User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
This is not a DPC issue.


This is an issue caused by a combination of

1. First Step being overpowered (saw writing on wall when Bort started thinking about how to buff it)
2. Slightly flawed OL logic
3. OL being built without enough speed/agility to counter the DL who magically become faster because of first step.

Don't believe me.

Run tests on the server.

#1 - design OL as I stated earlier against TPat DE.
#2 - design OL with 5 less agility and 10 less speed, give them 10 more strength and 5 more confidence against Tpat DE
#3 - OL from #1 against Tpat DE with 0 first step and 10 pts in other SAs
#4 - OL from #2 against Tpat DE with 0 first step and 10 pts in other SAs



Edited by Rage Kinard on Jul 15, 2009 12:49:21
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by jdros13

Originally posted by Cryptotich


Originally posted by lolMurp



Originally posted by Cryptotich




To end speculation on everyone's part.

We are looking at this as, a possible DPC exlploit, O Line Issue, AND a build issue. Or combination of all 3. This interaction is being heavily scrutinized as we speak.



I hope the term O Line Issue includes the coding and AI.


It might, we are going to have to deconstruct everything and see what we get. Don't expect the fix tomorrow. I am hoping by playoffs.


A "fix" to what though exactly? Hell, I looked at your team's game against an overmatched opponent where you pinched the DE's in, pulled out all the sacks and there was maybe one that looks a little funny (in the other thread about this).

The reason I'm even curious about this is because I do not want to see a return to what this game has been over the last couple of seasons, where only the very best DLine guys or really creative DC's ever get sacks. That game was boring and extremely unrealistic. Even the mediocre builds should occasionally find their way past the OLine to at least get a hurry. If you look at most Pro league team stats, most teams still aren't even allowing more than 1.5 - 2 sacks per game - wtf do you guys want?

USAPL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=1&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0
APL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=83&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0
CPL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=5&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0
EEPL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=11&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0
WEPL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=9&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0
OPL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=17&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0
SAPL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=15&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0
SEAPL: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=13&conference_id=0&stat=passing&sort=sacked&playoffs=0


We all want to be there... I suppose I should have directed you to both my last game, and the game before it, where I really over matched my opponent. I do all my own DC'ing, and the difference I saw in actual play, was so far out of the realm of "slight adjustments" that I am convinced this is a bug.

This isn't about nerfing DE's Its about a possible problem in the code that makes certain defensive alignments overpowered.


Well, I DC for arguably one of the better teams in GLB and another Pro team that has always been able to get sacks throughout every season, even the last couple of years. I also own a high level OT with a average to above average build (imo) and it is much more difficult to stop good pass rushers this season. That's a good thing.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
This is not a DPC issue.


This is an issue caused by a combination of

1. First Step being overpowered (saw writing on wall when Bort started thinking about how to buff it)
2. Highly flawed OL logic
3. OL being built without enough speed/agility to counter the DL who magically become faster because of first step.



FYP.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
This is not a DPC issue.


This is an issue caused by a combination of

1. First Step being overpowered (saw writing on wall when Bort started thinking about how to buff it)
2. Slightly flawed OL logic
3. OL being built without enough speed/agility to counter the DL who magically become faster because of first step.



IMO it is heavy amounts of #2 primarily, with #1 and #3 just bringing #2 to light.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Since I added after replies.

Run tests on the server.

#1 - design OL as I stated earlier in thread against TPat DE.
#2 - design OL with 5 less agility and 10 less speed, give them 10 more strength and 5 more confidence against Tpat DE
#3 - OL from #1 against Tpat DE with 0 first step and 10 pts in other SAs
#4 - OL from #2 against Tpat DE with 0 first step and 10 pts in other SAs
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sbuck143
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

This is not a DPC issue.


This is an issue caused by a combination of

1. First Step being overpowered (saw writing on wall when Bort started thinking about how to buff it)
2. Slightly flawed OL logic
3. OL being built without enough speed/agility to counter the DL who magically become faster because of first step.



IMO it is heavy amounts of #2 primarily, with #1 and #3 just bringing #2 to light.



No, it is not.

LG builds are far, far from pass rushing RDE builds.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by sbuck143

Originally posted by Rage Kinard


This is not a DPC issue.


This is an issue caused by a combination of

1. First Step being overpowered (saw writing on wall when Bort started thinking about how to buff it)
2. Slightly flawed OL logic
3. OL being built without enough speed/agility to counter the DL who magically become faster because of first step.



IMO it is heavy amounts of #2 primarily, with #1 and #3 just bringing #2 to light.



No, it is not.

LG builds are far, far from pass rushing RDE builds.


The OLine logic is shaky at best though....there are always ways to confuse those dots.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
So you don't think that maybe, in those instances, the OT and G failed their snap vision check while the DE fired FS and TV at once, propelling him off the line and leaving your OT and G in the dust?

Couldn't possibly happen!


TBH, the OL should know the snap count, thus a snap vision check for OL is a bit of a reach.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by tdm13

So you don't think that maybe, in those instances, the OT and G failed their snap vision check while the DE fired FS and TV at once, propelling him off the line and leaving your OT and G in the dust?

