User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > About to process compensation package
Page:
 
Link
 
I think it should be all who were on a PLAYOFF roster in season 2 or 3. If someone played 10 games then was traded well before the playoffs, how were they wronged from Dong cheating in the playoffs?

Or someone on a gutted team that Dong never messed with? What is their grievance?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Gturtle



Originally posted by Bort




I dunno, maybe Gturtle's idea is along the right lines (case by case kinda deal)...some people feel slighted while others don't really care.

It is an admin nightmare, though, depending on how many come forward.


I'm beginning to think the ideal case is a pay-out based upon player in the CPL during the last regular season game of Season 2/3. Then using case by case to handle people left scratching their heads saying "You missed me, I was in CPL from Season 3 game 1 to Season 3 game 13"


That might work...would be easy enough to parse out with a script. If I'm going to write a script to do that, though, I could just extend it to parse how many games in CPL each player_id played and just call it "good enough" if it's over X # of games.


Obv. problem with the arbitrary line, maybe 50 FP per game (1000/season divided by 20 games)?


For all 3 seasons? So max of 60 games? That comes out to 3000 per player if they've been CPL for 3 seasons, which is probably more than I gave out with the 40% for some people. Maybe a ceiling of 1000 per guy?


2 Seasons, but yeah a cap is fine I'd say.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Gturtle




Originally posted by Bort





I dunno, maybe Gturtle's idea is along the right lines (case by case kinda deal)...some people feel slighted while others don't really care.

It is an admin nightmare, though, depending on how many come forward.


I'm beginning to think the ideal case is a pay-out based upon player in the CPL during the last regular season game of Season 2/3. Then using case by case to handle people left scratching their heads saying "You missed me, I was in CPL from Season 3 game 1 to Season 3 game 13"


That might work...would be easy enough to parse out with a script. If I'm going to write a script to do that, though, I could just extend it to parse how many games in CPL each player_id played and just call it "good enough" if it's over X # of games.


Obv. problem with the arbitrary line, maybe 50 FP per game (1000/season divided by 20 games)?


For all 3 seasons? So max of 60 games? That comes out to 3000 per player if they've been CPL for 3 seasons, which is probably more than I gave out with the 40% for some people. Maybe a ceiling of 1000 per guy?


2 Seasons, but yeah a cap is fine I'd say.


let's place an arbitrary cap imo. 1500.53 flex points is the cap. The .53 is there to remind people for all eternity.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Gturtle




Originally posted by Bort





I dunno, maybe Gturtle's idea is along the right lines (case by case kinda deal)...some people feel slighted while others don't really care.

It is an admin nightmare, though, depending on how many come forward.


I'm beginning to think the ideal case is a pay-out based upon player in the CPL during the last regular season game of Season 2/3. Then using case by case to handle people left scratching their heads saying "You missed me, I was in CPL from Season 3 game 1 to Season 3 game 13"


That might work...would be easy enough to parse out with a script. If I'm going to write a script to do that, though, I could just extend it to parse how many games in CPL each player_id played and just call it "good enough" if it's over X # of games.


Obv. problem with the arbitrary line, maybe 50 FP per game (1000/season divided by 20 games)?


For all 3 seasons? So max of 60 games? That comes out to 3000 per player if they've been CPL for 3 seasons, which is probably more than I gave out with the 40% for some people. Maybe a ceiling of 1000 per guy?


2 Seasons, but yeah a cap is fine I'd say.


Quoting my own post because I'm cool like that. Why are we worried about the 2k, if someone only got 300 in this first pass you did, but they were here both "cheated" seasons, then they should get more.

Just put something in to update those already paid if the situation warrents it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I think it should be all who were on a PLAYOFF roster in season 2 or 3. If someone played 10 games then was traded well before the playoffs, how were they wronged from Dong cheating in the playoffs?

Or someone on a gutted team that Dong never messed with? What is their grievance?


It's far easier to just try to do a blanket deal than try to sort it all out. It would probably cost more for my time to sort through it all over several days than to just write a script and hand out FP's to people who might or might not "deserve" them.

