User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
Page:
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
I guess how good your pass protection is could really affect your QBs energy. Does the game consider that - scrambling wearing you down?

And I agree the D-line should be losing stamina faster than many positions, but I disagree there with o-line. How often do you see o-line replaced for anything but injury or coach decision? Same with QBs really - barring injury QBs can take every snap and not have to assisted off the field. The guys doing the chasing always tire faster.

You, know going way back, Strat-o-matic games always had the stamina figured in to affect how many times in a row a player could touch the ball. Maybe the stamina has to be tied into active involvement. A high stamina wideout can stay in the game and catch three passes in a row, a scrub catches a pass, runs a fly, or makes a block and then hits the sideline. The top RBs are different than other running backs not because they gain an avg of 4 yards on each carry, because their back-up can do that too, but because they can carry the ball over and over and over again. Stamina should (could?) be tied into the number of plays you can run in a row and the energy needs to be position specific and gained back in-game at an accelerated rate if you have a higher stamina. If that's already been considered - please excuse my redundancy.

Until we have players who are really high level - many seasons down the road - we won't really be able to see how this system truly works.

Thanks.
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
Another thing I'm seeing (I've been reading threads for hours, lol) is that back-ups seem to be hanging around and playing and playing after the starter leaves the game. Some of this is the in/out setting but some guys are seeing the starter, who has significantly more stamina, leave the game after 40 plays and then the back-up go in and play twice that many plays. You can try to explain that away with what happens on those particular plays but that's the kind of situation that is somewhat troubling and something I've seen a lot of so far (I'm still a real noob, however). In my own case I'm splitting action with a back-up who probably has a third of the stamina I do. If I'm so gassed I have to leave the game how come he's OK? He's playing with the same settings (in/out, normal/hard/relaxed) as I am...

Thanks.
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
If it helps... My Team (Legion of Doom) just played it's 1st game... No one on the team was below 75 energy... Everyone played on "HARD" & I had my Sub out/in ratio at 70 Out/95 In...

The only position where the Ratio of Plays for the Starter & Back-Up did not add up, was the QB position....

Both of our QB's played almost the identical # of plays... WHich shouldn't be looking at their Stamina Ratings (JMO)... for the other positions they are close also, but only because the back-ups were in on Special Teams also... Had they not counted Special Teams plays the difference would definetly favor the Starters (Except QB)...

I think if anything, the QB position should be looked at as far as Subs go... JMO...

But overall.. I have no complaints about the new set up for energy/stamina.. JMO comparing the play ratio from this game to last years game.
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcnorth

Until we have players who are really high level - many seasons down the road - we won't really be able to see how this system truly works.


I agree 100%...

We are just scratching the surface of this & if you can put together depth, not even TOP NOTCH depth, but just depth... it really helps out.... JMO.
 
Iktomi
offline
Link
 
This reminds me of PEE-WEE football with the "everyone has to play" mentality. Has anyone ever watched a real football game. Starters get 90 per-cent of the snaps, at every position. The only time there are subs are in situations plays (i.e 3rd and long and you want pressure on the QB or 4th and short and you want a double TE set). It is obvious to me this is turning way too quickly into a money thing. The more players that get playing time, the more money GLB makes. Sure make the starters wear out (in my game I had subs in the first quarter, and I had just boosted every position giving them all a minimum of 20 stamina) so the next guy in line gets some plays, good plan if its about money, bad plan if its about football.

One last note and my vent will be complete. Most of you have probably played football at some level in your life. Do you remember H.S.? Most kids play two ways and never come out for a series. And I certainly remember the Giants playing four road games in route to a Superbowl win and still their starter were all over the Patriots in the fourth quarter... subs... no there were none... they played the game.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gassyazz
I think the biggest problem right now is depth. Sub in/out ratings are all nice to have set right but when you are a new team these days you either have crappy depth and are going to be dead at the end of the game or you have plenty of back up and will be broke by mid season. It is so hard to get players now with every lvl 1 and 2 saying they want a starting position or a randy moss contract. I know I only wanted to have 2 players, I went up to 4 just to put together a starting line up. Now after hearing how bad D-line stamina is affected and the overall how much it is affected I am up to 6 players and my owner is now up to 9 i think. Just to try to deal with this stupid stamina problem. This is way to big of a deal. I can tell you one thing all of you lvl 1 and 2's holding out for a big contract or starting position do not come knocking on my door now. I have spent my own money to fill your positions. I hope you all do not get to play this weekend.


Ditto. Minimum lvl is 10 now for me.

 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by claystone
Originally posted by sundevil

clay, your dt is a level 12 that went up against an o-line that is lvl 6 and 7. your defense was on the field for 55 plays, so don't act so high and mighty. you are only 2 deep at nt and dt, so we'll see how you do when you play against a real offensive line. you will be seeing you dts down to 60 when that happens. i wish you could play my team, so you could be knocked on your ass. our offensive line would own you.


