User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > TE appearing as WR3 when he`s not down on the depth chart for the position
Page:
 
Iwan Owen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CDZYO
Originally posted by Iwan Owen

I understand how the depth chart works so stop being smartass troll. It was a scrimmage so i arranged it to give everyone even playing time (which i achieved). If you can`t understand how the way i`ve set up my WR`s are perfect for getting them all even playing time in a scrimmage like this then then may i point you in the direction of the newbie section, you might learn a few things. Seriously, have a look at the GM`s on my team and what they`ve achieved and then try and come back to me and tell me we don`t know how to compile a depth chart ffs! My point was that players should not be appearing on the field in positions they are not down on the depth chart for, and i don`t want it to repeat itself in a real game. Is that simple enough for you to understand?!!


Not to put too fine a point on it, but if you can't figure out why, when the only two players on your WR3 depth chart are on the field at WR1 and at WR2, the CPU put someone else in at WR3, then maybe you still have something to learn about how the depth chart works.


Common sense says that the 3 freshest receivers should be put on the pitch in that situation and not a TE which wasn`t even on the DP at that particular position. Why are some people having so much trouble understanding the obvious?

The third choice was in at the WR1 slot with the 2 ahead of him in the DP rested, obviously in that situation (assuming the DP works in a logical way), the freshest of the 2 who wasn`t on the field and was ahead in the WR1 depth chart should have been on the pitch, the WR playing in WR1 should have been in WR2 position, and the one playing WR2 position should have been at WR3. Or does that make too much sense?
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 13:47:56
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iwan Owen
Originally posted by CDZYO

Originally posted by Iwan Owen


I understand how the depth chart works so stop being smartass troll. It was a scrimmage so i arranged it to give everyone even playing time (which i achieved). If you can`t understand how the way i`ve set up my WR`s are perfect for getting them all even playing time in a scrimmage like this then then may i point you in the direction of the newbie section, you might learn a few things. Seriously, have a look at the GM`s on my team and what they`ve achieved and then try and come back to me and tell me we don`t know how to compile a depth chart ffs! My point was that players should not be appearing on the field in positions they are not down on the depth chart for, and i don`t want it to repeat itself in a real game. Is that simple enough for you to understand?!!


Not to put too fine a point on it, but if you can't figure out why, when the only two players on your WR3 depth chart are on the field at WR1 and at WR2, the CPU put someone else in at WR3, then maybe you still have something to learn about how the depth chart works.


Common sense says that the 3 freshest receivers should be put on the pitch in that situation and not a TE which wasn`t even on the DP at that particular position. Why are some people having so much trouble understanding the obvious?

The third choice was in at the WR1 slot with the 2 ahead of him in the DP rested, obviously in that situation (assuming the DP works in a logical way), the freshest of the 2 who wasn`t on the field and was ahead in the WR1 depth chart should have been on the pitch, the WR playing in WR1 should have been in WR2 position, and the one playing WR2 position should have been at WR3. Or does that make too much sense?


You're relying on the game to make a decision for you, rather than make it yourself with readily available options, such as correct usage of the WR depth chart.

No need to get snippy. You're expecting too much out of the sim. If you want to control who goes into that WR3 slot, make sure there is no chance of them already being on the field. It is very simple.

Either learn how the DC works or don't use it. I don't give a fuck what your GMs accomplishments are. Any 12 year old moron can figure out how the DC works. It's really not that hard. Now stop being so butthurt and get a fucking clue. Or not, it's up to you. But claiming to be god's gift when you can't even figure out the simplest thing, depth charts, is a joke.

I was trying to be polite in my initial response. If you can't take criticism without getting a sore ass, you shouldn't post on a publicly viewable forum.

I'll check out the newbie forum for you. Thanks for the advice. Is there a specific thread that covers egotistical morons? I'd really be interested in hearing more about your background. Maybe I can strive to be as brilliant as you one day.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iwan Owen
Common sense says that the 3 freshest receivers should be put on the pitch in that situation and not a TE which wasn`t even on the DP at that particular position. Why are some people having so much trouble understanding the obvious?

The third choice was in at the WR1 slot with the 2 ahead of him in the DP rested, obviously in that situation (assuming the DP works in a logical way), the freshest of the 2 who wasn`t on the field and was ahead in the WR1 depth chart should have been on the pitch, the WR playing in WR1 should have been in WR2 position, and the one playing WR2 position should have been at WR3. Or does that make too much sense?


The logic worked like this: #1 guy on WR1 gets tired and is subbed out. #2 guy on WR1 gets tired and is subbed out, but #1 guy isn't ready to come back in, so #3 guy goes in as WR1. The AI looks in order -- "WR1... okay, I'll take the third guy... WR2... the first guy is too tired, the second guy is already assigned to WR1, so I'll take the third guy... WR3... the first guy is already assigned to WR1, the second guy is already assigned to WR2, and there's no one else on the depth chart, so I'll look to see who else is available." The AI then looks at your roster for an alternate -- "he's too tired... he's too tired... this guy will do."

