Depends if the sim is hardcoded to use floats, or can be converted fairly painlessly to use integers. If it's the latter, then I wouldn't mind a script being created to merge the decimals with the training bars, and the code for leveling to use the bars instead of decimals. If it's the former, then it's not important.
Forum > Suggestions > percentages in training bars should be included in sim calculations
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by G33
Depends if the sim is hardcoded to use floats, or can be converted fairly painlessly to use integers. If it's the latter, then I wouldn't mind a script being created to merge the decimals with the training bars, and the code for leveling to use the bars instead of decimals. If it's the former, then it's not important.
just to note it:
i'm not advocating that the sim become integer-based... i just want the training bar percentages to be included in sim calculations like skill fractions are.
Depends if the sim is hardcoded to use floats, or can be converted fairly painlessly to use integers. If it's the latter, then I wouldn't mind a script being created to merge the decimals with the training bars, and the code for leveling to use the bars instead of decimals. If it's the former, then it's not important.
just to note it:
i'm not advocating that the sim become integer-based... i just want the training bar percentages to be included in sim calculations like skill fractions are.
Cuivienen
offline
offline
I still think pushing decimals into the bars, but not making the percentages count would make the new training system a much more involving and dynamic system.
Currently, most people train one or two skills all season. Making the above change would make people pay attention to what they are training all season, instead of picking a skill or two at the start of the season.
Currently, most people train one or two skills all season. Making the above change would make people pay attention to what they are training all season, instead of picking a skill or two at the start of the season.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cuivienen
I still think pushing decimals into the bars, but not making the percentages count would make the new training system a much more involving and dynamic system.
Currently, most people train one or two skills all season. Making the above change would make people pay attention to what they are training all season, instead of picking a skill or two at the start of the season.
perhaps... but then the effects of training would become increasingly staggered and inefficient. plus, the effect of automatic leveling points would be incredibly delayed (e.g. HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills).
also, there's the whole issue of "stray percentages rotting in the training bars"... which is starting to become my catchphrase.
I still think pushing decimals into the bars, but not making the percentages count would make the new training system a much more involving and dynamic system.
Currently, most people train one or two skills all season. Making the above change would make people pay attention to what they are training all season, instead of picking a skill or two at the start of the season.
perhaps... but then the effects of training would become increasingly staggered and inefficient. plus, the effect of automatic leveling points would be incredibly delayed (e.g. HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills).
also, there's the whole issue of "stray percentages rotting in the training bars"... which is starting to become my catchphrase.
Cuivienen
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catullus 16
perhaps... but then the effects of training would become increasingly staggered and inefficient. plus, the effect of automatic leveling points would be incredibly delayed (e.g. HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills).
also, there's the whole issue of "stray percentages rotting in the training bars"... which is starting to become my catchphrase.
That's exactly my point though. Without that inefficiency/delay/inconvenience to the player, the training system remains one dimensional. You put it best, but left something out:
"HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills" - yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low.
Anyway, to take that example, do you really think 80.2 is much different from 80.36? I hardly see implementing something like this seriously screwing existing players over. There is essentially zero change to how they currently play in the match engine.
perhaps... but then the effects of training would become increasingly staggered and inefficient. plus, the effect of automatic leveling points would be incredibly delayed (e.g. HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills).
also, there's the whole issue of "stray percentages rotting in the training bars"... which is starting to become my catchphrase.
That's exactly my point though. Without that inefficiency/delay/inconvenience to the player, the training system remains one dimensional. You put it best, but left something out:
"HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills" - yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low.
Anyway, to take that example, do you really think 80.2 is much different from 80.36? I hardly see implementing something like this seriously screwing existing players over. There is essentially zero change to how they currently play in the match engine.
