User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbryan
I will receive my degree in Economics in December. I think it is a good/bad idea for the government to bail these companies out. On one hand it really helps out the companies such as AIG and Merrill Lynch. These companies got themselves into this problem with risky creditors and they were just trying to make quick money. If these financial institutions fail then it all falls back onto the taxpayers, because that is where the government money comes from. I don't want public corporations to think it is "OK" to be so risky because the Government will bail you out if you mess up. Lehman Bros. had its hands in way too many risky investments for the government to help out. As far as Freddie and Fannie go, they had to be bailed out because 1. over half of all housing mortgages are through these companies and 2. the government pretty much set them up to fail, by lowering there capital/liabilities ratio to only 2%. That is insanely low. just my 4 cents



So it was a necessary evil. thats what I am thinking. In terms of fairness, it is not fair that some companies flopped. But the gov can;t be expected to cover everyone. So they chose the ones that weren't the biggest liability and were the least stupid with their investments.

Least stupid...kinda like who to vote for this election. But that is a ball of wax that I am not going to go into. All I will say is look at the VPs...because for 2 different reasons...the VPs will probably be the ones running the coountry within the next couple years.
 
Spazz
offline
Link
 
My job will always be secured. Everyone needs air conditioning in Texas.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
^^ I almost went to Lincoln Tech for ac/heating repair.
 
jbryan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
Originally posted by jbryan

I will receive my degree in Economics in December. I think it is a good/bad idea for the government to bail these companies out. On one hand it really helps out the companies such as AIG and Merrill Lynch. These companies got themselves into this problem with risky creditors and they were just trying to make quick money. If these financial institutions fail then it all falls back onto the taxpayers, because that is where the government money comes from. I don't want public corporations to think it is "OK" to be so risky because the Government will bail you out if you mess up. Lehman Bros. had its hands in way too many risky investments for the government to help out. As far as Freddie and Fannie go, they had to be bailed out because 1. over half of all housing mortgages are through these companies and 2. the government pretty much set them up to fail, by lowering there capital/liabilities ratio to only 2%. That is insanely low. just my 4 cents



So it was a necessary evil. thats what I am thinking. In terms of fairness, it is not fair that some companies flopped. But the gov can;t be expected to cover everyone. So they chose the ones that weren't the biggest liability and were the least stupid with their investments.

Least stupid...kinda like who to vote for this election. But that is a ball of wax that I am not going to go into. All I will say is look at the VPs...because for 2 different reasons...the VPs will probably be the ones running the coountry within the next couple years.


Yes pretty much exactly. It is kind of like the Gov. should not step in, but the hand that is helping them up is the same one holding them down. If that makes and sense.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
^^ you mean that if the GOV keeps bailing them out (hold them up) then they will continue to be stupid with their risky investing (keeping them down)?
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
Look, when it affects the public, the govt HAS to step in. Change the word BANK with AIRLINES. How would you feel if the govt didnt bail out airliners every so often and they no longer existed in the US. Every so often, the govt has to do something
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cptafw163
^^ you mean that if the GOV keeps bailing them out (hold them up) then they will continue to be stupid with their risky investing (keeping them down)?


Think this will be a one time thing in a unique economic period in our lifetime. I can still see everything possibly crashing years from now as well even with the Gov't assistance. We live in a time where most people were not fiscally responsible and its time to pay the piper. This goes for the Blue Collar worker, to the corporate executive, all the way to the top with the Government... Financially this country is on the brink of exploding, I think this might end up like stopping an artery gash with a band-aid
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
I am thinking the same thing. With interest rates at an all time low, people think they can affoard anything. So more long term loans:

For example:

A PFC making 1500 per month pre tax comes back from deployment and buys a brand new shelby cobra for 55K making a 5K down payment and gets a 5.7% loan for 6 years.

If interest rates were like what they were in the 80s, no one would ever get a 6 year loan for that much money.

Also, a single CPT buys an 85K corvette. He makes 4,500 per month pre tax (without housing allowance which is dependent on location) and buys the vehicle and has to pay 750 per month for the loan. After rent and bills (utilities, phone insurance etc), then the loan he ends up only having 300 to play around with per month.

