User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
LordMortis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Bort mentioned a few different options. The first was player vs. league level. If, say, the cutoff was 8 levels above league average for the penalty, it would take a level 19 to even be punished, and they would only be punished for two or three games before the league average catches up a bit and he is no longer 8 above. This is not enough to detract "drop down pwners." If it is a gradated system that punished everyone above league average accord to how far they are above, many innocent players who are 2 or 3 above average are going to be punished. And eventually, everyone will be exactly the same. What's the point of even trying to make good players then?


I think you show why "punishment" is generally bad.

Originally posted by
Another option Bort suggested is players vs. player.


I thought he rejected player versus player flat out after explaining his consideration.

Originally posted by
There is a team that was gutted in my league and filled with a bunch of level 1 players of the owner. So, now my whole team is supposed to take a hit because of that asshole? No way. That punishes innocent people and rewards jerkoffs.


Try being the owner of team who filled his place in line to find that the team was let go and the coffers emptied and then being asked to compete in an existing league.

Originally posted by
Another option was just to reward lower level players. This is a terrible idea because it makes boosting pointless. If you boost and another player doesn't, they will get bonuses and catch up any way. Bort will lose thousands, if not tens of thousands, of dollars that way. Plus it is a terrible exploit for those that want to "super-level."

This idea is completely horrible and can not stand.


I think you are overestimating the the XP bonus he is tossing around. 15% when a team is outmatched by at least three levels is what I think he was talking, which is to say that a team that starts and stays behind an entire leagues at least three levels might make a two level gain in an entire season before you add the politics off boosting late season or early season.

So in short, it will definately heavily dampen the effects dampen non strategized boosting. But it will be far from making boosting pointeless. Especially as seasons go by and it begins to take three games to level and then four and then five...

The ultimate question is one that Bort is already considering. And that is if some people (power levelers as he would call them) can break a system that helps a lesser team eventually become more competitive then the system is still punishing higher level characters while rewarding the type of play (power leveling) that he that he doesn't want to foster.

This is the reason he was asking about exploits to the proposal, how it may broken, rather than if it has merit. It has merit. It is likely being considered as a way to help owners build teams that stay competitive even when they have players abandon them or when they are new to an established leauge. It gives teams a better chance to have building years and such and a reason to sign players who aren't at a minimum of level 16 right now.
 
Jcdawg23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo


If you move up, you will gain XP bonus or not. if you go down normally that's because you don't have the level so you will have no penality.


Ok, so say a higher lvl player is trying to help a bad team, and they are stuck in a lower league. That player trying help a team mover up will be hurting himself. I don't think that is right.
 
Link
 
this is a great idea and I support it fully, should be put into effect ASAP.

The entire suggestion
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jcdawg23
Originally posted by Cedo



If you move up, you will gain XP bonus or not. if you go down normally that's because you don't have the level so you will have no penality.


Ok, so say a higher lvl player is trying to help a bad team, and they are stuck in a lower league. That player trying help a team mover up will be hurting himself. I don't think that is right.


You are right but if this player want to help does he really care about XP? Xp which he will still gain 85-90%. It's like if he lets few snaps go to back up...
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
Originally posted by oldskool

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


random rambling whine
Then come up with something better.



There is something better. The way things are.


The way things are, with too many ringers and too many 118-0 games, is unsatisfactory.

Either this solution with some modifications that help teams that stay together, or a soft level cap, would be a vast improvement.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Originally posted by Jcdawg23

Originally posted by Cedo




If you move up, you will gain XP bonus or not. if you go down normally that's because you don't have the level so you will have no penality.


Ok, so say a higher lvl player is trying to help a bad team, and they are stuck in a lower league. That player trying help a team mover up will be hurting himself. I don't think that is right.


You are right but if this player want to help does he really care about XP? Xp which he will still gain 85-90%. It's like if he lets few snaps go to back up...


Great post. I just want to say that.
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy

Originally posted by oldskool


Originally posted by thunderdoozer



random rambling whine
Then come up with something better.



There is something better. The way things are.


The way things are, with too many ringers and too many 118-0 games, is unsatisfactory.


Make the owners and GMs do a better job.

 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy


Make the owners and GMs do a better job.



Come ON!! OPEN THE EYES!!!

Last edited Jun 8, 2008 15:02:10
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Again, I think people are too focused on what I would consider the worst case scenarios of their arguments.

I do not think teams would suffer, nor would they be penalised. A small dip to experience for playing a signficantly under leveled team doesn't stop you, from gaining expereince, you'll still get likely 90% of the normal experience.

Also, the 'weak' teams aren't going o be brought to parity just from receiving a 10% bonus to their EXP for playing a toucher team.

What would be affected is those people who bring players that may be 10+ levels ahead of the rest of the league and gives them a small penalty to expereince earned per game. They'll still advance and still level, but it may be enough of a carrot to try to play against 'equal' opponents.

PS - I still say this should be focused on the Median and not the Average.
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
Hey Enkidu, how do you feel about the median and not the average? I'm not quite getting it.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
Hey Enkidu, how do you feel about the median and not the average? I'm not quite getting it.


LOL i was about to say that average people won't understand...
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
Hey Enkidu, how do you feel about the median and not the average? I'm not quite getting it.


Take this group: 1,1,1,1,1,4,7,7,8,9,9,10,12.

The average is 5.4, too low as it's affected by all those 1's.

The median (middle number) is 7, which better represents the group and is harder to manipulate by adding some number on either end.
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 15:26:17
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
Hey Enkidu, how do you feel about the median and not the average? I'm not quite getting it.



Well I know you're just trying to be funny, but I'll answer anyway.

The Median will better help filter those folks attempting to abuse the system by signing a lot of level 1 benchwarmers to their team. The quick example.

Lets presume a team of guys who are all level 20. 24 players * 20 = 480 which averages back to 20. Median here would be 20 as well.

Now, to offest this, they hire a bunch of level 1's, lets just say 10 for sake of argument. Now is ((24*20) + (10*1)) / 34 = 14.41 for the Average level.

The Median of hat same group would be 20.

It takes much more monkeying around with the roster to affect a Median measure and these efforts would be obvious.


 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy

Hey Enkidu, how do you feel about the median and not the average? I'm not quite getting it.


Take this group: 1,1,1,1,1,4,7,7,8,9,9,10,12.

The average is 5.4, too low as it's affected by all those 1's.

The median (middle number) is 7, which better represents the group and is harder to manipulate by adding someone on either end.


I know what it is. He has said the same thing least 4 times in this thread, and in my teams' forums as well.

It was sarcasm. Read my post again. I didn't say "I don't get the difference between median and not average."
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Sweet Daddy


Hey Enkidu, how do you feel about the median and not the average? I'm not quite getting it.


Take this group: 1,1,1,1,1,4,7,7,8,9,9,10,12.

The average is 5.4, too low as it's affected by all those 1's.

The median (middle number) is 7, which better represents the group and is harder to manipulate by adding someone on either end.


I know what it is. He has said the same thing least 4 times in this thread, and in my teams' forums as well.

It was sarcasm. Read my post again. I didn't say "I don't get the difference between median and not average."


Okay. Sorry. But I'll bet among the lurkers, someone learned something, anyway.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.