User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > The Truth - Open your mind and then your eyes.
Page:
 
mHart20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scottjameson123
God i love how this guy is telling us to do our own research from clearly biased sources


It's his way of saying that he doesn't care about everybody else's opinion.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by redsoxrule124245

even ignoring that answer the other questions if one guy on the list clearly is false how can you be sure that the others are true? Again Why Were Lewinsky and Tripp allowed to speak instead of being killed or paid off? Also can you really take a video that was published by a disgruntled former employee who has flip flopped his opinion on clinton numerous times at face value?


There is no comeback to this. Unlike crap posted by extremism websites and journalists that have never published a type-printed article, this has the backbone of common sense and logic. A small minority of people in this world tune out all semblance of reason and agree to anything that substantiates their misguided and perverse view of the world. Perhaps it may be neurosis. But he'll never get it. It's like arguing with inanimate objects: they never get it either. But inanimate objects are better off: at least there is no conscious choice to disregard reason.

 
Scott_Jameson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mHart20
Originally posted by scottjameson123

God i love how this guy is telling us to do our own research from clearly biased sources


It's his way of saying that he doesn't care about everybody else's opinion.


he doesnt use rogerian argumentation and therefore cannot be taken seriously
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scottjameson123
Originally posted by mHart20

Originally posted by scottjameson123


God i love how this guy is telling us to do our own research from clearly biased sources


It's his way of saying that he doesn't care about everybody else's opinion.


he doesnt use rogerian argumentation and therefore cannot be taken seriously


Cha-ching!
WINNER!
/Thread.
 
DedJVE
offline
Link
 
All sources are "biased." The sooner you realize that the better.
 
Scott_Jameson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JimVenice
All sources are "biased." The sooner you realize that the better.


but he needs to present both sides of the argument amd not just try to shove his beliefs down the throats of others
 
DedJVE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scottjameson123
Originally posted by JimVenice

All sources are "biased." The sooner you realize that the better.


but he needs to present both sides of the argument amd not just try to shove his beliefs down the throats of others


Why do you say "shoving." He's not shoving anything. You either agree and you make comments. You don't agree and you make counter arguments or you just forget everything you see here and go back to posting in some other thread,


Pretty easy.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JimVenice
Originally posted by scottjameson123

Originally posted by JimVenice


All sources are "biased." The sooner you realize that the better.


but he needs to present both sides of the argument amd not just try to shove his beliefs down the throats of others


Why do you say "shoving." He's not shoving anything. You either agree and you make comments. You don't agree and you make counter arguments or you just forget everything you see here and go back to posting in some other thread,


Pretty easy.


There's a big difference in "this is plausible, let's debate its merits" and "let me find every fringe website that tangentially supports my view and fail to answer with a logical response to any rational counterargument".

 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Merry strange foreign Christmas, JV!
Last edited Dec 25, 2008 01:47:10
 
ChicagoBlitz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scottjameson123
Originally posted by mHart20

Originally posted by scottjameson123


God i love how this guy is telling us to do our own research from clearly biased sources


It's his way of saying that he doesn't care about everybody else's opinion.


he doesnt use rogerian argumentation and therefore cannot be taken seriously


Ive scanned through pages of this thread and followed it off and on for months. I've seen news articles posted and comments made by the OP and have seen more insults and ridicule than discussion/argumentation coming from the target audience. Im not convinced Rogerian Argumentation would work against a crowd that is already hostile to the material being presented.

I dont know enough about all of the things he claims or the articles he presents claim but seldom have I seen any real concerted effort by most of the responders that would lead me to believe that Rogerian Argumentation would be successful in this particular case.

The nature of some, certainly not all, of material already has a fringe "conspiracy" tag labeled on it i.e. 9/11 so that for the most part the target audience is already generated walls towards what the OP is saying. Personal beliefs that have been shaped by their own experiences and understandings of the events that have taken place. Just because the majority in this particular thread appear to be against Sulfs positions, it doesnt necessarily mean what he is saying is false out right. I've watched many of the videos from page 1 over the past 3-4 years and there are some eye openers and some duds. Ultimately its up to the individual to make up their own minds as to the validity of the subject material being viewed.

