User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
pnewtonjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Deathblade

Give me GM access and I'll find out why it did that.

I already know why it did that. The sim doesn't always follow the play-calling. 99.9% of the time it does, but like any programming, there are bugs.

And for the record, on other 3rd & shorts later in the game out of the same offensive formation, all three LBs did blitz. It only screwed up once.


Unfortunately, this is true. I have medium TE and medium WR passes set to trigger in this situation for my offense (and verified by the AI Tester). I definitely don't have a WR screen set for this situation, yet that is what the sim called. (and I also don't use the WR Screen with an actual WR in the slot, either, which is why I know the sim just picked a random play from my playbook).

I don't care about the game as it was just a scrimmage, but this and many plays like this DO happen and ARE bugs. The AI is not always followed.
 
driftin079
offline
Link
 
Started a thread on this before I saw this stickied up top. I agree with jdbolick and pnewtonjr that the sim just doesn't always follow the AI. Here's why.

So, the past few games, nearly every time we get into the red zone, this happens:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=370105&pbp_id=14400507

No, we don't score every time, but we run that HB screen almost every time. Funny thing is, it's not in our AI. I ran a test of that exact situation, and here's what came up:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_test.jpg

So maybe I have an output wrong. Maybe not:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_outputs.jpg

Okay, so maybe one of my outputs calls for a play that's not in the playbook, so the sim is defaulting to the Basic Settings. Okay, maybe not:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_MHB.jpg
http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_OT.jpg
http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_SWR.jpg

I'm not saying what I called for in the AI would've been perfect. In fact, we scored 2 TD's in two games off of that screen. But there are instances where the sim is calling plays on its own, and I'd like to at least know why it's happening. And no, auto-adjust is NOT turned on. IMO it's definitely a bug.

Here are the two plays from the game before where we ran a HB screen as well. Obviously I can't verify that there were no screens in the AI, but I guess you'd have to take my word for it that there weren't any.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=366046&pbp_id=13728185
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=366046&pbp_id=13728206

It's happened in some other games, but I'm too lazy to find them.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftin079
Started a thread on this before I saw this stickied up top. I agree with jdbolick and pnewtonjr that the sim just doesn't always follow the AI. Here's why.

So, the past few games, nearly every time we get into the red zone, this happens:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=370105&pbp_id=14400507

No, we don't score every time, but we run that HB screen almost every time. Funny thing is, it's not in our AI. I ran a test of that exact situation, and here's what came up:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_test.jpg

So maybe I have an output wrong. Maybe not:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_outputs.jpg

Okay, so maybe one of my outputs calls for a play that's not in the playbook, so the sim is defaulting to the Basic Settings. Okay, maybe not:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_MHB.jpg
http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_OT.jpg
http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_SWR.jpg

I'm not saying what I called for in the AI would've been perfect. In fact, we scored 2 TD's in two games off of that screen. But there are instances where the sim is calling plays on its own, and I'd like to at least know why it's happening. And no, auto-adjust is NOT turned on. IMO it's definitely a bug.

Here are the two plays from the game before where we ran a HB screen as well. Obviously I can't verify that there were no screens in the AI, but I guess you'd have to take my word for it that there weren't any.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=366046&pbp_id=13728185
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=366046&pbp_id=13728206

It's happened in some other games, but I'm too lazy to find them.



I am having this EXACT PROBLEM- at first i thought it was my genius gameplanning until i looked and realized i never included screens in my gameplanning. In my most recent problem the sim decided going to a 5 wide formation was a good idea
Last edited Feb 8, 2009 23:20:53
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Every person who thought it was a bug have been proven wrong so far.

If you want to be proven wrong, then PM me the plays that didn't work correctly and then give me GM access to view your AI and don't change your AI.

I really should start betting people $10 that I can find their error. If I did, I'd be up a bunch.


i'll take you up on that either way your help is appreciated
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
yeah last couple games we have had our AI mostly ignored.

There are many examples, I thought about creating a bug thread, but since there's really no purpose in reporting bugs (it will just be ignored and overlooked - thanks worthless admins)

3-3-5 used to be an option for our defense vs Singleback 3 WR, it was set for 0% and was still being used by the AI. The other settings which were set for 50% and 50% were also being used with the 0% setting.

On offense, we were running Singleback sweeps on 3rd and 10, and running the ball is not even an option within our AI on 3rd down. The Strong I offtackle was also being used by the AI on 3rd and long situations, despite not even being an option.

At least in the defense example, the 3-3-5 was one of our 0% options, on the offensive side it seemed to just be pulling any random play.

This is a problem and it has continued for the post-season scrimmage games. I do not expect anybody to help, because most of you who are being paid to help, really suck D.
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftin079
Started a thread on this before I saw this stickied up top. I agree with jdbolick and pnewtonjr that the sim just doesn't always follow the AI. Here's why.

