User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Eliminate skills decimals
Page:
 
yabo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Angry Beavers
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by GenoBong


Originally posted by ShamsTron



You still get decimals from your minor/major skills at level up.


I think the most elegant solution here is to put whatever decimal % you have, into the "training progress bar". As you level and get major/minor increases, the relative decimal values would go into the bar as well.

e.g. if I'm getting .25 per level for a skill, I'd get a 25% increase in the progress bar.


I thought of doing that, actually, but I'm kinda 50/50 since it doesn't really matter that much.

I figured somebody's OCD would pop up and suggest this.



YES! Please take these out!!! Drives me nuts to look at decimals that don't have an impact anymore. Can we just round these either up or down, depending? Or a equivalent measurement on the training bar?

PLEASE please PLEASE!


adding them onto the bar would be cool. or you could just round them to .5 since during level up would take care of this.
Last edited Sep 14, 2008 00:18:24
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GenoBong
Originally posted by ShamsTron

You still get decimals from your minor/major skills at level up.


I think the most elegant solution here is to put whatever decimal % you have, into the "training progress bar". As you level and get major/minor increases, the relative decimal values would go into the bar as well.

e.g. if I'm getting .25 per level for a skill, I'd get a 25% increase in the progress bar.


I like this too. It would unify things, make it all cleaner and more consistent.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GenoBong

Originally posted by ShamsTron


You still get decimals from your minor/major skills at level up.


I think the most elegant solution here is to put whatever decimal % you have, into the "training progress bar". As you level and get major/minor increases, the relative decimal values would go into the bar as well.

e.g. if I'm getting .25 per level for a skill, I'd get a 25% increase in the progress bar.


I thought of doing that, actually, but I'm kinda 50/50 since it doesn't really matter that much.

I figured somebody's OCD would pop up and suggest this.


Yeah OCD or not, though, it would definitely look more "clean", and perhaps give somebody cause to train a skill they might normally not train if they were close to the 100% mark.

I'm not sure about the code, but it might make sims and stuff run faster if they were using integers only (if you wanted to go that route, as well).

Last edited Sep 14, 2008 00:17:06
 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
The game uses the decimals so I'd prefer to keep them in the skill instead of the progress bar.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DiMo28
The game uses the decimals so I'd prefer to keep them in the skill instead of the progress bar.


Yeah. Plus I'd imagine maybe somebody could write a greasemonkey script to take away the decimals if it's that big of a deal.
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
I'd say it makes better sense and is easier for newer folks to understand if you round the decimal into the training bar.

It kind of sucks that you may not level a skill for awhile though and see the benefit from it right away. However, I think it's a better flow on the system if training, and leveling up use the same system to advance skills, not having one add to a training bar, and one add to the raw skill.

 
Cylon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DiMo28
The game uses the decimals so I'd prefer to keep them in the skill instead of the progress bar.


I also like it because visually it makes builds look a little less similar. Also when I reach the attribute cap I like getting that extra tenths or hundredths of an attribute before it cost me more SP to increase it.

Under the old system it was also a way of seeing who was training what on the team. Under this new system I won't know until they have the +1 but that's nothing major.

 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I'd want to get rid of the decimals. I've been striving with my nightly training to do away with them on my own.
 
chad19r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I'd want to get rid of the decimals. I've been striving with my nightly training to do away with them on my own.


+1 , I would like them either rounded up/down or put in the skill bar also, definitly makes for a cleaner look to it with whole numbers.
 
hovard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chad19r
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

I'd want to get rid of the decimals. I've been striving with my nightly training to do away with them on my own.


+1 , I would like them either rounded up/down or put in the skill bar also, definitly makes for a cleaner look to it with whole numbers.


+1 My OCD demands that this is done...
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GenoBong

Originally posted by ShamsTron


You still get decimals from your minor/major skills at level up.


I think the most elegant solution here is to put whatever decimal % you have, into the "training progress bar". As you level and get major/minor increases, the relative decimal values would go into the bar as well.

e.g. if I'm getting .25 per level for a skill, I'd get a 25% increase in the progress bar.


I thought of doing that, actually, but I'm kinda 50/50 since it doesn't really matter that much.

I figured somebody's OCD would pop up and suggest this.


You're 50/50 about giving people credit for stuff they've been training but couldn't cap..? Bort, serious question, do you care about your customers at all? I mean, seriously, this should be an easy choice.
Last edited Sep 14, 2008 05:57:25
 
Nat Belmont
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thepigmarcher
Looking over the proposed changes , doesn't this now render the decimal points in attributes as useless. I would assume someone has already picked up on this (I didn't manage to read the 1500+ posts in the original thread).

Perhaps when the change over is completed the odd .?? in attributes could be added to the new progress bar so they aren't lost , just in case , that hadn't been thought of.

Not the biggest issue , admittedly


I dunno about the decimals being useless. I know decimals make a difference to the scouting bars. See my 2 level 17 guards below, they have identical builds but one has .4 more strength and .2 more blocking, his scouting bars are higher.

He also had better stats last season, but since he's playing RG and the very slightly worse one is playing LG, I can't really say that confirms anything. I suspect the decimals are actually used in the game calculations though.

I will agree that it'd be nice to convert the decimal to training %, though, at least for the sake of having nice round numbers for stats

Guards:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=476495
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=483767
 
thepigmarcher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nat Belmont

I dunno about the decimals being useless. I know decimals make a difference to the scouting bars. See my 2 level 17 guards below, they have identical builds but one has .4 more strength and .2 more blocking, his scouting bars are higher.



Perhaps useless was the wrong word , but apart from the part point increases on levelling up (which I obviously forgot about) then there is no other way of building them , so it does seem a bit redundant having them now.

As I said , not a major issue and it's comforting to know that I'm not the only one with OCD tendencies .

Last edited Sep 14, 2008 06:35:59
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
Instead of rounding up or down, make it so the decimal filter it's way through the meter bar
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
I kind of like the idea of just putting level ups in the % bars...kind of fixes the issue of getting %s sort of stuck/leftover when you are training a combo and one levels and then you move to another combo
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.