User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jpjn94
Game Replay's
Each purchase of Game Replay will give the ability for a coach's effectiveness on that given play by 1%.


this would be really cool.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Double post
Edited by David Stern on Sep 4, 2009 17:47:11
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern

BORT, If you really want coaches to work and be realistic. Allow us to "Watch film" with our position coach. Then give us say 5 options per player.

Free safety watches film, decides team A runs 5 Favorite plays. He studies plays, and when he sees these plays he gets.

Play 1) HB Screen Ace X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 2) Strong I slam .8X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 3)Shotgun Screen .6x% boost
Play 4 etc
Play 5 etc
This way we could actually game plan, and use "Coaches" to give our players boosts to these teams who abuse the same 4-5 plays game in game out. Would force teams to truly devise schemes, and really come up with new game plans week to week.

Edit: this would take more work, but I Don't want coaches to be some BS thing that just gives people a reward for having them. I Want people to have to study, and work to get advantages out of these coaches, not just some Free pass for finding this website first.


Originally posted by maxx Misery
Of everything I've seen in this thread, this has been my favorite by far.

The numerous ways that this could work out would just add a whole new flavor to gameplanning/AI. Offense with a good coach being able to pick 5 plays to get the bonus vs. a Defense that focuses on shutting down 5 plays could make for some amazing games.

Thanks
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Scary stuff.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Spin off item crafting idea for coaches:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3227045
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Reficuul
Bort -

is it possible to get some cliff notes of what is already set in stone, and what you like from these post?

There is a lot of information and being able to see it all in ONE post would be a huge help!

I'm sure you got a note-pad of crap that you have been writing down somewhere! I'd love to know the short version of what is on it! Especially when it comes to the cost of owning a coach!

~refi


I am working that up. It's long and taking a while
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by christianhall
To make sure salary is not abused due to teams farming cash to give coaches super high contracts, impose a salary cap for coaches. Apply minimum contract restrictions (possibly maximum as well), and let the teams balance their money based on what type of coaches they would like. Then there is no possible way for coaches to have too much money, and it means they must make a choice on what to spend money on.


Or we could just make coaches cost a set amount of salary and the cash isn't really used for anything (so not even kept track of). And then just make all the coach skills have daily or seasonal limits, and forget about cash for them.
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by christianhall

To make sure salary is not abused due to teams farming cash to give coaches super high contracts, impose a salary cap for coaches. Apply minimum contract restrictions (possibly maximum as well), and let the teams balance their money based on what type of coaches they would like. Then there is no possible way for coaches to have too much money, and it means they must make a choice on what to spend money on.


Or we could just make coaches cost a set amount of salary and the cash isn't really used for anything (so not even kept track of). And then just make all the coach skills have daily or seasonal limits, and forget about cash for them.


Yeah, probably much simpler that way.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Sorry if this has already been answered but:

So do you have it worked out how the real money impact will work? Will coaches cost flex? Will you still eventually get the 70% back on a player that becomes a coach?
 
Xero00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Or we could just make coaches cost a set amount of salary and the cash isn't really used for anything (so not even kept track of). And then just make all the coach skills have daily or seasonal limits, and forget about cash for them.


Have their set salary scaled to the skills they bring to the team.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Scary stuff.


 
Link
 
Eh, a mod told me to move this post into here.


One possible exploit, in which, I believe will be used is the ability to move coaches down to a low level cap team, in which, there was no connection between the 'coach' and that specific 'team'. Why I understand it is part of the game, it worries me that it will impede on the advancement of some of the lower level teams that are not associated with any organization. While there is no way to prevent that from occuring, but should their not be some type of way to prevent a team from sending all of its coaches down to the minors?

I propose:
A) A maximum cap for each level of the minors, like player caps, for there should never be a maxed out 'coach' on a pee-wee or minor lvl 13.
Also B) Like players, a team must dump their high level coaches, when the request regulation, like players. Forced regulation should be taken on a case by case occurence.

I understand that this will be unpopular to many of the oldest organization, but coaches should not be allowed to help organizations get a larger advantage then they do already.

 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
I am thinking that you need to K.I.S.S. it Bort. Keep It Simple Stupid. Just give them shopping tokens to roll AEQ that they can buy and sell which ever players it would work for the best, this would be a big help to a lot of players that don't have the X-factor when rolling AEQ.
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Bort, how about having a poll on the following:

Do you want coaching implemented in season 12?

or

Do you want us to spend our time and resources improving current issues with the game?


 
Mauler
Tsalagi
offline
Link
 
This should be voted on by each League once you lay down this new Coaching gimmick. I personally don't think every League should have it whether you decide to go with it or not because you would basically be alienating 80% of your business. I myself barely have enough time to run a team as it is and this would just make more work for a owner which I just don't have. I am not even going to go into how this will be exploited, but the agents who have been around for a while knows exactly what this would do and do not like it one bit. I vote a resounding "No" for this idea & just hope there is at least a casual League to play in that doesn't have such nonsense in it if you decide to go through with this anyways just to appease the 20%, if that. Otherwise, I will not be buying any more FP's from here on in as the game is just getting to far away from football using terms like crafting, etc. that in know way have anything to do with football!!!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.