User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by awesome

I agree with this completely. As I have previously stated, I think it is time for the player/moderators to go. They should pick one role or the other. It is ludicrous that a select few players who happen to have been here a little longer are given the ability to draft rules and at the same time continue to play the game in a way that provides only themselves with the benefit of these rules. (with no accountability)

The way GLB is set up right now, those who were here early have such an incredible advantage that there really isn't any hope of competing with them for the foreseeable future. They are allowed to have farm teams, make FP "gifts" to their current high level players, and are given "moderator" status so they can reinforce their systemic advantage by drafting and voting on rules.

The fact of the matter is that this rule is intended to be enforced on a "case-by-case" basis. Who, pray tell, is the arbiter of this standard? The moderators. Who, pray tell, has the most to gain from FP gifts to current players? The moderators.

The fundamental flaw in this rule is this: the rich get richer.

-USA Pro teams are not forbidden from paying their current players in FP.

-Anyone that hopes to become a USA Pro team will need USA Pro-caliber players.

-USA Pro-caliber players are mostly in USA Pro teams where they can receive FP from their current owners.

-These players will likely never become free agents because if they do that, any future FP transactions would be banned.

-Thus, the only way these players can continue to benefit from FP transactions is to stay with their current teams and continue to receive them as "gifts."


To make matters worse we have a moderator stating:
"this is a rule. not a negotiation."
"The only reason to dislike this rule is if you offered or recieved a offer including FP in the past and wanna do it again."
and "stop trying to find loopholes."

So, instead of listening to paying users' valid concerns, we have a moderator who was involved in the drafting of a rule that affects all of us saying, "we're right, you're wrong, naner naner boo boo."
"screw you guys, we've been here longer and we'll do whatever we damn well please."

The solution: Ban all FP transactions.


Moderators are accountable to the admins. Should we break an actual rule we would have to answer to one of them.

Find me a mod with an actual farm team. tpaterniti is the only mod who owns multiple teams and he's attempting to compete with all 3, not gutting one team to help another.

The people who will really enforce the rules are the admins.

And should an owner in USA Pro be found to be giving their players flex points in order to stay with the team they will be punished


Serenity Tpat's Caracas Lions aren't competitive at all...they are plain terrible!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hud


Hey Steelers, I apologize. I did not understand where you were coming from. I really thought you had a problem with the rule other than the fact that you want to have the option to be the best. I truly hear where you are coming from man. I understand that from other games. Why play if you have to settle for second best no matter how much effort and work you put in? It does sucks, and I dont know the answer. think about a competitive guy who runs across the game today, he loves the concept and the game play, but how long will it take him to get to the top? Who knows. It sucks even worse for him. I do understand that totally, but I feel obligated to defend a couple of things.

First, there are non alpha guys doing real well in the USA pros, so it is not an absolute. And I imagine that in at least two seasons, an owner of a non alpha team with mostly non alpha players will win the USA pro.

Second, stopping FP contracts is not a mod's initiative. this was Bort's intent from the beginning. We just had no power to enforce blatant disregard for this issue. If someone was offering FP contracts on the boards, we would lock or delete the thread, but we didn't feel we had the power to go further. These rules were approved by the admins to help in that regard. they are not perfect, but now with official word, we can help curb something Bort doesnt want to the best of our ability.

Third, I think you go to far when you question Bort's intent and bias when it comes to the early guys. I dont mind you question us for putting ideas in his ear that help us, but Bort is not a weak man. And he loves this game, has poured himself into for longer than most imagine, and wants it to be fun and playable for all who come along. Hell, Daggers even compared it to his own baby as I remember. If it has happened that we have unfair advantages, it is not because Bort wanted it that way, it is because he was doing what he thought was best when the issue arose. Just as an example, take the multiple teams. When the game started Bort had no clue that there would be so many who wanted to own a team so quickly. so we didnt have a rule about owning more than one team. when the shortage came at first, he didn't think it was right to strip people who had paid for and worked on teams. In hind sight, maybe he should have. But it is too late at this point. So to imply that "he just did it for his buds" is not taking into account the history of the game and also is a pretty harsh statement to make about bort. Slam those you consider his buds all you want, I dont know all of their motives.

Finally, I am not sure that battling this issue is gonna do anything for your disappointment in the overall situation. Again, I dont know the answer, but you are probably gonna have to battle it in another format, this one is come and gone. I am sure there are some viable ideas out there, I dont go to the suggestions much. But it is probably time to focus on this issue in a positive way.

Thanks for confronting this problem again, in my arrogance, i overlooked it completely in this FP contract issue.



From the bolded parts above:

1.) Thank you for understanding why I'm fighting this. I want to win. I just don't appreciate being labeled a cheat. Even the wording of this policy might as well have my name written in it. When you put (you know who you are), you might as well put "no more FP contracts SteelersInsider!"

