User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
My whole team went on power for three games. Way too many missed tackles with a whopping one forced fumble. Put it back on wrap up, problem solved and ironically we forced more fumbles.

Definitely not working.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
My whole team went on power for three games. Way too many missed tackles with a whopping one forced fumble. Put it back on wrap up, problem solved and ironically we forced more fumbles.

Definitely not working.


I'm not convinced, until someone tells me they have players with higher than 50/60 tackling and strength. That just doesn't cut it.

Would you build a speedster WR to have 50 speed at level 30? Nope. Shouldn't expect the same from LBs, and yes I do realize how many attributes are required to properly build a good LB. Gotta sacrifice somewhere though. You can't have a 70 speed, 50 agility LB forcing fumbles left and right. At least, not at only level 30.

I don't think there are any established teams with the proper builds to test power tackling. You guys are all using season 3 builds, albeit modified during season 4...It may just not be enough.
 
ColorChAnGe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by thehazyone

My whole team went on power for three games. Way too many missed tackles with a whopping one forced fumble. Put it back on wrap up, problem solved and ironically we forced more fumbles.

Definitely not working.


I'm not convinced, until someone tells me they have players with higher than 50/60 tackling and strength. That just doesn't cut it.

Would you build a speedster WR to have 50 speed at level 30? Nope. Shouldn't expect the same from LBs, and yes I do realize how many attributes are required to properly build a good LB. Gotta sacrifice somewhere though. You can't have a 70 speed, 50 agility LB forcing fumbles left and right. At least, not at only level 30.

I don't think there are any established teams with the proper builds to test power tackling. You guys are all using season 3 builds, albeit modified during season 4...It may just not be enough.


best example of how power tackling sucks ass my dt 86 strength 51 tackling, and ill add 52 agility for anyone who wants to blame it on that played on power every game made 0 forced fumbles all season
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=169543&playoffs=0
and hes no slouch lvl wise, power tackling just made him miss a ridiculous amount of tackles
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
26 tackles, and 9 missed tackles?


How many fumbles do you think you should force in 35 ATTEMPTS?


DTs don't get many tackles, generally. Especially NTs, in season 4. What we need is an MLB built with strength and tackling, or an MLB type build playing out of position at LOLB.
 
ColorChAnGe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
26 tackles, and 9 missed tackles?


How many fumbles do you think you should force in 35 ATTEMPTS?


DTs don't get many tackles, generally. Especially NTs, in season 4. What we need is an MLB built with strength and tackling, or an MLB type build playing out of position at LOLB.


for 85 strength i think more then 0..but ur right wit the fact nts didnt get many tackles in season 4 but thats a whole other issue entirely-_-
Last edited Sep 13, 2008 02:01:44
 
Link
 
It's probably working and giving like a 10% greater chance to fumble. But when your player has like a 2% chance to force a fumble, improving to 2.2% isn't going to show up in most stats.

 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
It's probably working and giving like a 10% greater chance to fumble. But when your player has like a 2% chance to force a fumble, improving to 2.2% isn't going to show up in most stats.



This is something I figured was the root of the issue... and when going to power tackling means 4 or 5x's as many of your tackling attempts are failures and get no shot at forcing a fumble because they've failed to land the tackle, the amount of fumbles you cause actually goes down.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm
Originally posted by fallingmercury

It's probably working and giving like a 10% greater chance to fumble. But when your player has like a 2% chance to force a fumble, improving to 2.2% isn't going to show up in most stats.



This is something I figured was the root of the issue... and when going to power tackling means 4 or 5x's as many of your tackling attempts are failures and get no shot at forcing a fumble because they've failed to land the tackle, the amount of fumbles you cause actually goes down.


Depends on if it's the actual finalized tackle that leads to a fumble check, or if the fumble check happens at the beginning of contact. No way to tell.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Forbin


And all of these tests were done with a player beyond the 2nd cap on both strength and tackling, correct?


3 defensive tackles, all 50+ tackling. One was 60 modded, our starting NT.
2 linebackers both a bit over 50 tackling and strength - with similar speed and agility as players in the secondary who, on wrap-up were causing three times the amount of forced fumbles.

Moreover, when we reverted back to wrap-up, coincidence or not, the forced fumbles came back.

Then again, you wouldn't know anything about players over level 25, would you now?


I'm not exactly sure what that has to do with anything. Oddly enough, it seems I do know a bit, and probably more than some jackass that's got 4 players and goes running his fucking yap when someone makes a perfectly innocent comment and interrupts the whiny little bitchfest going on.

Please, carry on with your crying, and continue with your "high" attributes of 50 and 60. Don't let my civil posting hamper your bitching and moaning.


Yeah, because your previous post was in such a civil tone. Right...sure, you know plenty. In your own little pea-brained mind. I believe the carrying on belongs to you, as several owners with higher level players thus far seem to agree.

Last edited Sep 13, 2008 08:05:46
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
26 tackles, and 9 missed tackles?


How many fumbles do you think you should force in 35 ATTEMPTS?


DTs don't get many tackles, generally. Especially NTs, in season 4. What we need is an MLB built with strength and tackling, or an MLB type build playing out of position at LOLB.