Cuivienen
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cuivienen
yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low
BTW, let me add that that is exactly the kind of thing a slow/power builder would do, which would make something like this one of the first things in GLB that actually advantages regular builders over slow/power builders.
yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low
BTW, let me add that that is exactly the kind of thing a slow/power builder would do, which would make something like this one of the first things in GLB that actually advantages regular builders over slow/power builders.
Tito716
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Originally posted by Cuivienen
yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low
BTW, let me add that that is exactly the kind of thing a slow/power builder would do, which would make something like this one of the first things in GLB that actually advantages regular builders over slow/power builders.
How would that be different from the old system?
The old system certainly didn't benefit tradional builders
Originally posted by Cuivienen
yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low
BTW, let me add that that is exactly the kind of thing a slow/power builder would do, which would make something like this one of the first things in GLB that actually advantages regular builders over slow/power builders.
How would that be different from the old system?
The old system certainly didn't benefit tradional builders
Cuivienen
offline
offline
In the old system, fractions counted. In this system, fractions don't.
You have to train a high fraction at a low return to get to the next integer if you want it to count.
Slow/power builders don't like to do things that have a low return.
You have to train a high fraction at a low return to get to the next integer if you want it to count.
Slow/power builders don't like to do things that have a low return.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cuivienen
That's exactly my point though. Without that inefficiency/delay/inconvenience to the player, the training system remains one dimensional. You put it best, but left something out:
"HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills" - yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low.
Anyway, to take that example, do you really think 80.2 is much different from 80.36? I hardly see implementing something like this seriously screwing existing players over. There is essentially zero change to how they currently play in the match engine.Originally posted by Cuivienen
BTW, let me add that that is exactly the kind of thing a slow/power builder would do, which would make something like this one of the first things in GLB that actually advantages regular builders over slow/power builders.
most likely you would indeed be training your major skills (with a few notable exceptions)... but once you get a player past the mid-levels, it will become increasingly difficult to capitalize on stray leveling bumps.
no, there's not much difference between 80.2 and 80.36, but there is an appreciable difference between 10.0 and 10.99 or 10.99 and 11 (depending on what system is in play).
personally, the current system makes it easier to time the softcaps (not that big of a concern anyway), so i don't see it as privileging spreadbuilders over slowbuilders.
That's exactly my point though. Without that inefficiency/delay/inconvenience to the player, the training system remains one dimensional. You put it best, but left something out:
"HB/WR/LB/CBs would have to wait six levels before they see the benefit of automatic leveling points to their major skills" - yes, if they steadfastly refused to train that skill because the training percentage is low.
Anyway, to take that example, do you really think 80.2 is much different from 80.36? I hardly see implementing something like this seriously screwing existing players over. There is essentially zero change to how they currently play in the match engine.Originally posted by Cuivienen
BTW, let me add that that is exactly the kind of thing a slow/power builder would do, which would make something like this one of the first things in GLB that actually advantages regular builders over slow/power builders.
most likely you would indeed be training your major skills (with a few notable exceptions)... but once you get a player past the mid-levels, it will become increasingly difficult to capitalize on stray leveling bumps.
no, there's not much difference between 80.2 and 80.36, but there is an appreciable difference between 10.0 and 10.99 or 10.99 and 11 (depending on what system is in play).
personally, the current system makes it easier to time the softcaps (not that big of a concern anyway), so i don't see it as privileging spreadbuilders over slowbuilders.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Slow/power builders don't like to do things that have a low return.
depends. for example: if you can hit the 3:1 by L6 (possible with a maxrolled C/K/P), it's worth it instead to train away on your primary skill regardless of return. in fact, since that skill will have been maxrolled, it will indeed be your worst return. okay, i'm shutting up now.
ETA: and yes, i realize that a slowtrained C/K/P can hit the 3:1 much prior to L6, but i'm talking about a traditional d0L4 slowbuilt C/K/P.
Slow/power builders don't like to do things that have a low return.
depends. for example: if you can hit the 3:1 by L6 (possible with a maxrolled C/K/P), it's worth it instead to train away on your primary skill regardless of return. in fact, since that skill will have been maxrolled, it will indeed be your worst return. okay, i'm shutting up now.
