User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Divide Advance Equipment into Departments
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
I think this is a good idea.

Another idea would be to make sure at least one piece out of three is relevent to your class with the other two random.


atleast this I would be ok with.

Because I don't care what kind of comment bort makes, First Step for a punter will NEVER make sense, Throwing for a punter will NEVER make sense, and BIG HIT for a QB will NEVER make sense

 
po
offline
Link
 
Does this piece of equipment makes sense?

Superior Green Cleats
+1 throwing
Catch ball chance +2%
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
I can guarantee you, 100%, that Bort included kicking and punting equipment.

I kept getting it on my linebacker.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by po
Does this piece of equipment makes sense?

Superior Green Cleats
+1 throwing
Catch ball chance +2%


OMG the Qb is going to throw it to him self, LOOK OUT!
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GwennA
I can guarantee you, 100%, that Bort included kicking and punting equipment.

I kept getting it on my linebacker.


damn so now all fg kickers have to be LBs Damn I hate changes.
 
po
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by po

Does this piece of equipment makes sense?

Superior Green Cleats
+1 throwing
Catch ball chance +2%


OMG the Qb is going to throw it to him self, LOOK OUT!


Whats sad is it was for a HB lol.

I am having fun just making level 1s training 3 them 3 times getting 3 tokens and then seeing what I get retire and repeat.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
oh the ol clinton pass to cooley for a TD. I can't wait until those plays are on GLB
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by po
Does this piece of equipment makes sense?

Superior Green Cleats
+1 throwing
Catch ball chance +2%


It makes about as much sense to me as +1 throwing, +1 Big Hit Sa on my HB.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GwennA
Originally posted by po

Does this piece of equipment makes sense?

Superior Green Cleats
+1 throwing
Catch ball chance +2%


It makes about as much sense to me as +1 throwing, +1 Big Hit Sa on my HB.


Originally posted by bort
Big hit helps break tackles for when rushing


 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
They should all be at least semi-relevant to your position.

So giving First Step to a QB, while not all that useful, would be reasonable. Or, say, any of the LB SA's (like Aura, Diving Tackle, Monster Hit) to a CB. Not one of the first things you think of, but they could be useful at times.

But giving a QB (or any offensive player) Big Hit or a punter First Step is a complete waste.

I tried it with a WR and everything was a bonus to making tackles. After that, I thought it was a bug and haven't used it since (but expected to be fixed).

Again, not everything had to be bonuses to catching or to usual SA's. Give a WR Lower The Shoulder or Cover Up and it's not optimal but still has some relevance.

With it costing 10 tokens for custom eq upgrades, if this is functioning as intended and isn't changed, then any reasonable tradeoff isn't there and I'll just use Intense training exclusively.

Equipment should be at least somewhat relevant to one's position. A "bad" eq offering should simply have its bonuses in a spot you don't prefer for that player, rather than completely useless to the player.
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
They should all be at least semi-relevant to your position.

So giving First Step to a QB, while not all that useful, would be reasonable. Or, say, any of the LB SA's (like Aura, Diving Tackle, Monster Hit) to a CB. Not one of the first things you think of, but they could be useful at times.

But giving a QB (or any offensive player) Big Hit or a punter First Step is a complete waste.

I tried it with a WR and everything was a bonus to making tackles. After that, I thought it was a bug and haven't used it since (but expected to be fixed).

Again, not everything had to be bonuses to catching or to usual SA's. Give a WR Lower The Shoulder or Cover Up and it's not optimal but still has some relevance.

With it costing 10 tokens for custom eq upgrades, if this is functioning as intended and isn't changed, then any reasonable tradeoff isn't there and I'll just use Intense training exclusively.

Equipment should be at least somewhat relevant to one's position. A "bad" eq offering should simply have its bonuses in a spot you don't prefer for that player, rather than completely useless to the player.


By and large I agree with you. I admit that I have a WR where I'd /love/ to get lower the shoulder or the like, so I do see that as relevant.
but in many cases, I just don't see some of the bonuses being that helpful.

What is particularly painful is getting a /great/ item for a player its useless for, and having no real option but to skip past one of the fairly rare really nice items.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GwennA
Originally posted by Ken1

They should all be at least semi-relevant to your position.

So giving First Step to a QB, while not all that useful, would be reasonable. Or, say, any of the LB SA's (like Aura, Diving Tackle, Monster Hit) to a CB. Not one of the first things you think of, but they could be useful at times.

But giving a QB (or any offensive player) Big Hit or a punter First Step is a complete waste.

I tried it with a WR and everything was a bonus to making tackles. After that, I thought it was a bug and haven't used it since (but expected to be fixed).

Again, not everything had to be bonuses to catching or to usual SA's. Give a WR Lower The Shoulder or Cover Up and it's not optimal but still has some relevance.

With it costing 10 tokens for custom eq upgrades, if this is functioning as intended and isn't changed, then any reasonable tradeoff isn't there and I'll just use Intense training exclusively.

Equipment should be at least somewhat relevant to one's position. A "bad" eq offering should simply have its bonuses in a spot you don't prefer for that player, rather than completely useless to the player.


By and large I agree with you. I admit that I have a WR where I'd /love/ to get lower the shoulder or the like, so I do see that as relevant.
but in many cases, I just don't see some of the bonuses being that helpful.

What is particularly painful is getting a /great/ item for a player its useless for, and having no real option but to skip past one of the fairly rare really nice items.


My point was that Lower the Shoulder is fine for a WR, as it's not the first thing you think of but has some relevance; but "+X% to making a tackle" isn't.
 
kjayb51
offline
Link
 
I agree..sort em out bort
 
Aanidar
offline
Link
 
I think the point it is at is at least close to what Bort has intended (though saying this implies I'm a mind reader??? oh well.).

I don't believe the point is to get the best piece of equipment with only 3 days of tokens built up. I think the whole point is to make you save up shopping tokens and money until you have enough to dig through quite a few refreshes and get one piece of equipment, and then you work on upgrading that piece of equipment. Then, perhaps, do it again with a second piece.

I know Bort has stated in other threads that you can theoretically get four pieces of advanced equipment all with SA and attribute bonuses fully upgraded - or sets, this I think is what will really be worth going after - but the math shown to upgrade four pieces of equipment is rediculous.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
bump this back up
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.