If the guy who was three-deep on the WR1 was in at WR1 anyway, doesn't that tell you that the two players ahead of him weren't fresh enough to be in on the play? And that the freshest eligible player (the TE) should be the one to go in? Especially if the sub-out # for WR3 isn't lower than what it is for WR1 or WR2?

You can set the WR3 (& WR4) sub-out # to 0, which should force the AI to take a WR instead of the TE, regardless of energy level. If there's a bug, it's that the AI called for a 3-WR set when you only had two ready to go.

"The ultimate guide to offense and defensive depth charts" ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=261893 ) is wrong on how to use the WR1/2/3/4/5 depth chart, but that's what you should expect when the author himself says "to be honest I don't even use them" and "I don't think it is wise to use these as your main means of setting things up, the regular DC accomplishes the same thing just a lot simpler to use."

But maybe you don't want to hear that.

Originally posted by Forbin
I checked, and your DC is all F'd up. Just use the basic WR depth chart. It's a lot easier, if you don't understand how the other one works.


 
Iwan Owen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by Iwan Owen

Originally posted by CDZYO


Originally posted by Iwan Owen



I understand how the depth chart works so stop being smartass troll. It was a scrimmage so i arranged it to give everyone even playing time (which i achieved). If you can`t understand how the way i`ve set up my WR`s are perfect for getting them all even playing time in a scrimmage like this then then may i point you in the direction of the newbie section, you might learn a few things. Seriously, have a look at the GM`s on my team and what they`ve achieved and then try and come back to me and tell me we don`t know how to compile a depth chart ffs! My point was that players should not be appearing on the field in positions they are not down on the depth chart for, and i don`t want it to repeat itself in a real game. Is that simple enough for you to understand?!!


Not to put too fine a point on it, but if you can't figure out why, when the only two players on your WR3 depth chart are on the field at WR1 and at WR2, the CPU put someone else in at WR3, then maybe you still have something to learn about how the depth chart works.


Common sense says that the 3 freshest receivers should be put on the pitch in that situation and not a TE which wasn`t even on the DP at that particular position. Why are some people having so much trouble understanding the obvious?

The third choice was in at the WR1 slot with the 2 ahead of him in the DP rested, obviously in that situation (assuming the DP works in a logical way), the freshest of the 2 who wasn`t on the field and was ahead in the WR1 depth chart should have been on the pitch, the WR playing in WR1 should have been in WR2 position, and the one playing WR2 position should have been at WR3. Or does that make too much sense?


You're relying on the game to make a decision for you, rather than make it yourself with readily available options, such as correct usage of the WR depth chart.

No need to get snippy. You're expecting too much out of the sim. If you want to control who goes into that WR3 slot, make sure there is no chance of them already being on the field. It is very simple.

Either learn how the DC works or don't use it. I don't give a fuck what your GMs accomplishments are. Any 12 year old moron can figure out how the DC works. It's really not that hard. Now stop being so butthurt and get a fucking clue. Or not, it's up to you. But claiming to be god's gift when you can't even figure out the simplest thing, depth charts, is a joke.

I was trying to be polite in my initial response. If you can't take criticism without getting a sore ass, you shouldn't post on a publicly viewable forum.

I'll check out the newbie forum for you. Thanks for the advice. Is there a specific thread that covers egotistical morons? I'd really be interested in hearing more about your background. Maybe I can strive to be as brilliant as you one day.


Talk about bullshit. I never said i was good or `god`s gift`, as you put it. In fact i never bigged myself up at all, just my GM`s. Learn to read, it would have saved you writing 75% of that insignificant crap. Or maybe you just prefer trolling whether you have a point or not, have your fun then....
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iwan Owen
Talk about bullshit. I never said i was good or `god`s gift`, as you put it. In fact i never bigged myself up at all, just my GM`s. Learn to read, it would have saved you writing 75% of that insignificant crap. Or maybe you just prefer trolling whether you have a point or not, have your fun then....


Alright, then. Don't claim to have such awesome GMs if they can't even figure out the damn depth chart. It ain't rocket science, junior.
 
MentalMisfit
offline
Link
 
Your wr's werent rested or it would of put them in. I want your magic wand that lets you see your players in game energy during replays.....

Just add a 3rd wr and you'll be set problem solved its not a bug. if your other wr's where rested it would of put one in instead of a TE. I don't feel like digging threw your replays again i had to watch them all once already to find the 2x it happened. but I'm sure you can find a replay where it had those 2 and another wr at 3rd that wasnt in the depth chart for the 3rd spot.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.