It sucks that people are so hung up on bling nowadays. But you aren't fooling anyone when you own a corvette and then when you are out drinking with your buddies, you notice the person with the corvette never buys rounds. Or they break out a calculator when it comes time to split the bill ad leave a shitty tip that someone who drives a 96 dodge ram has to cover for.
 
GP1
offline
Link
 
You guys are looking at the extreme. I live in NYC. 1 BR room is 1600 a month, a 1 family house is about 1,000,000. Where do you want people to live? They have to live somewhere. But these prices are outrageous. A lot of these defaults are simply due to the state of things..
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GP1
You guys are looking at the extreme. I live in NYC. 1 BR room is 1600 a month, a 1 family house is about 1,000,000. Where do you want people to live? They have to live somewhere. But these prices are outrageous. A lot of these defaults are simply due to the state of things..


YOure right, i gess higher interest rates would just drive inflation through the roof with the housing market. Building supplies being at an all time high doesn't help either.

ABout the car thing, i was stating how society is skewed to getting fancy cars, rather than saving for homes. A 2007 corvette doesn't work when you live in a matchbox.

Then again, i can't talk because i bought a harley after my first deployment. I was single and always wanted one. But now that i have a wife and kids i don't buy aything for myself...unless its fishing gear. But my wife doesn't omplain because she likes seafood.

Gp, i am from NJ (Ft Lee area), so I know how crazy the market is in the northeast near the city.
 
sjg006
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbryan
Originally posted by cptafw163

Originally posted by jbryan


I will receive my degree in Economics in December. I think it is a good/bad idea for the government to bail these companies out. On one hand it really helps out the companies such as AIG and Merrill Lynch. These companies got themselves into this problem with risky creditors and they were just trying to make quick money. If these financial institutions fail then it all falls back onto the taxpayers, because that is where the government money comes from. I don't want public corporations to think it is "OK" to be so risky because the Government will bail you out if you mess up. Lehman Bros. had its hands in way too many risky investments for the government to help out. As far as Freddie and Fannie go, they had to be bailed out because 1. over half of all housing mortgages are through these companies and 2. the government pretty much set them up to fail, by lowering there capital/liabilities ratio to only 2%. That is insanely low. just my 4 cents



So it was a necessary evil. thats what I am thinking. In terms of fairness, it is not fair that some companies flopped. But the gov can;t be expected to cover everyone. So they chose the ones that weren't the biggest liability and were the least stupid with their investments.

Least stupid...kinda like who to vote for this election. But that is a ball of wax that I am not going to go into. All I will say is look at the VPs...because for 2 different reasons...the VPs will probably be the ones running the coountry within the next couple years.


Yes pretty much exactly. It is kind of like the Gov. should not step in, but the hand that is helping them up is the same one holding them down. If that makes and sense.


The government bears a lot of responsibility with regards to mortgages, but the companies affected didn't argue against what the gov wanted either. Both decided that it was a swell idea to give out home loans to credit risks, but it was the responsibility of fannie mae and freddie mac to protect themselves by hedging against rising interest rates. They chose not to do so because they knew their lobbyists had the influence to have the Fed step in and save them. Privatized profits and socialized losses are an unacceptable and unsustainable way to run the economy.


Originally posted by GP1
Look, when it affects the public, the govt HAS to step in. Change the word BANK with AIRLINES. How would you feel if the govt didnt bail out airliners every so often and they no longer existed in the US. Every so often, the govt has to do something


That entirely depends. The real issue is does government intervention have a more positive effect than not intervening. The government is funded by taxpayers and by the government buying up these assets every taxpayer in the country is being forced to buy them. What is worse overall: a recession or an additional 2500 in debt to your name. Also how will this impact future market behavior? Will firms in the future continue to look for government aid with the slogan "we're just too big to fail". Will additional government regulations decrease market efficiencies and increase deadweight loss? By no means does the gov have to do anything. The same airlines might not have been operating now, but we certainly would have had some companies step in.

The airlines are in fact a perfect example. People stopped wanting to fly after 9/11, but it was clear to anyone things would eventually return to normal. If the airlines didn't have the money to wait that period out tough luck. A few would have gone under and a few would have remained servicing the market that was left. As more people felt comfortable flying and the demand went back up new and old firms would pick up the slack by entering the market and those that survived would increase their capacities. Sure a few might be foreign owned the next time around and the people working at the airlines that went under would have to get new jobs, but is that worth having every taxpayer in America fork over money to keep the airlines afloat? I'm willing to bet very few people looked at the actual economic considerations.