2.) I didn't say that Bort wasn't behind the change in policy. I just said it makes it harder to catch up to Tim Harper's team.

3.) I never meant to question Bort's intent. I just know how competitive that Tim Harper is and I know there are others lke him in USA Pro who want to hold on to power as long as possible and early testers and mods have some influence over Bort I would imagine. I love this game. I love the way it has been set up. I love the direction it is headed in. I would just tweak some of these policies to make them a little more fair for everyone. Greater number of plays and controls will make it more likely for lesser skilled teams to have a chance against more skilled teams, so that is at least a step in the right direction.

4.) About taking away teams from owners that have more than 1.......why is it too late to change that policy? You changed other policies. Those players have to understand why they are being taken away. And P.S. if you do change that policy and take the other teams away, will the owners be called "cheaters" like I am called after the change?

5.) I'm about ready to let the subject go. I see why the policy is in place. Auctioning off FA's would be the dumbest game ever. A possible way to "cap" this though and make it affordable for everyone would be to set a MAX price that you could offer for a FA. For instance, the amount of their boost for that year. So if they need 900 flex points to boost, then that would be the max. No one could bid higher. That way a high level player wouldn't be "punished" from leaving his team in USA Pro and that owner had been paying for his flex points because he was such a good player.

Another player mentioned another way to open up USA Pro and break up some of those teams:

Have an Ultimate league where all teams feed into. That way a USA Pro team player who is tired of finishing in 2nd or 3rd place in USA and never getting into the ultimate league, might switch to Canada or Africa as they feel they could push one of those teams into the elite league. Likewise, when a USA Pro team that gets into the ultimate league gets relegated, like Bort said, they would have to randomly be put into one of the other groups. Bort didn't want to do that for some reason. (I'm assuming that his USA PRO buddies said that they didn't want to play with anyone except their little group).


Last point I want to make is that you say that within 2 or 3 season we may see a non-early tester team win USA Pro. Well that may be true, but unless things change, there is 0% chance that it will be my team or any team that isn't already in USA, because we can't switch to that league. How are we supposed to win USA Pro when there is no way for our teams to get to USA??

Thank you for seeing where I'm coming from.

I'm just trying to help.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Please explain how drawing up a rule in the Mod forum and presenting it to Bort for approval is different from drafting rules.


Because they didn't make it a rule...Bort did. If Bort had said no...would it had been a rule...no. Bort MAKES the rules.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity

The people who will really enforce the rules are the admins.

And should an owner in USA Pro be found to be giving their players flex points in order to stay with the team they will be punished


Ahh, but the procedure, as I understand it, requires a reporting to the Moderators any evidence that would tend to show an FP transaction. At that point, the moderators decide, on a "case-by-case" basis, whether the case should be forwarded to the admins for action. You see, by giving yourselves the decision making ability in the middle, you can effectively look the other way whenever it is convenient.

What the hell does "in order to stay with the team" mean? Again, how in the world is that decided? I submit that EVERY GIFT OF FP INHERENTLY CARRIES WITH IT THE INCENTIVE TO STAY WITH THE TEAM.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by awesome

Please explain how drawing up a rule in the Mod forum and presenting it to Bort for approval is different from drafting rules.


Because they didn't make it a rule...Bort did. If Bort had said no...would it had been a rule...no. Bort MAKES the rules.


But they DRAFTED it. THE ONLY VERSION THAT HE SAW WAS THE ONE THEY WROTE. We have been finding all kinds of things wrong with it all day, but the only response from the drafters is, "stop looking for loopholes." That can mean only ONE thing: they don't want us questioning their intentions.

Edit: your avatar confused me.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 04:36:49
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

MODERATORS DO NOT MAKE THE RULES THEY ENFORCE THE FORUM RULES...THE ADMINS MAKE THE RULES! READ THIS THREAD ON WHAT MODERATORS CAN AND CANNOT DO:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=486508


One 'slight' flaw in this. You see, when I contacted one moderator (the same one who's originated all the threads about the FP ruling) he knows all about steelinsider's wrongdoings and, in his own words, sees him as 'a ringleader'.

Yet when I approached Thorn about the same matter, he knew nothing about it??

So, who knows what, who's making up what rules, and how can anything have been signed off when an admin says he doesn't know what I'm talking about??

Oh - and just as another little polite enquiry, if 'all the admins and mods' signed off on this new rule, does that include the mod, who, despite his previous cheating in the game which is widely acknowledged by other mods (but, again, not by the admins) is still a mod??

I mean - we just need to make sure everything is fair, and I'm sure none of us have a problem with a cheat being instrumental in both developing and enforcing the rules of the game.................

**still looking for the banging head against brick wall smiley**

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity

And should an owner in USA Pro be found to be giving their players flex points in order to stay with the team they will be punished



Why would an owner give a player FP's other than to have that player stay with the team?