ETA: and yes, i realize that a slowtrained C/K/P can hit the 3:1 much prior to L6, but i'm talking about a traditional d0L4 slowbuilt C/K/P.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 01:12:34
Thystle Missile
offline
offline
This needs to happen. I also posted a thread to address this exact problem. We have 2 systems right now. It should be one or the other.
Plus, all skills would be whole numbers, which would look a lot cleaner and easier to evaluate when recruiting.
Anyone who disagrees now will see the problem first hand after a couple of weeks of training and leveling up. Then, they'll change their mind once they realize they have to spend a days training something that only needs 2% to finish, which means they will have a huge % chunk carried over that can't be used unless they train that skill all the way again, which they might not want to do anymore for what ever reason. But if the level up bonus are added to the training bars, then you can top off that 2% with the next level up instead of a whole days training.
Plus, all skills would be whole numbers, which would look a lot cleaner and easier to evaluate when recruiting.
Anyone who disagrees now will see the problem first hand after a couple of weeks of training and leveling up. Then, they'll change their mind once they realize they have to spend a days training something that only needs 2% to finish, which means they will have a huge % chunk carried over that can't be used unless they train that skill all the way again, which they might not want to do anymore for what ever reason. But if the level up bonus are added to the training bars, then you can top off that 2% with the next level up instead of a whole days training.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 01:21:35
Cuivienen
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catullus 16
no, there's not much difference between 80.2 and 80.36, but there is an appreciable difference between 10.0 and 10.99 or 10.99 and 11 (depending on what system is in play).
Yes, there is definitely a large difference between 10.00 and 10.99, but training is fast at those low levels too, so it is easy to rectify. As it becomes harder to pop a skill via training, that pop becomes less meaningful.
There is the potential for a very elegant system here really. One of the marks of a good agent will be having a gut feel for when it makes sense to manually pop a skill via training, and when to leave it alone because the return on training is just too low. Those people who are a little OCD and/or have to have the highest SPD/STR/whatever will being training skills that they really shouldn't, and stubborn power builders will not be training skills that they really should.
no, there's not much difference between 80.2 and 80.36, but there is an appreciable difference between 10.0 and 10.99 or 10.99 and 11 (depending on what system is in play).
Yes, there is definitely a large difference between 10.00 and 10.99, but training is fast at those low levels too, so it is easy to rectify. As it becomes harder to pop a skill via training, that pop becomes less meaningful.
There is the potential for a very elegant system here really. One of the marks of a good agent will be having a gut feel for when it makes sense to manually pop a skill via training, and when to leave it alone because the return on training is just too low. Those people who are a little OCD and/or have to have the highest SPD/STR/whatever will being training skills that they really shouldn't, and stubborn power builders will not be training skills that they really should.
Cuivienen
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catullus 16
depends. for example: if you can hit the 3:1 by L6 (possible with a maxrolled C/K/P), it's worth it instead to train away on your primary skill regardless of return. in fact, since that skill will have been maxrolled, it will indeed be your worst return.
I personally wouldn't qualify that as a low return activity.
BTW, is it just me, or does Bort actually encourage power building by dropping the free level up ability increases when you reach certain level plateaus? It should either be flat throughout, or, to actually discourage power building (and I'm just throwing out numbers here), you should get something like the equivalent of 10 normal training sessions split amongst your majors and 5 normal training sessions split amongst your minors when you level up.
That way, your included ability increases at level up would be based on the skill, not your level. The new power build would be a balanced player, which would make power builders heads explode.
depends. for example: if you can hit the 3:1 by L6 (possible with a maxrolled C/K/P), it's worth it instead to train away on your primary skill regardless of return. in fact, since that skill will have been maxrolled, it will indeed be your worst return.
I personally wouldn't qualify that as a low return activity.
