User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
There is no range set, its all default


this is your problem. If you are confident that your kicker can make a 60 yard field goal, then set it accordingly at the top of the top of your AI.

What happened to you may (or may not) be a bug, but you shouldn't leave these things to chance.

Although it's admittedly odd that the game, down 2 with one play left, would not go for the field goal, the only logical explanation is that the game decided the probability of your kicker kicking the 54 yarder was really low.

Stupid AI call, but you set yourself up to fail by trusting the AI to make this decision. Take control of the game.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Vilita

There is no range set, its all default


this is your problem. If you are confident that your kicker can make a 60 yard field goal, then set it accordingly at the top of the top of your AI.

What happened to you may (or may not) be a bug, but you shouldn't leave these things to chance.

Although it's admittedly odd that the game, down 2 with one play left, would not go for the field goal, the only logical explanation is that the game decided the probability of your kicker kicking the 54 yarder was really low.

Stupid AI call, but you set yourself up to fail by trusting the AI to make this decision. Take control of the game.


Vilita,

Best way to avoid this in my opinion if you want to use the auto-range calculator.

In late situations where you want a FG, extend the range by using "within 5 yards of fg range" or "within 10 yards of FG range" on an input, with the output being 100% kick the FG.

Its a quick and easy fix to solve the issue -- just make sure you set it up for specific situations -- extend your kicker's range at the end of the half and the end of the game where a FG would make a difference.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1

What happened to you may (or may not) be a bug, but you shouldn't leave these things to chance.

Although it's admittedly odd that the game, down 2 with one play left, would not go for the field goal, the only logical explanation is that the game decided the probability of your kicker kicking the 54 yarder was really low.



Exactly. I don't need suggestions how to fix it anymore, I read the beginning of this thread and already dealt with it, but I'm still wondering why the hell the AI would be punting the ball in this situation to begin with, as there is nothing set that tells it to punt the ball in this situation.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by islander1


What happened to you may (or may not) be a bug, but you shouldn't leave these things to chance.

Although it's admittedly odd that the game, down 2 with one play left, would not go for the field goal, the only logical explanation is that the game decided the probability of your kicker kicking the 54 yarder was really low.



Exactly. I don't need suggestions how to fix it anymore, I read the beginning of this thread and already dealt with it, but I'm still wondering why the hell the AI would be punting the ball in this situation to begin with, as there is nothing set that tells it to punt the ball in this situation.


Yes there is...you were out of FG range and the matching input/output for that specific situation, yards and time and down, was to punt the ball. It isn't the SIM that has the error - the error was in your AI settings -- could have simply been the order you have them in, or the specifics of one input vs. another.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by islander1


What happened to you may (or may not) be a bug, but you shouldn't leave these things to chance.

Although it's admittedly odd that the game, down 2 with one play left, would not go for the field goal, the only logical explanation is that the game decided the probability of your kicker kicking the 54 yarder was really low.



Exactly. I don't need suggestions how to fix it anymore, I read the beginning of this thread and already dealt with it, but I'm still wondering why the hell the AI would be punting the ball in this situation to begin with, as there is nothing set that tells it to punt the ball in this situation.


Probably the same reason the AI in a game in season 3 with 1st and goal from the 3 and 32 seconds left automatically kicked a field goal rather then - I dunno, throw a pass or two?

Then the ensuing kickoff followed by 3 passing plays in 9 seconds (magic) resulted in the other team kicking a 56 yard field goal and still beating us.

The game AI is just dumb at times. It's kinda why I have it all configured from start to finish. If my team makes a mistake now, it's either the players failing, or my AI being dumb

Either way, I take the default AI offensively out of the equation.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Ironically, a team my CB is on had this situation occur today.

4th and 10 from their own 46 with 20 seconds left in the game down by 1 point.

and they punt?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=160574&mode=pbp

I really cannot grasp the concept of how this occurs unless someone has "Always follow my AI" checked and they have they AI set to "Always punt on 4th down"
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
You know there actually isn't a whole lot wrong with the standard AI, especially on offense. If people don't want to put the time and effort in to creating a complete offensive AI they should just use that. Then they'd kick Field Goals when they're supposed to at least. Really you are blaming the wrong thing here though. While you could make the case that the Offensive AI is tricky and counter-intuitive you still can't shout "BUG" for every failure of the end user.

In short, if you want to do the simple things right, use the simple AI. If you want to micromanage as much of your teams play calling as possible then you need to be complete. It's no-one's fault but your own if you are not, plenty of other people manage it.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
If somebody who does not have "Use my AI at all times" Checked is punting down by 1 with 20 seconds to go in the game, something is wrong.

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
If somebody who does not have "Use my AI at all times" Checked is punting down by 1 with 20 seconds to go in the game, something is wrong.



All that button means is that it will use your AI, even when there is no matching input/output.

You can't blame the SIM if you have a matching input/output that yields a result you don't like -- you can adjust your AI to fix the problem, and the only place you should point a finger is at yourself...
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
You can't have it both ways. When the AI was making all of it's own decisions in the early seasons people were having fits at what it was deciding to do. Now that you can tell it what to do but you don't and it doesn't decide to help you anymore people are apparently still complaining. The "Use my AI at all times" checkbox is designed to fill in blanks where there is no matching input at all, not even a general input.

In your specific example, it would only be a bug if *both* "Use my AI at all times" is unchecked and there are Zero inputs to deal with a situation. This person obviously does have an input being called here and it's to punt the ball. He should put in an override or use simple AI. After all, it's his team, the onus is on him, not Bort or anyone, to ensure it's tactics are functioning correctly insofar as that is possible. This guy obviously isn't doing that and if you fail to prepare, prepare to fail.

As I say, I'd probably support a post in the suggestions forum calling for a revamp of how the AI is presented but the Bugs forum is already cluttered without adding to it incorrectly.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
I'm not even talking about my AI anymore, so I'm not point the finger at myself.

Regardless of the reason, there should be no situation where a punt of the ball takes place down by one score or less in the final minute of the game.

I really don't think people should be subjecting to have to test every single yard line to find the 2 yards that a punt is triggered instead of a go-for-it just to avoid the ai making a bonehead move like that that no one would ever say if they were actually able to manage the game play by play.

Not everyone is going to sit there and chalk up 150,000 AI scenarios and they should be required to do so and run as many tests to avoid punting the ball away in such situations...
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Um. It takes 5 inputs for my team to cover every eventuality...

Or I could just turn off the Advanced AI. No-one is holding a gun to my head, or yours, or the owner of the team your cb is on either. It's not that hard to fix but if he can't be bothered then justice is served if he loses and a team that prepared better and tried harder wins. Should we all cry you a river at the increased likelihood of a just sporting result occurring on the internet?

edit: by "every eventuality" I mean what specific plays my AI calls and when, based on field position and time remaining, in any game where my team isn't winning with a score diff of between 0 and -14.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 15:05:32
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Its no a question of feasibility, its a question of realism.

Not everyone understands the game to a point where they can look at the events they have set and understand every possible scenario that can be covered by them. The game should know that with less than a minute to go in the game, unless there is a specific event that says

"With 60 seconds to go, down 1 point, 4 the down, 100% punt"

then the user does not want to punt. Its lunacy to suggest otherwise. It should "default" to something else if there is no specific event to cover it.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
I agree, but it is still not a bug. As I said, if this was on the suggestions forum I'd be posting in support of you.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.