Do you think any players take an end of season boost in flex points and then leave??


If they *didn't* give the non-booster flex points, then that player would be cut/traded and leave the team. Thus, giving them flex points is done in order so that the player stays with the team, right? What am I missing?

Oh yeah, "intent". Mods/admins need to determine the "intent" not only of why the FP's were offered, but also the "intent" of whether that player would have stayed or not otherwise. I hope that you guys start hiring people from Dionne Warwick's Psychic Friends Network.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 04:39:18
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Serenity


The people who will really enforce the rules are the admins.

And should an owner in USA Pro be found to be giving their players flex points in order to stay with the team they will be punished


Ahh, but the procedure, as I understand it, requires a reporting to the Moderators any evidence that would tend to show an FP transaction. At that point, the moderators decide, on a "case-by-case" basis, whether the case should be forwarded to the admins for action. You see, by giving yourselves the decision making ability in the middle, you can effectively look the other way whenever it is convenient.

What the hell does "in order to stay with the team" mean? Again, how in the world is that decided? I submit that EVERY GIFT OF FP INHERENTLY CARRIES WITH IT THE INCENTIVE TO STAY WITH THE TEAM.


There's also the handy little support tab that can be used that goes to the admins for them to look at, bypassing the mods.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Serenity


And should an owner in USA Pro be found to be giving their players flex points in order to stay with the team they will be punished



Why would an owner give a player FP's other than to have that player stay with the team?

Do you think any players take an end of season boost in flex points and then leave??


If they *didn't* give the non-booster flex points, then that player would be cut/traded and leave the team. Thus, giving them flex points is done in order so that the player stays with the team, right? What am I missing?

Oh yeah, "intent". Mods/admins need to determine the "intent" not only of why the FP's were offered, but also the "intent" of whether that player would have stayed or not otherwise. I hope that you guys start hiring people from Dionne Warwick's Psychic Friends Network.


I think they are being deliberately obtuse.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by jrry32


MODERATORS DO NOT MAKE THE RULES THEY ENFORCE THE FORUM RULES...THE ADMINS MAKE THE RULES! READ THIS THREAD ON WHAT MODERATORS CAN AND CANNOT DO:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=486508


One 'slight' flaw in this. You see, when I contacted one moderator (the same one who's originated all the threads about the FP ruling) he knows all about steelinsider's wrongdoings and, in his own words, sees him as 'a ringleader'.



Excuse me? He called me the "ringleader"? Is he the one who added the "you know who you are" part to the rule?

 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity


There's also the handy little support tab that can be used that goes to the admins for them to look at, bypassing the mods.


A smart ass response from a moderator. I don't know why I expected differently.

Excuse me for thinking that "support" meant "technical support" not "report violation."
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by jrry32


MODERATORS DO NOT MAKE THE RULES THEY ENFORCE THE FORUM RULES...THE ADMINS MAKE THE RULES! READ THIS THREAD ON WHAT MODERATORS CAN AND CANNOT DO:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=486508


One 'slight' flaw in this. You see, when I contacted one moderator (the same one who's originated all the threads about the FP ruling) he knows all about steelinsider's wrongdoings and, in his own words, sees him as 'a ringleader'.

Yet when I approached Thorn about the same matter, he knew nothing about it??

So, who knows what, who's making up what rules, and how can anything have been signed off when an admin says he doesn't know what I'm talking about??

Oh - and just as another little polite enquiry, if 'all the admins and mods' signed off on this new rule, does that include the mod, who, despite his previous cheating in the game which is widely acknowledged by other mods (but, again, not by the admins) is still a mod??

I mean - we just need to make sure everything is fair, and I'm sure none of us have a problem with a cheat being instrumental in both developing and enforcing the rules of the game.................

**still looking for the banging head against brick wall smiley**



Harper actually did that before there was a rule against that like Insider with this so neither are being punished.
 
Tim Harper
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Serenity



There's also the handy little support tab that can be used that goes to the admins for them to look at, bypassing the mods.


A smart ass response from a moderator. I don't know why I expected differently.

Excuse me for thinking that "support" meant "technical support" not "report violation."


Or you just read it to be a "smart ass" remark. I didn't get the same tone from it like you did, too each his own though.

Seriously though, if you click the link it does say customer report in bolded letters.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32


Harper actually did that before there was a rule against that like Insider with this so neither are being punished.


That seems to be the way all the rules work. Let the mods/alphas squeeze as much as they can out of the questionable practice, and once they have what they need, make a rule that prevents everyone else from doing it.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Serenity



There's also the handy little support tab that can be used that goes to the admins for them to look at, bypassing the mods.


A smart ass response from a moderator. I don't know why I expected differently.

Excuse me for thinking that "support" meant "technical support" not "report violation."


Yes, because I'm expected to be super nice to you after having you questioning my integrity? Which in itself it an insult.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.