I could possibly see the only playoff games thing, though, I guess.
 
kidcolin
offline
Link
 
not it's an absurd claim. SI takes the short bus to the internet
 
Sosha
offline
Link
 
Losing to the Dongs cause me so much distress I couldn't sleep or work, I lost my job and couldn't make my mortgage payments and am now homeless

I am seeking 1.3 billion flex points as compensation
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I think it should be all who were on a PLAYOFF roster in season 2 or 3. If someone played 10 games then was traded well before the playoffs, how were they wronged from Dong cheating in the playoffs?

Or someone on a gutted team that Dong never messed with? What is their grievance?


It's far easier to just try to do a blanket deal than try to sort it all out. It would probably cost more for my time to sort through it all over several days than to just write a script and hand out FP's to people who might or might not "deserve" them.

I could possibly see the only playoff games thing, though, I guess.


Play offs thing is a gray area imo. One could make an argument there that they only missed the play offs because of Dong. One could make an argument that the only reason *team* made the play offs is because of Dong. It's another arbitrary limit, which we should stay away from (except the 1500.53 FP arbitrary limit, maybe)
 
zagzil
offline
Link
 
are we just assuming every game in season 2 and 3 were haxed or something, i dont get this argument
 
Link
 
Originally posted by zagzil
are we just assuming every game in season 2 and 3 were haxed or something, i dont get this argument


That doesn't matter, they screwed up the whole season by doing what they did. Those seasons are worthless.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zagzil
are we just assuming every game in season 2 and 3 were haxed or something, i dont get this argument


We're assuming that enough games were hacked in Seasons 2 and 3 to essentially invalidate them entirely. The 50 fp/game is just a way to compensate without setting a hard limit that'd end in "lol only 9 games in the CPL? Sorry, you don't get the 1000 fp"

edit: Also, I'd like to hear Bort's stance on spinningrainbowcatfrog.gif
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 12:50:55
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I think it should be all who were on a PLAYOFF roster in season 2 or 3. If someone played 10 games then was traded well before the playoffs, how were they wronged from Dong cheating in the playoffs?

Or someone on a gutted team that Dong never messed with? What is their grievance?


It's far easier to just try to do a blanket deal than try to sort it all out. It would probably cost more for my time to sort through it all over several days than to just write a script and hand out FP's to people who might or might not "deserve" them.

I could possibly see the only playoff games thing, though, I guess.



You are far more generous than I would be if it was my site.

You might be headed down a slippery slope when the rest of GLB finds out about this.
Anyone who doesn't get a freebie is going to feel slighted and more likely to quit. If you give it to a whole league, then all the other leagues may start putting their hand out also.

If it was me, I would just pay teams that lost in the playoffs against Dong or teams that Dong had talked about screwing. To be safe, you could pay all teams in CPL that lost in the playoffs in seasons 2 and 3. I wouldn't go any further than that....

And please sue the crap out of the kids that cheated for damages.
 
zagzil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by zagzil

are we just assuming every game in season 2 and 3 were haxed or something, i dont get this argument


That doesn't matter, they screwed up the whole season by doing what they did. Those seasons are worthless.


yeah for playoff teams, im pretty sure nobody on terrible gutted teams was hurt? not like anyone needed to cheat to beat them. why would they?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by zagzil
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by zagzil


are we just assuming every game in season 2 and 3 were haxed or something, i dont get this argument


That doesn't matter, they screwed up the whole season by doing what they did. Those seasons are worthless.


yeah for playoff teams, im pretty sure nobody on terrible gutted teams was hurt? not like anyone needed to cheat to beat them. why would they?


Meh, pay all of them and remove all doubt. It's such a shitty situation all around that it's the best move, PR-wise, to make a clean sweep of any player that was affected.
 
Commander
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zagzil
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by zagzil


are we just assuming every game in season 2 and 3 were haxed or something, i dont get this argument


That doesn't matter, they screwed up the whole season by doing what they did. Those seasons are worthless.


yeah for playoff teams, im pretty sure nobody on terrible gutted teams was hurt? not like anyone needed to cheat to beat them. why would they?




Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

I think it should be all who were on a PLAYOFF roster in season 2 or 3. If someone played 10 games then was traded well before the playoffs, how were they wronged from Dong cheating in the playoffs?

Or someone on a gutted team that Dong never messed with? What is their grievance?


It's far easier to just try to do a blanket deal than try to sort it all out. It would probably cost more for my time to sort through it all over several days than to just write a script and hand out FP's to people who might or might not "deserve" them.

I could possibly see the only playoff games thing, though, I guess.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.