 
Agreed, voted to increase promotion/relegation. But the polls are not looking favorable now. I'm guessing there are a lot of good teams hoping they get shuffled into the USA, because I cant imagine any USA teams being OK with leaving, unless maybe they are BBB.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kenmoody
Agreed, voted to increase promotion/relegation. But the polls are not looking favorable now. I'm guessing there are a lot of good teams hoping they get shuffled into the USA, because I cant imagine any USA teams being OK with leaving, unless maybe they are BBB.


all the PRO/AAA teams that gravy trained in new areas because they didn't want to have to work their way up the USA ranks now all want a free pass back in ahead of us.

Asses.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.