BTW, is it just me, or does Bort actually encourage power building by dropping the free level up ability increases when you reach certain level plateaus? It should either be flat throughout, or, to actually discourage power building (and I'm just throwing out numbers here), you should get something like the equivalent of 10 normal training sessions split amongst your majors and 5 normal training sessions split amongst your minors when you level up.
That way, your included ability increases at level up would be based on the skill, not your level. The new power build would be a balanced player, which would make power builders heads explode.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Yes, there is definitely a large difference between 10.00 and 10.99, but training is fast at those low levels too, so it is easy to rectify. As it becomes harder to pop a skill via training, that pop becomes less meaningful.
sure, but then that means you're not training a different skill... and if that delays softcapping by a level, that's an issue. and yes, being -0.01 on a skill isn't a concern for most slowbuilders in the early going, but that just highlights the fact that we're using a constellation of competing strategies to evaluate this.
the point of my original post is that the new integer-based system marks a radical departure from how things worked in the past. it really doesn't matter to me if we stay decimal-based or switch to integer-based... i'm just curious why we have a mishmash of both. honestly, it feels like complexity for the sake of complexity... but then, i have the same questions about why we now have four types of currency (FP/TP/ST/BT) when it seems that two (possibly even just one) type would do.
Yes, there is definitely a large difference between 10.00 and 10.99, but training is fast at those low levels too, so it is easy to rectify. As it becomes harder to pop a skill via training, that pop becomes less meaningful.
sure, but then that means you're not training a different skill... and if that delays softcapping by a level, that's an issue. and yes, being -0.01 on a skill isn't a concern for most slowbuilders in the early going, but that just highlights the fact that we're using a constellation of competing strategies to evaluate this.
the point of my original post is that the new integer-based system marks a radical departure from how things worked in the past. it really doesn't matter to me if we stay decimal-based or switch to integer-based... i'm just curious why we have a mishmash of both. honestly, it feels like complexity for the sake of complexity... but then, i have the same questions about why we now have four types of currency (FP/TP/ST/BT) when it seems that two (possibly even just one) type would do.
Procrustes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cuivienen
I personally wouldn't qualify that as a low return activity.
ah. i thought you meant "low" in a relative sense, not in an absolute sense.
Originally posted by Cuivienen
BTW, is it just me, or does Bort actually encourage power building by dropping the free level up ability increases when you reach certain level plateaus? It should either be flat throughout, or, to actually discourage power building (and I'm just throwing out numbers here), you should get something like the equivalent of 10 normal training sessions split amongst your majors and 5 normal training sessions split amongst your minors when you level up.
That way, your included ability increases at level up would be based on the skill, not your level. The new power build would be a balanced player, which would make power builders heads explode.
indeed... and i feel the same way about how major/minor leveling skills are so unbalanced. WR/OTs are screwed up, and if you have a C/K/P/G/DE you're pretty much forced to slowbuild.
very interesting solution, btw... but until balanced players are rewarded by the sim, targeted builds would remain the best choice.
I personally wouldn't qualify that as a low return activity.
ah. i thought you meant "low" in a relative sense, not in an absolute sense.
Originally posted by Cuivienen
BTW, is it just me, or does Bort actually encourage power building by dropping the free level up ability increases when you reach certain level plateaus? It should either be flat throughout, or, to actually discourage power building (and I'm just throwing out numbers here), you should get something like the equivalent of 10 normal training sessions split amongst your majors and 5 normal training sessions split amongst your minors when you level up.
That way, your included ability increases at level up would be based on the skill, not your level. The new power build would be a balanced player, which would make power builders heads explode.
indeed... and i feel the same way about how major/minor leveling skills are so unbalanced. WR/OTs are screwed up, and if you have a C/K/P/G/DE you're pretty much forced to slowbuild.
very interesting solution, btw... but until balanced players are rewarded by the sim, targeted builds would remain the best choice.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