I think the idea of consolidating the stuff down into small segments for discussion where both parties have a clear understanding of the specific topic would be a good start but I don't see that as a viable option due to the outward hostility on both sides.

What is not particularly helpful is the constant traffic of individuals intent on derailing the discussion, though that is to be expected in the free-for-all forums.

I think Sulf creating a channel is win win for both sides of the kanundrum.
 
DedJVE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Merry strange foreign Christmas, JV!


Thanks Kretchypoo


and also I agree with ChicagoBlitz.
 
ChicagoBlitz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scottjameson123
Originally posted by JimVenice

All sources are "biased." The sooner you realize that the better.


but he needs to present both sides of the argument amd not just try to shove his beliefs down the throats of others


Why would Sulf have to present both sides of an argument? You think he should debate and argue with himself?
He has posted a lot of information, some from very main stream and reputable sources, some from obscure and fringe sites.
As JV just said, it seems to me that if there is something that someone doesnt agree with, its on them to provide that other side of the argument for arguments sake.

0_o
Last edited Dec 25, 2008 01:54:43
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoBlitz
Originally posted by scottjameson123

Originally posted by mHart20


Originally posted by scottjameson123



God i love how this guy is telling us to do our own research from clearly biased sources


It's his way of saying that he doesn't care about everybody else's opinion.


he doesnt use rogerian argumentation and therefore cannot be taken seriously


Ive scanned through pages of this thread and followed it off and on for months. I've seen news articles posted and comments made by the OP and have seen more insults and ridicule than discussion/argumentation coming from the target audience. Im not convinced Rogerian Argumentation would work against a crowd that is already hostile to the material being presented.

I dont know enough about all of the things he claims or the articles he presents claim but seldom have I seen any real concerted effort by most of the responders that would lead me to believe that Rogerian Argumentation would be successful in this particular case.

The nature of some, certainly not all, of material already has a fringe "conspiracy" tag labeled on it i.e. 9/11 so that for the most part the target audience is already generated walls towards what the OP is saying. Personal beliefs that have been shaped by their own experiences and understandings of the events that have taken place. Just because the majority in this particular thread appear to be against Sulfs positions, it doesnt necessarily mean what he is saying is false out right. I've watched many of the videos from page 1 over the past 3-4 years and there are some eye openers and some duds. Ultimately its up to the individual to make up their own minds as to the validity of the subject material being viewed.

I think the idea of consolidating the stuff down into small segments for discussion where both parties have a clear understanding of the specific topic would be a good start but I don't see that as a viable option due to the outward hostility on both sides.

What is not particularly helpful is the constant traffic of individuals intent on derailing the discussion, though that is to be expected in the free-for-all forums.

I think Sulf creating a channel is win win for both sides of the kanundrum.


If only Sulfidias would respond in such a cogent manner, now.

I do try to give the writers Sulfidas quotes a fair shake. I really do. I Google them, search their biographies when available, and even read some of their works with as open a mind as I can possibly have. However, I'm gravely disappointed when I see that the author has never published a type-printed article, or that the author's name comes back with less than 1,000 Google hits, or when the author doesn't cite to any other sources outside the fringe/conspiracy website from which he writes/is employed.

Typical argument:
Sulfidas: Clinton Chronicles prove that Clinton is a big-time drug trafficker who kills everyone who disagrees with him.
RedSox: Well, why were Jones/Lewinsky/Tripp not killed and allowed to speak?
Sulfidas: You got that from Snopes, Snopes is a joke, Clinton's a murderer.
 
DedJVE
offline
Link
 
I tend to think Snopes is bullshit too, but for my own set of reasons.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JimVenice
I tend to think Snopes is bullshit too, but for my own set of reasons.


I've had personal correspondence with the kind lady who owns the website. I do know for a fact that the information Snopes publishes is scrutinized more than one might at first think. I couldn't get a rumor confirmed true (the cause for Dr. Atkins' [of Atkins Diet fame] death) moved from "questionable" to "true" with three sources (including one British medical journal) to back me up. It was frustrating, but I move on.

If I may inquire, what are your reasons?

Last edited Dec 25, 2008 02:02:42
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.