User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
Originally posted by shield.bearer

Originally posted by datongw


Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.


What? How do you expect a CB to look into the eyes of a WR while he's running stride for stride right next to him? lol

It's called faceguarding, and in the NFL it is illegal.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
First, the fake in this case appeared to be a short pass to the CB's man, and then he threw later to him deep. The CB, if fooled, would definitely have stopped.

Secondly, man coverage still works too well compared to zones. Do you want to see no zone defense ever played? I still think zones need improvement and tight man coverage should, if anything, be nerfed even more (but balanced with better zone coverage), because most CB's can't get away in real life with tight man coverage often.


I agree with you except when you say tight man coverage should be nerfed. Tight man coverage is pretty realistic right now IMO. Zone coverage just needs to be a LOT better to bring it into the same realm as man.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
dots with cone vision l0l
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
Originally posted by shield.bearer

Originally posted by datongw


Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.


Good point, not necessarily 'looking into his eyes' but the idea is the same. A CB in M2M is following his reciever, if the WRs hands go up to make a catch, so does the DBs, but until that point, the DB is watching the WR ONLY. How can a DB in M2M cover the WR and watch the QB to be pump faked at the same time? Not possible.

Ken1 sais:
"First, the fake in this case appeared to be a short pass to the CB's man, and then he threw later to him deep. The CB, if fooled, would definitely have stopped."

If you believe that, I have a bridge for sale.
CB covers the WR, WR is running, CB is running, WR keeps running, CB stops running? I dont think so.

Next.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
Originally posted by shield.bearer

Originally posted by datongw


Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.


The defender wants to know what his man is going to do. He doesn't know the man is running a streak. It could easily have been a hitch, and that's how he reacted.

Tight man coverage should be hard to pull off. That's why real life teams use zones as much as they do, that's why there are shells for most man coverages, and that's why much of the time in real life they don't play tight.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot
Give me one good reason why a CB would bite on a pump fake and move towards that part of the field and just leave the WR to keep streaking down the field?

CBs wouldnt do that, Ive never seen it once in my life.
Maybe we need a stupidity attribute??

If the WR is running a go-route, the CBs not even looking at the QB to begin with. The WR didnt even give a move he was runnign straight down the field lol

I dont understand it, for a lack of a better term its just stupid.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187718&pbp_id=880386


Aside from everything else said in the thread, the main issue I have with these pump fakes, is that the pump fake triggers upon the actual release of the ball. The guys in coverage don't stop until the ball is actually thrown, and they stop for a good second or two while the ball is in the air, so they have no chance to even think about recovering. Instead they're standing there watching the ball go to the guy they were covering. If it was actually a pump fake, the coverage guys would slow down (not stop on a dime) about a second before the ball is released, and only for a split second before going back to covering their guy. If they're looking at the QB to see the fake, they'll see that it was a fake very quickly and get going again, not stand there for 2 seconds to say, "Ohhhhh, you... good one, haha, you got me," while his man scores a TD.

In our scrimmage today, our CB's must've been "pump faked" 15 times, and our corners are quite good for a 21 capped team.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Pump fake is much more effective against zone defense than man defense. I'm not saying it doesn't work against man defense, sometimes CBs will sneak a look at the QB, but that's really pretty rare, and most of the time it doesn't. A pump fake in M2M can help fool the safety who is playing deep zone, but not going to fool the CB playing man underneath.

Head fakes by the receiver is much more effective in M2M coverage than pump fake.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
Originally posted by shield.bearer

Originally posted by datongw


Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.

And good WR's know this and use it to their advantage when faking the Hitch. Watch a game or two this weekend and I promise you'll see a M2M CB bite on a pumpfake.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by cosmoxl

Originally posted by shield.bearer


Originally posted by datongw



Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.

And good WR's know this and use it to their advantage when faking the Hitch. Watch a game or two this weekend and I promise you'll see a M2M CB bite on a pumpfake.


That called good head fake, not pump fake.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by cosmoxl

Originally posted by shield.bearer


Originally posted by datongw



Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.

And good WR's know this and use it to their advantage when faking the Hitch. Watch a game or two this weekend and I promise you'll see a M2M CB bite on a pumpfake.


you're right - usually a WR has to go along with a pump fake by faking a hitch.
 
d1sregard
offline
Link
 
Hi. Football.

QBs pump fake to confuse safeties and spying LBs, not corner backs playing man-to-man. It can also be effective against zone schemes.

Bye. Fail.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by d1sregard
Hi. Football.

QBs pump fake to confuse safeties and spying LBs, not corner backs playing man-to-man. It can also be effective against zone schemes.

Bye. Fail.


+1, well said, thank you.

We need more input from football players, not arm chair quarterbacks.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by d1sregard
Hi. Football.

QBs pump fake to confuse safeties and spying LBs, not corner backs playing man-to-man. It can also be effective against zone schemes.

Bye. Fail.


Yea, seems thats a point people are sorely overlooking here. CBs in man2man coverage arent looking at the QB enough to be pump-faked...It just doesn't happen...They sometimes sneak a peek, but even then the QBs either not looking, or can't pump-fake him before he stops looking.

CBs in m2m should not be suceptible to pump-fakes, ever. Its called MAN to MAN for a reason, 'not man 2 QB'.

You can tell this Ken dude is lobbying hard for WRs cuz he even thinks the man2man coverage should be nerfed. Geeze you'd make a great politician man! lol
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot
Give me one good reason why a CB would bite on a pump fake and move towards that part of the field and just leave the WR to keep streaking down the field?

CBs wouldnt do that, Ive never seen it once in my life.
Maybe we need a stupidity attribute??

If the WR is running a go-route, the CBs not even looking at the QB to begin with. The WR didnt even give a move he was runnign straight down the field lol

I dont understand it, for a lack of a better term its just stupid.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187718&pbp_id=880386


clearly bit on it because he was expecting an out, then was hoping his safety would help over top
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Also remember that not all fakes are pump fakes. The WR's have head fakes and jukes they can use as well.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.