User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
New players will catch up to vets when the vets start to decline. That's the way it was always going to be and the only reasonable option.

The new "perk system" would widen the gap between players 31 and over and those below that point, but once the new players hit 31 they would be gaining prestige exp faster and the gap would begin to shrink a bit again.

If higher level players don't have the chance to gain new abilities they will likely start quitting. Gaining 1-2 attribute points every 8 days isn't going to keep people interested. If you insist on new players having the ability to catch veterans people will start to quit en mass. The tiered leagues and sportmanship penalties are there to adjust for disparity.
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 10:15:18
 
jackATTACK55
offline
Link
 
i like the idea
 
Canadaleaf
offline
Link
 
Excellent idea
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
You've also squashed any discussion of the original idea because no one will be willing to sort through a dozen pages of you whining. Thanks. I've lost all respect for you for the tactics you've employed here. You've essentially filibustered the thread to your own ends.


QFT

Drifter, maybe you can convince Bort to sticky a new thread on this topic. You could, in the first post, list ideas you find at least worthy of coinsideration as VA's (not filtering out all that you don't like, just removing duplicates or any that are silly), and GG can be given a warning that he will lose his posting privileges if he doesn't stay out of the thread.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Or just edit the first post, put what Bort said in there, put a note to skip to page 19, 20, or wherever we are at that time, and keep that first post updated.

And it's not against the rules for GG or anyone to voice his opinion on something, as long as it doesn't go into spam-levels (which in this case, it's getting close to).

Bort asked for ideas of SA's for this idea, so people should post some and discuss them. Continue
 
shawndme7
offline
Link
 
What about as the hysical skills decline--then the other skills like Confidence and Vision improve?

Might be an easier fix
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Anarcho...

The other flaws...

1. If it's the low level team being risen up to the average of the higher team, the higher team will still beat them silly. Maybe it could be BOTH the teams weighed up and averaged and so BOTH teams brought to the same average level.

2. A lot of teams have a bunch of level 25 players in them, but a bunch of level 15s in them. And inside that, a lot of different SA bonuses going on from play to play around speed/vision/tackling etc. There may be some teething problems here in forever tweaking/nerfing SAs due to their effect in the game. Ie, some players are level 10 and have a tree of 5-5-5-5-5 and some may be level 20 with SAs of 1-1-2-2-1. The averaging thing will end up complicated trying to have an average Base attribute effect whilst also trying to balance the SAs. Eg: high SAs with low base can cause wonky things to occur.

3. Basically, easier to re-spec and re-do, as a lot of time ideas tend to band-aid and end up requiring constant nerfings and changes that tip the scale in other areas. Like all of season 4 so far and how tweaking something here ends up creating a big problem/bug somewhere else.



Wow, i was all for some of the other ideas in this thread (another SA tree for vets, prestige levels, etc), but theres no way I would want to play this if we "made everyone equal". This isnt a friggin communist game. What would be the benefit of having a great build, or of keeping up with the training of your player if all it's going to do is be "averaged out" with your opponent? Higher level teams and players SHOULD be winning more often than not! Thats not the problem i see in this game right now.

The biggest problem, aside from minor bugs in the game, is that too many people that play this game want a QUICK fix. Teams go 2-14, and then they quit. Owners sell out way too quickly, never giving the team a chance to develop. One of the teams i play on and GM for was 3-13 their first season. We sucked. We were outlevelled by around 6 or 7 levels at every position. But we decided to tough it through and just keep plugging away, and now we're a much better team for it. The BIGGEST problem in this game IMO are the individuals with thin skin and no patience. Sure there are things in the game that can be made better, and there are lots of great ideas in this thread alone, but "making all teams equal" is NOT something i (or many others) would support.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Ok, well I was trying to think of other perks to add to this idea, and I came up with one. After thinking about it for a while though, I'm not sure if it would be better off as its own separate idea.

Anyway, I was thinking of something along the lines of a "threat level". It would increase your performance very slightly (maybe a boost to vision and confidence?), but it would also increase the amount of attention you receive.

For example, a WR with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to force double coverage on the WR (if they have an extra player to cover), if it doesn't trigger double coverage, the WR gets a slight increase to his attributes for the play.

For QBs, a high "treat level" will trigger the other team to play the pass (unless in an obvious run situation), if it doesn't trigger the pass play, the QB gets an increase in attributes for the play.

For RBs, a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to play the run (unless it is an obvious pass situation), if it doesn't trigger the run play, the RB gets an increase in attributes for the play. Also, the "threat level" could trigger the other team to force a LB to cover the RB on passing plays (a lot of teams don't cover the backs), and if they don't, the RB gets the increase in attributes for the play.

I'm not sure how it could apply to FBs and TEs though since they are often two way players.

On defense, a DE (or DT/NT) with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to force two blockers on the DE (if they have an available lineman/TE/FB/HB to block), if it doesn't trigger the double team, the DE gets a slight increase to his attributes for the play.

A LB with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to pass or run plays away from him, if it doesn't, the LB gets the increase for the play.

A CB/Safety with a high "threat level" will trigger the other team to avoid passing in his direction, if it doesn't trigger, the defensive back gets the increase in attributes for the play.

When I say trigger, I mean that it would work like a SA, more points means it has a higher likelihood to trigger.

These "threat levels" make it so the player has a higher likelihood of getting more attention (or less in the LB/CB/S cases) and thus less stats. It also makes it more likely that if the other team doesn't account for you, you'll perform better on that play. Finally, while the "threat level" puts the attention on you, it also opens up opportunities for other players.