So, the past few games, nearly every time we get into the red zone, this happens:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=370105&pbp_id=14400507

No, we don't score every time, but we run that HB screen almost every time. Funny thing is, it's not in our AI. I ran a test of that exact situation, and here's what came up:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_test.jpg

So maybe I have an output wrong. Maybe not:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_outputs.jpg

Okay, so maybe one of my outputs calls for a play that's not in the playbook, so the sim is defaulting to the Basic Settings. Okay, maybe not:

http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_MHB.jpg
http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_OT.jpg
http://i613.photobucket.com/albums/tt217/driftin079/AI_SWR.jpg

I'm not saying what I called for in the AI would've been perfect. In fact, we scored 2 TD's in two games off of that screen. But there are instances where the sim is calling plays on its own, and I'd like to at least know why it's happening. And no, auto-adjust is NOT turned on. IMO it's definitely a bug.

Here are the two plays from the game before where we ran a HB screen as well. Obviously I can't verify that there were no screens in the AI, but I guess you'd have to take my word for it that there weren't any.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=366046&pbp_id=13728185
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=366046&pbp_id=13728206

It's happened in some other games, but I'm too lazy to find them.


This is exactly our problem too. Exactly the same problem.

The AI tester gives the correct results, but the SIM produces results not in line with the AI gameplan and playbook.
Last edited Feb 9, 2009 12:10:08
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Dear Bort,

Your paying customers need your attention.

Do not send your lecherous mods and admins because they cannot help.

We need the kingpin to step up and fix this.
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pnewtonjr

I don't care about the game as it was just a scrimmage, but this and many plays like this DO happen and ARE bugs. The AI is not always followed.


I agree with you, it's not that important - these are scrimmages - but the SIM must work correctly because we pay for it to work correctly. It's come to a point where I'm about to create 10 new players for a rebuilding team, but the idea of paying more and more cash into this thing when progress rarely occurs, it makes me wonder if it's a wise thing to do. On one hand I really enjoy the strategy, but if the sim just isn't going to work correctly........then what's the point? F#&^ I'm just so frustrated anymore!
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by teamriots
Originally posted by pnewtonjr


I don't care about the game as it was just a scrimmage, but this and many plays like this DO happen and ARE bugs. The AI is not always followed.


I agree with you, it's not that important - these are scrimmages - but the SIM must work correctly because we pay for it to work correctly. It's come to a point where I'm about to create 10 new players for a rebuilding team, but the idea of paying more and more cash into this thing when progress rarely occurs, it makes me wonder if it's a wise thing to do. On one hand I really enjoy the strategy, but if the sim just isn't going to work correctly........then what's the point? F#&^ I'm just so frustrated anymore!


it's time to ROIT!
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
I just played a scrimmage where I had auto-adjust on '0', no advanced AI, and run 100%

Why are there passing plays in there then?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=372183

.
 
LTPapabear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
I just played a scrimmage where I had auto-adjust on '0', no advanced AI, and run 100%

Why are there passing plays in there then?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=372183

.


qb called audibles on the field?
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Cool

 
Samythe41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by teamriots
Originally posted by pnewtonjr


I don't care about the game as it was just a scrimmage, but this and many plays like this DO happen and ARE bugs. The AI is not always followed.


I agree with you, it's not that important - these are scrimmages - but the SIM must work correctly because we pay for it to work correctly. It's come to a point where I'm about to create 10 new players for a rebuilding team, but the idea of paying more and more cash into this thing when progress rarely occurs, it makes me wonder if it's a wise thing to do. On one hand I really enjoy the strategy, but if the sim just isn't going to work correctly........then what's the point? F#&^ I'm just so frustrated anymore!

I think that's overreacting a bit.
Bugs happen. It's in the nature of computer games.
In fact, I remember playing several very enjoyable games that were full of bugs (remember, UFO enemy unknown back in the 90's?)

 
WiL@ES21
offline
Link
 
In the pro-season scrimmage games, I was testing my AI, I have set 5WRs shotgun long pass to be called in 1st-3rd downs in the entire 2nd Quarter ,Ball Spot(yard line Between own 5 to opp5. And I have adjusted my playbook to allow only 1 type of 5WR shotgun to be called.

Then I found that when I go into the red zone, my 5WRs shotgun plays were not the one in my playbook. It seems to like all my WRs were creating a new route, but what is weird is they just do so in the red zone.

This is the play I want to call:http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=369135&pbp_id=15722353

This is the play I don't want to call but it has been called EVERY TIME in the red zone:http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=369135&pbp_id=15722465

So is this a bug? Im not very sure but I think the 5WRs shotgun called in the red zone is not better than the one I wanted.
 
LTPapabear
offline
Link
 
I dunno, it was the eact same formations on D.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.