Sundevil:

Shut the "F" up before I smack you. I'm not trying to be high and might as you say. I'm making a statment that the sub in sub out is where it needs to be tweak. Our other players are lower in level and they are above 70.

Just because i'm smiling in my photo doesn't mean i won't kick your teeth in, with that comment you gave me. Always the tough guys behind the computer.



Grow up.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by porkies
The first thing he says in this post is " You will be able to lose up to 40 energy from your energy from one game, instead of 30".

Last season it was not accumalative. You could go down to 70 in one game. so people were going down in energy to like 10 during the game, but after it was always reset to 70 so you had 2 days to train relaxed to get back to 100.

Same thing, now the lowest we can go to is 60. So you could set your sub rate to really low like 10, but they're reset after the game to 60. Then you can train on relaxed to get to 90.

He did say that he's going to rework the energy so it has more of an effect on your performance if you're not at 100%. But he used the word "slight" which is just a little. And that he'd rework it as necessary.

It is Beta version and I would suggest testing if you're not winning your games. Additionally, I've noticed that owners don't publicly share winning strategies for sub rates. You have to manually watch their games and figure it out.


So why waste points on stamina? If no matter what you're going to drop 60 for a lineman then you're foolish to waste ability points on stamina.

 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcnorth
My first experience with the new energy system has been a little disappointing. My center basically split time with his back-up.

My guy played 47 plays, the CPU back-up played 41. My guy was level 12 at the time of the game and had a stamina of 30. The back-up is a Lvl 4, I don't know what his stamina is. Last season the split seemed much better for the two players in question - much closer to a 75/25 which I felt was pretty solid, actually.

I've been reading the threads about energy and stamina and it's pretty confusing - I appreciate the time and effort put into it and post this merely as feedback.

One of the big problems I'm seeing is that GLB seems to be making the EA Sports mistake of having a player basically gas out and then sit so the back-ups play the last part of the game when the actual game is on the line.

We do need back-ups involved in the game and depth needs to matter but starters have to play in the fourth quarter of football games. The system has to move towards having back-ups come in for a play every now and again, to spell the starter for a series at most or more likely a set of downs, but not just take over the position as the game goes on.

I went over the play-by-play and my center played the first half only - with the lone exception of a special teams play where he was on the kick return team.

It's one example and one game. Perhaps it's an anomaly. Thanks.





So much for new players requesting a "starting position" as now there is no such thing.
 
Chriztian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tmoon
This reminds me of PEE-WEE football with the "everyone has to play" mentality. Has anyone ever watched a real football game. Starters get 90 per-cent of the snaps, at every position. The only time there are subs are in situations plays (i.e 3rd and long and you want pressure on the QB or 4th and short and you want a double TE set). It is obvious to me this is turning way too quickly into a money thing. The more players that get playing time, the more money GLB makes. Sure make the starters wear out (in my game I had subs in the first quarter, and I had just boosted every position giving them all a minimum of 20 stamina) so the next guy in line gets some plays, good plan if its about money, bad plan if its about football.

One last note and my vent will be complete. Most of you have probably played football at some level in your life. Do you remember H.S.? Most kids play two ways and never come out for a series. And I certainly remember the Giants playing four road games in route to a Superbowl win and still their starter were all over the Patriots in the fourth quarter... subs... no there were none... they played the game.


While that is true that it is an everyone must play mentality, do you really want to be stuck at backup perpetually because you found out about the game halfway through the 1st official season? It is a game, and thus about having fun. Also, NFL starters outside of QB play about 75-80% of snaps, not 90.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pumchavas28
If it helps... My Team (Legion of Doom) just played it's 1st game... No one on the team was below 75 energy... Everyone played on "HARD" & I had my Sub out/in ratio at 70 Out/95 In...

The only position where the Ratio of Plays for the Starter & Back-Up did not add up, was the QB position....

Both of our QB's played almost the identical # of plays... WHich shouldn't be looking at their Stamina Ratings (JMO)... for the other positions they are close also, but only because the back-ups were in on Special Teams also... Had they not counted Special Teams plays the difference would definetly favor the Starters (Except QB)...

I think if anything, the QB position should be looked at as far as Subs go... JMO...

But overall.. I have no complaints about the new set up for energy/stamina.. JMO comparing the play ratio from this game to last years game.



What if you leave the QB backup off the depth chart? If that works then we might have a work around. So now all these backup lvl 4's wanting as much playing time as a starter can get ZERO.
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chriztian
Originally posted by tmoon

This reminds me of PEE-WEE football with the "everyone has to play" mentality. Has anyone ever watched a real football game. Starters get 90 per-cent of the snaps, at every position. The only time there are subs are in situations plays (i.e 3rd and long and you want pressure on the QB or 4th and short and you want a double TE set). It is obvious to me this is turning way too quickly into a money thing. The more players that get playing time, the more money GLB makes. Sure make the starters wear out (in my game I had subs in the first quarter, and I had just boosted every position giving them all a minimum of 20 stamina) so the next guy in line gets some plays, good plan if its about money, bad plan if its about football.