If the WR forces double coverage, it'll help another player get open.

If the DE/DT forces a double team, it'll help another lineman or blitzer get a better shot at the QB or the runner.

Etc., etc.

"Threat level" could also be something that is implemented in a scouting report. That way teams have a way of knowing what they should be doing to account for the player when coming up with AI and gameplans.

Thinking about it though, the "threat level" could just be something entirely separate (maybe even performance based). It's just something off the top of my head.

Either way, great original idea though Drifter.



While the "average level" thing was just an idea I tossed out (I don't actually like it), the "threat level" idea is something I fully endorse. I don't want it to get lost in the off topicity that's taken place. I think it's a good idea and would like to hear opinions on it.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Or just edit the first post, put what Bort said in there, put a note to skip to page 19, 20, or wherever we are at that time, and keep that first post updated.

And it's not against the rules for GG or anyone to voice his opinion on something, as long as it doesn't go into spam-levels (which in this case, it's getting close to).

Bort asked for ideas of SA's for this idea, so people should post some and discuss them. Continue


I'd say he's well over the line of spamming the thread; but anyway, since I've given the best ideas I've thought of so far, I'll simply find and repost them to try to get the thread back on track.

Acceleration: Enhances acceleration (duh). Bort's admitted he should have made it its own attribute, so it could at least be a prestige attribute.

Crease Closer: Improves a DB's performance in zone defenses (effectively a Vision booster, not speed as with Closing Speed, that helps him find receivers in creases before the throw).

Quick Feet: Improves a player's Head Fake and Juke moves at all times, as well as Quick Cuts when running with the ball.

Reliability: Decreases the chance of the player fumbling, dropping a pass, blowing coverage on defense, drawing penalties, and the like.

First Down Marker: Knows where the first down marker is, and if he needs an extra half a yard to get the first down, has a better chance of getting it.

Scat Back: Increases a HB or FB's abilities as a receiver on pass plays (maybe even making him almost...useful). When used as such, he gains a bonus to speed, agility, vision, and catching.

Comeback Kid: Provides a bonus to offensive players' making big plays when behind. This isn't Clutch, as it's when behind by 1 or by 40, and it only applies to big play potential.

So a QB or WR or TE would get bonuses from this, when behind, on long passes (but only long passes), or a HB when in the clear or trying a move or broken tackle that will put him in the clear for a big play.

Special Teamer: Bonuses across the board when playing on special teams as something other than a returner.

Energy Bounceback: When a player isn't in the game, he recovers energy faster (both "breath" and "freshness"). Not the same as Stamina as it doesn't affect how fast it's lost when in the game.

Thick Skin: The player is affected less by intimidation abilities (not the same as Confidence, because it doesn't help a player who, say, just fumbled maintain morale).
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Thanks for reposting since I missed those in that mess.

I wonder if some of those (Quick Feet, for instance) might be a bit too powerful, but I like the rest.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Thanks for reposting since I missed those in that mess.

I wonder if some of those (Quick Feet, for instance) might be a bit too powerful, but I like the rest.


Well, for Quick Feet, keep in mind that one of Drifter's ideas for VA's is basically the opposite, allowing people not to get fooled as easily; so one can counter the other.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
By the way an idea behind both that and "Crease Closer" is partially as a way to help create WR's that can't be covered easily man to man, as well as DB's that are especially good at zone coverage.

The reason for that is clear to me: While Zone coverages have their uses, Man to Man is useful much more often, whereas in real life football their relative usefulness is much more similar. So, one way to help that balance is through VA's.

I'd also suggest that the VA's go from 0 to 100 and have no soft caps nor any diminishing returns. We should encourage people to specialize in a few. In fact, it might be that once you place points in, say, 5 (if there are 20) you can only add to those 5 (or probably about 1/4 of however many there are, but hopefully at least 20 total will exist).
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Well, for Quick Feet, keep in mind that one of Drifter's ideas for VA's is basically the opposite, allowing people not to get fooled as easily; so one can counter the other.


Very true.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
By the way an idea behind both that and "Crease Closer" is partially as a way to help create WR's that can't be covered easily man to man, as well as DB's that are especially good at zone coverage.

The reason for that is clear to me: While Zone coverages have their uses, Man to Man is useful much more often, whereas in real life football their relative usefulness is much more similar. So, one way to help that balance is through VA's.

I'd also suggest that the VA's go from 0 to 100 and have no soft caps nor any diminishing returns. We should encourage people to specialize in a few. In fact, it might be that once you place points in, say, 5 (if there are 20) you can only add to those 5 (or probably about 1/4 of however many there are, but hopefully at least 20 total will exist).


I like the "no softcaps" idea. By level 30 people players have hit a plateu in skills and this would be the ultimate customization of a player's role.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
The biggest problem, aside from minor bugs in the game, is that too many people that play this game want a QUICK fix. Teams go 2-14, and then they quit.


Agree...everyone wants to pwn from day 1, though it's not possible for everyone to always be a winner when you're competing against each other - half of the teams in the game win every "week" and half lose. If everyone played CPU teams, everyone could win, but that would kinda defeat the purpose of the game.

It's just the nature of the beast, though. This isn't really a game for the insta-gratification ultra-impatience crowd.

Now I'm off-topic, though - back to the ideas!
Last edited Aug 27, 2008 14:28:36
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.