To me it keeps coming back to politicians looking out for their job security, making a great show of what their doing to save everyone from disaster, and the firms that run to the waiting arms of the politicians had a war chest built for them. Sure, they'll keep that company afloat and donating to the campaign and we'll make a great show of things to the public about how we secured their future. It worries me how few people are interested in the long term health of the economy and how many people will do anything to look good during an election year.
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Good points S..... Read an interesting article in the USA Today how our Govt. did exactly what we preached not to do to Russia, China, Japan and other markets that were in severe trouble... Gist of it was the US's message was to let the market correct itself instead of forced correction leading to further problems in the end, and this is exactly what our Gov't did here. I obviously do not have the economic knowledge to make any educated assumptions on what should be done, but found the article interesting nonetheless.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
^^ I couldn't agree more sjg. People will say anything to be elected. Obama has a good campaign going. "Change" but i guarantee when he steps into office he won't change a damn thing his first term...then say "I have been working on it, i will get it complete in my second term." just so he can be elected again.

Hence why he votes "present" for every controvertial law. He just wants to look good to the public and not offend either side so he can get votes.

About the war thing, A pres has to petition congress to go to war AND TO GET OUT OF WAR. I bet if Pres Bush called congress' bluff and stood on the floor and said "I would like every available air force assset ready to go so we can get all our troops out of Iraq in 6 months." COngress would say "Wait a minute...i have constituents making a lot of money with the war...like the company in Natick mass that makes the armor for humvees...and all the civilians over in iraq adding necessary communications infrastructure, etc...they will not have the protection of US troops."

It makes me sick that congress is using getting out of iraq as the platform, when we will still be there even if Obama is in office for 8 years.

And don;t worry about having to pay higher taxes...Pres Bush made the 27% cap on taxes LAW until mid 2012. So Obama is gonna have to find other ways to fund all his grand ideas for change...like socialist healthcare. I am in hte army, and Tricare is socalized healthcare. Yet, i keep getting bills sent to my house when they should not have billed me. Luckily i can take off work to go nto the tricare office to fix that, but someone working a shift at the factory will get screwed because he has to take off work to fix the mess.

And the US economy will never fail. We have too many things that the rest of the world wants. Yeah our dollar will go down, but people still want US goods. So thats not a problem. I cannot foresee the US becoming a third world country.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 19:20:56
 
jbryan
offline
Link
 
These are all excellent points. I am glad that there are rational people out in this world that understand that out economic structure is in trouble. There are several ways to fix it, but none overnight. Some say the housing slump won't stop sliding until 2010! Who knows? I know that the U.S. will get through this though. Mistakes made in the present are ones we need to stay away from in the future. The dollar is going up, and oil is going down, but there is always something wrong in the economy.
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
The bad thing is that I wanted an honest leader to become president after GW...but we need a businessman. Running a counry is a lot like running a business.

I think i have lost faith in the coming of an honest leader who can become the president, and not a politician that is enjoying the glamour of being in office. Thats why I am not voting. Nothing really good to choose from. I think Obama will win, but some people say that there is too much "good old faishoned" racism in hte country, that even some democrats will not vote for obama (not saying they will vote for McCain, but they either won't vote for obama, or not vote at all).

If you like country economics...take a look at brazil. They are a member of OPEC and can sustain all their energy needs without importing anything. Albeit, most of their cars run on straight ethanol (have been for decades) but brazil has the sugar cane to make it. We can't grow sugarcane. Otherwise all US cars would be running on E-85. But in brazil, its straight ethanol...so you can get wasted off it

I haven't done much research about brazil, but it has really sparked my interest. Especially since i am in language school to learn portuguese and my 3 teachers teachers are from brazil.

I think the economy will fix itself, but not without some changes. The bad thing is....if we limit big businesses...that takes away from the freedom that has made our county oo great. But I have to admit, the power these companies have is too big for our country to handle right now. If a company gets so big and powerful, that its fall can ruin our country's economic state, then its actually a threat to national security.

When nostrdamus spoke of "the giant falling" which will spark the armageddon...maybe he was talking about a bank, and not a nation.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.