Those two linebackers I tested with? Yep, my own linebacker - who split time at all threee positions the past season, and Lino Pino, the primary LOLB.

Also note that Pino had 11 forced fumbles. 9 came after the 7 game experiment ( It's more realistic to say 7 games, as we did this in the pre-season scrimmages as well).

Then we reverted to wrap up - and he forced 9 fumbles the rest of the way.
Last edited Sep 13, 2008 08:01:40
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by thehazyone

My whole team went on power for three games. Way too many missed tackles with a whopping one forced fumble. Put it back on wrap up, problem solved and ironically we forced more fumbles.

Definitely not working.


I'm not convinced, until someone tells me they have players with higher than 50/60 tackling and strength. That just doesn't cut it.

Would you build a speedster WR to have 50 speed at level 30? Nope. Shouldn't expect the same from LBs, and yes I do realize how many attributes are required to properly build a good LB. Gotta sacrifice somewhere though. You can't have a 70 speed, 50 agility LB forcing fumbles left and right. At least, not at only level 30.

I don't think there are any established teams with the proper builds to test power tackling. You guys are all using season 3 builds, albeit modified during season 4...It may just not be enough.


Every player on my DL has numbers higher than 50/60 tackling and strength and three of my six LB's do as well. My team was 16-0 and our average level is over 29, so I think we're pretty well established and not every team follows the same cookie cutter builds... I know for a fact we have some very non-standard builds on our team (for example, we don't have one single WR with over 80 speed and you'd be hard pressed to find a team that is our level who can say that).

But keep deluding yourself into thinking it's working.
Last edited Sep 13, 2008 08:52:49
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Ratphlegm

Originally posted by fallingmercury


It's probably working and giving like a 10% greater chance to fumble. But when your player has like a 2% chance to force a fumble, improving to 2.2% isn't going to show up in most stats.



This is something I figured was the root of the issue... and when going to power tackling means 4 or 5x's as many of your tackling attempts are failures and get no shot at forcing a fumble because they've failed to land the tackle, the amount of fumbles you cause actually goes down.


Depends on if it's the actual finalized tackle that leads to a fumble check, or if the fumble check happens at the beginning of contact. No way to tell.


I suppose it's not concrete evidence, but every time a fumble happens, the player that had the ball and the plyer that caused the fumble both "go down"... they stop moving at least until someone else picks up the ball. I'm grasping at straws though as to why wrap up seems to cause more fumbles.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
It is still messed up.

Fumbles are so rare (in real life as well as GLB) that what's needed is something like Wrap-Up cutting the chance of a fumble to 10% of normal, with Power doubling fumble chances, before it would ever be worth going to Power.

Bort might have raised Wrap-Up's fumble penalty from, say, 20% to 40%, while decreasing its bonus on making tackles from, say, 20% to 10% (and maybe something like the reverse for Power). But because the missed vs. made tackle question comes up so much more often than a fumble chance, the 4-1 ratio still isn't enough to make it worth going off Wrap-Up.

And there really shouldn't be one style that dominates all others, even if its bonus has been lessened so that breaking tackles is now possible vs. Wrap-Up (unlike Season 3).
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Forbin

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by Forbin



And all of these tests were done with a player beyond the 2nd cap on both strength and tackling, correct?


3 defensive tackles, all 50+ tackling. One was 60 modded, our starting NT.
2 linebackers both a bit over 50 tackling and strength - with similar speed and agility as players in the secondary who, on wrap-up were causing three times the amount of forced fumbles.

Moreover, when we reverted back to wrap-up, coincidence or not, the forced fumbles came back.

Then again, you wouldn't know anything about players over level 25, would you now?


I'm not exactly sure what that has to do with anything. Oddly enough, it seems I do know a bit, and probably more than some jackass that's got 4 players and goes running his fucking yap when someone makes a perfectly innocent comment and interrupts the whiny little bitchfest going on.

Please, carry on with your crying, and continue with your "high" attributes of 50 and 60. Don't let my civil posting hamper your bitching and moaning.


Yeah, because your previous post was in such a civil tone. Right...sure, you know plenty. In your own little pea-brained mind. I believe the carrying on belongs to you, as several owners with higher level players thus far seem to agree.



I posed a question in direct conflict with the lack of evidence that had been posted thus far in the thread. I never claimed to know one way or the other whether or not power tackling was broken or not. I was simply putting forth a query to balance the discussion, and to hopefully come to a more concrete conclusion.

If all people post is "OMG IT R BROKEZ! HALP! FIX IT WTF!", and provide zero evidence or attribute totals to back up their claims, you really think people should just take your word for it?

I'm sorry that you felt I did not post in a civil tone, and felt it was necessary to retort with a jab at my experience. I was simply posing a question to deepen this discussion, rather than allow it to remain one-sided.


Ultimately, nobody knows for certain why wrap up seems to cause more fumbles. It's quite possibly a major issue with power tackling, but there are multiple factors and variables involved in such an equation.

People need to stop getting so fucking butthurt when someone posts something in direct opposition to their beliefs. It's called a discussion, people.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
tell them forbin tell them
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.