Couldn't possibly happen!


TBH, the OL should know the snap count, thus a snap vision check for OL is a bit of a reach.


They should have some type of check for recognizing who they are supposed to pick up though. The OLine actually does a better job than I would expect at picking up the all out blitzes.
 
Den
offline
Link
 
First, I want to admit I did not read all 18 pages of back and forth debate on this. I did skim looking to see if my thoughts were already covered tho and didn't spot it. Apologies if this was already debunked and I missed it.

But....

Personally I think the biggest reason this is an issue is the lack of the ability for a QB to call an audible when faced with a 'gimmick' Defense. I know, it's never gonna happen. But that is the flaw. Any HS+ level QB would audible a pitch/sweep upon seeing all the interior linemen bunched up like that. Or even a simple rollout if he just has to pass the ball.

As long as the Offense is not allowed to make a Defense pay for gimmick positioning, by reacting as any competent QB would in RL, they (the gimmick defenses) will remain in Dotball.


EDIT - for clarification in last sentence.
Edited by Den on Jul 15, 2009 13:13:21
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Den
First, I want to admit I did not read all 18 pages of back and forth debate on this. I did skim looking to see if my thoughts were already covered tho and didn't spot it. Apologies if this was already debunked and I missed it.

But....

Personally I think the biggest reason this is an issue is the lack of the ability for a QB to call an audible when faced with a 'gimmick' Defense. I know, it's never gonna happen. But that is the flaw. Any HS+ level QB would audible a pitch/sweep upon seeing all the interior linemen bunched up like that. Or even a simple rollout if he just has to pass the ball.

As long as the Offense is not allowed to make a Defense pay for gimmick positioning, by reacting as any competent QB would in RL, they (the gimmick defenses) will remain in Dotball.


EDIT - for clarification in last sentence.



the defense would need to audible as well if that is going to get implemented
Edited by mikeandbrooke07 on Jul 15, 2009 13:16:00
 
Den
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07
Originally posted by Den

First, I want to admit I did not read all 18 pages of back and forth debate on this. I did skim looking to see if my thoughts were already covered tho and didn't spot it. Apologies if this was already debunked and I missed it.

But....

Personally I think the biggest reason this is an issue is the lack of the ability for a QB to call an audible when faced with a 'gimmick' Defense. I know, it's never gonna happen. But that is the flaw. Any HS+ level QB would audible a pitch/sweep upon seeing all the interior linemen bunched up like that. Or even a simple rollout if he just has to pass the ball.

As long as the Offense is not allowed to make a Defense pay for gimmick positioning, by reacting as any competent QB would in RL, they (the gimmick defenses) will remain in Dotball.


EDIT - for clarification in last sentence.



the defense would need to audible as well if that is going to get implemented


Audible for what? They currently get the final say already as to what Defense to use vs. any particular Offensive Set.

I'm just talking a simple audible to another play out of whatever set the Offense is already in. Just the Basics would be enough to help balance the issue. If the Defense shifts back to a 'normal' set every time the QB opens his mouth, real audible or not, then the effect is adaquate.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
perhaps an 'audible' slider - much like the 'auto adjust' that gets chosen -
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Den
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07

Originally posted by Den


First, I want to admit I did not read all 18 pages of back and forth debate on this. I did skim looking to see if my thoughts were already covered tho and didn't spot it. Apologies if this was already debunked and I missed it.

But....

Personally I think the biggest reason this is an issue is the lack of the ability for a QB to call an audible when faced with a 'gimmick' Defense. I know, it's never gonna happen. But that is the flaw. Any HS+ level QB would audible a pitch/sweep upon seeing all the interior linemen bunched up like that. Or even a simple rollout if he just has to pass the ball.

As long as the Offense is not allowed to make a Defense pay for gimmick positioning, by reacting as any competent QB would in RL, they (the gimmick defenses) will remain in Dotball.


EDIT - for clarification in last sentence.



the defense would need to audible as well if that is going to get implemented


Audible for what? They currently get the final say already as to what Defense to use vs. any particular Offensive Set.

I'm just talking a simple audible to another play out of whatever set the Offense is already in. Just the Basics would be enough to help balance the issue. If the Defense shifts back to a 'normal' set every time the QB opens his mouth, real audible or not, then the effect is adaquate.


How about audible for "Fuck, we called a normal strong I defense and they have their starting QB in the game at TE and their really fast Vick clone backup in at QB - I bet they are going to run a QB scramble now". Or maybe "Oops, we called a play to stop the strong I slam by their powerback and they have the RB that only catches passes in the game - might be a screen instead."

But you are right, the defense always gets the advantage in the matchup game.
 
Den
offline
Link
 
Don't get me wrong - I think the odds of any audible system being put in are nil. Way too much work when he's already a couple seasons behind the curve.

Just saying, normally that would be the 'fix' in RL to gimmick Defenses like that. Since we can't do that, seems like the gimmicks need to be removed or some other "Dot" method of balancing it out needs to be achieved to simulate the lack of a major part of RL Football. (Audibles)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.