One last note and my vent will be complete. Most of you have probably played football at some level in your life. Do you remember H.S.? Most kids play two ways and never come out for a series. And I certainly remember the Giants playing four road games in route to a Superbowl win and still their starter were all over the Patriots in the fourth quarter... subs... no there were none... they played the game.


While that is true that it is an everyone must play mentality, do you really want to be stuck at backup perpetually because you found out about the game halfway through the 1st official season? It is a game, and thus about having fun. Also, NFL starters outside of QB play about 75-80% of snaps, not 90.


Wrong. Cleveland had 6 players play on O-line ALL SEASON.

 
Chriztian
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by porkies

The first thing he says in this post is " You will be able to lose up to 40 energy from your energy from one game, instead of 30".

Last season it was not accumalative. You could go down to 70 in one game. so people were going down in energy to like 10 during the game, but after it was always reset to 70 so you had 2 days to train relaxed to get back to 100.

Same thing, now the lowest we can go to is 60. So you could set your sub rate to really low like 10, but they're reset after the game to 60. Then you can train on relaxed to get to 90.

He did say that he's going to rework the energy so it has more of an effect on your performance if you're not at 100%. But he used the word "slight" which is just a little. And that he'd rework it as necessary.

It is Beta version and I would suggest testing if you're not winning your games. Additionally, I've noticed that owners don't publicly share winning strategies for sub rates. You have to manually watch their games and figure it out.


So why waste points on stamina? If no matter what you're going to drop 60 for a lineman then you're foolish to waste ability points on stamina.



Math...it's fundamental. Being able to lose 40% per game does not mean you end each game at 60%. It means you end each game 40% below where you started at at max. Basically by game 10 if you drop the full 40 each game, you're going to miss a game, even training on relaxed. Thus, stamina plays a roll because it affects how many plays you get in and how low you drop for doing those plays.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 13:50:22
 
porkies
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chriztian
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by porkies


The first thing he says in this post is " You will be able to lose up to 40 energy from your energy from one game, instead of 30".

Last season it was not accumalative. You could go down to 70 in one game. so people were going down in energy to like 10 during the game, but after it was always reset to 70 so you had 2 days to train relaxed to get back to 100.

Same thing, now the lowest we can go to is 60. So you could set your sub rate to really low like 10, but they're reset after the game to 60. Then you can train on relaxed to get to 90.

He did say that he's going to rework the energy so it has more of an effect on your performance if you're not at 100%. But he used the word "slight" which is just a little. And that he'd rework it as necessary.

It is Beta version and I would suggest testing if you're not winning your games. Additionally, I've noticed that owners don't publicly share winning strategies for sub rates. You have to manually watch their games and figure it out.


So why waste points on stamina? If no matter what you're going to drop 60 for a lineman then you're foolish to waste ability points on stamina.



Math...it's fundamental. Being able to lose 40% per game does not mean you end each game at 60%. It means you end each game 40% below where you started at at max. Basically by game 10 if you drop the full 40 each game, you're going to miss a game, even training on relaxed. Thus, stamina plays a roll because it affects how many plays you get in and how low you drop for doing those plays.


Actually, it means that at every game no matter how low your guys go to, they're always reset to 60 if they went below 60. It does not accumulate. You will always be able to get back to 90 before the next game using relaxed training no matter how low you go. Because directly after the game, anyone that went below 60 gets reset to 60.

Thats how I read the post from Bort and from other posts about it.

So what role would stamina play? THe more stamina you have the "slower" your energy rate falls. WHy do you care if you get reset to 60 anyway? because he's now working on the math to make it so that the lower your energy before/during game then it lessens your effectiveness. He's working on this according to his original post on this thread and it will change as he works it out.

I only know of 2 things that you can control to "lessen" the amount of energy taken during a game. 1 raise your stamina, 2 set your play to not hard. THe owner sets the subs rates and a player has no control of that. Bort makes the math and you have no control on that.

I am only a player on here and would love to be validated or not. I spent alot of time during the offseason reading posts and would love any feedback from either Bort or some other moderator that "knows"..

EDIT: I was just reading my own response and I think that if I'm correct then a good resolution for stamina would be for players to set their own sub rates. THe player knows when he is tired and when he should come back in. Maybe an override by the coaches on 3rd downs or on the goallline. Just like in the NFL, a player is pooped and signals the sideline for a sub.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 14:25:21
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Can someone please set the record straight for stamina lost after the game? Some people on this thread are saying you can drop below 60 after a game and some say that you can never drop below 60 after a game. This is very important. Thanks.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.