Originally posted by GwennA
Originally posted by Ken1
They should all be at least semi-relevant to your position.
So giving First Step to a QB, while not all that useful, would be reasonable. Or, say, any of the LB SA's (like Aura, Diving Tackle, Monster Hit) to a CB. Not one of the first things you think of, but they could be useful at times.
But giving a QB (or any offensive player) Big Hit or a punter First Step is a complete waste.
I tried it with a WR and everything was a bonus to making tackles. After that, I thought it was a bug and haven't used it since (but expected to be fixed).
Again, not everything had to be bonuses to catching or to usual SA's. Give a WR Lower The Shoulder or Cover Up and it's not optimal but still has some relevance.
With it costing 10 tokens for custom eq upgrades, if this is functioning as intended and isn't changed, then any reasonable tradeoff isn't there and I'll just use Intense training exclusively.
Equipment should be at least somewhat relevant to one's position. A "bad" eq offering should simply have its bonuses in a spot you don't prefer for that player, rather than completely useless to the player.
By and large I agree with you. I admit that I have a WR where I'd /love/ to get lower the shoulder or the like, so I do see that as relevant.
but in many cases, I just don't see some of the bonuses being that helpful.
What is particularly painful is getting a /great/ item for a player its useless for, and having no real option but to skip past one of the fairly rare really nice items.
My point was that Lower the Shoulder is fine for a WR, as it's not the first thing you think of but has some relevance; but "+X% to making a tackle" isn't.